The study was well done and followed good documentation procedures and the results showed that “all three participants not only mastered the skill, but demonstrated generalization to novel people, settings and exemplars.” (Persicke, Tarbox, Ranick & St. Clair, 2013, p.197) However after working with several students in the class situation and helping some others in a group home environment, I have to pause and wonder about its importance in the much wider field of all autistic individuals with their very varied abilities. As others have mentioned the study sample was very small and I noted the selection process additionally required completion or near completion of the Skills curriculum. Would the study have shown the same results over a larger sampling and a less defined choice of individuals? The authors in their discussion area indicate as well the limitation, that other forms of deception were not used. This addition to the autism knowledge field was helpful and important for the few it impacts, personally though I’d like to have seen something that had a wider
The study was well done and followed good documentation procedures and the results showed that “all three participants not only mastered the skill, but demonstrated generalization to novel people, settings and exemplars.” (Persicke, Tarbox, Ranick & St. Clair, 2013, p.197) However after working with several students in the class situation and helping some others in a group home environment, I have to pause and wonder about its importance in the much wider field of all autistic individuals with their very varied abilities. As others have mentioned the study sample was very small and I noted the selection process additionally required completion or near completion of the Skills curriculum. Would the study have shown the same results over a larger sampling and a less defined choice of individuals? The authors in their discussion area indicate as well the limitation, that other forms of deception were not used. This addition to the autism knowledge field was helpful and important for the few it impacts, personally though I’d like to have seen something that had a wider