Preview

Bernard Bailyn's Interpretation of the American Revolution

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1762 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Bernard Bailyn's Interpretation of the American Revolution
Introduction No one will argue that the American Revolution was one of the most significant events in shaping American ideology. The impact on the economy, sociological and ideological make-up of America are still seen in today's society. Many great minds have passed commentary on the causes and impacts of the American Revolution such as; Bernard Bailyn, Louis Hartz, Joyce Appleby, and Gordon Wood. This research examines why these experts believed what they did about the causes of the American Revolution and how we can correlate those causes to the economic and political crisis America is now facing in the 21st century as compared to the 18th century.
Literature Review The Revolutionary War physically started in 1775 and ended in 1783, however radical ideas and the beginning of anti-British feelings started at least a decade before the revolution actually took place. In Bernard Bailyn's work, "The Ideological Origins of the American Revolution", he first attributes American political thought to the pamphlets that circulated throughout England and the American colonies. These pamphlets enabled revolutionary writers to openly express themselves and their ideas and above all, not be made to follow a strict pattern as newspaper articles and periodicals usually did. While other forms of communication still existed, "it was in this form- as pamphlets- that much of the most important and characteristic writing of the American Revolution appeared."[1] They were a means for writers and thinkers to exchange ideas and refute each other's arguments on political theory. Pamphlets written by American colonists were often viewed as crude and nothing more than amateur literature compared to the practiced technique and artful literary constructions of the Englishmen. The major reason why American pamphleteers were more outspoken in their writings was because they were more readily able to write exactly how they felt about the British crown and the changes that should be made

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Gary Nash

    • 885 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In the essay written by Gary Nash, he argues that the reason for the American Revolution was not caused by the defense of constitutional rights and liberties, but that of "material conditions of life in America" were not very favorable and that social and economic factors should be considered as the driving factor that pushed many colonists to revolt. The popular ideology which can be defined as resonating "most strongly within the middle and lower strata of society and went far beyond constitutional rights to a discussion of the proper distribution of wealth and power in the social system" had a dynamic role in the decisions of many people to revolt. The masses ideas were not of constitutional rights, but the equal distribution of wealth in the colonies that many felt that the wealth was concentrated in a small percentage of the population in the colonies. The Whig ideology that was long established in English society had a main appeal towards the upper class citizens and "had little to say about changing social and economic conditions in America or the need for change in the future." The popular ideologies consisted of new ways of changing the distribution of wealth. Nash in his essay continued to give good evidence to prove his point that the American Revolution was not caused by the defense of constitutional rights and liberties, but by improper distribution of wealth. During the pre-American Revolutionary times, the "top five percent of Boston's taxpayers controlled 49 percent of the taxable assets of the community, whereas they had held only held only 30 percent in 1687." As evident by this statistic, it is clear that the wealthy were getting wealthier and controlling more of the taxable assets of the community. As the wealthy increased their assets in the cities, at the same time, a large class was "impoverished city dwellers." A huge contrast between the wealthy and the poor were forming and becoming more apparent from the beginning of the eighteenth…

    • 885 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The American Revolution was a war between Great Britain and the American Colonies. The American Revolutionary war was started because the colonist wanted to be free from England. The colonist rose up against the English soldiers in the army on April 19th 1775. The American Revolution ended on September 3rd 1783. Today I will be discussing three documents that I analyzed for this assignment. These documents lead to ending the American Revolutionary War which gave the Americans their freedom.…

    • 457 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Woods Pulitzer Prize winning account of U.S. society during the time of the American Revolution, he shows how the Revolution was not merely a coup de taut but a complete remodeling of social structure and organization. In Woods opinion the American Revolution was as radical as any revolution in history. The Revolution was very different from other revolutions, in that the British monarchy was being replaced by an American Republic and not another tyrant. “In fact, it was of the greatest revolutions the word has known, a momentous upheaval that not only fundamentally altered the character of American society but decisively affected the course of subsequent history” (Woods 5).…

    • 887 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The title, 1775: A Good Year for Revolution, may sound like a more modest undertaking, though its size -- well over 500 pages -- indicates otherwise. In some sense, the argument is simple: 1775, not 1776, was the real hinge of American history, the moment when independence transformed from a possibility to a reality. Indeed, it was only the tremendous sense of momentum that came out of 1775, especially in terms of the string of victories Phillips dubs "the Battle of Boston," that allowed the Patriot cause to absorb the many military blows that followed the Declaration, years in which the "rage militaire" (Phillips) of '75 largely dissipated, especially in the South. "The spirit of '76," by contrast, was a bicentennial marketing device. But the scope of the book is in fact much wider. Phillips offers a sweeping interpretation of the coming of the Revolution that encompasses familiar topics like politics and economics as well as less familiar ones like the logistics of international gunpowder supply and naval tactics. He also foregrounds the interplay between culture and geography, paying special attention to the dynamics of Massachusetts, Connecticut, Virginia and South Carolina, whose role he sees as pivotal (Connecticut and South Carolina too often overlooked). There's also a fine chapter on the…

    • 1412 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Throughout the history of the United States of America, the American Revolutionary War was undoubtedly the event that was most impactful and decisive towards the ultimate fate of this country. Without it, this country wouldn’t have seen its formation in the first place. It began in the 1750’s and 1760’s, when British colonists who settled in the 13 colonies became fed up with British rule, taxation, and laws set on them. For example, when the taxes for tea were imposed on the colonies, a large majority started revolting, and strived for liberty from the British, so that they could govern themselves and create their own laws. As a result, many who lived in the colonies, including famous patriots, eventually sparked a revolution until a full-out…

    • 2389 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    It all started with a propagandist writing one pamphlet that was made by an anonymous English man. This person didn’t just make the revolutionists more boastful and proud of themselves and made the bestseller of the 18th century, but he ignited them to split away from England and persuaded them to go on the road to freedom. This man was Thomas Paine, one of the most famous writers and founding fathers of this country. Thomas Paine was a founding father who has contributed to the war by writing two pamphlets, Common Sense and The American Crisis, writing articles, and donating money. Even thought he is an English Quaker, he still believes in the cause. As Thomas Paine writes in Common Sense, “In England…

    • 1359 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Revolutionary war occurred for many reasons- economics, the need for expansion, etc. However, before it occurred there was a period of time wherein the contention between Britain and her colonies was expressed in a war of words. While the events that would set into motion the revolution occurred, there was constant commentary from the people who lived through them and those who merely had an opinion.…

    • 2812 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Patrick Henry Dbq

    • 2948 Words
    • 12 Pages

    A complex mythology has been built up around the American Revolution: it is a national story of great significance to the way the United States views itself. But the mythology is just that - a mythology. Contrary to the picture presented in American primary schools, the Americans were not a separate, turkey-eating people, subjugated by the cruel, tyrannical and essentially foreign British. In fact, many colonists thought of themselves as British. Historians accept that the American Revolution had a wide variety of motives and causes: these included slightly differing political traditions, the economic interests of both parties, the trading interests of those directly or indirectly involved in transatlantic commerce, the large…

    • 2948 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Through Gordon Wood’s work, entitled The Radicalism of the American Revolution, I am convinced that the American Revolution was the most radical event that occurred in American history. In the face of the ways and basis of other revolutions that occurred in history, the American Revolution was unlike any other major rebellion of the past for it completely shaped our nation’s foundations for the future. The revolution sought drastically different ideologies within the nations politics, society and culture. The American Revolution was as radical as any revolution in modern history, for it replaced monarchical authority with representative government and created a society that was far more democratic than even the founding fathers had anticipated. These new ways of thinking are why Gordon Wood strongly believes that the American Revolution was "the most radical and far-reaching event in American history".…

    • 738 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The American Revolution displayed certain stages throughout that matched with the broad general pattern. As a prelude before the Revolution itself, there were already preliminary symptoms of unrest within America that followed the first step in the general pattern of revolutions. Prior to the initial shots in 1775, growing discontent against the British Government who were passing certain acts that the Americans thought as very unfair had already risen to a high degree. With the majority of acts incurring economic and financial costs, by 1767, the Townshend Acts had been passed, putting further taxes on paper, glass and tea. Upon the taxes that the Stamp Act of 1965 incurred on such items as newspapers, official documents and almanacs, the American people became highly agitated and a feeling of resentment quickly spilled over the masses, ‘several person were for dying rather than submitting to it...’ [pg52 Maier, P.] Additionally, the Colonialist became increasingly violent, ‘Almost immediately after the Acts [implementation], outbreak of mob activity. By 1770, the preliminary symptom of unrest displayed through protest and discontent was evident. The Colonialist did not feel that they were obligated to be subject to these taxes without representation in British Parliament. Additionally, the psychological pre-condition associated with the cause of war was present in the Colonialist discontent regarding the numerous Acts bearing economic consequences. Not only had the events up till 1770 displayed active protests and early mob activity, it also hinted at the potential oncoming violence the growing mob could inflict which was the next step in the general broad pattern of revolutions.…

    • 1506 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A prevalent question that comes up while studying America’s past is “was the American Revolution a true revolution?”. Depending on the whether the historian sides with the theory of a strict or loose constructionist, the answer will vary. Strict constructionists tend to believe that a revolution produces a significant end result whereas loose constructionists refer to any type of violence in conjunction with a constitution, rulers, or policies. This differentiation leads to the topics of conservatism and radicalism. In correlation with the American revolution, conservatists claim that the outcome of the revolution was nothing great. On the other hand, radicalists feel that the changes after the revolution were extraordinary. Pulitzer Prize-winning Carl N. Delger agrees with the conservatists…

    • 759 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Since the colonies suffered more due to the economic reason, it can be concluded that the American Revolution was caused more by economic reasons than political…

    • 309 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    American Revolution, started from New England to the South, culminated with the Declaration of Independence. Both spiritual and economic factors exerted crucial influences on this monumental event. American Revolution was doomed to be launched. Economically, benefits of both upper-classes and lower-classes were offended respectively by Great Britain dominators and English businessmen.…

    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    America’s Revolution seemed like a wonderful celebration ! 1765- 1782, when America’s thirteen colonies fought back and took their independence from Great Britain ! But have you ever thought that the american revolution was a mistake? Most people would disagree and say that it was the right thing to do since the king, George III, were taxing them too harshly, yet it was their fault that the taxing was even existent !…

    • 180 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    The American Revolution embarked the beginning of the United States of America. A war that lasted eight years, 1775-1783, was able to grant the thirteen colonies the independence they deserved by breaking free of British rule. The war was an effect of the previous French and Indian War, which forced England to tax the American colonist, compelling them to rebel against parliament. From the 1760’s to 1775, many factors lead up to the American Revolution such as the various acts the British Parliament passed to pay the war debt, no representation in parliament, and the American people wanting to gain their independence. “No Taxation without Representation”, a slogan used by the American colonist, was the most important cause of the colonists declaring war for their independence on the British government.…

    • 1116 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays