Preview

Among The Hidden, By Margaret Peterson Haddix

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
714 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Among The Hidden, By Margaret Peterson Haddix
Maya Angelou once said, “Freedom is never free.” This is true because a person always has to pay some sort of price in order to be free, whether in a literal sense or not. In the book Among the Hidden, by Margaret Peterson Haddix, Luke Garner is an illegal third child in a place where overpopulation forces the government to make unfair laws. Each family is allowed to have two children, so Luke envies his older brothers and cannot live his life the way he wants to. This is similar to in “Two Sisters, Two Americas,” by Brooke Ross, which tells the reader about an illegal immigrant named Veronica Saravia. Veronica came to the United States with her parents illegally when she was 4 years old. Her sister, Diana, was born in the United States. Diana …show more content…
For example, Luke’s parents made him sit on the bottom step during dinner. They didn’t want anyone to get suspicious of their family. When more people moved near the Garner’s home, his parents became more concerned than ever. Luke’s mother asks, “‘Luke, honey? Can you eat sitting on the bottom step?… Dad thinks – I mean, it’s not safe for you to eat in the kitchen.’” (Haddix 20-21) In the same way, Veronica had to move around often and changed schools often. This was so the government couldn’t track her family. If the government found out that the Saravias were in the United States illegally, they would be deported and sent back to the violence and gangs that they were escaping. In order to keep one step ahead of the government, “… the family had to move frequently (and the kids had to change schools) to avoid being discovered.” (Ross 3) Luke and Veronica were treated differently and forced to act differently because of a law made by their government. They had to take many precautions in order to avoid discovery. Therefore, in order to refrain from being found by the government, Luke and Veronica had to …show more content…
Luke’s older brothers, Matthew and Mark, can go to school and meet other people. Luke is unable to do this because of his legal status with the government. Luke was more than disappointed when he realized that he would have to hide forever on his 6th birthday. In an effort to make himself feel better about hiding his entire life, 6-year-old Luke lamented, “Who wanted to meet strangers, anyway? Who wanted to go to school…” (Haddix 11) Likewise, Veronica’s younger sister, Diana can vote when she turns 18 and can apply for federal student aid when she goes to college. Veronica has no say in who our president is and cannot apply for federal student aid to go to college. Since Veronica is an illegal immigrant, she doesn’t have all the rights that her sister will eventually have. The author explains, “Veronica doesn’t get a say in this year’s presidential election, even though she’s old enough… she can’t ask the federal government for a loan.” (Ross 1) Both Luke and Veronica’s siblings have rights like suffrage and attending school because they are legal in their countries. Since Luke and Veronica are considered illegal, they don’t have any freedoms or rights. All in all, Luke and Veronica can’t do many of the things that their legal siblings can

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Film Essay on Entre Nos

    • 328 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Marianna and her family may have come to the U.S illegally, but this family has gone through what many Americans go through. About forty percent of American families are in a fatherless home. Just like many of the families here Marianna was left to care for her two children all alone. With being an immigrant family with no one to help, it gets hard. When the kids got hurt Marianna had to tend to their wounds, because she could not take them to a hospital without people finding out that they are illegal immigrants.…

    • 328 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the book Among the Hidden by Margaret Peterson Haddix is about the Governments rules and restrictions about having more then two children and in this essay I'm going to describe the three characters and how they resisted the Government. The book Among the Hidden is about Government controlling the population by limited the number of children people can have and how one boy Luke survives bing hidden in his house his whole life. I'm going to write about three main characters and how they resisted the population police. They can change the future by opposing the government and population police by helping the shadow children. I'm going to write about Luke, Jen and Mr. Talbot and how they defied the Government and population police. Luke resisted by getting a fake I.D, Jen resisted by creating the shadow children chat room and Mr. Talbot resisted by sabotaging the population police work. Each characters had there own way to combat the suppressive Government.…

    • 639 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    |its author. |herself. After she moved she thought a lot about the little yellow house, and how it |…

    • 1302 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    U.S. born children struggle to survive after their parent(s) are deported. Because of the recent intensification of immigration enforcement in America, the children have been put at risk of being separated from their parent(s), economic hardships, and psychological trauma. The children of undocumented immigrants are just as vulnerable to the immigration enforcement. When a parent who is the provider of the household gets deported, the entire family undergoes a traumatic shift, because they are left to struggle through economic hardships, and are impacted emotionally. A study released by the Center for American Progress…

    • 1952 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    What would you do if you were the third child having to hide your whole entire life? Well in the book “Among the Hidden” by Margaret Peterson Haddix. This book is very suspenseful. In their town that they live in they are only allowed to have two children, but one family decides to have three. Luke, as the third child is not allowed to step outside, he has to stay hidden, because they are too scared the population police will come and get him. Therefore this book is a mystery, because it leaves you with a cliffhangers. The book is told in first person point of view, the genre of “Among the Hidden” is a mystery. “Among the Hidden” is rather short at 153 pages.…

    • 265 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Reyna Wences uses her personal experience in “My Life in the Shadows” to raise public awareness to the problems illegal immigrants, like herself, face on a daily basis. Wences opens a window for her audience to see the frustration encountered by youth pleading for a chance at success in the country that has become their new home. Her writing implores support for the DREAM Act bill, which will allow for these young individuals to come out of the shadows. Her personal illustrations of the adversities faced in her birth country, Mexico, and in crossing the border emphasize the importance of giving immigrants an opportunity at a better life, since the opportunities for an undocumented immigrants are “only half open,” particularly in education and employment.…

    • 519 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Over the years families immigrate to the free world for an opportunity to thrive and grow. A chance to achieve the “American Dream” and provide their young ones with a future worth striving for. Immigrating from countries with no rights or a means to make an earning, the United States seems like a sanctuary to most. Unfortunately, the current immigration policy in America denies many immigrants from achieving a secure future. Immigration has always been an integral part of the United States, allowing people from all backgrounds to have basic rights you're often denied in other countries. Although, recent events have been put America’s immigration policies in question, from denying citizens entry into the states to deporting those who’ve been residing here for several years.…

    • 1264 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    A young teen, Viviana “Andazola” Marquez, struggled most of her childhood to find a warm, cozy place to sleep each night. Marquez’s mother and father divorced when she was attending the third grade. After the divorce, she, her mother, her sister, her two younger brothers stayed many nights on different strangers’ kitchen floors. Throughout the majority of their life they did not know if the strangers would open their homes up to them; not knowing if they had a place to sleep was devastating. When she reached the age of thirteen, Marquez’s mother was arrested for disturbing the peace because she was not documented, she was moved to Immigration and Customs Enforcement. At this time, this tragedy served as a breaking point for this family.…

    • 461 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    At the age of seven, I escaped the poverty-stricken neighborhood of Paterson, New Jersey because my parents’ priority was their children’s education. So when we moved to Georgia, I was thankful to have a yard, house, even my own room, but each blessing has a curse. Each day I realized why my mother worked at subway, why my father worked at a warehouse, why my mother had to walk 3 ½ miles every day, to and from work, in hot and cold, why my father grew anxious at the sight of a police, why my family could barely travel anywhere, even Atlanta...they were illegal immigrants. Being an anchor baby, I appreciated all the efforts my parents made, like driving me to school early, tutoring, and providing me with their love and support. Years later with the stricter immigration laws, my father got laid when I was in 10th grade and we soon grew very tight on money. Thankful a year…

    • 1177 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    citizen children believe they are are the only ones that have illegal parents that were deported. Due to this assumption, many children feel alienated and isolated from their friends and school environment. Countless of them feel misplaced or no longer feel close to those people they once had a good connection with. In addition, the deportation proceedings can influence a childs social abilities and friendships. For example according to Stanton-Salazar 2001 study, it states that “ The need for secrecy demonstrates a strategy of a face-saving and selective avoidance that many immigrant student employ as a way to avoid humilation from school personnel and peers they feel do not understand their experience.” In other words, children facing the removal of one parent or even two, feel embarassed to say anything because they believe they will not be understood or related to. Furthermore, many adolescents feel the need to constantly stay with their family because they are fearful for any potential deportation threats, and this leads to alienation from friends and society or any type of social involvement outside the…

    • 554 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Emma Sanchez Paulsen lived in a nice home in Vista, California. In this this home, she resided with her three beloved sons and husband Michael Paulsen, who was a U.S citizen and a military veteran. Emma loved to spend her time cuddling with her children and telling them stories of her childhood. Life was excellent and prosperous for this adorable family, however things went sour for them nine years ago. One day Emma received news that it was time for her to leave. She was being deported back to Mexico. She tried to fight it and aimed to stay here however, her efforts were futile. Now Emma can only tell stories and cuddle with her children when they visit her in Tijuana every…

    • 124 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    When you are living in a country of poverty and dreaming about the great life waiting for you in America, it isn't long before immigrants begin to migrate. People from other countries realize the difficulties attaining visas and becoming American citizens, it often leads immigrants to birthright citizenship; granting their child's citizenship at birth instead of going through struggles to gain it when they are older(anchor baby). Due to the narrow path to become an American Citizen;birthright citizenship or the naturalization process, immigrants often find themselves coming undocumented. The realization of not being a legal immigrant in the eyes of the law, “means living a different reality”(vargas). It evokes constant fear, and no room for trust. Franciscos father drills this fear in him and his brothers as he continues to warn them how importrant it is to make sure no one knows they are illegal, “You have to be careful.You can’t tell a soul you were born in Mexico”(pg 115). They always have to look behind their back and be ready to hide from the immigration officers that often invaded the camps, “searching for undocumented workers who ran into the wilderness, trying to escape”(page 114). Being legal is far more than a label, it changes all aspects in your life especially your level of trust with…

    • 973 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Victoria Sanford’s book, Buried Secrets helps readers to understand the violence that occurred during the genocide that took place in Guatemala. This destruction happened during the 1960’s until 1996. She reviles the tragedies that happened from the standpoint of more than 400 rural Maya survivors, former soldiers, archival research and formerly classified documents. There were 626 villages and 200,000 civilian victims that were affected by this genocide. The Guatemalan army were the ones who led this genocide.…

    • 599 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Leticia Gonzalez 6 November 2017 Book Report Unearthly By Cynthia Hand The book that I chose to write about is Unearthly by Cynthia Hand. I chose this book because it was a very interesting and suspenseful. This novel was entertaining because it was realistic, but also had some fantasy in it.…

    • 419 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Linda Sue Park once said, “The books in the library showed me that there is a whole world out there big enough for misfits like me,” In every one of us there is a little bit of extraordinary deep inside of our most ordinary thoughts. Even a plain girl like Jane Doe, with no talent, no skills, no extraordinary gifts, can find her own remarkable story. Her story involves pirates, evil twins, and a whole lot of laughs for anyone looking for a new twist on the ordinary “talented kids story”. This story is a shout out to all the misfits, rejects, outsiders and to all of those who feel truly, ordinary.…

    • 612 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays