Argument Analysis

Good Essays
Arguments are an integral part of human society, and structuring these arguments properly is important to emphasize a point. In the documentary I Can Change Your Mind About Climate, many legitimate and illegitimate arguments are put forward to the viewer. Some of these arguments are structurally wrong, and in some of them the premises are not relevant to the conclusion.
The purpose of the documentary was for the two main protagonists, Anna Rose and Nick Minchin to try and change each others minds about climate change. The documentary follows Anna and Nick around as they bring each other to people that they think will change the other persons mind, or help to.

The first argument I will be analyzing will be an argument from Marc Morano, a notorious climate denier and blogger who runs the website climatedepot.com. His argument, as put into standard form, is as follows:
P1: The sea level is dropping,
P2: The population of polar bears is rising,
P3: Global temperatures are decreasing,
C: Therefor climate change is not happening.
While at first glance this argument looks like a solid deductive argument, the premises are lacking. The lack of actual numbers, along with the debatable follow on to the conclusion, make this argument worth looking further into.
The structure of this argument is a deductive empirical argument. The structure is sound and valid, being a deductive argument, where the premises entail the conclusion. As a deductive argument, the premises must not only support the conclusion, they must directly lead on to the conclusion. Mr. Morano has appeared to have done this, however we must first look further into the premises and the structure to determine weather the argument is conclusive or not.
Premise one states ‘The sea level is dropping’. Mr. Morano has given no evidence to support this premise, losing conclusivity. This is much the same for the other premises, no supporting evidence is shown, and so the truth of the premises is always

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Analysis of an Argument

    • 466 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The following appeared in a memorandum from the president of Aurora, a company that sells organic milk (milk produced without the use of chemical additives): “Sales of organic food products in this country have tripled over the past five years. If Aurora is to profit from this continuing trend, we must diversify and start selling products such as organic orange juice and organic eggs in addition to our regular product line. With the recent increase of articles in health magazines questioning…

    • 466 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Argument Analysis

    • 420 Words
    • 2 Pages

    For My discussion forum, I decided to view the Ted Talk title "The jobs we'll lose to machines -- and the ones we won't" by Anthony Goldbloom. In the video, Anthony describes how machine learning is revolutionizing the traditional way we work. He cites a 2013 study done by Oxford University where the researchers predict that one in every two jobs is at a high risk of being automated by machines. 1.) Right off the back the concept of Ethical Challenges Involving Technology from chapter 11 came…

    • 420 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Argument and Citation: A Reflective Experience The issues four and five in Understanding Rhetoric provided a good sense of stunned comic relief and irony. These issues discussed argument and citation in depth. The issues were entertaining, informative, and clarifying in the topic discussed. The authors took each subject of the issue, and broke it down to the very foundation of the knowledge. The authors reconstructed the topics from the bottom up, helping to ensure the proper understanding of argument…

    • 682 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Wormald consistently and effectively uses evidence from both contemporary and modern sources to support her arguments throughout the article. Her evidence is largely used critically, with evaluation of source material appearing in either the main body of the text or in the footnotes. Consequently, this evaluation of evidence provides for a stronger and more convincing argument by demonstrating the reliability of her sources. Wormald is also able to acknowledge flaws in her evidence, but successfully…

    • 532 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In regard to this analysis this essay will reflect on each different aspect these authors bring forth in their writings concerning the topic “Fear.” The first author who will be discussed within this essay is Frank Furedi. As he is the one that started this essay on the trail of finding how different authors reflect on this topic of fear. Furedi starts his topic with “The only thing we have to fear is the “culture of fear” itself” (Furedi, 2007, pg. 1). In stating his argument that” fear is playing…

    • 802 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    bleed"(199) She Martian that there is no legitimate distinction between rape and pornography, describing pornography as "sexual terrorism" () Implicit to virtually every aspect of Mackinnon's arguments is the assumption that women are unmitigated, unequal perpetual victims of human sexuality. This argument is harmful to the feminist cause because it divorces women from their sexuality. It creates a double standard in which women are inherently degraded by sex, but men are not. It perpetuates the…

    • 269 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    blaming us for the misery. The second article is on feminist economics which is the economic impact of feminist ideals in economics and jus the study of how women affect economies but aren’t adequate reciprocated. These are both heavily left leaning argument on viewpoints and realist, right leaning conservative politicians may disqualifying both…

    • 749 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    ARGUMENT ANALYSIS WORSHEET Use this worksheet, your understanding of critical thinking, and the structure of an argument to analyze the Grohol article titled “The Debilitating Effects of TV on Children”. APA Citation: Grohol, J. (2009, September, 9.). The debilitating effects of TV on children [Web log message]. Retrieved from http://psychcentral.com/blog/archives/2009/09/27/the-debilitating-effects-of-tv-on-children/ The main purpose of this article is . . . [State as accurately as possible…

    • 538 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Critical Argument Analysis

    • 1043 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Critical Argument Analysis - Fantasy Violence Laura Salter ENG/215 – Effective Academic Writing November 16, 2011 Critical Argument Analysis - Fantasy Violence Children’s programming has been a bone of contention for a very long time. As a parent and a grandparent, the article from this week that caught my attention was “Bang, You’re Dead” by Sara Rimensnyder. Since my daughter was young in the 1980’s, I have worried about the declining quality of children’s programming and the possible…

    • 1043 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    ARGUMENT ANALYSIS WORKSHEET Title of Article: Debilitating Effects of TV on Children Author: Dr. John M. Grohol The main purpose of this article is to convince the reader of the negative consequences of television being watched by our younger generation. Not just the quantity but the quality as well. It is too also show how parents fail to monitor what they allow their children to watch on television. It also shows how their developing minds are absorbing what they see and hear and television…

    • 540 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays