Preview

Arguments for and Against Mandatory Vaccination

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2273 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Arguments for and Against Mandatory Vaccination
Mandating the HPV Vaccination: A Controversial Debate
Background:
The Human papillomavirus (HPV) is the virus responsible for cervical cancer. It is one the most common viral sexually transmitted infections. A vaccine was approved in 2006 that is effective in preventing the types of HPV responsible for 70% of cervical cancers and 90% of genital warts. Proposals for routine and mandatory HPV vaccination of girls have become sources of controversy for parents of school-aged youth, legislators, members of the medical community, and the public at large (Cooper et al. 2010).
Evidence Based Arguments against Mandatory HPV Vaccination
Childhood immunizations, such as measles, chicken pox, and polio, are mandatory for school-aged youth and are required because of their highly contagious nature, especially in settings where people congregate in large numbers (De Jong and Bouma, 2001). Therefore, parents question whether there is justification for mandating that children be vaccinated against a sexually transmitted virus, one that can only be transmitted through sexual behavior (Cooper et al. 2010). Moreover, the vaccine only protects against the high-risk HPV types responsible for 70% of cervical cancers. This incomplete protection does not reduce susceptibility to the other HPV types that cause the remaining 30% of cervical cancers and will still require females to undergo yearly cervical cancer screenings and to practice other preventive measures of reducing STI exposure (American Social Health Association, 2006). Therefore, parents believe that mandating the HPV vaccine for girls of school age is an unnecessary action in response to a promiscuous but preventable behavior (Gottvall et al. 2011).
Yet, another argument against the vaccine’s mandatory use is that there are too many unknowns regarding the HPV vaccine such as side effects and long-term effects. Advocates against mandatory vaccination also believe there has not been enough time for science to ascertain



References: Cooper Robbins, S. C., Bernard, D., McCaffery, K., Brotherton, J., Garland, S., & Skinner, S. R. (2010). “Is cancer contagious?”: Australian adolescent girls and their parents: Making the most of limited information about HPV and HPV vaccination. Vaccine, 28(19), 3398-3408. De Jong, M. C. M., & Bouma, A. (2001). Herd immunity after vaccination: How to quantify it and how to use it to halt disease. Vaccine, 19(17-19), 2722-2728. DiMario, F., Hajjar, M., & Ciesielski, T. (2010). A 16-year-old girl with bilateral visual loss and left hemiparesis following an immunization against human papilloma virus. Journal of Child Neurology, 25(3), 321-327. Gottvall, M., Tydén, T., Larsson, M., Stenhammar, C., & Höglund, A. T. (2011). Challenges and opportunities of a new HPV immunization program. Vaccine, 29(28), 4576-4583. Kyrgiou, M., & Shafi, M. I. (2009). HPV vaccine. Obstetrics, Gynaecology & Reproductive Medicine, 19(1), 26-28. Mah, C. L., Deber, R. B., Guttmann, A., McGeer, A., & Krahn, M. (2011). Another look at the human papillomavirus vaccine experience in canada. American Journal of Public Health, 101(10), 1850-1857. Perkins, R. B., Pierre-Joseph, N., Marquez, C., Iloka, S., & Clark, J. A. (2010). Parents’ opinions of mandatory human papillomavirus vaccination: Does ethnicity matter? Women 's Health Issues, 20(6), 420-426. Pruitt, S. L., & Schootman, M. (2010). Geographic disparity, area poverty, and human papillomavirus vaccination. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 38(5), 525-533. Ramet, J., Esso, D., Meszner, Z., & , . (2011). Position paper—HPV and the primary prevention of cancer; improving vaccine uptake by paediatricians. European Journal of Pediatrics, 170(3), 309-321. Women in Government. (2004). The Oncology Policy Resource Center. Retrieved from: http://www.womeningovernment.org/oncology

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Specific Purpose: To persuade the audience on why all of them should get the HPV vaccine.…

    • 837 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    financial climate. The lack of guidelines for HPV screening and surveillance in high-risk populations may…

    • 653 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    * www.dshs.state.tx.us/chs/brfss/Reports/hpv_poster.ppt * Javitt, Berkowitz and Gostin C. Length of Immunity is Unknown 1. Pro Gardasil Vaccination for elementary aged girls * Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting Systems (VAERS) * CDC 2.…

    • 409 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Best Essays

    Mooney, Chris. "VACCINATION Nation." Discover 30.6 (2009): 58. MAS Ultra - School Edition. Web. 17 Sept. 2012.…

    • 2276 Words
    • 66 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Arthur Allen presents strong points for the mandatory vaccine while addressing opposing viewpoints. He highlights that “as long as the HPV vaccine is not required, the people who need it the most probably won’t get it.” For the young girls that really need the HPV vaccine to be able to receive it, they need the vaccine to be mandated and affordable or even free of charge. Making the HPV vaccine readily accessible will help the vaccine to gain credibility over…

    • 1079 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    References: Vamos, Cheryl A., McDermott, Robert J., Daley, Ellen M. Journal of School Health (The HPV Vaccine: Framing the Arguments FOR and AGAINST Mandatory Vaccination of All Middle School Girls) June 2008 Vol. 78 No. 6, pg. 302-309…

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Rebuttal Paper

    • 804 Words
    • 4 Pages

    • Mercola, J. (2012). New Evidence Demolishes Claims of safety and effectiveness of HPV vaccine. Retrieved from http://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2012/10/16/unproven-hpv-vaccine-safety.aspx…

    • 804 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hpv Controversy

    • 1698 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The recent news of a vaccine that could prevent a large percent of cancer deaths in the United States alone would generally be considered a reason to celebrate. However, the current attempts of many states, including the governor of Texas, Rick Perry, to pass an ordinance making it mandatory for preteen girls to have the Gardasil vaccine to protect them from some of the forms of cervical cancer caused by HPV has met a great deal of opposition. The objections to this legislation getting passed are primarily voiced by concerned parents who believe that the vaccination is too new to the market and that the long term effects are still too unknown.. This essay will discuss what genital HPV is and how it causes cancer in women, will describe the Gardasil shot and the attempts to make it a mandatory vaccine inoculation for schools in the United States and will detail both sides of the controversy surrounding it. Though the benefits of this vaccine could greatly outweigh the risks, the governor attempting to force a mandate requiring the vaccine to be given to all sixth grade girls could be considered an imposition on parents’ right to choose what is best for their children.…

    • 1698 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Another point was that girls who refuse the vaccine are more likely to contract the HPV virus and therefore more likely to need cervical cancer treatment in the future. The cost of this cancer treatment is around £30,000 per person whereas a vaccine is only £130 per dose, which is an example of justice. The opposing group also stated that the money that could be saved by reducing the number of women who require cervical cancer treatment could be better placed elsewhere within the…

    • 434 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Reality of Vaccinations

    • 1907 Words
    • 55 Pages

    Cited: Blevins, Sue. "Vaccinating Children:Where Do We Draw the Line?" Institute for Health Freedom. Pacific Research Institute, 1999. Web. 28 Apr. 2013…

    • 1907 Words
    • 55 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although vaccination has proved to be an effective measure in preventing disease, controversies remain over whether the risks of side effects of vaccinations outweigh the risk of contracting the disease. Vaccination is the process when pathogenic cells are injected into the cells of a healthy person so that the body develops immunity through antibodies to that virus or bacterium. The U.S Center for Disease Control and Prevention recommends that children get 16 vaccines including Diphtheria, hepatitis A, hepatitis B, Haemophilus influenzae, influenza, human papillomavirus, measles, meningococcal, mumps, pertussis, pneumococcal, polio, rotavirus, rubella, tetanus, and varicella (Merino 7-8). Vaccines, along with an acute amount of the disease…

    • 1654 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Measles may be a name found in the household but this next infection is not typically spoken about in a public manor. Human papillomavirus (HPV) may not be spoken about publically but this is not because of lack of cases reported. The HPV vaccination rates are extremely low even though the CDC recommends this vaccine for all boys and girl between the ages of 11 and 12. Gaining access to adolescents for vaccination is a victory in itself. Since vaccinating adolescents is a fresher idea parents aren’t quite sure of it yet therefore adolescents go without. Also they are in their prime they are fit, healthy, and active so getting them into a doctor’s office to even explain the benefits of adolescent vaccination is a chore. At least with HPV vaccination…

    • 254 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Thank you for sharing your ideas. You give me a new point of view that I never think of, and I totally agree with you. One of the reasons why measles vaccination is more acceptable is its effectiveness. Compared to the HPV vaccine, the measles vaccine is more beneficial to the girls. Measles is more contagious than the HPV, which means one person can get measles just by standing in the crowd and without having sex. Therefore, measles vaccination is more effective than the HPV vaccine. However, I still keep my point that the HPV vaccine is also beneficial to the girls’ health. The vaccine has already been approved by the FDA, which means that the vaccine is effective and useful. We should not say no to those which can improve our…

    • 133 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Males, Mike.”HPV Vaccine Texas Tyranny.” Perspectives on Contemporary Issues: Readings Across the Disciplines. 2006. 6e. Ed. Katherine Anne Ackley. Boston: Wadsworth/ Cengage Learning, 2012. 446-448.…

    • 314 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    There is a vaccine available to help prevent cervical cancer from developing. Treatment options are also available for women who are unfortunate enough to get it.The human papillomavirus (HPV) is the sexually transmitted infection that is known to be the main cause of cervical cancer. HPV is a non-enveloped double stranded DNA virus that can be grouped into group one of the Baltimore Classification System (Radosevich, 2012, p. 6). Since it is transmitted by sexual intercourse, it is very common that most people get it at some point in their lives. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, there are over forty types of HPV documented that infects the genital area of male and females (“What Is HPV”, 2016). Most of the cervical cancer cases deals with HPV 16 or HPV 18. HPV usually has no symptoms so you cannot tell that you have it, but that is okay for most women because it usually goes away on its own. Unfortunately, if the HPV stays in your system it can lead to cervical cancer. This causative agent goes through the lysogenic cycle in the basal cells of the squamous epithelium to synthesize a huge number of viral…

    • 886 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays