Preview

Analysis: Is Torture Ever Justified?

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1598 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Analysis: Is Torture Ever Justified?
Is torture ever justified? This question response automatically comes the way one may perceive torture or defines torture’s meaning. In a number of dictionaries torture is defined as, “extreme pain; anguish of body or mind, or the act of inflicting excruciating pain, as punishment or revenge as a means of getting a confession for information”. In layman’s terms, torture is just sheer cruelty and in no way morally right, not permissible, or in no situation justified. Slavery would be a situation leading to a form of torture. To take someone from the only family, home, and in some cases, sanity they might have in a blink of an eye is morally unjustified. Imagine waking up one day with your whole world being shattered beyond disbelief and being …show more content…
The United States Holocaust Memorial Museum overview of the killing centers displays:
The Nazis established killing centers for efficient mass murder. Unlike concentration camps, which served primarily as detention and labor centers, killing centers (also referred to as "extermination camps" or "death camps") were almost exclusively "death factories." German SS and police murdered nearly 2,700,000 Jews in the killing centers either by asphyxiation with poison gas or by shooting.
The Diary of Anne Frank was a book written by a young girl, who was in hiding from the Nazis, captured and taken to a concentration camp where she kept detailed notes on her life during this process. An insight of a fifteen year old who had dreams of becoming a journalist wrote in her diary: Is discord going to show itself while we are still fighting, is the Jew once again worth less than another? Oh, it is sad, very sad, that once more, for the umpteenth time, the old truth is confirmed: What one Christian does is his own responsibility, what one Jew does is thrown back at all Jews.
…show more content…
During war or potential terrorist attacks would be a common answer a person would give in response to this question. The September Eleventh attacks, often referred to as “9/11” (pronounced “nine eleven”), were a series of suicidal attacks on the United States by al-Qaeda. On that morning, al-Qaeda terrorist hijacked four commercial airplanes and intentionally crashing two of them into the Twin Towers of the World Trade Center in New York City, killing everyone on board and many other workers in the building (CQ Homeland Security). Until this event, the words “terrorist” and “torture” were not your common topics in an everyday conversation. Ten years later, this event can be remembered as vividly as if it happened yesterday. Torturing a terrorist poses one question, will any information that a person gives while being tortured be the right information? A person who is experiencing extreme pain will say anything to stop the pain, whether it is true or not. People will confess to crimes they have not committed, and throw out any information that pops in their heads in order to stop the torture. Leading to false information, we are led on wide goose chases that waste time and expend resources. The thing we Americans put above these monsters called “torturers” are the high value we put on Bill of Rights, human rights, and our freedoms. We should not lower our moral ideals to the point where we are no

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Anne wrote in her diary when she was in hiding and she wrote about the events happening in the secret annex and about her feelings. "Anne wrote in her diary that she wants to become a writer or a journalist in the future, and that she wants to publish her diary as a novel" (Stitching The Story). Anne Frank hoped and wished she becomes a writer or journalist, so she wrote and recorded her feelings, the events that were happening and she wrote some poems and quotes from other writers. She was editing so she can publish it, but she got arrested. She died in a concentration camp, but her father survived and found her diary, he published the book and many people bought and read it. Anne Frank may have died but her dream did co me true, she became a well known writer due to her…

    • 787 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Killing centers were established by the Nazis. These killing centers were simply just "death factories." Almost 2,700,000 Jews were murdered in these centers, either by asphyxiation with posionous gas, or by shooting. The first of these camps was Chelmno. Not only Jews, but some Gypsies, were also gassed here in mobile gas vans. Belzec, Dobibor and Treblinka were all opened in 1942 in Generalgouvenement (territory in the interior of occupied Poland.) These camps were refered to as the "Operation Reinhard camps." In these camps the German SS (major paramilitary organization under Adolf Hitler and the Nazi Party) killed exactly 1,526,500 Jews between March of 1942 and November of 1943. All of the people that arrived at these camps were sent to the death in the gas chambers as soon as they arrived (excluding a small amount that were chosen for a special work team called the Sonderkommandos.)The largest of these centers was Auschwitz-Birkenau. By spring of 1943 this camp had four operating gas chambers, in which they murdered up to 6,000 Jewes a day.…

    • 295 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    At some point everyone has heard of torture. It could have been in a movie or on the news, but they have heard of it. In this day and age, people would like to have believed it was all behind us in the past. Then 9/11 happened, everyone’s lives were changed with one simple act of cruelty. Before 9/11 hit the U.S. in a wave of pain, panic, and anger, our viewpoints on torture would probably have been less likely that it should be allowed. The decision to torture people who are suspected of being part of terrorist groups has always been decided by the government, for the simple reason that it is required to keep us safe from harm. Some people believe that torture is cruel, unsightly and just inhumane. On the other hand there are people who see it the same way but also believe it could be necessary in extreme circumstances. We’re going to look at two different points of torture: When it is acceptable and when it is not acceptable.…

    • 886 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    If torture is used in retaliation and as an “eye to eye” concept, then torture would be an unethical way of punishing someone (Guidebook). For this example, I would argue that torture is being used to provide the members with the realization for their actions, so torture is an unethical way of punishment. Also, torture is not a replacement for the death penalty, so it is not saving an individual’s life because in the guidebook it states that if “torture is vengeful and not being used to protect innocent lives, then it is not technically a moral reason for punishing someone” (Guidebook). Without protecting innocent lives, torture cannot be considered an ethical reason for punishing someone, so I would argue that the type of punishment that should be used is an elongated amount of jail time. Incarceration meets all the requirements for being a moral type of punishment because it doesn't cause mental harm that torture would and incarcerating the members would not be a retaliating…

    • 1062 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “The Truth about Torture,” Charles Krauthammer critically analyzes the John McCain, an individual with tremendous moral influence who was tortured by the North Vietnamese, amendment. This amendment would prohibit all forms of torture from being executed on war prisoners of America. In response, Krauthammer states that in certain scenarios, torture is not “just permissible, but also morally required.” He divides the war prisoners into the following three classifications: ordinary soldiers arrested on the battlefield, captured terrorists, and finally, terrorists who possess information. With regards to the ordinary soldiers, McCain’s amendment is justified because although these war prisoners are on the opposite side of the conflict, they are nonetheless lawful fighters who committed no crime. On the contrary, Krauthammer believes that the terrorists are not worthy of the same protection and privileges since they intend to harm innocent citizens.…

    • 497 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In light of the recent events such as the War on Terrorism and the war in Iraq, torture has become a topic of close consideration. Torture is sometimes used when a person who is believed to have information about a possible harmful event or information about an illegal organization, is then inflicted with pain by members of the opposing side with a series of different physical and mental distresses, in hope of forcing the person to give over desired information. Torture has often been used during times of war and political unrest, and in situations where the information could protect the society from danger. I believe that torture is never an…

    • 1500 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Considering terrorist attacks that harm or potentially kill at least thousand(s) of people, torture may seem justifiable. Torture, defined in these instances as physically non-lethal, has been generally used to extract information from terrorists that may lead to the prevention of massive terrorist attack.…

    • 696 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tragedy In Torture

    • 1125 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Advocates of torture argue that torture is a necessary tool especially in time sensitive scenarios, like if an individual is the only person alive who knows the whereabouts of a bomb that is set to detonate, resulting in the deaths of hundreds. I could not even imagine how stressful the interview process of this scenario would be, as time progresses and no results are being produced, inflicting pain does not only have the possibility of yielding results but it would also be a convenient way to externalize your frustrations.…

    • 1125 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    We are put under a time crunch that affects how we deal with situations. Michael Levin wrote in his essay “The Case for Torture” that we should use torture because it is better to torture one person who is obviously guilty. This would help insure that thousands of lives could be saved at the expense of just one or a few people. In a brief statement about terrorist’s rights, Levin says “torture is barbaric? Mass murder is more barbaric” (532). In this simple statement, Levin argues that torturing is the lesser of two evils. And it is true. Would we rather sacrifice many lives for one that is potentially guilty? Most would say no. In fact, if we allow torture to become legal, we might get results that many have not thought of. If torture was made legal, it could potentially intimidate future terrorists into thinking twice about their plans. Still, nothing is for…

    • 1284 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are many questions relating to the use of torture against any person whatsoever. As such, there are different perspectives on the ethics of its usage as well. While some believe that the use of torture becomes necessary at times, others believe that whatever the circumstances are, torture can never be justified. Some very pertinent issues related to the use of torture are, “Suppose a child has been kidnapped and a person has been suspected of committing the crime. Is it justifiable to torture that person in order to try to extract information from him about the child? Now suppose the person would not react at all if he is subjected to torture but there is a chance that he would divulge information if his child of the similar age as the…

    • 545 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Arguments Against Torture

    • 590 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Justifying the needs of implementing various methods of torture is strongly a recommended option to protecting America’s security and American citizens. While the debate of whether the use of torture is valid to protect the United States of America overall, supporters of the argument strongly argue that interrogating terrorists is only useful when various torture methods are involved. During one of the United States of America’s darkest periods in the nation’s history, the terrorists attack of September 11, 2001 rebooted the discussion of how various methods of torture are a justifiable means to not only place vengeance on the terrorists involved in the attacks on America’s soil. In the course of the aftermath of the horrific attacks of September 11, 2001, supporters of using various methods of torture during the interrogation process observed a central argument to prove their case. For example, if America’s security becomes unfortunately at risk of another terrorists attack, the nation could potentially protect Americans by implementing various methods of torture to only not question terrorists’ against their willpower.…

    • 590 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Why Torture Is Wrong

    • 933 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Torture has been a technique use by many nations in the world including the United States. Physically and psychologically damage captured people is what the government do when under attack. There were innocent victims along with attackers that got captured for terrorist and war interrogation. Terrorist attacks like September 11 are unpredictable and it then disturb every citizen’s everyday life. However, that should not be the reason to arrest suspects and torture them, sometimes to death, to get ahold of the true culprits.…

    • 933 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Why Is Torture Wrong

    • 1345 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Torture is the intentional inflicting of severe pain and suffering on people to punish or intimidate them so that they will extract information (Doing Ethics). Torture is morally wrong if it is unjustifiable or does not serve a purpose. On the other hand, to protect and secure our country from extremist and other terrorist, it can be morally justified. Keeping torture quiet with the public and out of world news is crucial. If it got out that the Americans were torturing assumed terrorists or enemies of the state for answers, it could cause great controversy. Although torture can be seen as unethical and unjustifiable, it is needed to protect…

    • 1345 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The information that is acquired through the use of torture is often time sensitive. A common question that is debated is, “should a terrorist be tortured if they hold information that will prevent a ticking bomb from detonating in a metropolitan area?” In this scenario, torturing the terrorist is the only way to prevent the bomb from exploding. Without question, the lives of the thousands of innocent Americans in danger far outweigh the life of the terrorist. Although we do not intend to kill the suspect when we torture him, this always remains a possibility if they do not comply. The suspect should be tortured until he reveals the location of the bomb because the only reason we value his life is to disarm the bomb. If the explosion were to…

    • 544 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Justification Of Torture

    • 1192 Words
    • 5 Pages

    While the idea may seem contradictory, countries around the globe use torture as a form of national security. As noted in the works of an online database, Opposing Viewpoints, reasons originating from the early 1800s in Jean Larteguy’s novel, Les Centurions, depicts the opposing justification of why such a method is necessary for safety (7). In his novel, Larteguy stresses millions of lives were saved because a French soldier tortured an Algerian rebel, thus justifying the use of torture (“Opposing” 7). As time prevails, the question of whether or not torture for national security is still justified through a social lens has led to an uproaring debate amongst many parties due to societal…

    • 1192 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays