An Analysis of the Financial Crisis of 2008: Causes and Solutions

Topics: Credit default swap, Debt, Subprime mortgage crisis Pages: 24 (7399 words) Published: October 29, 2012
An Analysis of the Financial Crisis of 2008: Causes and Solutions

By Austin Murphy*

________________________________________________________________________ *by Austin Murphy, Professor of Finance, Oakland University, SBA, Rochester, MI 48309-4493 (248-370-2125;

Electronic copy available at:

This research evaluates the fundamental causes of the current financial crisis. Close financial analysis indicates that theoretical modeling based on unrealistic assumptions led to serious problems in mispricing in the massive unregulated market for credit default swaps that exploded upon catalytic rises in residential mortgage defaults. Recent academic research implies solutions to the crisis that are appraised to be far less costly than a bailout of investors who made poor financial decisions with respect to credit analysis. JEL: G11, G12, G13, G14

Electronic copy available at:

An Analysis of the Financial Crisis of 2008: Causes and Solutions

The financial crisis in 2008 is of such epic proportions that even astronomical amounts spent to address the problem have so far been insufficient to resolve the it. Besides the well-publicized $700 billion approved by Congress, the Federal Reserve has attempted to bail out institutions and markets with about $1.3 trillion in investments in various risky assets, including loans to otherwise bankrupt institutions and collateralized debt obligations like those backed by subprime mortgages that are defaulting at rapid rates (Morris, 2008). A further $900 billion is being proposed in lending to large corporations (Aversa, 2008), making a total of nearly $3 trillion in bailout money so far, without even counting the massive sum of corporate debts guaranteed by the U.S. government in the last year. An analysis of the fundamental causes of this “colossal failure” that has put “the entire financial system… at risk” (Woellert and Kopecki, 2008) is warranted in order to both solve the problem and avoid such events in the future.

Root Cause of the Crisis: Mispricing in the Massive Credit Default Swaps Market Many blame defaulting mortgages for the current financial crisis, but this massive tragedy is only a component and symptom of the deeper problem. The pricing of credit default swaps, whose principal amount has been estimated to be $55 trillion by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and may actually exceed $60 trillion (or over 4 times the publicly traded corporate and mortgage U.S. debt they are supposed to insure), are totally unregulated, and have often been contracted over the phone without 2

documentation (Simon, 2008), is the primary fundamental issue from which all the other problems of the crisis emanate.
Credit default swaps are actually rather simple instruments in concept, merely mandating that one party paying a periodic fee to another to insure the debts of some entity (such as a specified corporation) against default for a particular amount of time like 5 years. They are effectively debt insurance policies that are labeled otherwise to avoid the regulation that normally is imposed on insurance contracts. This unregulated market grew astronomically from $900 billion at the turn of the millennium to over $50 trillion in 2008 after Congress enacted a law exempting them from state gaming laws in 2000 (PIA Connection, 2008)..

Any investment in a debt requires compensation not only for the time value of money but also a premium for the credit risk of the debt. Compensation for the time value of money is usually provided by the debt promising, at a minimum, a yield equal to that of the rate available on default-free government securities like U.S. Treasury bonds. The credit risk premium above that rate must compensate investors for not only the expected value of default losses but also for the systematic risk relating to the debt, as well as for any...

References: E. Altman. “Financial Ratios, Discriminant Analysis and the Prediction of Corporate
Bankruptcy.” Journal of Finance 23 (1968), 589-609.
J. Aversa. “Fed Eyes Plan to Fund Short-Term Business Loans.” Associated Press
(October 7, 2008).
Boni, L., 2006. Strategic Delivery Failures in U.S. Equity Markets. Journal of Financial
Markets 9, 1-26.
M. Buchanan. “Crazy Money.” NewScientist (July 19, 2008), 32-35.
J. Burns. “Former Ratings-Firm Officials Blame Conflicts for Rosy Views.” Wall Street
Journal (October 23, 2008), A4.
J. Callaghan and A. Murphy. "An Empirical Test of a Stochastic Cash Flow Theory of
Evaluating Credit." Advances in Financial Planning and Forecasting 8 (1998), 31-51.
F. Duffee. “Estimating the Price of Default Risk.” Review of Financial Studies 12 (1999),
E. Elton, M. Gruber, D. Agrawal, and C. Mann. “Explaining the Rate Spread on
Corporate Bonds.” Journal of Finance 56 (2001), 247-277.
G. Favel. “Sold Short.” Futures (November 2008), 32.
FinancialWire. “StockGate: The Tune May Have Changed, But the Song is the Same.”
Investors Business Daily (June 25, 2004).
FinancialWire, 2005. “Regulation SHO Gets Confuser and Confuser as Listing
‘Disappear’.” Investors Business Daily (January 28, 2005).
G. Gigerenzer. Gut Feelings: The Intelligence of the Unconscious. Viking: New York
M. Glantz and J. Mun. The Banker’s Handbook on Credit Risk. Elsevier: Burlington
B. Jameson. “The Blunders that Led to Catastrophe.” NewScientist (September 27, 2008),
C. Jones and O. Lamont. “Short-sales Constraints and Stock Returns.” Journal of
Financial Economics 66 (2002), 207-239.
R. Merton. “On the Pricing of Corporate Debt: A Further Note.” Journal of Finance 29
(1974), 449-470.
G. Morgenson. “Behind Insurer’s Crisis: Blind Eye to a Web of Risk.” New York Times
(September 28, 2008).
C. Morris. “Fed 's $1.6 Trillon Bet: The $700-Billion Wall Street Bailout Was Only the
Half of It.” Washington Independent (October 14, 2008).
A. Moses and S. Harrington. “Company Bond Risk Surges on Argentina Default
Concerns.”Bloomberg (October 23, 2008).
A. Murphy. “A Discounted Cash-Flow Model of Fixed-Income Securities Subject to
Multiple Calls." Southern Economic Journal 55 (1988), 21-36.
A. Murphy. Scientific Investment Analysis. Quorum Books: Westport (2000).
NewScientist. “Crunchonomics.” July 19 (2008a), 5.
NewScientist. “Blinded by Science.” September 27 (2008b), 5.
PIA Connection. “Congress Exempted Credit Default Swaps from State Gaming Laws in
2000.” October 15 (2008).
R. Shiller. “Homes are a Risky Long-Term Investment.” TIAA-CREF (Summer 2005),
E. Simon. “Meltdown 101: What are Credit Default Swaps?” Kansas City Star (October
26, 2008).
Weiss, G. “The Mob is Busier than the Feds Think.” Business Week (December 15,
1997), 130.
Yost. “AP IMPACT: Mortgage Firm Arranged Stealth Impact.” Associated Press
(October 20, 2008).
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Essay about causes of financial crisis
  • The Causes and Consequences of the Financial Crisis of 2008 Essay
  • Causes of the Financial Crisis of 2008-2009 Essay
  • Causes of the 2008 Financial Crisis Essay
  • Essay on 2008 Financial Crisis
  • Global Financial Crisis 2008 Essay
  • Financial Crisis 2008 Essay
  • 2008 Us Financial Crisis Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free