Preview

An Analysis Of William Of Rubruck's 'William And The Khans'

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1064 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
An Analysis Of William Of Rubruck's 'William And The Khans'
History 2B
January 31, 2013
William and the Khans
William of Rubruck composed a sequential and descriptive analysis of his experiences during his journey to the Mongolian empire in 1253 CE. His conquest took place primarily to affirm that Sartach Khan and the other Mongol Khans were Christian. Throughout his recordings he is repeatedly overwhelmed by the religious, cultural, linguistic, and political differences between the Mongolian Empire, and Western Europe. As a Franciscan friar, his humble circumstances pose a challenge as he proves to be unprepared in his encounters with Captains and the Khans. With little gifts to bear, William is advised by the merchants of Constantinople that the captains and the Mongol Khans must be greeted with gifts, otherwise he will not be looked upon properly (William, p. 49). William embarked on this mission to deliver a letter on behalf of King Louis IX to Sartach,
…show more content…
However, in his encounters with Sartach, Baatu, and Mangu Khan the purpose of his visit is misunderstood by a linguistic misinterpretation. Despite his failure to convert many people to Christianity, his letter is significant in presenting some of the educational and religious movements occurring within Europe, and the relations that were emerging through commerce in the thirteenth century. Europe’s growing emphasis on education would broaden the horizons of Christianity, and commerce created interconnectedness among cultures regardless of religious differences. Western Europe developed a growing desire for advancements in education during the twelfth century. Places such as Toledo, Spain was “renowned as a center of learning where Muslims, Jews, and Christians freely intermingled” (Smith, Crossroads p. 414). After the Latin translations of Aristotle’s works began to enhance the method of thought towards the natural world,

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    DBQ: The attitudes of Christianity and Islam toward merchants and trade form the religion’s origins until about 1500.…

    • 710 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Religious enthusiasm had spread from France to Northern Britain and other areas of the west at that time. Along with the expansion of extremely devout races such as the Normans came the spread of the pope’s influence across Europe. Christians were anxious to demonstrate their faith, and the crusade provided the perfect opportunity to combine the interests of the pope with the purposes of the lay people of Christendom. The ardent religious factor was one of many of the Christians’ show of faith. It was fulfilling what they felt as a religious duty, but also love and charity which was a part of being a Christian. Another was the idea of “punishing evil” which was the underlying reason for the crusade. And of course, the promise of the many “sin reprieves” promised by Urban II for the participants. In addition, the traditions of pilgrimages and Holy Wars were not new. Pilgrimages had been established long before with the idea of going to shrines and holy places as a show of the peoples’ faith. Pilgrimage was regarded as the primary method for the articulation of faith and…

    • 524 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    (1) The historical influence of Christianity in the West (Europe and the Americas) and in Africa and Asia…

    • 187 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    As time progressed in the Post-Classical Era there were major changes in Islam and Christianity as seen in the discussions of Authorities. Islam had expanded across Afro-Asia and had become very wealthy because of trade in Dhar Al-Islam. On the other hand Christian Europe had entered a Dark-Ages of little trade with the fall of the Roman Empire in the West. However, by 1200 C.E. Europe had come out of the Dark-Ages on its way to the Renaissance. Europe was very interested in wealth and trade. An additional source of trade maps displaying trade wealth in 800 C.E. and 1500 C.E. of Islam and Christianity would help to explain why the views of the religions were changing. This change can be seen in Reginald’s writing about St. Godric…

    • 588 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    4. In what ways might his account of Mongols vices be simply dismissed as “sour grapes” resulting from European defeats?…

    • 389 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Best Essays

    Once he was crowned, William gained a surprising amount of English support, including military support, which could be used against rebels. William initially gave the appearance of trying to rule with the help of the surviving English aristocracy. Overall, William and his sons maintained the relatively sophisticated government they had seized and built on their inheritance from the Anglo-Saxon. William’s desire to push the current government to new accomplishments can best be seen in the massive survey undertaken at the end of his reign that resulted in the Doomsday…

    • 1552 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    They were ingenious with their tactics in fighting and bold in trying methods of war that were uncommon or not previously used before. During the thirteenth century, a story went around and was later recorded about how Chinggis Khan, the leader of the Mongols, wanted to conquer the Chin Empire in Northern China. Using trickery, faking retreat and then advancing on them, the massive Mongol army was able to accomplish this conquest. (Document 1) The legendary explorer Marco Polo, studied the…

    • 669 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Christianity became more accepting and encouraging of trade as time progressed. Document 3, The Life of St. Godric written around 1170, states that St. Godric achieved spiritual greatness and closeness to G-d through trade. This shows that Christianity was progressing to being more tolerant of merchants. Summa Theologica written by Thomas Aquinas in 1273 (Document 4) further shows the progression of tolerance by stating that trade is acceptable as long as merchants are honest. Lastly, Document 6, letter to and from Italian merchants, show that in the fourteenth-century Christians fully embraced trade and wealth and even traced back their good fortune to G-d.…

    • 408 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    For William the Conqueror, success was a way of life. During his reign as king of England, William conquered three locations. The first was in Pevensey in the South of England, after, he went toward Hastings and Fought at Senlac Hill, lastly he took England. William the Conqueror was one of the most influential men in history.…

    • 738 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Rubruck with the Mongols

    • 1687 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Perhaps the first quotation above is a harsh assessment of the lack of success William of Rubruck experienced on his journeys into Mongol territory from 1253-1255, but highly accurate when considering his intended goal of spreading the gospel and bolstering an alliance with the perceived Christian Mongol prince Sartach. That he also failed to make contact with slaves from Hungary who had been carted off to Asia from Mongol invaders a decade prior is rather insignificant in retrospect considering the larger significance of his travels. As precursor to his venture, it is important to be reminded of the Mongol invasions of Russia, Poland and Hungary with as many as 150,000 warriors from 1240-1242; this army was virtually unstoppable throughout all of western Europe, as no Christian force large enough could unite against this highly mobile and fiercely destructive enemy. Almost as quickly the Mongols withdrew with no clear explanation, and although many feared their immanent return it was Pope Innocent IV who foresaw that only through diplomacy in the form of papal envoys could he determine Mongol composition and intentions. Rubruck was not the first missionary to travel through Crimea, the Caucasus, Central Asia and Asia Minor- nor was he even sent on behalf of the Pope. Of his own accord did he decide to undertake his mission of faith and through his detailed and lucid observations of the Mongols, do we see the futility of his efforts to spread the gospel and create converts to Christianity. Perhaps Rubruck’s own prejudices foiled his attempts; his western perceptions (and misperceptions) of their customs, daily practices, and standing belief systems failed to yield the proper empathy required of a missionary. This paper will examine Rubruck’s harsh misperceptions of the Mongol lifestyle, and a few examples how it changed (although modestly).…

    • 1687 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The leader of the invasion would be William III. He had to prepare the invasion very carefully, because it was a profound event. Three point were very important, in order to succeed, according to William: help of the English, gathering a vast army in the United Provinces, the help of the Holy Roman empire. Firstly, the help of the English was very important, because the army of Charles would have been, without any help, too big. William had circa 16.000 soldiers, but Charles could easily put 25.000 against William’s army. Although the Dutch were better trained and equipped, it would have been impossible to defeat Charles. So, William needed the support of the nation and moreover the support of English army, that is decent amount of the army…

    • 461 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Through the years , Christianity was one of the most questioned religion . Although , Christianity became a ruling religion in the European and Western world.Religion became a state of the Roman Empire, and Christianity became an enormous and influential religion nationwide . Some still wonder why and how religion has shaped through centuries, yet it’s clear that it is and was one of the most important events in history. Christianity changed the western world in so many different ways during the Middle ages and adapted now in the global world since The Enlightenment.…

    • 225 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Next Christendom

    • 1833 Words
    • 8 Pages

    This ten chapter book can be divided into two major sections. In the first five chapters, Jenkins traces the historical growth of Christianity in the global South to its current relative boom status. Jenkins provides a short history of Western Christianity, noting that it found its Western foundation during the post-Constantine days of Rome, and soon after fused with European culture. Jenkins does give a nod to the fact that, in the beginning, Christianity was a new faith that was a blend of both Jewish and Greek expressions. The gospel spread throughout the Roman provinces east to China and India, north and west to Europe, and south to Africa. Although there was a multi-continent spread of Christianity, Jenkins points out that “Christianity for its first thousand years was stronger in Asia and North Africa than in Europe and only after about 1400 did Europe (and Europeanized North America) decisively become the new Christian heartland.”[3]…

    • 1833 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    This is the awakening of a new era in natural philosophy supported in the Islamic empire that affects social structures, cultures and attitude towards learning. One may ask, how do the features of my society explain its achievements in natural philosophy? And, how did Al-Kindi and Averroes change the course of history in natural philosophy? While it seems like the days of enlightenment in natural philosophy have slowed as a result of upheaval in kingdoms because of warfare and economic collapses in Europe and the Middle-East. However, circumstances are less severe in Islamic empire that now stretches from North Africa and Spain to India. In the discussion of natural philosophy credit goes to the influential works of Aristotle and Plato, the great Greek philosophers because they had laid the current foundations of natural philosophy. Al-Kindi and Averroes had spent countless time reflecting on the philosophies and theories of Aristotle.…

    • 775 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Raphael’s The School of Athens effectively grasps the concept of education and the acquisition ok knowledge. Looking at this famous work of sixteenth century art, Plato and Aristotle discuss their differing philosophical viewpoints and learning from each other in a communal setting with many other prominent figures, such as Pythagoras, instructing the common people. Although painted far after the time period it depicts around 300 BC, the general setting of a gathering place in which the teacher and pupil interact is accurate, in the same degree it was in the sixteenth century when Raphael erected the piece, as it was in the young children growing up around the Cave of Altamira, as it is today as we learn from Mrs. Osborn the greatest teacher ever. The roots of early perceptions of the world are largely formed in the confines of a schoolroom; nearly every foot that has passed over the earth has learned, and been the pupil to a teacher- everyone has the ability to learn, and therefore, the right. Hours upon hours children sit patiently, or sometimes not so patiently, and receive information and knowledge in the teacher’s hopes that application will breed wisdom in due time. For centuries there has been a system in place for the acquisition of knowledge- whether on a bigger, societal scale or in the simplest of communities. As depicted by Raphael, Aristotle and Plato learned from each other, discussing various philosophies, but not always agreeing with each other. Education is spreading the acquisition of knowledge to the masses so we may progress and keep laying the bricks of invention and progress, this rejecting a stagnant state of being. We must evolve intellectually through teachings of different variety- of which the most common is teacher and pupil. Education occurs, but is useless without man’s innate curiosity towards understanding the world and environment. Education breeds progress- without which, the flow of time and history…

    • 380 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays