Article Critique: The Reason behind Good People Doing Bad Things

Good Essays
Article Critique
The main points discussed are the reason behind good people doing bad things, dehumanization, heroes and the effect of institutional power. The author was arguing that a person cannot quite literally be sweet, if they are surrounded by a sour environment. The strengths possessed in this article were that dehumanization is a very real notion as well as the fact that people change with the induction of anonymity. The weakness that is portrayed is that there are heroes around when in fact, yes they are around, but they are a quickly dying breed. My conclusion is that by uniting everyone and seeing each other as another human life regardless of being anonymous or not that maybe experiments like the Stanford experiment might not have needed to be done.
Phillip Zimbardo’s, You Can’t be a Sweet Cucumber in a Vinegar Barrel has many valid points. The first point that could be considered obvious is the question that he prose’s is, “Why do good people do bad things?”(Zimbardo 1). This question can be answered by a number of contributing factors. Such as how a person was raised and where they were raised. He uses the example of the police man stating that it was a bunch of black and Puerto Rican kids that were vandalizing an unattended car(Zimbardo 7). The officer, probably said that because of how he was either raised or how he was conditioned to think while in the service. By assuming that the vandals of the car were a certain demographic, he makes it seem as though the people he believes is capable of such things fit that same group of kids. This attributes to the circumstances of why the car was vandalized by those kids in the first place. The setting, more than likely a dark area of the Bronx or also maybe in a “bad” neighborhood allows for the inhabitants of that neighborhood to act or be expected to act as such a person in a “bad” neighborhood would act, i.e., stealing, vandalizing, and selling illegal substances. In retrospect, Zimbardo also

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Good Thing Critique

    • 1385 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Critique of "Too Much of a Good Thing" "Eating too much food is a bad thing (Steam, n.d.)." says Greg Crister in his op-ed essay "Too much of A Good Thing" featured in the Los Angeles Times (July 22, 2001). Crister raises the issue of child obesity as a growing epidemic plaguing America and the world and proposes that in order to fight this crisis the American public needs to stigmatize the idea of overeating. By stigmatizing overeating children will be less likely to overeat, thus having positive…

    • 1385 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Article Summary The article discusses on the relationship between the unhealthy organization culture and the employees' unethical behaviors. At the beginning of the article, the author gives us an example of how an ambitious and energetic employee, called Crystal, becomes unenthusiastic and institutionalized under the organization’s risk-management policy and corrupt organizational culture. The author believes that people who join organizations with full of enthusiasm often feel cheated by organizations…

    • 955 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    "Why do bad things happen to good people?" the young and naive Chanyeol in third grade would ask his father when he spotted a teenager being dragged by his collar to a dark alley before being pushed against the wall. That teenager was his neighbor, the guy that would tell him good morning everyday while pushing his glasses up, or walk across the street while reading his book, and sometimes offer Chanyeol candy whenever he see him playing outside. "Keep walking and don't stare at them, buddy." Pulling…

    • 693 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Why good people do bad things? “Doing bad is easy but doing well is not”. Yes, that saying is the most concrete explanation why good people do bad things. Good people do bad things with good intentions. We, humans, are all sinful by nature. No one of us can behave perfectly and sinless. But we have the capacity to avoid temptations and to distinguish what’s right from wrong. Good intentions cause most of the world's great evils. There are many things that happened in the past that can construe…

    • 315 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    People Good or Bad

    • 1099 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Ethics In my personal opinion I think that human beings are combination of good and bad with many factors in hand. What I may think is bad can be good to others and what I think may be good could be horrible to others. In other cases something may be wrong morally. Something may be wrong because society says so. It’s a matter of opinion. Here are a few examples to justify my argument. A child for instance can be brought up with a family that society sees as near perfect and still turn in…

    • 1099 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It's easy to blame individuals for engaging in illegal or unethical activities by assuming bad behaviour is an inherent personality trait. "Only shady people do shady things," right? We assume the CFO who reports false financial data and the hedge fund manager who commits insider trading do so because they are inherently "bad people." The maxim of individual responsibility is comforting because it implies that, to eradicate criminal or unethical behaviour, all we need to do is identify and weed…

    • 475 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When Bad Things Happen to Good People When someone does something good, great, amazing; however it is said, a reward is expected. That’s just the way the human brain has been trained in many cultures. People think just that with every good deed that is done. Movies have taught us that the “bad guy” never wins and that a hero will always triumph in the end. Not so much in the real world. Religious views, daily decisions, and just pure coincidence, if you will, all influence the outcome of a good…

    • 1010 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Why Bad Things Happen to Good People? A belief by definition is a confidence in the truth or proof of existence. Your beliefs determine the meaning you assign to any event in life. No event is either "good" or "bad" until you decide then assignment is given. This is your reality. Whatever the hardships or challenges you face, it can be interrupted as an opportunity for spiritual growth. The knowledge can be used to evolve as a person. Our desire to assign meaning to…

    • 672 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Pei Ou Theo 279 20 September 2013 When Bad Things Happen to Good People The author Harold Kushner wrote this book because his spent a life to search what puzzled him for a long time. He experienced tragedy in his early life. His son was found afflicted with progeria that is a kind of the fatal illness of pre-mature aging. He fall into hopelessness, and then started to question God. Why bad things often happen to good people? Many people may confuse this question too. If God really exists…

    • 583 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Good & bad people

    • 281 Words
    • 2 Pages

    There are different types of people in this world. Some are good, some are bad & some are in between. The boy in the striped pajamas is a perfect example of that. The family was “good” people & the dad was “bad.” not everyone can be trusted. Everyone has their hero & shadow. Bruno was the “hero” in the striped pajamas. He was a little 9 year old boy who was very curious. He was always ready to explore. When they moved into the new house he wanted to play & go exploring. So that’s what he did…

    • 281 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays