Preview

Analysis Of The Film 'Working Girl'

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1752 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Analysis Of The Film 'Working Girl'
The film “Working Girl” illustrates the feminist fight and struggles of women in the work force in the 1980s to the present, every contradiction relates to the main problems that women face. The two main women characters in “Working Girl” represent the two types of stereotypes of women that establish themselves in the corporate world, Kathrine Parker and Tess McGill. Despite the film being an inspirational feminist story, the writer Kevin Wade created a love plot between the main character, Tess McGill and a side character, Jack Trainer. This side love plot takes away from the main tone and contradicts the original goal of the film, to inspire women to break barriers. The movie did not require this love trope, if the film had a stand alone …show more content…
The irony of having men direct and write this women’s right film is similar to person with fully functioning legs writing literature explaining the struggles of being disabled. Since the literature is written by the oppressors of women’s rights, their make of the situation and view is extremely inverted. Furthermore, the main character, Tess McGill was not based off of any businesswoman, Wade created this character without inspiration from a woman that actually drove that path, which makes it seem unattainable. Having no real life woman to look up to, after turning off the television, made the journey seem romanticized and unrealistic in the 1980s. Young women were not given many or no female business role models to follow after since business and politics are such a male dominate fields. The importance of women in the media is extremely consequential since they impact the young girls that grow up, thinking that working is a man’s game. A group or person outside of a minority group will never understand the oppression and write about women’s struggles respectively or correctly. It is the difference between someone experiencing sympathy, but think they can put themselves in the opposing side and empathy, knowing the fight and discrimination. The message behind the film “Working Girl” would have been more influential if an actual businesswoman had done what Tess McGill achieved or at least based off of some individual. While Kevin Wade did a fantastic job at capturing feminism in the 1980s and everything, the cause faced, it contradicts with the theme of the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Thus, in an attempt to further promote equal opportunity between men and women, a second wave of feminism emerged between 1968 and the 1980’s, which can be best characterized by women’s refusal to acclimate to society’s rigid belief of what an ideal woman should be or act like (Mancia, Class, 12/2). This problem is perfectly illustrated in the Feminine Mystique, written by Betty Friedan, in which Friedan discussed the unhappiness of many young women in the 1950’s and early 1960’s despite many of them being married and having children, living the life a woman is “supposed” to have. Furthermore, Friedan complained of young women who were being taught that “truly feminine women do not want careers, higher education, political rights” (Friedan, p. 271). Instead, they were being taught that it was a woman’s “job” to essentially be a housewife (i.e. stay home, clean the house, make food for her family, take care of the kids, etc...) (Friedan, p. 273). However, Friedan largely opposed this view and believed that it embodied the false prototypical stereotype about women. Rather, Friedan believed that a truly feminine woman would do just the exact opposite and does aim for a career, higher education, and political rights in the same way that a man would (Mancia, Class,…

    • 738 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    However, Tina represents a society of the woman who are pursued by men at an early age with empty promises! At first, the film compromised women regarding their reputations. Nevertheless, concerning the times, women were required to spend their time performing their maternal duties. The resentment of these stereotypical female roles matches the quality, or lack thereof, male trustworthiness and loyalty.…

    • 425 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Using personal experience, Peggy Orenstein, discusses the impact businesses such as Disney and Mattel have on reinforcing gender roles. The fact that she is a mother discussing her own struggles gives the piece a more casual and personal tone. She is speaking to those like her. Having a conversation with the readers causes the piece to be well-rounded. While she does not address the reader directly the casual nature of the writing allows her to make an argument, bring up questions about the argument and then answer those questions all while simply talking about an experience she had with her own daughter. Also unlike a ‘Scholar of women’s studies’ her main focus is on her daughter. Not political correctness or staying true to her feminist beliefs, but providing the best atmosphere for her daughter.…

    • 483 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Girl Interrupted Analysis

    • 1132 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Soaked, little, and naked is how the viewer finds Susanna in the middle of Girl, Interrupted. Or rather, soaked, little, naked, and hysterical. A state James Mangold utilizes to further illustrate his message. The film serves as a vehicle for Mangold to discuss madness and the society it exists within. Valerie, the asylum’s registered nurse, throws Susanna, the film’s suicidal protagonist, into a tub filled with water in order to snap Susanna out of her depressed state. Susanna lashes out at Valerie with every hurtful vulgarity she has within her. Despite this, Valerie remains calm and collected. In this interaction between Susanna and Valerie, madness is portrayed in its most basic form; it is an ongoing battle between the individual and the environment surrounding it. The individual is a victim of his environment, overwhelmed into regurgitating the detritus surrounding him that are readily filtered and suppressed by those deemed sane by society.…

    • 1132 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In part 1 of Makers: Women Who Make America it talks about how it was complicated for women in society, because they weren’t treated equally as men. People viewed women as being less capable of what man could do. When they interviewed …… she explain how women weren’t able to run in the Boston marathon. She had a good interest in running and thought women should be able to run in the marathon as well. So she sign up for the race with just her initials, and when she was in the race everyone was surprised. When she crossed the finished line she showed how women could be good at certain sports just as men. Also another scene from the movie is when women didn’t have many job opportunities as men. It was hard for them to get jobs they were criticized by men who didn’t think it was right for women to work other than stay home and take care of their family.Also when they interview Carolyn Graglia she saids all the things women at home can do which is extremely worth while is dismissed and uworthy of any respect. This made women feel as if they were unworthy to society.…

    • 522 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    We as Americans reminisce on history to see and understand the advancements we have accomplished and the same can be said of not only the advancement of women but also the image of how women are portrayed. Although in today’s day and age, their figures and beauty are scrutinized but also exploited. For instance in both Tennessee Williams motion picture, “A Street Car Named Desire” and Lorraine Hansberry A Raisin in the Sun you are able to see the evolution of the not only the portal of women but also the advancements they accomplish.…

    • 508 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This film was nominated for the Sundance Film Festival for all the right reasons. Multiple interviews provided first-hand experience of the effect media, and gender inequality (which sometimes goes unnoticed) has on women in recent years. Videos that were shown in the documentary were uncut and unedited to showcase the sometimes hidden side of the media. The writer of this documentary wanted its viewers to become enlightened about the problems we face today in our society regarding gender exploitation and…

    • 571 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cracks in the Mold

    • 1020 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In the 1950s, the attitudes surrounding women’s roles were very “Leave it to Beaver” oriented. Women were homemakers, not educated thinkers who should compete in a global economy. In a 1956 Life magazine article, the introduction charges that “many of woman’s current troubles began with the period of her preoccupation with her ‘rights” (Evans, 177). “Ladies, we have won our case, but for heaven’s sake let’s stop trying to prove it over and over again” (177). But in fact, women had to “prove it over and over again.” Women from different ideologies, stronger or more moderate in their philosophies would have to fight for equal opportunity well beyond the disillusioned consumer crazy 1950s. When a growing overall sentiment of unhappiness seemed to seep up from the “feminine mystique” façade, many critics fought back against the society-challenging thoughts of mid-century feminists. Theorists…

    • 1020 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Working Girl, directed by Mike Nichol, recalls a rags-to-riches story in a modern society where the class divisions are precisely sharp. Set in the 1980s, the film provides a historical situation of inequitable distribution: this inequity sways all the characters’ behavior. Though Tess McGill and Jack Trainer spark up a romance, it is Tess’ acquisitiveness that make the romance sizzle. In order to impersonate the bourgeoisie, Tess undergoes an extraordinary transformation. Tess, a proletariat, learns that if she wants to get ahead, she has to act, talk, and dress like the bourgeoisie. The film offers clear evidence of conspicuous consumption—the clothing Tess’ boss, Katherine Parker, wears—suggesting a negative example of the Marxist theory and a tacit endorsement of the free market.…

    • 1088 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Real Women Have Curves

    • 1038 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The play Real Women Have Curves was written by Josefina Lopez, it depicted the hard ships of immigrant female workers and the power and strength of women working together as one. About a decade later a movie was made. However the movie Real Women Have Curves still shows the same struggles these women in the play face and also shows how strong women working together can be. The key differences from the movie and the play are that they depict two different stories and almost give off completely different messages, especially when the movie has male influences. The theme of the play is that women are powerful especially when working together. The theme of the film is that a woman is more about being independent and making one’s own decisions: like deciding to leave and go to college and start her own life.…

    • 1038 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Many scenes throughout the movie show the white American society’s negative perception of the capabilities of female African-American’s. This prejudice results in female African-American women developing their own self-concept (Cooley, 1902). Instead of feeling insignificant, these women strive to show the intelligence they hold and disprove their colleagues’ false perceptions. For example, in one scene, Mary Jackson is told by her boss to pursue her engineering degree to which Mary replies “I’m a Negro woman, I’m not going to entertain the impossible” (Melfi, 2016). The American society of the 1970s influences how Mary responds to her boss’s encouragement. She believes that due to her race and gender, she will not be able to pursue her dream. However, Mary realises that she is one of the smartest engineers and should not limit herself thus taking the issue to court. Although society has affected the way Mary views herself, she knows that she is more than what others say and later realises that her capabilities are endless. This film is very relevant to many areas around the world. Engineering is considered as a male-dominated profession and females that wish to enter in that field are discriminated. It shows that society’s view on how gender and races should behave influence our understanding of what we can…

    • 1530 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    However in the years to come many in the film industry would begin to challenge these guidelines starting with films such as 1960’s Mary Poppins. Anne Mcleer in her essay makes clear that although not radical ,”Mary Poppins” would begin to have us question our traditional roles. Films like such challenged the idea of the stay at home mother, and the father being the bread winner, even questioning the role of the father in their children’s lives, encouraging men to be more involved. Yet even as we began to progress, giving women larger roles in film with films such as Julie Andrews in “Victoria, Victor Victoria”, and Tracy Turnlab in “Hairspray” many in the film industry still encouraged traditional ideals. This was espeacially prevalent in the 1980’s, in Elaine Berland , and Marilyn Wetcher’s research they give us the example of the film “Fatal Attraction” this film shows us an stay at home mother with a husband who is cheating on her with a career driven women, and all of the problems that come with this…

    • 1334 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In order to look after her family, Tess took up a job in an insurance company entering data. Her job did not pay her much yet she worked for long hours with no pay rise. (Wiseman, 1998 p.7). This was because women were seen "lower down the hierarchy" in the workforce. (Connell, 2009 p.2). Also, women worldwide regardless of being from developed countries or the Third World countries have always been considered cheap labour. Jobs such as Tess’s were no longer as secured and well paid or full-time job when male participation was higher. (Acker, 2010 p.379). In addition, her job as a mother was limited due to constant work and her husband losing his job.…

    • 623 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gail Collins argues, “The Feminine Mystique is a very specific cry of rage about the way intelligent, well-educated women were kept out of the mainstream of American professional life and regarded as little more than a set of reproductive organs in heels” (1). At a time when women were at their academic peak with the highest college attendance and graduation rates, one would assume that women would confidently take on more important roles in the workforce, especially following the Rosie the Riveter campaign that empowered female workers during World War II; however, women took on more domestic roles in higher percentages, forgetting the progress in women’s rights their mothers and grandmothers worked so hard to achieve. Louis Menand explains, “When Friedan was writing her book, the issue of gender equality was barely on the public’s radar screen. On the contrary: it was almost taken for granted that the proper goal for intelligent women was marriage” (2). A large contributor to this decision is the false sense of accomplishment women were promised in return for their spousal duties. Critic Catherine Judd explains, “Friedan notes that suburban housewives have been told by the media, by the medical community, and by educators that they…

    • 1340 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Feminine Mystique

    • 357 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The treatment of women in the workplace, school and wider society has evolved since the first wave of feminism. But to what extent are women treated as equal to their male counterpart? The persistent gap between the treatment of men and women even after the first wave of feminism provoked a second wave. The catalyst to mainstream feminism in the 1960’s through 1970’s was Betty Friedan’s book,The Feminine Mystique. Women's right activist and writer, Betty Friedan, a leading figure in the Feminist movement. Her book ,The Feminine Mystique, was a major influence in the second wave of Feminism because it voiced what so many women lacked to say; they wanted more. The Feminine Mystique was published in 1963 and over two million copies were sold…

    • 357 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics