Preview

Analysis Of Miss Representation

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1291 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Analysis Of Miss Representation
Throughout a women’s life she is faced with many obstacles just because of the gender she is. A little girl will eventually hear, “you can’t do that because you are not a boy”. It never occurred to me that the media has a hand in this way of society’s thinking. At the end of watching Miss Representation the viewer will actually feel that the media is the primary reason for undermining the growth of women in the United States. Jennifer Siebel Newsom, the director of Miss Representation, does an excellent job to convince her audience that women need to be portrayed as more than just pretty objects in the media. She does this by sharing many disheartening statistics, interviewing various types of people, and by showing offensive images and …show more content…
This persuasion method is great because you hear the point of view of young women, celebrities, doctors, women in power and, men. As Caroline Heldman PhD says, “The more women and girls self-objectify, the more likely they are to be depressed, to have eating disorders, they have lower confidence, they have lower ambition, lower cognitive-functioning, [and] they have lower GPA’s.” The viewer is now seeing the detrimental effects of women pursuing these unrealistic levels of beauty that the media has shown us. By Newsom incorporating commentary from doctors you get the validity needed to persuade the audience of how important it is for women to be portrayed as more than just objects in print and television. Another part to the film that is welcoming, is the commentary by men. For example, the former Mayor of San Francisco Gavin Newsom says, “When you are not treated the same, you are dehumanized”. Having the element of male commentaries in the film helps the male viewer connect with the issue at hand and make them angry as well for the prejudices women face. By having the male perspective in the film, it shows that this film is not biased and gives the director’s argument more credibility. Last and definitely not least, Newsom interviews young girls, who all explicitly express their need for change. There’s one young girl named Maria who cries to the camera as she explains that her …show more content…
For example, we are shown a picture of Sarah Palin at the podium, but the image is shot between her legs. Here we have a woman trying to advance in politics and all we see are her legs. This woman is trying to be taken seriously yet the media is still knocking her down as just a ‘pretty object”. For the female audience of the film this type of imagery is terribly upsetting. Also, throughout the film the audience is shown many images of women licking their fingers, prancing around in bikinis, and being sexy. These images make the viewer shake their head because it makes them think, “is this what women really are?” Newsom selected many images that make the audience’s skin crawl, because women are more than just sexual objects. Another great example of the how the images in the film are persuasive are the images of how models are photoshopped. Models are considered to be some of the most beautiful women of the world, yet they are still being altered. Women are being fed these unrealistic ideas of beauty, when the women they are viewing, do not even really look this way. By Newsom including this ‘unmasking” it is a great way to show the audience of how the media disillusions us. Overall, Newsom did a sperb job of the images and television clip selection for her film, because they paint the media in a horrible light. The imagery she gives us shows us how

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Hi Vy, I like how you started your rhetorical analysis! Through your introduction I can get an understanding of how manipulative the media is, how it degrades women, and why the way women are portrayed is a big issue in America. I think it is effective that you mentioned how it is a big issue because it makes readers want to continue reading. I like that you said, “Moreover, in the film, “Only 34 women have ever served as governors. Yet comprise only 17% of Congress, women have not made gain in Congress since 1979.” This demonstrates that Newsom uses logical appeals to persuade her audience that there is an under-representation of women not only in popular culture (films and music), but also in congress. 17% out of 100% is a small number which…

    • 169 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Miss Representation, the 2011 documentary about how the mainstream media depicts women negatively in the United States, educates the viewers on the harmful media representation that is brought upon women. Females who are featured in the media are often depicted as a sexual image to men. When the film states that “the media is selling young people the idea that girls’ and women’s value lies in their youth, beauty, and sexuality and not in their capacity as leaders.” it informs the viewer that the media is a dangerous tool used to explicitly demand what women should do, say, buy, and look like. The audience is directed towards anyone who is interested in learning more about the ways the media adversely portrays women. The tone of the film alters…

    • 166 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The documentary Miss Representation shows the false representation of women through media. The media’s portrayal of what a powerful women is includes harmful and artificial substances to the body. It is important for all of us to learn the truth behind media because false stereotypes are created. We must value and respect human beings and not as objects. People must know that they can be powerful just by being themselves and not by trying to be someone else. The truth behind feminist anger can awaken our society and start a change in the world. Our everyday lives are effected by these false advertised women in television, magazines, music videos, etc. The film points out that influential women do not need to wear clothes that reveal their body…

    • 229 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Miss Representation was an accurate depiction of the media’s influence in our society, especially in women. The film showed how women are subjected in the media, in particular the mass media, and how the development of young women is altered by the media. This film was entered in the 2011 Sundance Film Festival and achieved praise from many viewers and critics. This is why I selected to review Miss Representation.…

    • 571 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Media depicts women in a subordinate role in relation to men. Media objectifies hyper-sexualized representations of women in order to appeal to the male viewer. Codes of Gender unveils methods used in photography to perpetuate the idea that females are dehumanized subordinate objectified figures. These codes or methods include various actions, poses, or positions female models are forced to perform. For example, the feminine touch, the bashful knee bend, the head tilt, poses lying down, etc. all of which subordinate the female figure in relation to men. Miss Representation gives a broader view into society’s representation of women within media. The film emphasizes the impossible ideal standard, the hyper-sexualization, the objectification, and scrutinization, women must undergo to achieve any type of success in our current society. Miss Representation focuses on the average viewer, whereas Codes of Gender appeals more to intellectual viewer. Although each film takes a different perspective, both address issues women face in society as represented and visualized through media. One thing is clear; media is directly linked to societal beliefs. In order for one to change, we must address and change the…

    • 1734 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As I watched ‘Killing us Softly 3’, I began to feel the clutch of Jean Kilbourne’s hand around my dignity as I already found myself preparing my mind’s susceptibility to her reprimanding me for being a part of the mass media culture who through its advertising objectifies women. Unfortunately for Mrs. Kilbourne however, these feelings of self-loathing were short lived. I realized that as a sympathizer for the hardships and discrimination that women are faced with, I was almost drawn into this amalgamation of carefully chosen advertising and continual castigation. I only approach this so critically because I strongly feel as though her prancing through what she would have us believe is ‘modern media’ is actually completely detrimental to her cause.…

    • 639 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Miss Representation, a film written and produced by Jennifer Siebel Newsom, paints a vivid image of how mass media is souring the minds Americans all throughout the country. News stations and advertisement agencies perpetuate gender stereotypes, and continue to uphold unattainable standards for American women. This film struck a particular chord with me, as I was riveted by the discussion of the inequalities amongst women and men in several different areas of society. The power structure in America is fundamentally flawed, and women are severally misrepresented. Newsom captures the harsh consequences of gender inequalities and body image discrepancies through multiple first-hand accounts, and hard-hitting statistics. I found the commentary…

    • 1379 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    WGS Frozen Paper

    • 578 Words
    • 2 Pages

    I am writing to you today regarding an issue in today’s society of social construction of gender in media. As you may know, the media has a very powerful effect on today’s modern society and culture. People tend to believe that birth is where gender is formed, which technically isn’t right. The self-identification of being male or female (sex) is shaped through cultural and social conditions. Through these cultural and social conditions, we set these ideals for gender performance that then sets a societal standard for both women and men.…

    • 578 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Rhetoric Analysis Essay

    • 1175 Words
    • 5 Pages

    For example, the young woman is sitting or passed out on the bathroom floor with her underwear down to her ankles. That is the rhetorical strategy. The rhetorical appeal that is being demonstrated is pathos. This is because when analyzing the image the audience feels emotion; sympathy. To further demonstrate that pathos is active in this image; just the image in general the young women looks so helpless. The authors use pathos to demonstrate an image of a woman’s legs with her underwear down to her ankles. The audience gets the sense of emotion there because it is not normal for someone to be passed out on a bathroom floor. Another example of pathos being used in this PSA is the use of word choice. Where it says “She didn’t want to do it, but she couldn’t say no” it gives the audience the need to show sympathy towards the young women. Then the PSA goes on to talk about making bad decisions and how making the bad decision like going home with someone they hardly know and leading themselves into a vulnerable situation. Which can lead to date rape. Furthermore, pathos is demonstrated again, it reads, “Help your friends stay in control and stay safe.” By the authors inserting this text is too make you want to watch out for your friends and to make sure everyone makes it home…

    • 1175 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    1950 Gender Roles

    • 596 Words
    • 3 Pages

    This depiction of women in the media teaches women to oppose working outside the home. There is a distinction between TV depictions of women and the genuine position of women in the present day making young girls to learn out dated gender roles. TV sustains the idea that women do not make a difference as much as men and they have inside a home because the vast majority of the women on TV appear to be inside a home. Women’s magazines propose the idea that a women’s goal is to be hitched and deal with children not to have a profession. Media representation of women leads young girls to trust that their role in society is…

    • 596 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Miss Representation

    • 2008 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Women are constantly unrealistically portrayed; they are objectified and hyper sexualized in the media. The documentary features the difficulties women have to go through when their ideals are unobtainable and the pressure they feel when people want them to look a certain way. These images allow women to think that their body is the only voice they have, it’s the only tool to identify themselves and that this is their worth. Jean Kilbourne quoted beautifully, “Girls are being encouraged to achieve that ideal at younger and younger ages all the time. They end up measuring themselves against an impossible standard and feeling themselves wanting as a result of it.” Miss Representation showed ordinary high school students speaking about the issues they felt about the negative perceptions of women. We were able to understand the pain and pressure young women have to face everyday to conform to this ideology of beauty. It makes it difficult for teenagers because if they do not look…

    • 2008 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The most sensitive and controversial topics from time to time is gender representation. Gender representations in media often portray male and female stereotypically, in which they are depicted differently (Doring 2006, p. 173). Even though the representation of gender in media has already been developed lately, but women’s representation in media are still portrayed stereotypically in various ways. According to Amancio (1993), he stated that gender stereotypes are seen as social representations or collective ideologies defining model of behavior. Media do not simply reflect the reality in society about the gender stereotypes; it supports the ruling class’ ideology of patriarchy which controls the issue of gender all over the world by producing…

    • 189 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Where The Girls Are

    • 635 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The portrayal of women in the media has gone through a shift in the past 50 years. A shift incited by the feminist movement of the 1970’s in which women rebelled against their assigned role as the subordinate housewife. The media could no longer ignore the rising presence of feminism. As a response, it infused feminist ideals with traditional values to showcase an unrealistic standard for women. A standard, which Douglas argues in Where the Girls Are, that caused the “cultural identity crisis” many women faced (Douglas 1994). Women were told that they could have it all. They can be independent working women while being obedient housewives. While this depiction is optimistic and assumes women can have the best of both worlds, it fails to recognize…

    • 635 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Kilbourne

    • 727 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In the video, Kilbourne’s main audience that she is trying to reach is young women. The movie aims to inform girls about the world that they live in and how advertising affects us all. Awareness about what is being done is said sometimes in a humorous way as to capture and interest the audience. This is done quite well when an ad, advertising shampoo uses example of how imperfect your breast can be, but at least your hair can be perfect. This is then humorously contrasted with what one for men would sound like. She uses milder facts, statistics, and stories that will have shock value but completely upset the viewer of her presentation in contrast the essay contains a starling amount of statistics that reveal the truth about woman battery and abuse. The target audience for the book is more of the average women. The tone is one used to talk to other adults around her age. She even makes a reference to the women of her generation and how that may have experienced harassment in the school but, it is nothing like what the girls and women today are experience, “how different from the “teasing “some of us might remember from our own childhoods”. In the essay there are at least two example given of how a court has gone in favor of the perpetrator no the victim of the crime done. Where the video gives and overview of all the topics discussed the essay goes deeper into the logistics and details of how the advertisements are really affecting people.…

    • 727 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Signorelli, N. (1997). “Reflections of Girls in the Media: A study of Television Shows and…

    • 5062 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays