Preview

Animal Farm Comparison Essay

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1876 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Animal Farm Comparison Essay
Animal Farm: Comparison of Animal Characters with Human characters

Animal Farm by George Orwell is a political story concerning the concept of Leninist Marxism, written from an animal’s perspective. It is a story of dreams; dreams of freedom and equality that are dashed into pieces by greed and avarice for power and comfort. Basically, Orwell has incorporated his own political views in this book regarding Marxism and simultaneously he has spotlighted the major flaws in Marxist philosophy which he illustrates throughout the story. I first want to emphasize that the events in Animal Farm are comparable to the Russian Revolution of 1917. The book illustrates the ideals of the revolution and how the masses were maltreated by corrupt leaders
…show more content…
Squealor changed and manipulated the seven commandments to suit Napoleon and the pigs. You may have noticed by now that the character names all have a symbolic meaning to them. The name Napolean refers to the legendary emperor of France. He was ruthless and he killed anyone who opposed him. Squealor, by his contemptuous actions, implied that he was a spy and he informed Napoleon about any activity against him. Napoleon could be compared to Josef Stalin, the madman of Russia. He was not as educated or convincing as Trotsky. Yet Stalin was a brutal man who craved power. He killed millions of people and used the KGB (indoctrinated dogs) to punish dissenters. Napoleon also used Moses, the tame raven, to control the animals. Moses represented the Church where he constantly babbled about Sugar Land Mountain. This heavenly abode is where all animals go when they died and they forever lived in peace and tranquility with good food and lots of rest. The animals believed in Moses because their lives were already full of misery. Surely there had to be a better place where the animals could go and be content. Moses was a tool for Napoleon. He said all this jargon in order to make the tired animals work hard and not complain and Moses was paid with bread soaked in beer. On the topic of religion, Marx considered it the, “Opiate of the people.” (2) Orwell however said that people will always turn to religion for answers and places …show more content…
What were the goals, what were the dreams and what were the results? The basic idea was to share power and to stop the tyrant Mr. Jones (who represented the Czar). The goals of the newly established government was to declare all animals equal, that they would get more food, more sleep, respect, rules to protect animals from oppression, and technology-in the form of windmill to make life better for all. The animals owned the farm. Everything was to be equally shared. Humans were the enemy and no animals should deal with Man and no one could act like Man. As Major said, “..in fighting Man, we must not come to resemble him. Even when you have conquered him, do not adopt his vices.”(pg 12) The seven commandments were made for the protection of the animals and their rights. Leaders and workers will work together and education is available to all. These were the hopes and dreams of all animals so that they may be free from the bonds of slavery and live in happiness and equality. However, when Napoleon claimed power, the entire basis of the revolution crumbled into dust. The goals of the government were stripped to suit the Pigs. As the rule said, “some animals are more equal than others.” Rather than motivating animals to work, they are forced to work otherwise they would not receive their ration of food. The Seven commandments were changed to Pig Laws. Pigs became more powerful and thus they controlled every aspect of the farm. What I note, and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Ever since the Seven Commandments had been written, Napoleon used his power to change the commandments and make them the way he wanted them to be. One of them he changed was, “All animals are equal, but some are more equal than others” (Orwell, 111). Here, Napoleon is abusing his power because at the beginning of his regime, he followed the commandments, but after becoming accustomed to his power, he claimed it as a right and abused it. Napoleon proclaimed the absolute equality of all the animals, but gave extra power and privileges to himself and the pigs. Napoleon believes that he and the pigs have complete control and have extra privileges, while the working animals exist only to serve the pigs, to provide them with everything they desire,…

    • 243 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    George Orwell's Animal Farm is a satire written about the Stalin Era. The events and characters in Animal Farm parallel the early history of the Soviet Union. While all of the animals seem to have parallel characters in the real world, Orwell directly connects the character Napoleon to Joseph Stalin in a letter to the publisher in 1945. Orwell created Napoleon to represent Stalin, a dictator who was supposed to reshape the Soviet Union but instead created many problems during his regime. He used a secret police force that is also noted in animal farm by the puppies that Napoleon raises to be his secret guard dogs. Orwell shows a strong disapproval of the Stalinist corruption of socialist's ideals. This book has become well-known for showing what happens when power is overthrown only to have the over thrower become power-hungry and oppressive. This is represented by the swift transformation of the animals on the farm. The seven principles of animalism, known as the seven commandments, are reduced to a single principle that reads, "all animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others." The animals become more and more like the humans that they had once thought were awful. They walk upright, wear clothes and carry whips. The animals have become the very thing that they had been working against. If nothing else, we are left with the feeling that a totalitarian government is never a good idea.…

    • 639 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Napoleon and Squealer immediately started to enforce their own rules. Many of the commandments that the Animals made were changed. For instance, the first commandment, “Whatever goes upon two legs is a enemy.” was changed as soon as the pigs start walking on two legs. Now it’s four legs good two legs better. The fifth commandment was also changed. At first it was “No animal shall drink alcohol.” but is changed to “No animal shall drink alcohol to excess.” “No animal shall kill any other animal.” was changed to "No animal shall kill any other animal without cause." Like these commandments all the others were changed, to benefit the pigs that were in charge. Napoleon taking over the farm did nothing to benefit the animals or the farm. The pigs changing all the commandments and rules, is causing the farm to go away from the roots of what it was grown…

    • 806 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many books are made into movies whether people realize it or not. Some movies could be very well done, and others completely terrible. When the producers of Animal Farm made the book into a movie, they did not do as well as they could have. The book and movie of Animal Farm can be compared in many ways through their differences, similarities, and even why it contains the changes it does.…

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The story Animal Farm is not just one of farm animals working for human beings. Rather, the tale gives us insight of the Russian Revolution and what occurred during and after the event, the animals functioning as certain historical figures and groups. George Orwell, in Animal Farm condemns and criticizes the actions and injustices that occurred during the reign of Joseph Stalin with the evil character Napoleon. As the farm animals are encountered with no freedom, no equality, and are being slaughtered by their own kind, Orwell illustrates the misinterpretation of a Utopian society and the wrong turn rebellion can take with the wrong leader in charge.…

    • 780 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Could you ever imagine being physically and emotionally controlled and mentally corrupted by a single “being” everyday? In both novels, Animal Farm and 1984, the author, George Orwell shows how Napoleon and Big Brother, both head figurines for their society, contain numerous correspondences linking both of them. In the novel Animal Farm the author displays how Napoleon exhibits dictating traits while trying to selfishly control a government for his own contentment in return, than everyone’s contentment as a whole. However, when his strong dictatorship begins to terminate, it seems the book reveals some thoughts of the animals wanting to return back to the type of government that they once had when they first rebelled against Mr. Jones due to…

    • 1263 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Satire Animal Farm

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages

    George Orwell uses criticism to establish his opinions on the Russian government heard. Orwell criticizes the leaders of Russia in many different manners, he portrays them as various animals on a farm. One of the most important leaders in the book is Squealer, a pig; his followers are the animals on the farm. Squealer's manipulation is his main way of controlling the animals, he controls their thoughts, beliefs, and how they each think. Squealer uses many diverse tactics to confuse the animals about the different laws, and ideas on the farm. This pair of leading and following shows how blindly following can lead to the downfall or social corruption in a book or in a real…

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Imagine living in a society where you are brainwashed into believing something is good, where you are forced to follow someone who is addicted to power. A society where you have no say, but you think that is okay. On Animal Farm, that is reality. The animals rebelled against the humans on their farm and took over, everything was good at first, but soon, the pigs became power hungry. They needed to be in charge, and Napoleon, the leader, became so attached to his power, he was willing to sacrifice other animals life, to simply stay in charge.…

    • 1012 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Animal Farm - Propaganda

    • 569 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Orwell warns against giving too much power to leaders. The pigs were given way too much supremacy. Napoleon was so honored that they adopted the phrase "Napoleon is always right." Doing this gave Napoleon the right to do basically whatever he wanted. The pigs were allowed the break all the commandments they had set. They ate all the good food and drink while the other animals went hungry. The laborers like Boxer said things like, "I'll work harder", only so that the pigs could waste more resources and food.…

    • 569 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Outline

    • 426 Words
    • 1 Page

    Explain 1: when the pigs change the seven commandments, the animals do not think badly of Napoleon’s use of cruelty and violence.…

    • 426 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Human beings and animals have many connections in both good and bad ways; one obvious correlation is selfishness. Naturally, humans have always prioritized their own superiority. In real world, nations want to be dominant and above others similar to human’s selfish desire to be greater than other humans. Nowadays, corruption are way worse than it was before. Egotistical people are finding new ways to cheat and make their way up in society without doing anything. Thailand gives a perfect illustration of corruption: governors accept illegal money from the people that want to do dirty works but doesn’t want to face any problems with the authority. Power slowly turn people evil. “With great power comes great responsibility”- Spiderman. What if…

    • 533 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In writing Animal Farm, the author Orwell illustrates disillusionment with socialist revolution. Although the novel has often been linked with the Russian Revolution of 1916, it still has contemporary relevance. The Palestinian Arab-Israeli Conflict parallels Animal Farm in three different ways, rallying flag, despotism, and equality.…

    • 877 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The novel, Animal Farm and the movie both contain many similarities and differences. Many of the differences come from the movie. The movie, Animal Farm, has a lot more detail and events added to it. For example, Old Major’s death. In the beginning of the movie, as Old Major is finishing his speech, he tumbles out of the barn, and falls to his death. In the novel, Old Major dies three nights after his big speech. He doesn’t fall to his death, but instead he dies in his sleep. Unlike the novel, in the movie the song, “Beasts of England” has a different tune to it. The novel explains that the song goes something along to the tune of La Cucaracha and Clementine. The tune to the song in the movie doesn’t…

    • 576 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The battle of the cowshed and the Russian Revolution both originated with intentions of equality and improving the quality of life. Both revolutions ultimately ended up where they began. The seven commandments were articulated at the beginning of the fable by the pigs, and were the basic rules of animalism. The commandments signified equality amongst the animals and the hatred they carried toward the selfish villainous humans. The first commandment ‘whatever goes upon two legs is an enemy’ (15) inferred that all humans were enemies to the animals and pose a threat to equality.…

    • 770 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The leaders put seven commandments out there that they themselves are breaking. In fact, they're the only ones breaking the rules, while everyone else abides by them. Because the pigs are considered “better than” the others, they think that they can break the rules and everything will be okay. They've got the other animals thinking this too. And though all of the commandments are eventually broken by Napoleon, there are three that come to mind first. #5: “no animal shall drink alcohol”, #6: “no animal shall kill another animal”, and #7: “all animals are equal”. The other animals don't deserve to be treated like they're inferior to the pigs. Who suddenly decided that the pigs were going to be the rulers anyways? This is not a real democracy, this is a dictatorship. Unfortunately, this does happen in real life. This book does a very good job of showing…

    • 892 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays