Preview

American Dbq Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
562 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
American Dbq Analysis
America was in the crisis of deciding whether to risk more U.S. casualties. They had to decide whether they should send more troops to risk their life or allow to take the course of the A-bomb. They went with the second option, but it is hard to know if it was justified or not.
In Doc A, Truman believes that it was necessary to save as many American lives as possible. This would keep them out of the way of the kamikazees that were flying through and only cause the persistant Japanese to lose lives. Also, from Doc C, the atomic bomb was a way for America to show our might against the Russians.
The brawl between the two left theaters was a great impact on the loss of lives. Both were putting equal deaths on eachother and it seemed it was not going to be a simple problem solved unless they used the bomb.
…show more content…
They suffered many innocent lives that were surrounding the radius of the explosion and were wiped out right away.
Yoshitaka states from document D his life changing event on how much he had to endure. He explains how he had to witness countless lives pulling at his ankles as he tries to make it through the tradgedy himself. He was left to fight for his life as he was injured brutally and had to walk through a radioactive wasteland. Also in Table A, there was a total life loss of over 200,000 taken away and in hiroshima 30% just died from the collapsing debri.
There were so many lost lives that had no reasoning to enter the war, but they were still killed in the process. It told one point of view from a teenager who had to pull through to survive and the statistics that prove how significant the bombs were to Japan.
In the eyes of the Japanese, it was not needed for U.S. to drop the bomb. They were struggling to survive after the collapse of the land.

In my opinion, I believe that it was unnecesarry to jump on board with the decision so quickly. They should have taken more time to justify their

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    The first important fact I learned while reading this book is that about 100,000 people were killed, only six people survived. One of the survivors, Mr.Tanimoto had heard about raids in other nearby towns. Mr. Tanimoto had worried that something would happen to Hiroshima too. The night before the city was destroyed Mr.Tanimoto did not sleep because of anxiety and the warnings.…

    • 228 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Hiroshima PROS and CONS

    • 278 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Even though the bomb killed many inocent civilians were killed, I believe that it was necessary because with out the dropping the war would have gone on, and more lives would have been taken on both sides. The Japanese had no means to stop in the war but the dropping of the bomb showed that the US had no means to stand down either and we would take the actions necessary to protect ourselves and make sure that the Germans and Japanese made no advances. I believe it was…

    • 278 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ronald Takaki's Hiroshima

    • 2131 Words
    • 9 Pages

    The official reason given for dropping the bomb was to bring a quick end to tht war and save American lives. However, Takaki presents many different explanations as to why the decision to use the bomb was made. He disagrees with the popular belief that the decision to use the bomb was made solely to quickly end the war in the Pacific and to save American lives. Takaki presents theories such as international concerns, American sentiment, and racism in an attempt to more fully explain why this decision was made.…

    • 2131 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Not only did the Japanese attack Pearl Harbor without any notification, killing thousands of American men and women, but they were also trying to get Russia to join them in the war. Truman knew that if the war continued, there would be more bloodshed and he would have to send in ground troops to invade Japan. This could possibly result in the loss of many more American lives. The biggest reason for why he dropped the bomb was to end the war as early as possible (Donohue, 2012). Truman however, did not want to use the bomb unless he absolutely had to. He was trying to figure out ways to end the war at the lowest possible cost without using this bomb. The attack on Pearl Harbor was also a big reason to drop the bomb. Japan attacked the United States without even as much as a minute’s notification. Truman wanted retaliation and this was a sure way to get…

    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    This decision vien very late because the damage of the Bomble were Priceless "A hundred thousand people Were killed by the atomic bomb, and six thesis Were Among the survivors" (from Hiroshima page 9). In May 1945, after the capitulation of Nazi Germany, the existence of these bombs of a new type was a source of great hope together of great uncertainty for the small number of leaders who knew about it. They hoped that this new and terrible weapon hasten the end of the war with Japan. But then again, many doubts remained about the bomb and its use. Roosevelt has somehow left to Truman's strategy of minimizing the losses in American lives. Indeed, given the number of dead Soviet, German, Chinese, Japanese, English and many others, and taking into account the strength of the Japanese enemy, the number of American deaths during the Second War world was relatively small, about four hundred and twenty Thousands of dead people, compared to the millions or even tens of millions of other belligerents, especially if there are civilian casualties. Beyond its determination to remain true to the legacy of Roosevelt, Truman sought to minimize US casualties because of his own combat experience. Former artillery captain in World War II, he found himself under fire from the enemy, he saw soldiers die before his eyes, including those who were under his command. Truman was therefore in great…

    • 945 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    You could easily imagine the hopeless feelings of the people of Japan as doctors came to try and treat a disease that they had never seen before and were leery of even trying to treat if for fear of catching it themselves. You can easily see the paranoia as "air raids" were yelled out again and again as people put on their air raid caps and ran for cover. When I think of war I think of a battle fought far off in a foreign land. We feel protected because we are in our own country. These people probably felt the same thing until the bombing. I can't imagine the horror of having not only your house, but also having your entire hometown destroyed in the blink of an eye. The destruction of the city was only the initial damage done. The sickness that affected the people reminded them for many years to come of the effects the bombing would continue to have on their lives. When the book ends, you are really given dose of the fear of the people as they ponder what was going to happen to them at the end of the war. You can feel the fear of the people as they try to imagine the things that are going to happen as they are taken over by another country. They feared that their culture was about to be taken away from…

    • 1042 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There were many steps taken and effects considered, before dropping the atomic bomb. One main consideration was the effect the bomb would have on the Japanese citizens. With a bomb as destructive and massive as the one they had created, they had to consider the loss of life it would ensue. Not only would it most likely kill thousands on impact, it would also kill more with the radiation that the bomb would disperse. J. R. Oppenheimer said that “the active material of the bomb itself is toxic” therefore the effects of the bomb after would be detrimental to the people and the area surrounding the city. An…

    • 1268 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One way that the US is justified in dropping the atomic bomb, is because it signaled the end of the war with Japan- or sped up the surrendering. After the second bombing at Nagasaki, the Japanese government surrender unconditionally to the United States. However, Japan was on the verge of surrendering at any moment, according to President Truman. In his opinion, as soon as Russia entered the war Japan would quickly ‘fold up’. While a tough competitor, Japan had no idea of who they were really at war with, on the grounds that the United States were willing to do anything to stop the war with a victory. The two atomic bombs was that heavy and destructive push that showed Japan just what they were up against.…

    • 559 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Idea was proposed to the Secretary of the Navy that the bomb should be demonstrated to the Japanese so that they had an idea of what they were facing…

    • 800 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Atomic Bomb Justified

    • 2243 Words
    • 9 Pages

    On August 6th, 1945, an American B-29 bomber named “Enola Gay” dropped the world’s first Atomic bomb on Hiroshima in Japan. The nuclear explosion killed nearly 90 percent of the cities population, killing 75,000 people from the point of impact and thousands more dying from Radiation Poisoning later on. Three days later, on August 9th, a second B-29 bomber named “Bockscar” dropped a second Atomic bomb on the Japanese city, Nagasaki. This bomb killed 40,000 people on impact with over 60,000 more people dying after from Radiation Poisoning. The Atomic bomb was a new technology to everyone worldwide and its raw destructive power was enough for the Japanese Emperor Hirohito to agree to the Americans unconditional surrender terms. The terms were to release all prisoners of war, end the fighting and to agree with the Potsdam declaration.…

    • 2243 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    There were many reasons why America would have chosen to drop the bomb and the majority can be justified. Before the atomic bomb was dropped, America was nearing the end of the war. They had made the Potsdam declaration requesting Japans surrender and at this point had the Japanese at a very weak position. At a similar time, the Americans had completed the development of the Atomic bomb or Project Manhattan that, after Germany surrendered, had no other competition. A lot money had been put into the development of the bomb and at this point, Truman’s options were limited. Invasion was out of the question due to the Japanese’s strong military and patriotic values: The continuation of conventional bombings and a naval blockade were also considered but deemed unsuitable. The negation of surrender had been tried with the ‘Potsdam Declaration’ and had failed. It is important to point out that by ignoring the declaration; the Japanese in effect gave their acceptance of the Americans threats of ‘prompt and utter destruction.’[1] America…

    • 1576 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Truman's decision was a hard one to make as there were many reasons for and against the bombs. We assume that his decision was altruistic, trying to make the best possible decision based on the information that he had at the time. The main reason given for dropping the bomb was that it was going to shorten the war and save American lives. Truman said he had acted "In order to shorten the agony of war, in order to save the lives of thousands and thousands of young Americans."…

    • 3077 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hiroshima Bombing

    • 782 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Many historians have different opinions and views why the United States dropped the bomb. I agree with historians Alperovitz and Frank, unlike most they’re anti-atomic bomb on Japan. I’m against the use of atomic weapons altogether and especially in Truman’s situation the atomic bomb was a bad decision. The use of the atomic bomb in Hiroshima was unjust and overkill. The bomb killed thousands of civilians in Hiroshima to compel the Japanese to surrender, but as historian Berstein stated “conventional bombings could have produced the same result by November 1st.” Berstein points out that the Japanese government was collapsing on itself and their transportation system throughout the country was very poor and couldn’t supply its people with food and resources so the United States could have waited the Japanese out. The use of the bomb could cause public backlash as well, rather than using the bomb the United States could have demonstrated the bomb before hand in which compelling the Japanese to surrender. The Truman administration had millions of other options rather than the atomic bomb or a direct invasion. The United States could have let the Soviet Union join and this would also pressure the Japanese to surrender,…

    • 782 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    August 8, 1946 will be a day etched into the memories of the many people that survived the nuclear bombing of Hiroshima. John Hershey wrote a book titled, Hiroshima, which told the stories of six survivors from that day. The stories that are told by these brave people are heart wrenching, horrific, and almost painful to even read. Two survivors, Akihiro Takahashi and Eiko Taoka, tell a story about the air raid and what they saw after the large red flash had hit the ground. Many people went about their day knowing that there was an air raid in effect but also knowing that they could not stop their lives due to what could happen later on that morning. It was almost minutes after people of Hiroshima continued with their day to day lives that their world was turned upside down in just a few moments.…

    • 802 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The main external conflict in Hiroshima is the bomb itself and the consequences from it. In the beginning of the book, the bomb is clearly described as being the cause of many people's pains. The destructive force causes eyes to melt, scars, burns, broken bones, and the hate and disgust of Americans. This proves to be a conflict for citizens and the government of Japan, having never experiencing this before. Eventually, it took a really long time to rebuild the city and immediately treat all of the victims. Because of this piece of evidence, it reveals that this one external conflict's effects can live on for many generations through long term…

    • 112 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays