Preview

Discussion Questions on the Ethicality of PGD in My Sister's Keeper

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
315 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Discussion Questions on the Ethicality of PGD in My Sister's Keeper
My Sister's Keeper Discussion Questions Given what you've just seen, which character are you most sympathetic to? Why?
Imagine you are the mother: while Kate is dying, you discover that Anna refuses to give Kate the last possible life-saving treatment. How would you react? How would you try to keep your family together?
Do you think it is ethical to design and conceive a child that meets specific genetic requirements?
If so, is PGD ethical in all cases? (prevent miscarriages, prevent inheritable genetic diseases, sex selection for social reasons, etc)
If not, do you believe there should be specific exceptions - such as saving another person's life - or is this just a "slippery slope"?
Knowing what you now know about PGD, do you agree with the parent's choice to "design" Anna to save Kate?
Is it ethically ok to screen embryos for desired genetic traits, and reject the "undesired" embryos?
How does the knowledge that Anna was conceived to save Kate affect Anna's and Kate's perceptions of themselves, and their relationship with each other? For instance, you might consider the following:
Will Kate feel guilty knowing that Anna was created to save her life?
What if Anna can't save Kate? Will Anna face lifelong psychological damage?
Does Anna feel objectified as a "spare parts baby"? Does Kate feel objectified as a sick person?
Do you think the parents went too far in their concern for Kate by making Anna a savior for Kate? When is it too far to save one child by using the body of another? By taking umbilical cord blood? Bone marrow transplants? Kidney donation? After Anna has spoken up in opposition to any further use of her body?
Recall the physician in the movie who recommended PGD, an ethically questionable procedure, "off the record." If you were a physician, would you recommend PGD to a couple in a similar
Continue Reading
View Writing Issues

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    How Would You Explain Annas Mental and Spiritual Unravelling? What Are the Pivota Experiences Leading Up to Her Breakdown and Eventual Rebirth?
    • 867 Words
    • 4 Pages

    How Would You Explain Annas Mental and Spiritual Unravelling? What Are the Pivota Experiences Leading Up to Her Breakdown and Eventual Rebirth?

    “How would you explain Anna’s mental and spiritual unravelling? What are the pivotal experiences leading up to her breakdown and her eventual rebirth”…

    • 867 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    My Sister's Keeper Book Review Essay
    • 734 Words
    • 3 Pages

    My Sister's Keeper Book Review Essay

    The love amidst two sisters Anna and Kate is unconditional throughout the novel. In Kate’s body, Anna’s blood is constantly flowing in her veins and arteries. Anna is the only Savior for Kate and because of her Kate is alive. Anna was born with it only one mindset l which was to help Kate. When she grew up, she did a lawsuit against Kate because she wanted her own rights for her body but even after that she loves Kate. The only reason why Anna did a lawsuit was because Kate told her to. Kate pulled out different examples from her head and convinced and Anna. Kate explained, “Think about it Anna. You could go to your hockey camps. You could choose a college in a whole different country. You could do anything you want and never have to worry about me.” (Picoult, 390) Kate played with Anna's mind thoughts. Kate was the one that actually wanted the lawsuit to happen because she felt so bad for…

    • 734 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Geraldine Brooks 'The Transformation Of Anna Frith'
    • 1065 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Geraldine Brooks 'The Transformation Of Anna Frith'

    Some of those characters could not cope but Anna however seized this opportunity to become even stronger and still always put others before herself. At first Anna struggled as any human being would, “let it be done unto me according to thy word.” Anna was asking to die. This was after she had lost her two young boys within weeks of each other due to the plague, but somehow Anna pulled through and still put others before herself so unselfishly. “The plague had already taken from me the greatest part of what I had to lose”, Anna’s pride and joy was in her two sons Jamie and Tom but when they were taken away from her she decided to stay in the village “because she had small will to live.” Anna presents her real strength when she delivers Mrs. Daniels baby despite her past experiences, “you know a great deal more than you think.” It is evident that Anna underestimates her ability to do things and to help others but this is cured during the novel as she becomes a confident, brave women. Due to the fact that Anna had lost her two darling sons and her loving husband Sam, Anna found happiness in giving help in the deliveries of village women’s babies, as she not only got to see the beginning of a family but she took part in that beginning. This made Anna realise that although there was so much darkness around her there was also light at the end of the tunnel. Although deaths were occurring each day new life was growing all around…

    • 1065 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Satisfactory Essays

    anthro 102 assignment 1
    • 562 Words
    • 2 Pages

    anthro 102 assignment 1

    A second ethical issue that could arise from genetic testing would be that it might be hard to interpret the information about the child through facts and online readings. If a mother decides to abort her child due to a gene mutation she doesn’t consider positive, she isn’t giving this child a chance to possibly fight it and live longer than expected. There’s not a chance given if the mother takes it away.…

    • 562 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    Geraldine Brooks 'Year Of Wonders'
    • 1301 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Geraldine Brooks 'Year Of Wonders'

    This allows Anna to develop more confidence in her knowledge and become a stronger, more assertive woman. When Elinor calls for Anna's help to deliver Mary Daniel's child, she is at first hesitant to assist because her own mother died during childbirth when she was just four years old. Elinor insists, however, telling Anna that "You know a very great deal more than you think you do" and eventually, Anna gives in and prepares to deliver the baby, recalling memories from her own first confinement to help her. Anna tries not to think about the fact that she is about to "invade the body of a living woman", however she quickly overcomes this thought, and tries to "...quiet that part of my mind hammering away about modesty and violation." Although she is unsure of what she is doing, she acts as though she does, as she thinks it important that Mary sees her acting confidently. Once her hands were inside of Mary, however, it seemed as though her flesh "felt as familiar" to her as her own and Anna has little difficulty in helping her deliver the baby. Afterwards, they laughed and "for an hour, in that season of death," they celebrated a life. This particular event sees Anna developing a part of her that is confident and sure of her own knowledge and skills. Due to her experiences in birthing livestock, Anna is already equipped with the skills necessary to assist in childbirth but there exists a different part of her inside that is naturally gifted in midwifery and it is this part that truly allows her to shine and take control of what she can do thus leading her to discover her natural confidence and…

    • 1301 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Year of Wonders Essay Topics
    • 802 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Year of Wonders Essay Topics

    13. Discuss Anna’s mental and spiritual unravelling. What are the pivotal experiences leading to her breakdown and eventual rebirth?…

    • 802 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Crow Lake
    • 1120 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Crow Lake

    To begin with, Kate Morrison is plagued by the guilt of her bother, Matt’s broken dreams. As a consequence, the guilt causes many emotional problems in her life. For instance, the constant mental pressures of guilt causes Kate’s “crisis” during one of her zoology lectures. “Because if things had turned out differently, it would have been Matt standing in front of them” (Lawson, pg. 200). During a lecture, Kate has a flashback about a childhood visit to the ponds with Matt. It is clear that Kate feels guilty for leaving Matt, who was her idol as well as her brother, behind. He taught her not only to see nature but to observe and understand it; and Kate feels that it is injustice that she should be teaching others when Matt taught her “everything” she knows. Furthermore, Katie is always in an emotional battle with her own mind due to the guilt she felt for Matt’s situation. “I had betrayed him, that was how I felt” (Lawson, pg. 201). Even though she knows Matt had caused his own demise, deep inside her mind, she feels that it was her own fault. This feeling causes her to fight with herself. Her situation shows that Kate could never come to terms with what had happened to her family and what had become of the Morrison dream. Finally, Kate’s guilt causes her to lose communication with Matt, which hurts their relationship. “What are you actually researching Kate? I don’t think you’ve ever said” (Lawson, pg. 274). It is plainly obvious that Matt is interested in…

    • 1120 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Year Of Wonders Character Analysis
    • 1539 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Year Of Wonders Character Analysis

    For Anna however, she believes the work of the Gowdie’s was innocent, and has a strong desire to keep the practice of herblore alive. Anna openly shares that she never had a close relationship with Anys, yet before she was murdered, the pair bonded. It is when Anna learns of Anys’ relationship with George Viccars, which intrigues Anna to get to know Anys and learn of her beliefs and values. Anys teaches Anna that it is acceptable to be independent. Anys believes she was, “not made to be any man’s chattel” and following this Anna admires her for, “listening to her own heart rather than having her life ruled by others conventions”. The plague’s devastating effects require Anna to research herblore. Together with Elinor, the duo explore and grow in this area of expertise together. Anna is able to quickly grasp many herblore concepts and invent new herbal remedies in hope that each new one may be a good treatment for the plague. Anna goes on to deliver several children in the area. At first she delivers a baby with no experience only motherly instinct. Over time, she develops the skills necessary to repeat this many times. With the help of Elinor, Anna begins to learn and see the world as a bigger place, as well as have better understanding of it through education brought about by the plague. When it is revealed to her that Michael Mompellion had mistreated Elinor, Anna has the…

    • 1539 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Satisfactory Essays

    my sisters keeper-health
    • 513 Words
    • 3 Pages

    my sisters keeper-health

    Besides the obvious part of health, the emotional aspect is also included. Because the book switches point of view from one character to another, we get to see the different emotions that each one of the family members, as well as an attorney, are feeling throughout the book. Kate’s condition has made her the favorite of her mother and this takes away from her siblings, especially Jesse who is her older brother. Kate also has a hard time dealing with emotions because she doesn’t and never has felt beautiful. The emotions strain the family and cause them to loose the connections they had once had before Anna filed the lawsuit.…

    • 513 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Ethics and Natural Method
    • 720 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Ethics and Natural Method

    Within the text, the natural method of conception is genetic engineering unlike to what our society perceives to be natural. Genetic engineering leads to genetic selection from the parents who choose to eliminate any defects, diseases or genetic illnesses. Some parents may want to leave several genetic traits to chance rather then selecting the attributes of their son or daughter. To what extent is this process of conception morally right? If even morally right at all. Ethically speaking, genetic engineering in embryos should only be used in extreme circumstances. If the natural method of conception isn't possible in parents then I believe genetic engineering should be a last resort, but only enough genetic selection should take part to provide a healthy child not to give this child any foreseen advantages over other children.…

    • 720 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Bioethics Paper: Prenatal Genetic Screening
    • 651 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Bioethics Paper: Prenatal Genetic Screening

    Others question the effectiveness and benefits of genetic screening and wonder if the process would prompt undue emotional distress, distress for the safety of the fetus and also the issue of…

    • 651 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Image Analysis
    • 486 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Image Analysis

    So the question we now face is, is it ethical to genetically engineer a child? Should embryos with potential risk be discarded without knowing, with all certainty, that there will be future problems? These embryos could end up growing into adulthood, living until 40 – 50 years of age before a problem ever occurs.…

    • 486 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    My Sister Keeper
    • 715 Words
    • 3 Pages

    My Sister Keeper

    Kate Fitzgerald was diagnosed suffering from leukemia when she was 2 years old. The doctors said to Sara and Brian, her parents, that there is maybe a solution to save Kate; have a genetic baby. Since Anna was born, she had a lot of operations to save her sister. Kate turns 15 and she has a renal failure and Anna knows that the only person who cans help Kate is she and she knows that their parents will force her to donate one of her kidneys. She realizes that if she does the operation, she will not have the life that she wants to have, she will not be able to have kids or even to play some sports. With Kate’s illness, Sara forgets to care about Anna and Jesse, Anna and Kate’s big brother, because she is concerned to keep Kate alive. Sara and Brian are shocked when they find out that Anna took a lawyer to sue her parents for infringement of the rights of her own body. Later during the film we learn that he agreed to take the case not for the notoriety, but because he is epileptic and he knows what is to not having his own body control. Sara gets furious, she can not understand Anna’s decision and why she does not want to save her sister.…

    • 715 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    The Labeling Theory In The Movie 'Orphan'
    • 763 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The Labeling Theory In The Movie 'Orphan'

    Esther has a history of disguising herself as a little girl, hurting several families, and trying to seduce the fathers but fails to. Kate was in the hospital when she found this information out and rushed home to…

    • 763 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Utilitarianism and Genetic Engineering
    • 1595 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Utilitarianism and Genetic Engineering

    In the past thirty years, humans are witnessing a huge revolution in the genetic engineering industry. Having identified most of the Human Genome, gene sequencing has become programmed and extremely fast, and laboratory techniques in molecular biology allow for in-vitro fertilization and transfer of genetic material. Gene therapy and repair based on stem cells research allows for replacement of a defected allele in the DNA, and even a whole damaged tissue in the patient. In general, it is accurate to say that genetic engineering is a controversial topic about which people tend to have strong opinions. The genetic engineering issues that mainly catch the attention of the moral community involve the pre-birth improvement of human fetuses. The ability to screen for detectable diseases is already available in the laboratories. Fertility clinics are also currently able to satisfy the need of a couple for conceiving a male or female child, following the parents’ request, but this is routine compared to the potential of genetic engineering, whose avant-garde aim is the selection of specific traits such as hair color, height and even intelligence. It is this selection that is the most fascinating upshot of advances in genetic engineering, but also the most difficult genetic issue facing the moral society.…

    • 1595 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More

Related Topics