Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Andrew Jackson, Hero or Villain?

Satisfactory Essays
480 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Andrew Jackson, Hero or Villain?
Andrew Jackson, our seventh President of the United States, is a rather acceptable President. He was considered as the "People's President," he was very straight forward and honest to his people. He takes his job seriously and is probably the most liberal president in history. His presidency however was neither a hero nor a villain, but shared a fair amount of each.

First off, the good qualities he had was the fact he had bold commitment to enforce laws and fight back against secession threats from the South. Two high tariffs were passed during 1828 and 1833 which increased taxes on imported foreign goods. The South was outraged by the high taxation, so they created the Nullification Act that allows states to nullify the laws that they do not like. Soon after the second tariff was issued, they formed a convention to build up an army with the idea of secession. Jackson was so enraged that he was willing to use all the power he had to stop it. Fortunately he was able to make a deal with the Vice President John Calhoun, who was in favor of the South, to lower the tax prices. The South backed off from secession and things settled down between the North and South.

Secondly, the bad if not malicious duties Jackson did during his presidency was the forced removal of Native Americans from Georgia to the west. The state of Georgia was against the Supreme Court who was not in favor of the removal of the Natives. Even though the Supreme Court won, Georgia as well as Jackson ignored it and forced the Natives out of Georgia to the present state of Oklahoma. Many died before they even got there. It was known as the "Trail of Tears."

The ending of the National Bank system was the other bad deed of Jackson. He believed that it was a monopoly towards the upper class people and as a result refused to re-charter it. Jackson used one of his vetoes, and the Bank's congressional supporters did not have enough votes to override him. The Bank ceased to exist when its charter expired in 1836, but even before that Jackson had weakened it considerably by withdrawing millions of dollars of federal funds. This later resulted in contributing to the panic in 1837.

Jackson was not a hero or a villain during his presidency. He did remove the Indians from their homeland against their will and against the Supreme Court and he did get rid of the national bank causing panic. But he enforced the laws of the United States and stopped the south from secession. Also when he became president he made it so not only men that owned land could vote, he made it so all men could vote in the presidential election. Because of these reasons I do not think Andrew Jackson was a hero or a villain.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Andrew Jackson was an impactful president whose strategies and actions transformed the country. He was a controversial figure in American politics, due to both his empowerment of the “common” American man, his ruining of the economy, and his deplorable acts he subjected the American Indians to.…

    • 285 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Andrew Jackson a democratic man who cared about the word of the people, but criticized by his enemies. Jackson lived a tough life from losing his father days before his birth ,at the age of 13 he enlisted in the Revolutionary War he was captured by a British officer and later freeed with a negotiation for him and his brother by his mother .Shortly after returning home his mother dies, leaving him alone.Jackson worked hard from studying law to being elected Tennessee’s first representative in the U.S House of Representative and later elected to the U.S Senate.As you may have assumed Andrew Jackson is a democratic man perceived as a non -demorcatic man .Jackson was a hero to the lower class by giving them the ability to vote . Jackson gave…

    • 822 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jackson also supported the ban of anti-slavery pamphlets in the mail because he was a slave owner as well. During Andrew Jackson's term of presidency, he confronted some of the issues that defined a nascent nation still searching for its identity. The removal of all the Native Americans off their home land, the rise of the corporations, and slavery. A great president is someone who is a very strong and confident leader. Someone who can make choices that will change the country for the better, and does what is best for the good of all the people. Some people might just consider Andrew Jackson to be a very good president because he did things such as revolutionizing presidential campaigning, which also made him the very first modern president, and using his presidential powers to veto some of the bills that he thought could be unfit or harmful. Some others would argue that The former president Andrew Jackson was an evil president because he did things like enforce the Indian Removal Act and abided the power to veto in an effort to take more control over and intimidate congress. Speaking of the Indian Removal Act, it is the one thing Andrew Jackson did that most people totally and completely disagree with. Andrew Jackson instated the Indian Removal Act in 1830. This act evicted thousands and thousands of Native American families, specifically Cherokees, from their homes in Georgia and the Carolinas so the white…

    • 501 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I think that there were many reasons and situations that proved Andrew Jackson to be a bad president. One of the reasons was “The Spoils System”. He wasn’t a very fair president. He gave government jobs to his friends and the people that voted for him. This was known as the spoils system. The spoils system corrupted the government because no one had a chance to get good at their job or even get a job. He was almost similar to a king, which was not a good thing for the country. For example, when the Supreme Court sided with the Indians against the state of Georgia, Jackson ignored the ruling of the Supreme Court. Another reason was the withdrawal of the second national bank. Jackson tried to destroy the National Bank by withdrawal federal funds and placing them into state banks. The bank supported the rich white men, but did not cater to the needs of the working white men. Jackson believed that “Congress had no right under the Constitution to charter a bank.” But, it was not Jackson’s position to determine the constitutionality of the bank, because the Supreme Court had already ruled that the bank was constitutional in the case “McCulloch vs. Maryland”.…

    • 824 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Secondly, the bad if not malicious duties Jackson did during his presidency was the force removal of Native Americans from Georgia to the west and the ending the National Bank system. The state of Georgia was against the Supreme Court who was against the removal of the Natives. Even though the Supreme Court won, Georgia as well as Jackson ignored it and forced the Natives out of Georgia to the present state of Oklahoma. Many died before they even got there. As to the National Bank issue, Jackson believed that it was a monopoly towards the upper class people and as a result refuse to recharter it. Jackson used one of his vetoes, and the Bank's congressional supporters did not have enough votes to override him. The Bank ceased to exist when its charter expired in 1836, but even before that Jackson had weakened it considerably by withdrawing millions of dollars of federal…

    • 359 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Jacksonian Democrats

    • 452 Words
    • 2 Pages

    A major dilemma for Jackson was what to do with Native Americans living in the South and on this issue Jackson failed at protecting the rights of Native Americans. As shown in the picture, Native Americans living in the South were driven away from their lands to Oklahoma on a path known as the Trail of Tears. Did the Native Americans not have the same rights as the whites living in the South? Apparently Jackson and his successor Martin Van Buren did not ever consider this question and upon this they failed to protect the Constitution. In relation to the issue of Indian removal came another violation of the Constitution by Andrew Jackson. When John Marshall and the Supreme Court ruled that Georgia's extension of state law over Cherokee land was unconstitutional, Andrew Jackson totally ignored the decision. This action violated Supreme Court decisions and strengthened Jackson's reputation as an enemy of the law.…

    • 452 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Andrew Jackson was the 7th president of the United States, and was in office from March 4, 1829 to March 4, 1827. Many would argue if jackson was a man of good deed or just an evil president. However, Jackson cast many negative outcomes while in office, therefore showing that he was not a man of good deed but was a cynical president.…

    • 535 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In conclusion, after all that had happened Jackson still stood for what he believed in. In my opinion Andrew Jackson was a good man who had been thru trouble times while still holding his president position. Even thru the National Bank argument, moving the Native tribes and the law changing of South Carolina. He still fought for what was right and still never gave…

    • 403 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jacksonian's viewed themselves as guardians of the constitution, political democracy, individual liberties, and equality of economic opportunity. Many of his followers from that time tended to agree but a lot of people today look back and disagree with each of these assumptions. I believe that he was a keeper of the constitution and political democracy. Depending upon your outlook, Jackson was a guardian of individual liberties, even with his oppression of African American slaves, Indians, and women. His equality of economic opportunity was more towards the common man that the elite but gave that common man a larger chance for equality with the elites without allowing the elites a greater chance to increase their wealth.…

    • 767 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Andrew Jackson can be credited for being either one of the best presidents or one of the worst. It can go either way depending on the ideals of the viewer. Many historians believe that Andrew Jackson abused and overstepped the rights to his presidency, whereas others believe that he expanded and enhanced political power. Jackson greatly influenced and enhanced the power of the presidency. Jackson once declared that while each member of Congress represented a specific regional group, only the president represented all the people of the United States. During Jackson 's term he greatly increased the power of the presidency but believed that it was subject to the will of the people. Jackson carried through an unprecedented program of domestic reform, moving toward a hard-money currency policy, and checking the program of federal internal improvements. Although Jackson 's presidency was subject to many changes, he disapproved of many actions by Congress and vetoed twelve bills, more then all the previous presidents combined. Many of these bills sought to increase federal spending on domestic improvements. The democrats believed that the states, not the national government, should pay for such projects. Overall Jackson 's strong actions won him much praise from the people and in the election of 1828 and 1832 he won a lot of popular votes. He believed himself to be the people 's man and established during his presidency many goals for the expansion and benefit of America. One goal that Jackson believed to be very important was the termination of the Bank of the United States, the "monster bank", which he viewed as a tool for the elitists; he attacked the bank and was successful in destroying it. But aside from that he also accomplished many other things during his presidency. He successfully resolved the nullification crisis in which South Carolina threatened to secede from the Union. He also strengthened the Democratic Party and institutionalized the party system in…

    • 1286 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 1829 Andrew Jackson created the Indian Removal Act. The Indian Removal Act was a law that stated that Native Americans that were settled east of the Mississippi River had to move west of the river to a portion of land that was set aside for them in the Oklahoma territory. The Cherokee Indians that were settled in Georgia became angry with the law and decided to sue the state of Georgia, because they felt like they were entitled to the land. The Supreme Court case became known as Worcester v. Georgia. It was won by the Indians and the law was proven unconstitutional. President Jackson chose to ignore the results of the case and carry on wih the law, causing the Trail of Tears. The Trail of Tears was the name given to the horrible event where Jackson force the Native Americans to travel during one of the worst winters to the other side of the Mississippi River. Jackson went against the constitution and around the verdict of the Supreme Court, so that he could get exactly what he wanted. Jackson was very unlike the presidents before him, by performing selfish deeds such as the Trail of Tears to get what he wanted.…

    • 639 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Task:   Discuss at least one positive effect of Jackson’s presidency Discuss at least one negative effect of Jackson’s presidency…

    • 738 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    My first reason on why I believe President Andrew Jackson was a hero is for the fact that he vowed to pay the national debt to prevent the liberty of his country from being destroyed, and kept his word. The reducement of the national debt was lowered in 1835. Andrew Jackson had been able to decrease the national debt to only $33,733.05, the lowest it has been since the first working year of 1791. This was a major accomplishment, and a very difficult task. Andrew Jackson was the only president in United States history to ever succeed in paying off the federal debt.…

    • 629 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although President Jackson was a champion of democracy and egalitarianism, there are some instances where he takes advantage of his presidential powers and uses him for his own benefits and beliefs and not for the good of the country. President Jackson did a lot of good for the early Democratic Party though. He helped expand voting and focused on destroying monopolies like the national bank that he believed were harming the nation. He did however take manners into his own hands at times. For instance disregarding Supreme Court rulings. Enacting Military action on a state and Vetoing bills like the Maysville road that would’ve helped the union, but since he didn’t approve he vetoed it.…

    • 660 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Andrew Jackson is a very controversial figure. If the question was ever asked if Andrew Jackson is a good leader for America the answer would be no. Jackson was born into a very wealthy family. Not only was he wealthy, Jackson was a very intelligent person. According to “After the Fact”,” Jackson first moved to the town of Salisbury, North Carolina, reading law by day, and with the help of high-spirited young friends, raising hell by night” (131). Jackson would keep up this type of behavior all of the time. When you normally think about a leader you would think of them as being a very mature level headed person.…

    • 501 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays