Preview

Aquinas Vs Aristotle Happiness

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
445 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Aquinas Vs Aristotle Happiness
Being, which is God. This is confirmed to us in reason: our ultimate desire lies in absolute perfection.

Aristotle: In my opinion, the Supreme Good, or Happiness, is to lead a life that allows us to use and develop our reason.
In contrast to amusement or pleasure, which can also be enjoyed by other beings, such as animals, happiness is not a state but an activity, and if genuine, is long-lasting.

Aquinas: So what you’re saying is that good or bad fortune affects our happiness?

A- Yes. In order to have a good fortune, one needs external or material goods, a position in society, and even good looks. However, if one is living life to the full according to rational nature, they are bound to find happiness regardless. This is why happiness is more influenced by behavior and habit of virtue than by luck, good and
…show more content…
I disagree. Happiness is perfectly achievable in life on earth.

Aquinas: That is true for ultimate happiness, however we can have an “imperfect happiness” here on earth.

Aristotle: How?

Aquinas: Imperfect hppainess can be reached by the actualization of one’s natural faculties (). The highest faculty the human being possesses is Reason, from which it follows that we can achieve happiness in this life in proportion to the level of truth accessible to Reason.

Aristotle- I agree. Happiness in this lifetime can be reached by utilizing one’s natural faculties. By exercising the natural virtues of courage, wisdom, moderation, friendship, and justice, along with reason.

Aquinas: I do not think this is enough to reach ultimate happiness. Although, these will take us to the final end as long as we begin the effort here on earth. Even people who appear to have everything, are lacking in some area. Celebrities and the wealthy are evidence of this. Despite having every material good, there life is uncomplete and unfilled without beatific

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Happiness does consist in living in accordance with reason. For a man to be happy his soul must function and have activity. If a man is to have happiness he must find the right middle ground. Too much of something or too little of something will not be what he needs. Since happiness is having everything you may want or need it must be within reason because having too much will cause certain evils. Aristotle says “the good of a man is an activity of the soul in conformity with excellence or virtue, and if there are several virtues, in conformation with the best and most complete. In a complete life” Everyone must strive for excellence in what they do but they must still conform to…

    • 1197 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Happiness as a goal may seem unrealistic and unobtainable because of the nature of life.…

    • 323 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Aristotle states that everything that a man does is for an end purpose. He defines happiness as actions in accordance with reason. If humans live out their lives to their full potential and live according to reason and with virtues, than they can obtain happiness. In today’s world, many think that happiness is got from money, success, and fame. Many people believe that these things are essential for happiness. Aristotle suggests, it is what we do in our life, not what we gain from our life, like money or success, which gives us happiness. He argues that happiness does not occur instantly. In our world today, we want to feel happiness instantly. However, Aristotle does not rely on this idea. He believes that happiness comes over time and the things that happen in short lived moments do not truly make us happy, but that the activities or virtues, we engage in over time give us happiness in the end. He contends that by achieving certain virtues, it leads to happiness in the long run, not in an instantaneous moment. In our society today, Aristotle’s ideas on happiness would not be useful. In Aristotle’s perfect world, everyone would be virtuous and happy. Unfortunately, that is not how our society works today. Aristotle’s ideas are inaccurate because many people gain happiness out of doing unvirtuous actions. For example, Hitler gained some sort of happiness out of murdering Jews.…

    • 555 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Happiness is determined by virtue, and goods of fortune essentially facilitate virtue. Aristotle first asserts that “activities in conformity with virue constitute happiness, and the opposite activities constitute its opposite”. [NE 1100b] It means that once a person continuously acts virtuously, he will be happy no matter he possesses or lacks fortune, which provides none of the necessity of happiness. However, Aristotle also points out that “…a happy man also needs the goods of the body, external goods, and the goods of fortune, in order not to be obstructed by their absence.” [NE 1153B]…

    • 1259 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    It is clear that Aristotle thinks happiness is what every human desires. He defines happiness as the highest good (Ethics 1095a), which by definition every person pursues as an ultimate end (1094a). Furthermore, he says that happiness can only be achieved through fulfillment of our characteristic activity, which is the thing that something does which makes it be that thing; for example, the characteristic activity of a flute-player is playing the flute. The good of anything with a characteristic activity is to perform that activity well (1097b). The characteristic activity of a human, says Aristotle, is a life concerned with reason (1098a), or more specifically, the activity of a soul concerned with reason. Therefore, the good of a human is to perform this activity well; that is, to live a life in accordance with virtue. Because this is a good of the soul, and goods of the soul are the best type of good (1098b), and because achieving the good of a human is the ultimate goal of being a human, Aristotle says that a life in accordance with…

    • 1551 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    According to Aristotle, it is the attainment of happiness, for it is that alone that we…

    • 1095 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    aristole and kant

    • 734 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Aristotle’s main argument is that happiness is the ultimate goal for humans., “Happiness depends on ourselves, more than anybody else.” Aristotle states that the end goal for all human activities is happiness. He also states that as happiness is achieved, it occurs over the course of a lifetime; like friends, wealth, and knowledge.…

    • 734 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    ‘Aristotelianism is defined as happiness as the quality of a whole life time.’ “Happiness is the purpose for which we live. Aristotle concluded that happiness is not a moment to moment experience of pleasurable things but rather a way of characterizing how one’s life is being conducted. Happiness is living and having lived a good life”. (Janaro & Altshuler, 2009)…

    • 1333 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    happiness reside? Can this happiness be lost? Augustine answers these questions by the notion of one’s “chief good.” He explains that a man’s chief good is the reason behind all happiness. If one is not happy, it is because they have not found their chief good, and therefore cannot be happy until they find it (Augustine 264-267).…

    • 1103 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Most of the Greek moralists think that, if we are rational, we aim at living well or happiness. Living well or happiness is our ultimate end in that a conception of happiness serves to organize our various subordinate ends, by indicating the relative importance of our ends and by indicating how they should fit together into some rational overall scheme. Aristotle says that happiness is “perfect” or “complete” and something distinctively human. When we are living well, our life is worthy of imitation and admiration. For, according to the Greek moralists, that we are happy says something about us and about what we have achieved, not simply about the fortunate circumstances in which we find ourselves. So they argue that happiness cannot consist simply in “external goods” or “goods of fortune,” for these goods are external to our own choosing and deciding. Whatever happiness is, it must take account of the fact that a happy life is one lived by rational agents who act and who are not simply victims of their circumstances.…

    • 2821 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Many people try to define and consider different definitions of what happiness is, and I think that Plato and Aristotle offer interesting views of happiness and what it means for one to live a good life. Both philosophers agree that happiness is an important factor in one’s life and essentially the essence of how to live a good life. Plato offers many theories and definitions of justice leading to happiness, while Aristotle argues that happiness is the main goal that all humans aim for in their entire life. Plato offers a philosophical view of a happy life for an individual by explaining a just state and what it would entail and also the theory of the forms that one must understand to achieve happiness. After learning about both philosophers, I have come to the conclusion that I agree with Aristotle’s view of happiness more because he gives us a broad outline of what a good life is. Although Plato was Aristotle’s mentor, Aristotle offers a view of happiness that is more plausible and relevant than Plato’s because it places a large emphasis on the idea of the function of a human being. Therefore, in this paper, I will argue that I agree with Aristotle’s view of happiness over Plato’s because of the way Aristotle describes how humans can achieve the greatest good in life: happiness.…

    • 1782 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Aristotle’s eudaimonia (happiness) is living well and doing well in the affairs of the world. Happiness is life’s aim which like I stated before, involves both moral and intellectual arête. Aristotle states that “The happy life for a man is a life of the conscious following of a rule”. So to elaborate, a person must use their moral and intellect virtues to use good judgment to know what the right rule is, then they must follow and obey the rule even if they don’t understand the rule. So in order for us to do this we must possess moral goodness and goodness of intellect.…

    • 450 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Happiness is the ultimate reason why people live. Without the quest for happiness, there is no point of reason. Happiness is essentially the reason why the world and all its inhabitants keeps moving. Aristotle says, “…the ends of the ruling sciences are more choice worthy than all the ends subordinate to them, since the ends are also pursued for the sake of the higher,” (Aristotle pg. 1). Through reasoning, virtuous people should be able to see that…

    • 818 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Aristotle Virtue Ethics

    • 799 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In order to explain the fundamentals of Aristotle's Virtue Ethics, one must acknowledge his primary motive in this study, which is to understand what it means to live well. Unlike Plato, who believed that living well involves multiple higher forms to which we can't observe, Aristotle believed that there was just simply living well, and disregarded distinctions between what is morally good and what is good for an individual person. After studying other opinions of what it is to live well, Aristotle concluded that the ultimate human end is happiness. He had two reasons for regarding happiness as the ultimate good. The first reason relates to its completeness. For Aristotle, happiness is the ultimate intrinsic good. In other words, happiness has value within itself, and is not a mechanism to attain anything else. The second reason relates to its self-sufficiency, in the sense that once we have happiness, we do not desire anything else. Happiness does not need supplementation from other entities.…

    • 799 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Similar Men

    • 555 Words
    • 3 Pages

    “Achievement of your happiness is the only moral purpose of your life and that happiness, not pain or…

    • 555 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays