Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Ancient China and India

Powerful Essays
1255 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Ancient China and India
Differences: There was a dynastic cycle, the dynasties would rise and fall, and be taken over by a new person. India went back to independent city states when a ruler fell. China was generally able to be re-united through a ruler India was not, India was not able to be united in the north due to invasions from bordering countries. The only person to unite India was Ashoka Maurya

Similarities: Both were patriarchal societies. Major cities were built along major water ways, India (The indus river) China (the yellow river)
Both countries used forced labor (slaves, pows, etc). Used water ways for trade (religion was also able to be spread this way)
The Difference Between Classical China and Classical India
Classical China and Classical India were truly great civilizations known for their contributions to modern China and India. Yet as the two developed, they showed uniqueness. Some of the qualities shown were alike, and others were not as comparable.
The religions produced in China and India were very unique. In China, rather than developing full-fledged religions, they created more philosophical beliefs. Confucianism, the first and most popular of the philosophies, embraced moral virtues and values. For example, it taught to respect one's leaders, and for the leaders in return to be just and moral in their leadership. Confucius, the creator of Confucianism, believed that if the leaders set a good example, his people would follow it. It also stressed to delight in knowledge, delight in learning, to be polite, and to have good manners. Its teachings were recorded in the Analects. Daoism is another Chinese religion. Daoism, created by Lao-zi, was slightly more spiritual. It embraced nature's harmony and mystery and had an entirely different set of ethics. Instead of harmony with your fellow man and government, the Daoist belief harmony with nature was more compatible with frugal living and humility. India, however, was a different story. Hinduism was the major religion in India. Hinduism, unlike Confucianism and Daoism, is a full-fledged religion. It has many gods of nature like Daoism, but each god also represents something more abstract. For example, the god of wind might also be the god that "blows" someone to the right path in his or her life. Dharma is something taught by the Hindus as a guide to living in the world and still be able to obtain a higher spiritual level of thought. Also, Hinduism is not as one sided when it comes to balancing politics and government with humanly affairs. Confucianism was mainly based on a harmonious government, and Daoism, while more balanced, still leaned more to the worldly pleasures. The Hindu beliefs, like Confucianism, were recorded, too, but instead of being written like a book, it was written like a poem. A series of epics, two being the Rig-Veda and the Upanishads, keep the doctrine of the Hindu. These unique religions and philosophies are just some of the cultural distinctions these civilizations had.
Other unique ideals that came out of India and China were their political structures. In Classical China, the ruling powers were three different dynasties, or family of emperors. The "Mandate of Heaven" supposedly gave a dynasty's emperor the right to rule from God. As the dynasties changed, the Mandate of Heaven changed from emperor to emperor. The political structure in the beginning of the Zhou Dynasty was the already existing system of feudalism, which was a chain of command from the emperor down to small regional directors. They ruled through alliances and regional princes, making their government not very powerful. The Zhou work to undermine the feudalist system to obtain a unified cultural community, and were, in part, successful. Despite these attempts, the Zhou fell to the alliances' armies and the Qin dynasty arose. In the Qin Dynasty, the feudalist system was demolished. Shih Huangdi, the Qin emperor, was supposedly a very harsh ruler. He divided China into large provinces and personally chose the lords to rule them, so he would be sure he could keep his throne. This system probably would have worked well, had not the emperor been a "blood-thirsty animal," as many thought him as. The system did work, though, in the next dynasty twenty years later. The Han Dynasty kept the provinces and their lords, but didn't rule with an iron whip. With no opposition to the government, this dynasty ruled for about 400 years. India political structure was not as strong as China was. Indian religions did not usually have a concern for politics, though its rulers would claim that the gods chose them to rule, like China's Mandate of Heaven. It did, through most of its empires, use regionalism, like the Qin and Han Dynasties. The regionalist government did not work as well for India. The Indian culture was not as unified as Chinese culture. On top of that, the Caste System continued to overrule the national government. The Caste System was a chain of command one was born into, somewhat like Feudalism. For the most part, the caste system maintained order and tolerance, like a good political system would. Like China, status determined what land you received, if any at all. The similarities and differences between Chinese and Indian political structure are still only a few of the many.
The social structures of these great civilizations also had their own distinctions to them. In China, There were three main classes: the landowning gentry and the educated bureaucrats, also called Mandarins, then the peasantry, and the "mean" people. One inherited a class from his or her parents.
China and India
China and India were both very advanced ancient civilizations. Both agricultural based civilizations made various technological advances. Although China and India shared many similarities, they had differences such as the social system, politics, and the importance of trade in the economy.
The hierarchy of ancient China and India were similar with a noticeable sign of select individuals being considered “higher” then others. The caste system was strict in India and prohibited other classes from interacting with each other. China’s social system differed from India’s caste system, by not demonstrating a formal and strict social ladder. Where in India there existed over three hundred subcastes at one point, China had a simple three caste social ladder. Although the Chinese did not have as strong of a social ladder, there still existed “higher” people such as the bureaucrats. Bureaucrats and landowners were considered to be of a higher class then peasants, farmers, and merchants. Patriarchy was a very big factor in culture and social order in China and India. India’s strict caste system led to a more “flexible” and popular religion known as Hinduism. Many Indians preferred this religion over Buddhism, which the Chinese practiced, because the brahmans or priests strongly influenced the population. Brahmans and many other Indians did not like the idea of any being of any caste level achieving “peace” by their efforts, which Buddhism taught. The Chinese believed in Buddhism and reaching nirvana by finding peace within. A major difference between Indian and Chinese culture was that Indians lived to die and reincarnate to a better caste level and eventually reaching the gods, whereas the Chinese lived a good life with no rituals necessary to find nirvana. Although the Chinese and Indian culture was very different, both races strived and lived in balance to find their gift in the afterlife. A major difference between the Chinese and Indian culture was that...

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    APUSH outline

    • 253 Words
    • 2 Pages

    REASONS #2: China had close nit cities venerable to disease spread while the Indian empire were more spread apart and less susceptible to disease.…

    • 253 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Another political difference involves the use of a language. Han China had the standard language of Mandarin which kept the civilization more together and unified as a whole. India did not have a standard language at all. They did have the use for Sanskrit but this was mainly reserved for the elite only. Again this political method kept India more apart than Han China.…

    • 537 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    While European Rome and Asian Han Dynasty China were unique civilizations in their own ways, they did happen to share a lot of qualities between each other. A couple of the similarities were their monarchy-run governments - both placed a single person (an emperor) in charge of the respective empire, both of them had were originally made up of many different kingdoms in their countries with one ending up controlling the rest, they both used lots of agriculture in their economies, and both Rome and Han China gradually deteriorated after long rules.…

    • 180 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Though many Western civilizations have influenced the way we live our lives today, many forget the progressive movements of early Classical and Contemporary Oriental cultures. Two of these cultures that are still revisited by historians today were the epitome of early Asian civilization and very influential guides for cultures to come. Han China (206 B.C.E.-220 A.D.) and Gupta India (320 C.E.-525 C.E.) were two dynasty-based civilizations in the early conception of Southeastern Asian rule. Though both had a very similar class based society and both had to endure outside invasions as well as internal conflicts, they both had unique, and future utilized, ways of maintaining their rule.…

    • 688 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ccot China 100-600 C.E.

    • 391 Words
    • 2 Pages

    From 100 C.E. to 600 C.E., in classical China, there were many changes both cultural and political, like the increase of Buddhism and the expansion of territory. However not everything changed, there were also several cultural continuities, the continuation of ancestor worship, and political continuities, the ongoing building of the Great Wall.…

    • 391 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    During the classical period two early civilizations appeared. Ancient Athens arose with its intelligence and love for the human physique, while Han China arose with its strong beliefs of religion and love of nature. Even though Han China and Ancient Athens both have politically strong governments, they are very different in cultural beliefs and social structure because of how they treat women and how they feel about infanticide of babies.…

    • 316 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mesopotamia vs China

    • 468 Words
    • 2 Pages

    China and Mesopotamia are alike in a lot of ways. Both of the civilizations started on or by a river. This helped with the starting of their trade, and helped them get off the ground and running. They both also created many extraordinary inventions. The Mesopotamians invented the first ever wheel. This made it easier to move things around faster. As time went on the wheel got bigger and better and made things a lot easier. Mesopotamia also invented the first every calendar. This was a very basic calendar but it made time keeping easier. China invented the Silk Road. This was a huge trading route that went through almost every civilization. This made is extremely easy to trade which they could not live without. It was created during the Han Dynasty. Another similarity of the two is that they both made a way to write. Mesopotamia created the first ever form of writing during 3500 BCE. The writings were simple pictures which represented an object or idea. They used clay to draw the picture because that’s all they had. China also created a type of writing. The Chinese used a series of symbols that created a word or phrase. They both were very patriarchal. Both of the two civilizations had a lot in common.…

    • 468 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    During the Ancient times, China and India both had their own set of beliefs; Han Wudi excerised Confucianism in China and Ashoka promoted Buddhism in India but Han Wudi was not a lover of Confucian where Ashoka himself practiced Buddhism. However both ruled with a centralized bureaucracy and policed the provinces to maintain order and policies. And lastly, neither had strict policies constricting their people nor did they have much of a justified social structure.…

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Rome and Han china

    • 3772 Words
    • 16 Pages

    1. Roman Republic: The period from 507 to 31 B.C.E., during which Rome was largely governed by the aristocratic Roman Senate.…

    • 3772 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Han vs Mauryan

    • 860 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The Han Dynasty of China and the Mauryan/Gupta Empire of India in 206 B.C.E to 550 C.E had many social and cultural differences which made them unique societies, but their political structure and form of government seemed to borrow ideas from each other.…

    • 860 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    During the classical period, many civilizations and large land bases were formed. Of these many civilizations, two main ones were Han China and Imperial Rome. Although Han China and Imperial Rome both had similar government structures and trading systems, they both had two very different militaries.…

    • 394 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Indian civilizations didn’t stress politics, but relied on religion and the worship of gods. Hinduism was the religion that had the majority of support. It pursued numerous religious and ceremonial approaches that sought to unite individual humans. Other religions were Buddhism and Hinduism that gained a big following as well. China had Daoism, Confucianism, and Legalism, and as well formed the Mandate of heaven. The Mandate of Heaven was used to choose a ruler, that was said to have been given permission by the gods themselves. Both civilizations had religion as an enormous importance to them that accompanied them in developing and advancing. They also both had more than one belief system that people followed.…

    • 513 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Classical China and Classical India are one of the most unique early civilizations during the Classical Period. They are known for their contributions to its modern world. China and India are similar and different in many ways. Both China and India had many similarities and differences in politics, economics, and religion.…

    • 845 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Classical China and Classical India have many similarities, but some ideas like politics and the social classes can differ from one or another. Politics was a way on how these classical civilizations had a government and what made the government had power to lead their civilization. Social class was a way to put people in ranks which was also a way for the different types of jobs they did. Politics also goes with social class since it showed that only certain types of people could be in the government.…

    • 600 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The hierarchy of ancient China and India were similar with a noticeable sign of select individuals being considered “higher” then others. The caste system was strict in India and prohibited other classes from interacting with each other. China’s social system differed from India’s caste system, by not demonstrating a formal and strict social ladder. Where in India there existed over three hundred subcastes at one point, China had a simple three caste social ladder. Although the Chinese did not have as strong of a social ladder, there still existed “higher” people such as the bureaucrats. Bureaucrats and landowners were considered to be of a higher class then peasants, farmers, and merchants. Patriarchy was a very big factor in culture and social order in China and India. India’s strict caste system led to a more “flexible” and popular religion known as Hinduism. Many Indians preferred this religion over Buddhism, which the Chinese practiced, because the brahmans or priests strongly influenced the population. Brahmans and many other Indians did not like the idea of any being of any caste level achieving “peace” by their efforts, which Buddhism taught. The Chinese believed in Buddhism and reaching nirvana by finding peace within. A major difference between Indian and Chinese culture was that Indians lived to die and reincarnate to a better caste level and eventually reaching the gods, whereas the Chinese lived a good life with no rituals necessary to find nirvana. Although the Chinese and Indian culture was very different, both races strived and lived in balance to find their gift in the afterlife. A major difference between the Chinese and Indian culture was that…

    • 907 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays