top-rated free essay

American Is a Salad Bowl

By jmoe90 Apr 26, 2011 926 Words
America is a Salad bowl
The identity of America has changed from when the Indians came from Europe to America in 18th century. Where you live has a major affect on your identity from the north to the south. America has defined themselves not by race, religious, and ethnic identity but by common values and individual freedom. America is a salad bowl because there are all different kinds of races, religions, and people from different countries. An individual’s identity is created by where they came from. Everyone comes from different backgrounds. From state to state, everything is different. America is mixed with all different cultures and races. Your identity is created by where you grew up, gender, and your education. Countries try to manage their multilanguage like the Indian constitution recognizes nineteen languages and English being one of them. In “Should English be the Law?” By Robert King stated, “We like to believe that to pass a law is to change behavior, but passing laws about language, in a free society, almost never changer attitude or behavior”(King 442). People come to America to have freedom, not to be told what to speak. If people have to be told what to speak or do, our country wouldn’t be free. We live in a free society and laws will not change what we speak. In the “Good Immigrant Student’, Bich Nugygen’s spoke two languages English and Vietnamese. Her step-mother, Rosa puts her and her sister Anh in a bilingual school. They knew more English then Vietnamese. Her race had contributed to her identity. The teacher’s treated her badly because of her race. The Teacher stated “a foreigner winning our spelling bee!”(Nguyen 461). Her teachers were very rude to her and she doesn’t want to speak Vietnamese at all. People are treated badly because they don’t speak English or Spanish. The teachers should teach the kids how to speak Spanish when they are little. They learn langue better when they are little. Race has been a major issue since the beginning of formation. In the past, race has been segregated and isolated from one another. Americans have interracial relationships and some fear that America will be one single ethnic group. In the 1960’s the school system made blacks feel not welcome and made them go to a different school. In “Should English be the law? By Robert King, King stated “And: we must have but one flag. We must also have but one language”(king 435). If we all spoke one language, our identity and culture would be crushed. A person’s identity makes up who they are. We have one flag, and that flag represents freedom. To some, America represents home and to others it stands for freedom, refuge or the land of opportunities. America is a salad bowl full of races and cultures from around the world. One of the main reasons for migrations is because we all want freedom, but America does not have a single identity to call its own. We speak just about every language there is in America. In schools, we speak English but in our homes and just about everywhere else we speak our native language. In middle and high school, they are teaching kids how to speak Spanish, French, and Italian. King stated, “Doctors in state hospital must speak to patients in Solvak, even if another language would aid diagnosis and treatment”(king 440). In America, in the hospitals doctors speak English and they have a interpreter there to translate. You shouldn’t have to give up your identity because you don’t know English. Your identity is who you are. You get your identity by where you grow up and you peer groups. America consists of many different cultures, but none are agreed upon. One of the main reasons America has no cultural identity is because it has no ethnic origin. King stated “The official language of Yugoslavia was Serbo-Croatian, which was never so much a language as a political accommodation”(king 440). In America, English is not the official language, but politics want it to be. It’s not hurting us, so why make it such a big deal of what people speak. Bich stated that “Today, bilingual education is supposed to have become both a method of assimilation and a method of preservation, an effort to prove that kids can have it both ways”(nguyen 440). Kids should know two languages. They will have better opportunities in life if they know two. They can get better jobs and can pass it on to their children. The children who are bilingual have a better culture outlook. America is a salad bowl. We are all mixed into one country with all different types of race and religion. Even in America, the north and the south are total different. The atmosphere and the way people are. You just don’t make up their identity; it’s from where you live. The people you surround yourself with contribute a factor to your identity. America is still evolving into a nation that welcomes all races.

Works Cited
King, Robert “Should English Be The Law?” The Presence of Others Voices and Images That Call for Response 5th edition, Andrea A. Lunsford John J. Ruszkiewicz, Boston: Bedford, St.Martin, 2008 434-444 Nguyen,Bich “The Good Immigrant Student” The Presence of Others Voices and Images That Call for Response 5th edition, Andrea A. Lunsford John J. Ruszkiewicz, Boston: Bedford, St.Martin, 2008 458-465

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Melting Pot and Salad Bowl

    ...essentially founded on the principles of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness through solidarity of human kind. It has been the land of immigrants and still is. The melting pot and salad bowl, are two metahors often used to describe how the different cultures blend together.? The term “melting pot” was created by Israel Zangwill in ...

    Read More
  • Melting Pot or Salad Bowl

    ...The United States: Melting Pot or Salad Bowl? 1. Immigrants from all around the world have come to settle in the United States where they all gathered together and created one “Americanized” culture. All of the people in this culture have a lot of the same traits. Most of the Americans speak English. Almost all Americans dress the sa...

    Read More
  • Are We a Meltin Pot or Salad Bowl

    ...Are We a Melting Pot or Salad Bowl? Are We a Melting Pot or a Salad Bowl? Unless an American citizen is a Native American, he or she is part of a great country filled with immigrants. Those who came before us, our ancestors, came here from every corner of this small world. There was a time, and it was not so long ago, when America...

    Read More
  • America Is a Salad Bowl

    ...America is a Salad bowl The identity of America has changed from when the Indians came from Europe to America in 18th century. From the North America to South American live has a major affect on your identity. America has defined itself not by race, religious, and ethnic identity but by common values and individual freedom. America is a salad ...

    Read More
  • Dust bowl

    ... Imagine waking up each morning having to sweep up dust that blew into homes at night. Nearly starving from lack of food and water then going broke and living without a home with family's to care for. We'll that was life during the Dust Bowl having to face the Great Depression and loving in the Southern Plains.The Dust Bowl was a very unexpected...

    Read More
  • Salad Bowl vs Melting Pot

    ...Salad Bowl vs. Melting Pot There have been many to question and many so called answers to the merging of America and its different citizens. One cannot choose which term is better than the other; they both serve the same cause just in a different example. Along with this perspective, however, there is another expression that describes the d...

    Read More
  • melting pot vs salad bowl

    ...melting pot or a salad bowl? The metaphor for the melting pot is unfortunate and misleading for America. A more accurate metaphor would be a salad bowl, for the salad bowl can be very different from the melting pot because of all its ingredients can make it distinguished from the melting pot. Even today Americans are calling America a salad bowl...

    Read More
  • Is the Nation a Salad Bowl or Melting Pot

    ...connected. If the nation were a salad you could pick up something without the involvement of another issue or people. Despite few issues that people are still fighting for equality, I would say over all we as a nation are fighting for this equality as a whole. For example gay marriage, if you were to look at the support of gay marriage from the ...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.