Preview

Attack on Culture

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
587 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Attack on Culture
Written Reflection: The Reconstruction Era: 500 Nations, Attack on Culture The attack on culture is taught so much differently when you are learning about such things in regular, high school history classes. We are given an idea of how the Natives were thrown from their land and homes, but not a lot of in depth information to it. Many Natives welcomes the White people onto their land and into their homes, willingly, offering help and a kind hand. This is something that is not completely understood by anyone currently living today, and is not thought about often. We have lived with the idea that we are the true Americans and this is our rightful home. What we need to look deeper into is that this is slightly untrue, and we tore this land from it’s true, giving and loving Natives. So what is the truth, who is in the wrong and what should have been done? When the white people came to this land, there were many people already living here and thriving off the land. Unable to take care of themselves they turned to the Natives for help. The natives were more than willing to give a helpful hand to the new settlers, known as the white people, with nothing in return but friendship. Although we brought with us many diseases that killed many of the Natives that were here, they continued to help. When the white settlers traveled West, the Natives along the way took them in, fed them, harbored them, and helped them along their journey to another land. Suddenly, without notice or reasons the US Army and United States forced the Natives to other lands, killing their families, taking away their freedom and imprisoning them to use as slaves and death. Why would they do such a thing to people who were so willing to offer help and guidence in a time of need? Chief Joseph, of the Nez Perce people in Wallawo Valley, Oregon, is such a great example in showing exactly how these people were wronged. Although he knew of the awful behaviors the white men were engaging in to go

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Chief Joseph gave a very concerned speech on a trip to Washington in 1879. Analyzing Chief Joseph’s speech, proves the point that Native Americans were not being treated equally by any means. In the event that you read the speech aloud you can hear the sorrowfulness and worrisome and extreme concern Chief Joseph has regarding his people. During the migration the Native Americans were a part of a process called forced assimilation which basically made them move to different areas. At this point the Native Americans were furious because they were poor and most of the time on the verge of starving. Considering what the Native Americans were put through they made the decision to attack the migrating Americans. Of course these actions led to casualties and not just Native Americans. In fact there were 70-90 casualties in the Battle of the Big Hole which primarily effected the Nez Percé tribe. Unfortunately, Chief Joseph said “If I cannot go to my own home, let me have a home in a country where my people will not die so fast.” He also adds, “Whenever the white man treats the Indian as they treat each other then we shall have no more wars.” Chief Joseph is just emphasizing the fact that once the Native Americans are treated equally there will be no more violence. Finally in 1885, the Nez percé were allowed to return to the pacific northwest. However, Chief Joseph did not go to the Nez percé reservation instead Joseph settled at the…

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Chief Joseph-Leader of The Nez Perce tribe. He was continuously fighting for the civil rights of the Native Americans. He spoke to several government officials concerning the Native Americans right to their land. He spoke out strongly against confining them to reservations. Chief Joseph spoke about how every man deserved to be free. He continued his plight and the plight of his people to return to Oregon until he died.…

    • 173 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The land that was once thought to be sacred by the Indians now became a burial ground that grew more and more every time the Europeans pushed into new territory. More and more Indians were shot down with their blood spilling all over the fertile soil that once grew crops for everyone to share. What’s ironic is that all the Europeans wanted was to have land that would grow everything that they ever needed and to get away from the horrid leadership of the war driven parliament in Britain. But instead of getting brand new fresh land, they befriended the natives, made sure that the land was good and there was plenty of meat to go around and lots of space, and then they completely betrayed the friends that they had made in the new world. They turned the beautiful and amazing ecosystem that they had wanted and could have very easily shared with the locals into a battleground that eventually expanded further and further. And with the American Indians practicing resistance fighting and them having no weapons to fight back against them with when they needed to, there was never a fighting chance. And as the battleground pushed further and further into America, behind it was laid down a breeding ground for industrial cities and bustling towns that completely destroyed what the Native Americans had worked so hard to achieve and…

    • 775 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The natives lay on the cold, damp earth, taking in their final breaths, before their hearts ceased beating, and came their demise. The Wounded Knee Massacre was one of the biggest and most violent confrontations between the Native Americans and the American people and government. It claimed as many as 300 or more of the 350 Indian lives in Wounded Knee Creek, South Dakota, and half of those killed were women and children. It was the final major clash between the Native Americans and the U.S. military, and it finally proved that white men are the “true savages” of humankind. Yes, the Native Americans’ resistance was justified. White Americans brought many atrocities upon the Native American people. The white men gave them unfulfilled promises, purloined their lands and decimated their people.…

    • 622 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    (Doc 3.) And now the current land in the fort laramie treaty which is considerably smaller than the original is being taken again by the keystone pipeline it runs right through the natives land.(Native tribes unite… Robert boos) And finally the sand creek massacre was the nail in the coffin for native being treated well here us troops killed 200 native most being women and children. For there land which was known to have gold on it. (Doc 2.) Therefore Natives want to keep their original land because they have been on it for generations.The second way Native americans were impacted by westward expansion was in there culture. For example one of the leading causes to the demise of the native was the extinction of the the buffalo This was one of the leading causes to the demise of the natives Because the buffalo was their main resource do to the fact that the hard plains soil was difficult for their primitive tool to cut into which made large scale farming impossible. (Doc 5) Also natives were assimilated into white culture they cut their hair and change…

    • 596 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cassandra, I agreed with your thought on how white settlers were feeling toward Natives, versus slaves, which made the difference in the success of Antislavery movement and Native Americans' resistance to removal. Most Whites at that time hold the thought that Natives were not as civilized (or even civilized at all) as them. However, they still somewhat feared the Natives, because they had the legitimate reasons and the power to fight for the land. Natives were the original residents, people in the tribe lived together, they already established a society and their own belief. They would definitely fight to keep those things intact.…

    • 512 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I am writing this letter to you with the intent of helping you understand the finer points of what it has been to be a Native American throughout history. Our experience has been less than desirable since the 1400’s when Columbus arrived with his men and 17 ships. According to Churchill (1994), upon Columbus’s arrival, he was quick to enslave and exterminate the Native Americans; the Spanish colonists instilled their “superiority” through these acts. But it wasn’t just explorers that assisted in the demise of the American Indians, the European colonists killed 50%-90% of every tribe in North America from diseases such as Smallpox and Influenza (Delema, 2005). When the Europeans began coming over they viewed America as land for the taking. Native Americans were viewed as “savages” and needed to be eliminated (Delema, 2005).…

    • 929 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Imagine you an Native American working around your house just peacefully doing what you have to do. Then you see some settlers walking on your land with a gun ordering you out of your land. If you were that Native American what would you do? Native Americans once had all their land and were living peacefully then they signed a piece of paper and lost it all and got moved away. Then settlers and miners kept on taking and taking and taking their land away from them breaking the paper the Natives signed. This conflict could have been avoided if the Americans communicated better and treated the Native Americans Better. This conflict occurred because of the concept of superiority, land ownership, and gathering food.…

    • 812 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    According to Treaty Time at Nisqually by Cecilia Smith Carpenter, “The treaty team had met with the Nisqually people and had told them they would have a choice of which lands. But when the Nisqually people arrived at the treaty grounds, the reserved lands had been decided for them.” This shows that settlers didn’t really care for the natives. They thought of the natives as just more people they can manipulate to gain land from. This caused the natives to conflict with the settlers to get their preferred land back. In addition, in The Washington Journey on page 96, “In time, many children lost the ability to speak their native language. They felt like outcasts when they returned to their families and were unable to speak to them.” This shows how great of an impact the United States had on the natives, they had such an impact that the natives kids, forgot their own language. This may have caused the natives to conflict with the United States over how they turned their own children into American settlers who forgot almost everything about their culture and…

    • 541 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Trail Of Tears

    • 870 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Removing the Cherokees from their original home was disgraceful choice made by the United States government. Forcing the Cherokees out of their rightful land just so they could use it for resources they didn’t currently have access to was tragic. Historian Richard White said…

    • 870 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Trail of Tears

    • 1622 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The Indian Removal Act and the “Trail of Tears” was one of the worst tragedies in American history. It shows that the US government was forcing Native Americans to move from their homelands and endure great hardships of famine, cold and harsh weather, long treks on foot, and unfamiliar places with no regards to their safety, culture, history and wellbeing. Since the settling of North America by European colonists, relations between Native Americans and their increasing neighbors had been a bone of contention. While various groups were able to maintain peaceful relationships for a short time, the most general and often remembered state is one of hostility and disagreement. Both before and after its forming, the United States would encroach upon lands owned by Native Americans, ignoring treaties and guarantees made prior. In the more pleasant cases, settlers simply moved in and claimed land. In some less pleasant situations, whole tribes were killed or forced to move. The Native Americans had to leave their homelands, were forced on a dangerous, deadly journey, and shoved in a new land with which they were not comfortable.…

    • 1622 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the major “selling points” for mistreatment and the removal of Native Americans was that they were a alien like people who were uncivilized and simple. The dislike for the Native Americans was apparent well before the Indian Removal Act, many presidents before Jackson had talked of the importance of europeanizing the Native Americans. Settlers came to know this as the “Indian Problem,” and their solution for this “problem” was to civilize the Natives by teaching them european ways including, conversion to christianity, teaching them english, western farming and western gender roles. In relation to the Indian Removal Act, the “Indian Problem” was still just merely an excuse for settlers to remove Natives from land that they wanted. Around…

    • 359 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Native American Benefits

    • 690 Words
    • 3 Pages

    When the colonist first arrived they immediately attempted to maintain control of the land that the natives have first come upon before the colonist did. When they addressed this idea to the natives, they Immediately rejected it. From there, the colonists wiped out a huge population of the Native Americans by many different ways. First the natives had no immunity to the diseases that the colonist have carried along with them. The diseases that killed hundreds of the Native Americans were most commonly measles, smallpox, influenza. The colonist had also resulted in such horrific manners. Colonists attacked the natives by harassing them as well as killing thousands they killed the natives for land, racial beliefs, and lastly because they saw an opportunity of wealth. They also took some of the natives into slavery to work on their plantations on farms that the colonist had built on their land. Over all colonies showed no remorse for the Natives, they didn't give them a opportunity to have a say, never the less give them a opportunity to adjust to their new life…

    • 690 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Native Americans had been an old culture in America 2000 years ago. The first British settlers, the Jackson Administration, and the Westward expansion had no right to remove the Native Americans from their land. Nor did they have the right to attack Native Americans and start wars against them for land. What if aliens from another planet were to come to take over Earth because they needed our land and resources? How would we react and feel?In the process of taking their lands, Native Americans were highly discriminated against and mistreated. They were forced out of their lands, sometimes without a notice in advance, and had to take long journeys to reservations unprepared. An example of this harsh treatment was when President Jackson in the 1820's demanded the removal of the Cherokee from their homeland in Georgia and sent them to reservations in Oklahoma and Arkansas. Their journey from their homeland to the reservations was known as the "Trail of Tears" in which 4,000 died of starvation, disease, or exposure.…

    • 457 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Over the years the White Man has come onto Native lands and gradually pushed them out, using the land for whatever they have need to. In the 1800’s the White Man has taken several rights from the American Indians and tried to keep them under control under the guise of creating harmony, and putting them on reservations as an act of control. With the creation of the Dawes Act American Indians the American government gave land to the Indians on the reservations and noted it as creating harmony, but without the knowledge of Native Americans. In the mid-1900’s with the growing populations and the continuing need the American government came into reservations and took youth off the reservations and placed them in homes to educate and intergraded them into the civilized world creating less on the reservations to be responsible for. With the idea of work and a new life away from the hardships of life on the reservations the government offered to help integrate them into city life by giving them housing and education as well as the opportunity to work. When the Indians who chose to…

    • 1635 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays