Top-Rated Free Essay

"Beowulf" vs "The 13th Warrior" Comparison

Good Essays
Beowulf and the 13th Warrior are two stories that are centered around the Anglo-Saxon culture and even though they have many things in common, there are a few key differences to the stories. These are two great stories that portray the Anglo-Saxon culture very well. The two stories both show good and evil, different companions, and how they memorialize the dead. The written story, Beowulf, can only describe some of the gruesome details. The movie however brought out some of those details into full light. Such as, when the North Men pass around their "community bowl." It does not seem vastly surprising if that had actually occurred in the barbaric culture. Even though the Anglo-Saxon people seem barbaric they are still quite an organized culture.

Beowulf is quite different in how it portrays good and evil than its counterpart 13th Warrior. In Beowulf from the beginning it is very clearly defined who the hero is going to be. Beowulf always knows exactly what kind of evil he is going up against every time he fought. The people had told Beowulf about Grendel, Grendel's mom and the dragon. This is rather different in the 13th Warrior. In 13th Warrior Ahmad doesn't even want to go on an adventure, and even when he is called upon by the north men to go help king Hrogarth. When Ahmad gets Denmark he does not even know what he is supposed to be fighting. He is called there to talk after all, not fight.

Beowulf's companions are nowhere near as capable as Ahmad's. Beowulf gives his fellow companions all their equipment and has brought them from the bottom up. Beowulf's fellow warriors always tag along during his adventures, but when he needs them the most in his final battle, they all run except for one. Wiglaf is able to finish off the dragon, but not before it kills Beowulf. In 13th warrior, the companions of Ahmad are extremely strong both physically and mentally. In the movie one of the warriors got their head ripped clean off and it did not even faze the other warriors. In modern day, even in combat this would be a huge psychological factor to see one of your fellow companions get his head ripped off, but in this battle the other soldiers kept fighting like nothing had happened. All of the warriors would all fight and die for each other as some of them did throughout the movies. The same could not be said about Beowulf and his "friends."

There are a lot of similarities in Beowulf and the 13th warrior in how they memorialized the dead. In Beowulf after Beowulf dies he leaves the throne to Wiglaf who is said to be one of the last great geats. Before Beowulf died he wished for a great memorial to be built in his honor. This is extremely important in the Anglo-Saxon culture because with a memorial he could live forever through memories. Beowulf is cremated and had his ashes along with the great treasure he had collected from having the dragon killed inside the memorial. In the 13th warrior, Bulwyne is one of the better warriors and died in the final battle of the movie. Bulwyne wanted to die like a king and got his wish, at the end of the battle he with the Wendols, he is seen sitting on the throne. He is also cremated like Beowulf.

These are great stories that portray the Anglo-Saxon culture quite well. The movie really brought out some of the detail that the story just could necessarily portray. The 13th Warrior and Beowulf have many things to compare and contrast, however the comparisons between good and evil, different companions, and how they memorialize the dead stuck out the most. The Anglo-Saxon people are a strong and courageous people that had truly heroic values. The story and movie really brought out the true Anglo-Saxons.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The Comparison of “Beowulf” and “13th Warrior” Beowulf is an epic poem written a long time ago. The 13th Warrior is pretty much a movie based on Beowulf but not exactly. The two pieces of literature both shared a lot of differences and similarities as well. The 13th Warrior offered a more realistic, believable, and more understanding of the epic tale of Beowulf. It’s a short story covering the bases of a triumphant hero battling three supernatural monsters. But there had a lot of theatrical remake…

    • 885 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Not every book has something in common with another, but some have so much in common they could be the same book. In The 13th warrior and in Beowulf there seems to be some slight differences, but there are also some major similarities. Beowulf and The 13th Warrior are two completely different stories but yet seem to have so much in common. While both The 13th warrior and Beowulf are based on the same topic, they both have very different views of fighting and winning. One similarity that remains the…

    • 480 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The epic poem "Beowulf" and the motion picture "The 13th Warrior" are both very similar and at the same time distinct in various aspects. Both show how ordinary warriors become heroes and not necesssarily of the epic type. As well as how they differ in the way the plot occurs and how characterization is changed within the movie. Epic poem "Beowulf" and movie "The 13th Warrior" both take place in Hrothgar, an Anlgo-Saxon medieval town terrorized by malevolent demons. In "Beowulf" Hrothgar is terrorized…

    • 463 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Beowulf vs 13th Warrior

    • 410 Words
    • 2 Pages

    reading the poem Beowulf and watching the movie The 13th Warrior, I have found many similarities and a vast variety of differences. In both the poem and the movie the theme of good versus evil remains the same, reflecting the values of Anglo Saxons. The many differences throughout the poem and movie include character names, battles, and the way the heroes die. The most obvious difference between the two is the name of the heroes and their battling strengths. In the poem, Beowulf, the hero is known…

    • 410 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    between the story of Beowulf and The 13th Warrior written by a Christian Monk and the story called Eaters of the Dead what was later know as The 13th Warrior written by Ibn Fadlan who was Moslem which was later written by Michael Crichton. Then there was a movie called The 13th Warrior. The two things that will be compared and contrasted are going to be the movie of The 13th Warrior and the Epic of Beowulf. Instead of doing a translation of Beowulf, the writer of the "The 13th Warrior" used his creativity…

    • 856 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Beowulf and The 13th Warrior: Differences and Similarities Beowulf and the 13th Warrior, both are very good stories, one legibly and the other visually (unless you go to the roots of the 13th Warrior and read Eaters of the Dead). Although it is pretty obvious to anyone who has read Beowulf that the 13th Warrior was based on this great epic, there are still several differences that make for an interesting twist or two. While the two stories are very much alike in several ways, they are also very…

    • 1132 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    While both, the poem Beowulf and the movie The 13th Warrior seek for the need of an epic hero, fame is what Beowulf and Buliwyf desire. In the poem Beowulf , Beowulf hears of Grendel terrorising the Danes. Beowulf, showing his bravery steps up as the brave man he is. “Proclaiming that he’d go to that famous king, would sail across the sea to Hrothgar, now when help was needed” (lines 114 - 116) These lines show that Beowulf is desperate for fame. Unlike in The 13th Warrior Buliwyf bravery is not…

    • 369 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After the poem Beowulf (the destroyer of monsters, an Old English heroic epic poem of a courageous and powerful, well known warrior), and the movie The Thirteenth warrior (an Arab accompanies a band of Northmen in a quest to destroy the Wendol, Based on the book Eaters of the dead, which is a playful version of the Anglo-Saxon epic poem Beowulf.) you can notice a similar story plot between them. Beowulf dated between the 8th and the early 11th century, takes place in Denmark and Sweden. It begins…

    • 782 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Beowulf and The 13th Warrior have a various amount of similarities and differences. Beowulf is an epic told about the great achievements of the great hero, Beowulf. The 13th Warrior is a movie based on only one major character from Beowulf but instead, the main character is a poet named Ibn. The differences of the main characters, battle occurrences, conclusions, and the similarities of the characters, battles, and the results make up the majority of the major similarities and differences. The similarities…

    • 488 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    13th Warrior Culture

    • 1012 Words
    • 5 Pages

    What elements of Anglo-Saxon culture are evident in The 13th Warrior? The movie is a third person view of the uncultured northmen society. The Norse warriors are shown as brave warriors who fight for glory. The loyalty displayed by each man to his fellow warrior is astonishing.The 13th Warrior shows an superb variety of elements from the culture of the Anglo-Saxon people. Seen through the eyes of Ahmad ibn Fadlan, a Muslim ambassador whom has been exiled from his land, he enters a strange land full…

    • 1012 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays