Argument: An Always Present Force

Topics: Logic, Argumentative, Arguments Pages: 5 (1157 words) Published: July 20, 2014
Jessica Warren
Professor Holly Foster
English 111-09H
June 13, 2014
Arguing: An Always Present Force

Dr. Tannen is a professor of linguistics at Georgetown University. Her study of language and how it is utilized has led her to have many books on the “Best-Selling” List. In her book, “The Argument Culture”, Deborah Tannen takes a closer look at how we as a society have come to view arguing/debating as a normal form of communication. Our inability to look at more than two views at a time, has led us to limit the potential conversations that could easily take place. In this essay, Professor Tannen takes a shot at making us believe that being in an “Argument-culture” is not the best thing for us as a whole. She wants us to see that it is truly a problem but that it can be fixed by following her advice. Tannen feels that everything would be different if we just changed how we spoke. By asking more questions, rephrasing points, and remembering that not everyone wants a heated debate, we will begin to change the way our society speaks. Tannen states “Our determination to pursue truth by setting up a fight between two sides leads us to assume that every issue has two sides-no more, no less.” (Reid 2014). In her quest to convince us of her stance, she herself has fallen victim to the argument culture by trying to push one side and not the other. She argues that we need to be veering away from automatically setting up a debate and instead be open to all angles of an issue. By looking at all of the different sides, we are able to make a more informed and educated decision on our own. By being educated and making our own decisions, we would be less susceptible to the use of language in arguments that tend to sway us one way or another in a debate. While I feel that we need to learn to look at things from all different aspects, I also feel that this world I live in was founded on an argument. Tannen said “Conflict can’t be avoided in our public lives any more than we can avoid conflict with people we love”. (Reid, 2014) This is such a powerful statement that rings oh so true. We as humans are instilled with an every pressing need for “Fight or Flight”. According to the UT Counseling and Mental Health Center fight or flight is “a mechanism in the body that enables humans and animals to mobilize a lot of energy rapidly in order to cope with threats to survival.” (Fight or Flight 2014) This very thing, I feel, is the reason why we are more prone to argue and to take sides. When we feel our values, morals, ideas, etc. are being threatened we are prone to jump to their defense in order to protect them. While it is true that many things have gone terribly wrong over people’s inability to separate themselves from an ongoing argument, there have been some things that have been instrumental in the formation of the world we know today. Tannen said “Balance. Debate. Listening to both sides. Who could question these noble American traditions?” (Reid, 2014) The following example support how she would come up with that “reasoning” we feel as to why we argue. A few examples to help clarify what I mean by things being instrumental are as follows. My first example is of that our founding fathers argued about the Declaration of Independence for over a month before the final draft was written and signed. Second would be how Lincoln and Douglas argued over slavery and whether or not slaves should have the same freedoms as the white man. One example that never seems to dissipate would be that of the argument of how the world was made (religion vs. science) has been going on for years. Without these many arguments that have taken place over the years, the world in which we live would be extremely different. Tanner points out that being in this argument culture helps to mold us in to who we will be and who we are. She stated that “the argument culture shapes who we are”. (Reid, 2014) Who knows what type of world we would be living in had those...

References: Tannen, Deborah. “The Argument Culture”. The Prentice Hall Guide for College Writers (pg 305-308).Reid, S. (2014). Upper Sadle River, New Jersey: Pearson Education, Inc.
Fight or Flight. (n.d.). Stress Recess: Retrieved June 16, 2014, from http://cmhc.utexas.edu/stressrecess/Level_One/fof.html
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Arguments Essay
  • argument Essay
  • Essay about arguments
  • Question and Present Youth Force Essay
  • Essay on Conflict Is Always Present When Progress Happens
  • The Present Moment Is Always Where You Are Essay
  • CORE Arguments, Opinions and suggestions Essay
  • What it means to be in the Air Force Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free