top-rated free essay

Book Critique

By CarnesW Mar 03, 2009 1093 Words
Will Carnes
Into to Education

My thesis statement was developed after reading Herbert Kohl’s book, Stupidity and Tears. Mr. Kohl wrote this book after years in the education field. He reflects on his experience as a young teacher in the inner city systems of New York, his sabbatical year in Italy stretching himself to write about his experiences, many of them about students that he had taught. He then describes his current efforts to create a new kind of teaching program associated with the University of San Francisco which is unique in its philosophy and its style of grooming teachers to push beyond the expected in education. As a result of reading this book, I would question if in inner city schools, teachers were permitted to challenge the standard system, add creative thought to their lesson plans and teaching approaches and still adhere to the school system’s required curriculum, would this change the learning environment to be more successful for the students and the school system as a whole?

There is a premise that in many inner city schools, particularly underperforming schools, that the school curriculum is based on a strict curriculum that is put in place by local, state, political and teacher union mandates in order to address the poor performance and improve the results of the school program. However, many mandates do not consider the differing abilities and contributions that teachers can bring to the table, nor do they account for the many profiles of the students that are in the classroom which directly impact their success to learning. Herbert Kohl is a lifelong educator, who has taught in many inner city school systems and established the Institute for Social Justice and Education at the University of San Francisco. He believes that without being a little rebellious, challenging the norms, and allowing for creativity in the classroom with a solid understanding of the social environment that the students live in every day, that effective and successful teaching cannot be accomplished. In his book, he questions whether, “creating stupid teachers perpetuates stupidity in the classroom and keep stupid systems of education functioning”. (p.11) Stupidity is not defined as ignorance, but is the act of being hindered by a system of learning for both the student and the teacher. This system does not allow for adjustments, unusual teaching methods and imagination, gearing learning to the specific needs of the students. Instead of encouraging teachers to push beyond barriers, it reinforces acting like robots where anyone could deliver a prepared lesson. When programs do not encourage a student from feeling stupid, discouragement trickles down to feelings of inadequacy, frustration and lack of confidence. School is just the beginning of building those qualities to hopefully develop a student into being successful in life. Most successful people have a good sense of worth, and have confidence. Those traits can be nurtured in a creative, imaginative school environment.

There are instances where very imaginative and creative teachers have taken on a classroom of students that traditionally have failed and turned their learning to be positive and successful, yet are being shut down because they were not strictly conforming to the system curriculum mandates. The end result in some of these cases is discouraging a gifted teacher from flourishing and questioning his/her ability to be an effective teacher and an inspired teacher. It is also failing the students further by not providing an environment where they were succeeding. In some examples, teachers are actually moved to different schools for being successful because they were being a rebel by challenging the standards.

The realization is that school systems need to examine themselves and decide what will succeed and what fails. Education reforms often are pushed through under the auspices of the fear that our nation’s economic competitiveness is being derailed by unsuccessful school systems. Mr. Kohl goes on to suggest, “Obsession with national power distorts people’s perceptions of the problems youngsters face in schools, and most reform proposals end up by leaving out the concern for the quality of the children’s lives.” (p. 31)

1. There must be a progressive approach to change our educational system to critique and address current shortcomings, failings, and discriminatory practices. The approach must be grounded in ideals of social justice, equality in education, and a dedication to facilitating educational experiences where all students reach their full potential as learners and as socially aware and active people. Teacher-education programs must adopt new ways to approach education and help either new teachers or experienced teachers redefine the environment in which students learn and students succeed. You must start with teachers who believe in this type of social change so they can support each others ideas, collaborate on change and make adjustments when approaches are not working. Creating bonds infuses energy into this type of effort so that teachers are equipped to take on established, failing programs and believe that they can learn from set backs. They should feel energized to forge on to reach their goals of developing learning programs for students that reflect their everyday challenges and find the seed of a learner in them and make them feel OK that they can be a student and not feel the pressure of their peers that it isn’t acceptable to succeed in school. The new design of a student program has to be creative, but still adhere to the mandates that oversee education systems. Kohl believes that his program at the University of San Francisco is succeeding in developing a new generation of teachers where “their creative role in drawing from many radical democratic traditions, their own experiences, and the voices from within the communities they serve in order to make effective and excellent education for their students”.( page 149-150) The aim is for teachers to learn to act within the defined programs, but not ignore their feelings, their concerns, their guts so that they can react, encourage, inspire young learners to embrace education and become successful. This is particularly true in inner cities where support systems are not always readily available outside of school. If in inner city schools, teachers are permitted to challenge the standard system, add creative thought to their lesson plans and teaching approaches while adhering to the school system’s required curriculum, they could effect change in the learning environment of inner city schools to be more successful for the students and the school system as a whole.

Work Cited:
Stupidity and Tears, Herbert Kohl, the New Press, NY 2003

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Books

    ...Title: Books What are books? Well the answer is pretty simple which is books are a set of written, printed, illustrated, or blank sheets, made of ink, paper, parchment, or other materials, usually fastened together to hinge at one side. Books are available everywhere. We can get them at a bookstore, library, school and many more places. ...

    Read More
  • Critique Essay

    ... In Studio Art, students receive harsh criticism on their work by their fellow classmates. Some may say critiques are too judgmental and could effect on certain students. But ultimately, critiques have a chance to bring more confidence on students when presenting their own work. Once a student presents their work in front of the class, critic...

    Read More
  • Books

    ...touch" I am sure you all must have heard this definition in the movie 3 idiots. yes this is the dictionary definition for a book. But in reality a book is much much simpler than this. Today my speech is all going to be about persuade each and everyone of you to start developing this habit of reading books. The reason why I chose this topic ...

    Read More
  • Function of E-Book

    ...functions of E-book in teaching and learning. Books are no doubt the main element in teaching and learning activities. As we all know printed books have already been used for a very long time. However in this modern era, books in electronic forms (eBooks) are taking place. EBooks had already been introduced not only for adults but children ...

    Read More
  • Banned Books

    ...Mr. Harkins English 111 22June2012 Banned Books Banned books are becoming more current in this day of time. People often do not understand the challenge of books or why a book is being banned. Ken Petrilli, the author of “Banned Books Week: Celebrating You (and Celebrating Your (and Your Teens!) Freedom to Read” in the Young Adult Libr...

    Read More
  • Community Book Festival

    ...Community Book Festival According to the United States Census Bureau (2013), Queens, New York, has an estimated population of 2.2 million people living in this growing region. With a large population like this, it would be an ideal place to promote reading by conducting a book festival for the community. Not only will the book festival promot...

    Read More
  • How to Create a Smash Book

    ...How to create a smash book How to create a smash book, not a scrapbook. A smash book is a place where you can place the little things in life’ ticket stubs, magazine clips, recipes, snapshots, love letters, design ideas, pictures, and notes to self. It is faster than scrap booking and is portable too. A smash book can be made from a ringe...

    Read More
  • Internet and Books and time. Back in the early 19th century, when electronic devices had not been invented, the population could only use printed word such as books, posters, newspapers or magazines, to gather information. Later, in the mid 20th century, the use of computers, televisions and radios helped people to know about the incidents happening all aroun...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.