Journal of Pragmatics 35 (2003) 695–721 www.elsevier.com/locate/pragma
On newspaper headlines as relevance optimizers
Department of Communications, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv, Israel
Abstract This paper suggests an explanatory functional characterization of newspaper headlines. Couched within Sperber and Wilson’s (1986) relevance theory, the paper makes the claim that headlines are designed to optimize the relevance of their stories for their readers: Headlines provide the readers with the optimal ratio between contextual eﬀect and processing eﬀort, and direct readers to construct the optimal context for interpretation. The paper presents the results of an empirical study conducted in the news-desk of one daily newspaper. It shows that the set of intuitive professional imperatives, shared by news-editors and copy-editors, which dictates the choice of headlines for speciﬁc stories, can naturally be reduced to the notion of relevance optimization. The analysis explains why the construction of a successful headline requires an understanding of the readers—their state-of-knowledge, their beliefs and expectations and their cognitive styles—no less than it requires an understanding of the story. It also explains the fact that skilled newspaper readers spend most of their reading time scanning the headlines—rather than reading the stories. # 2002 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. Keywords: Headlines; Relevance theory; Pragmatics; News value; News framing; Media, communication
1. Introduction This paper is an attempt to suggest an explicit and generalized answer to a very fundamental question in the study of the mass media, i.e., the question of the communicative function of newspaper headlines. The importance of the role of headlines in the communicative act performed by newspapers can hardly be exaggerated, yet the nature of this role has virtually never been explicated in the literature. As we shall see below, the regular strategy adopted in the literature has been to make ﬁnegrained descriptive distinctions between diﬀerent types of headlines—news headlines in ‘quality newspapers’; news headlines in ‘tabloid newspapers’; ‘summarizing * Tel.: +972-3–6406521; fax: +972-3-6406032. E-mail address: firstname.lastname@example.org (D. Dor). 0378-2166/02/$ - see front matter # 2002 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. PII: S0378-2166(02)00134-0
D. Dor / Journal of Pragmatics 35 (2003) 695–721
headlines’; ‘localizing headlines’, ‘quotation headlines’, etc.—and assign them different types of communicative functions. In this paper, I will suggest an explanatory functional deﬁnition of newspaper headlines which attempts to transcend the above distinctions in type and explain the very fact that newspapers—all types of newspapers—have headlines in them. The functional deﬁnition to be developed in this paper relies very heavily on Sperber and Wilson’s (1986) technical notion of relevance. Newspaper headlines will be functionally deﬁned as relevance optimizers: Newspaper headlines are relevance optimizers: They are designed to optimize the relevance of their stories for their readers. This functional deﬁnition positions the headline in its appropriate role as a textual negotiator between the story and its readers. It explains why the construction of a successful headline requires an understanding of the readers—their state-of-knowledge, their beliefs and expectations and their cognitive styles—no less than it requires an understanding of the story. It reduces the diﬀerences between the diﬀerent subtypes of headlines mentioned above to a matter of tactical choice: As we shall see, all the diﬀerent subtypes target the same functional goal, that of relevance optimization, although they do it in diﬀerent ways. The literature on newspaper headlines covers a wide range of theoretical and empirical topics, all the way from the grammar of English headlines to the eﬀects of headlines on news comprehension...
References: Ariel, Mira, 1988. Referring and accessibility. Journal of Linguistics 24, 65–87. Ariel, Mira, 1991. The function of accessibility in a theory of grammar. Journal of Pragmatics 16, 443– 463. Bell, Allan, 1984. Good copy, bad news: the syntax and semantics of news editing. In: Trudgill, P. (Ed.), Applied Sociolinguistics. Academic Press, London. Bell, Allan, 1991. The Language of News Media. Blackwell, Oxford. Bernstein, M., Garst, R.E., 1982. Headlines are Deadlines. Columbia University Press, New York. Chang, Tsan-Kuo, Pollick, Barry, Lee, Jae-Won, 1992. The world as subjective reality: US newspaper editor’s view and its determinants. International Journal of Public Opinion Research 4 (2), 177–183. de-Knop, Sabine, 1985. Linguistic and extralinguistic aids for reconstruction and interpretation of metaphors in headlines. In: Paprotte, W., Dirven, R. (Eds.), The Ubiquity of Metaphor: Metaphor in Language and Thought. Benjamins, Amsterdam. Dierick, Jean, 1987. Equivalent messages: headlines in Le Monde and their translation into English. In: Maes-Jelinek, H., Michel, P., Michel-Michot, P. (Eds.), Multiple Worlds, Multiple Words. University of Liege, Liege. Dor, Daniel, 2001. Newspapers Under the Inﬂuence. Babel Publications (in Hebrew). Fasold, Ralph, 1987. Language policy and change: sexist language in the periodical news media. In: Georgetown University Round Table on Languages and Linguistics (GURT), 187–206. Galtung, Johan, Ruge, Mary Holmboe, 1965. The structure of foreign news. Journal of Peace Research 2 (1), 64–91. Henley, Nancy M., Miller, Michele, Beazley, Jo Anne, 1995. Syntax, semantics, and sexual violence: Agency and the passive voice. Journal of Language and Social Psychology 14 (1–2), 60–84. Iarovici, Edith, Amel, Rodica, 1989. The strategy of the headline. Semiotica 77-4, 441–459. Jenkins, Helen, 1990. Train sex man ﬁned: headlines and cataphoric ellipsis. In: Halliday, M.A.K, Gibbons, John, Nicholas, Howard (Eds.), Learning, Keeping and Using Language: Selected Papers from the 8th World Congress of Applied Linguistics, Sydney. Benjamins, Amsterdam, pp. 16–21. Kronrod, Ann, Engel, Orit, 2001. Accessibility theory and referring expressions in newspaper headlines. Journal of Pragmatics 33, 683–699. Leon, J.A., 1997. The eﬀects of headlines and summaries on news comprehension and recall. Reading and Writing 9, 2. 85–106. Lindemann, Bernard, 1989. What knowledge does it take to read a newspaper? Journal of Literary Semantics XVIII/1, 50–65. Lindemann, Bernard, 1990. Cheap thrills we live by: some notes on the poetics of tabloid headlinese. Journal of Literary Semantics 19–1, 46–59. Mardh, I., 1980. Headlinese: On the Grammar of English Front Page Headlines. CWK Gleerup, Lund. Nir, Raphael, 1993. A discourse analysis of news headlines. Hebrew Linguistics 37, 23–31 (in Hebrew). Perfetti, Charles A., Beverly, Sylvia, Bell, Laura, Rodgers, Kimberly, Faux, Robert, 1987. Comprehending newspaper headlines. Journal of Memory and Language 26 (6), 692–713. Pfau, Michael R., 1995. Covering urban unrest: the headline says it all. Journal of Urban Aﬀairs 17 (2), 131–141. Sidiropoulou, Maria, 1995. Headlining in translation: English vs. Greek press. Target 7 (2), 285–304. Sperber, Dan, Wilson, Dierdre, 1986. Relevance: Communication and Cognition. Blackwell, Oxford. van Dijk, Teun A., 1988. News as Discourse. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Publishers. Dr. Daniel Dor teaches at the Dept. of Communication and the Dept. of English, Tel Aviv University. His research interests include, among other topics, the role of the mass media in the construction of political hegemony, the linguistic consequences of globalization, and the cultural-biological evolution of language.
Please join StudyMode to read the full document