Preview

An Event Without Eyewitness

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1902 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
An Event Without Eyewitness
An Event Without A Witness: An Analysis of the Distortion of Eye Witness Testimony to Victims of the Holocaust at Auschwitz

This European study will analyze the narrative distortions of first-person eyewitness testimony in the killing of SS-guard, Josef Schillinger, in the Auschwitz concentration camp.. The theoretical premise of “an event without a witness’ will define the distortions of Schillnger’s role and death (by being shot by Franceska Mann) that arise through the “insider testimonies” of Filip Muller and Tadeusz Borowski. The differing interpretations of Mann’s killing of Schillinger take on differing forms of narrative distortion in these two testimonies. Muller’s dramatic description of Mann’s cunning sense of erotic seduction
…show more content…
The theoretical perspective of “an event without a witness’ has examined the first-person eyewitness of Muller and Borowski’s description of the killing of SS guard Josef Schillinger. Muller’s highly dramatic description of sexual prowess of Franceska Mann defines the means in which she gained access to a gun by seducing the SS guards. This is an important narrative point in the story, which reflects the bias and questionable truth to this story, as Muller is attempting to make Mann into a heroine that single-handedly seduced and shot down Schillinger. However, Borowski provides a more realistic perception of Schillinger’s death, which involves an unnamed woman that used her sex appeal to seduce her adversaries. However, the woman is not Franceska Mann, not does she does a strip tease to get access to the gun that would not shoot Schillinger, but to also shoot (and not strike him with her show) Quackernack in the face. However, Borowski tends to describe the questionable aspect of Schillinger’s movement after the shooting incident, which was more likely to have been done by the Nazis, and not the Jewish prisoners. Theoretically, the first-person narratives of these stories define the problem of “an event without a witness” because of the questionable validity and bias of the witnesses that appear to distort these testimonies through fictional literary stylistics. In this way, it is extremely difficult to get an objective historical eyewitness testimony due to the biases and psychological distortions of Schillinger’s death, which define the barrier of an event without a witness in Muller and Borowski’s first person narratives of this event in the Auschwitz concentration

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The Second World War began when Germany violated international law and invaded Poland in 1939. When the war began, huge amounts of human rights were violated by the major powers. “The Table,” by Ida Fink is a play that describes the recording of statements given by multiple witnesses on behalf of a war crime that occurred. The prosecutor in charge interviewed 4 people who were present during the crime and took note of their testimony. The interview seemed more like an interrogation, since the prosecutor wanted every detail from that day. Although a work of fiction, the tales of atrocity provided by the witnesses in the play represent the magnitude of brutality the Nazis implemented on civilians.…

    • 1191 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Fragments, a short Holocaust memoir, was published in Germany in 1995. Binjamin Wilkomirski, the author who is also a Swiss musician, claimed that he was a Holocaust survivor. He described the book as a memoir of his early childhood experience in concentration camps. The book became very popular and was soon translated into nine languages. After three years, it was published, and the public began to question the authenticity of the book. They found that Binjamin Wikomirski was a liar, and that he developed his fiction story on purpose. Stefan Maechler, a Swiss historian, proved that the book was fiction by examining specific details in his book that shows why it was considered fiction. Since that time, critics began to argue that Fragments has literary value. However, I would argue that the authenticity of the book matters, therefore, Wilkomirski’s lying undercuts the value of the book and it prevents the readers from knowing the real history of the Holocaust.…

    • 798 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The short story “The Death of Schillinger” was a story about a First Sergeant whom ruled over labor sector ‘D,’ a laboring portion of Birkenau which was formally known as the Auschwitz extermination camp. Schillinger was a short stocky man and was truly evil at his essence; “He visited the crematoria regularly and liked to watch people being shoved into the gas chambers.” (pp.144) One day in August of 1943, the SS were unloading a transport and preparing to load stripped Jews into the gas chambers. However, before this could be done Schillinger took a liking to one of the nude women and grabbed her out of line; she threw gravel in his eyes, grabbed his revolver, and shot him several times. After being fatally wounded Schillinger was repeatedly asking himself, “My God, what have I done to deserve such suffering?” (pp.146) Later that day several Sonderkommandos attempted to rally a revolt at the crematoria, however all were killed by German SS soldiers via machine gun. I believe the theme of this short story is that death was so prominent in Birkenau that no one, even the sergeants, were safe. While Schillinger may have been truthfully ignorant to his ways, I believe the death of the Sonderkommandos symbolized the lack of justice in Auschwitz. Even though the evil Sergeant was killed, by no means did that suggest the innocent would escape or achieve their vengeance.…

    • 1387 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Treblinka Research Paper

    • 2361 Words
    • 10 Pages

    “News of the German defeats filled the Jewish prisoners with both hope and trepidation. Many feared that the SS would soon liquidate the camp and its remaining prisoners so that all evidence of their heinous crimes would be destroyed.”9 Those who were in the camp wanted a way to escape and tell someone of the war crimes that the German’s were committing. The revolt was staged by the “Organizing Committee,” which consisted of Dr. Julian Chorazycki, “camp elder” Marceli Galewski, former Czech army officer Zelo Bloch, Zev Kurland, and Jankiel Wiernik, a carpenter who worked in the extermination area.”10 Samuel was unaware that the staging of a revolt was about to occur. How Samuel found out was in a truly remarkable way. While he was stationed with an Austrian guard, and elderly man walks into the room he is in, already stripped down and about to be executed, pleaded out that there is a conspiracy being planned to escape, but the Austrian guard couldn’t understand him and proceeded to shoot the man in the head. Leading up the revolt, the committee was faced with a major setback. Chorazycki, who was charged with the task of acquiring arms from outside was caught by the deputy commandant and would eventually commit suicide to prevent any other information from escaping. After hearing news of a revolt in the Warsaw Ghetto from prisoners coming off the trains, their morale’s and…

    • 2361 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Donald L. Niewyk’s fifth and sixth chapters both deal more with outside perspectives and outside reactions than it does with those who were persecuted. The fifth chapter, “Bystander Reactions,” offers four different arguments as to why bystanders acted they way they did during the Holocaust. The sixth chapter, “Possibilities of Rescue,” discusses three different viewpoints on what foreign governments could have done to prevent the Holocaust. These two chapters conclude Niewyk’s book The Holocaust and wrap up the final sequence of events surrounding the Holocaust and the camps.…

    • 1452 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Early in the Holocaust, German army units participated in the massacre of the Jews in Eastern Europe. Among these, the Reserve Police Battalion 101 was made up of civilian police men, German men, and volunteers subject to the military draft. They were middle-aged working family men with a lower middle class background. Their main purpose was to be an essential source of manpower in holding down German-occupied Europe. In 1941, they were told that they had to perform a gruesome and undesirable task executing the Jewish population in the area they patrolled. My paper will be focusing on factors that lead up to how these “ordinary men” allow themselves to be a part of a systematic genocide. In trying to understand the factors that made these men’s crimes possible the factors that are central to their actions are several: peer pressure and conformity, the roles, the developing of a rationale for killing, and the environment they were in. Without these elements, the men of Police Battalion 101would not have become executioners.…

    • 1305 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    People of America today are mostly sheltered from the poor reality of the world and are protected behind the safety of Laws and the standard social normality. Some people are so ‘protected’ from the real world that they have the impression that the Holocaust never existed. The denial of the Holocaust is assumably one of many reasons writers/prisoners of the Holocaust vocalized their stories. Eli Wiesel the narrator and author of ‘From Night’ expresses his experience as a prisoner of war, held by German Nazis, in his short autobiography. Wiesel employs imagery as a Literary device to reveal how they perceived the dehumanizing and harsh affects of the Holocaust and how they adapted for their survival.…

    • 525 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the text “Holocaust Survivor Stories” there are many accounts of people who underwent the holocaust, were even tortured and attended concentration camps. The beginning of the text talks about one victim and what happened when they first were captured. The text states “On May 14th Eugene was returning home from school. 200 yards from home, he saw a German military lorry outside the family home with his…

    • 679 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Witnessing.. Talk about all of the characters, different aspects of witnessing in the book, How characters handle witnessing (the way they cope), Jeliek (plays his violin, silence in words but witnesses in other ways) elies dad (total silence) elie himself (He writes a freaken book)…

    • 1295 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    During the late 1930’s the world was contaminated by the Second World War and the Holocaust. According to the Oxford English Dictionary, Holocaust is defined as follows: “a sacrifice wholly consumed by fire.” During the Holocaust, the Nazis, under the command of Adolf Hitler, liquidated over six million Jews. There is one Jewish survivor whose story especially touched my heart and changed my attitude towards life for the better. This amazing woman is Krystyna Chiger. Krystyna and her family escaped the Nazi liquidation by living in sewers for fourteen months (qtd. in “The Girl in the Green Sweater” 5). Accordingly, thorough assessments of my personal experiences according to the life lessons of Krystyna Chiger descriptively visualize the Holocaust and its everlasting impact on society.…

    • 1240 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Stanley Milgram, born a Jew, wonders how he was fortunate enough to be born and raised in the United States, however, he was still impacted by the Holocaust. He felt very passionate about the Holocaust and feels guilty that he hadn’t died in the concentration camps with his fellow Jews in Europe (Miller, 2015). Milgram, a psychologist at Yale University, sought out the reasoning behind why Nazi soldiers blindly obeyed authority, especially after the Nuremberg War Criminal trials in World War II (McLeod, 2007). The Nuremberg War Criminal trials consisted of thirteen trials against the higher ranked “Nazi war criminals.” The Nazi criminals killed innocent Jews but proceeded to do so anyway during the Holocaust (Nuremberg Trials, 2015). Some of the Nazis knew killing Jews was immoral, but claim they were “just following orders.” The fact that Milgram was a Jew (Miller, 2015) accompanied by the testimonies in…

    • 1019 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the novel “Night” by Elie Wiesel, Elie Wiesel tells the story of his life in the Auschwitz concentration camps. Mr. Wiesel was born in the town of Sighet, Transylvania and was only a teenager when he and his family were taken from their home he called the “ghetto”. Although they all had been worn by Moishe the Beadle, about his terrible story in which no one believed him and though he was a mad man. Nevertheless the Germen army arrived shortly, and all Jews where obligated to wait outside until there train was to come for them and take them. Once in the train arrived and it was there; soon it was Elie Wiesel and his family turn to get, on lying down was not an option or even siting down. The air was little and there was little food and thirst became a big problem as so did the heat. Then the train stop in Kaschau in Czechoslovakia and a German officer stepped in and told all the Jews in the train that they were know under the German army authority and to give them all there gold and silver. The Jews where treated like dogs and threaten to get shot if anyone went missing. After that the train continued to its destination, with in the train there was a woman named Mrs. Schachter a woman in here fifties started to cry out “Fire! I see a fire! I see a fire!” she did this many times and the Jews got tired of it after a while so the beat her, so she would stop crying. Once they arrived to their final destination Auschwitz she scram fire for the last time, but this time there was fire and shortly everyone had to get off the train the air smelled like burning flesh. After getting off Elie Wiesel was separated from his mother and sisters with he never saw again but stayed with his father. After separated Elie Wiesel saw as children and old where being burned and hoped it was all just a dream. Elie Wiesel was close to being thrown in the fire pit, but instead him and his father where forced to run to the showers and then to Block 17 where…

    • 865 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay On Elie Wiesel

    • 438 Words
    • 2 Pages

    There are countless numbers of documents and photographs depicting the Holocaust’s existence; and there are many people in the world that accept its existence. Although there are many people who believe that the Holocaust existed,…

    • 438 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    All But My Life Analysis

    • 1298 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The desire for power, fear, and self-preservation can cause people to change in ways one could not imagine. In the story, Night by Elie Wiesel, and Gerda Weissman Klein’s All But My Life, the authors share their tragic experiences from their times in Nazi concentration camps. In Addition, Klein’s All But My Life shows her experience in many different concentration camps for three years and how differently female inmates were treated than male. In Wiesel’s Night, he discusses his experience of being sent to Auschwitz along with his father for a year and how the tragedies he endured transformed his character. In Addition, Klein’s All But My Life shows her experience in many different concentration camps for three years and how differently female…

    • 1298 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    “…Imagine now a man who is deprived of everyone he loves, and at the same…

    • 3314 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays