top-rated free essay

Arguments against Dualism: Churchland

By bignerds Jun 28, 2008 299 Words
The main point of this essay is that Churchland's denial of the dualist position is based on shortsighted and ineffective views. Churchland poses an inadequate rebuttal by rejecting the position of dualism on false pretenses.

Early in the section of Churchland's essay entitled "Arguments Against Dualism," he poses the question, "Can the dualist tell us anything about the internal constitution of mind stuff? Of the non-material elements that make it up?" (Churchland, p.315). He goes on to reply that the dualists have made no such explanation. However, this interjection is begging the question since it involves the assumption that mind stuff consists of elements, and furthermore that such elements are comprehendible to the human mind.

Churchland's next argument is directed at the substance dualist's views. He concludes that if the mind is dependant on the physical brain only for sense experience as said by the dualist, then damage to the neural tissue would not affect rational thought. Yet if the mind is a separate entity dependant on the physical brain for sense-experience, then damage that causes the ceasing of input from the brain would impair thought. In this way, the body is dependant on food (a separate entity) for nutrients; if food is not taken in, the body cannot sustain its functions.

Churchland's final argument against dualism is called the "argument from evolutionary history," and states that there is no evolutionary basis for the origin of the non-physical mind. The evolution of physical things involves the belief that all physical things evolved from chemicals in "space," that were prompted by electricity to form life. These chemicals referred to as our physical origins have no explanation of their appearance. Why then must there be an origin for non-physical stuffs?

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Arguments Against Dualism - Churchland- the Movie, “Matrix”

    ...body has the material properties of extension and motion, and that it follows the laws of physics. The mind or soul, on the other hand, was described as a nonmaterial entity that lacks extension and motion, and does not follow the laws of physics” (Wikipedia, “Rene Descartes.”) Descartes believed that a thought is the product of mental act...

    Read More
  • Against Dualism

    ...Can one reasonably be a dualist in this day and age? Thomas Nagel is correct to argue that, ‘dualism....is usually adopted on the grounds that it must be true, and rejected on the grounds that it can’t be.’ Such a seemingly paradoxical statement, which exists within what I will call the ontological common-senseness of the human experi...

    Read More
  • Argument of Dualism

    ...Arguments of Dualism Dualism is the theory that mind and matter are two distinct things. The main argument for dualism is that facts about the objective external world of particles and fields of force, as revealed by modern physical science, are not facts about how things appear from any particular point of view, whereas facts about subjectiv...

    Read More
  • Arguments Against Dualism

    ..."Strengths And Weaknesses Of Dualism." Dualism focuses on dramatic difference between mind and the body. The argument against this theory is that mind is private and only the person of his own mind has access to it. Others can only observe behavior and take a guess about the content of the mind. Weakness of dualism lays in the lack of rational ...

    Read More
  • Descartes Arguments for Substance Dualism

    ...Does Descartes provide a convincing argument for the claim that mind and matter are distinct substances Descartes’ Argument For Dualism In his Meditations Rene Descartes aimed to reconstruct the whole of science by trying to prove the distinction between mind and matter. He gives an argument from doubt, and another from conceivability. I w...

    Read More
  • Substance Dualism and Its Arguments

    ...influential philosopher during the enlightenment era. This era, which is characterized by what, at the time, was controversial thinking is exactly what Descartes was known for. His "out of the box" thinking not only raised eyebrows, but it also brought a lot to the table. One of his most discussed ideas was that of substance dualism. In this the...

    Read More
  • Argument for and Against

    ...Factors For and Against Marijuana should be legalized in the United States. Reasons for legalization (ranked from strongest to weakest) 1. Medical benefits for terminal illnesses such as cancer. 2. Police and court resources would be freed to pursue more serious crimes. 3. The FDA could regulate the quality and safety of the drug. ...

    Read More
  • Dualism

    ...Question: In dualism about the mind and body a more plausible view than the view that we are purely physical beings? Give reason for your answer. Dualism is the view that you consist of a body plus a soul, physicalism is the view that your mental life consists of physical processes in your brain. I hold the position that Physicalism is mor...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.