Young Goodman Brown and The Allegory of the Cave have a lot of similarities in their stories. They 're both talking about a person 's struggle with good vs. evil. Also, they both refer to the darkness vs. the light. People deal with these type of struggles everyday. These two stories seem to be the epitome of that concept. In Young Goodman Brown, the story is revolving around a man who lives in Salem and seems to be struggling with his views on religion and the virtues of good and evil. He takes a dreary road headed towards an evil purpose even though his wife who has good virtues begs him not to take that path. But like most people, he decides to take it anyway, and hopes that he can come back after all the evil was done and still have the good part in his life. Young Goodman Brown was headed to an evil ritual and on his way to this ritual continues to struggle with his inner voice and whether or not he was doing the right thing. Yet, he continues to justify why the evil should prevail. He was struggling between whether or not he was doing the right thing. Yet, he continues to justify why the evil should prevail. He was struggling between whether he was in reality or whether it is just a dream and a figment of his imagination. In the end, Young Goodman Brown lets evil prevail and he lives a dreary, gloomy life and dies a gloomy death. The Allegory of the Cave is a story similar to Young Goodman Brown. It was a struggle between good and evil, enlightened or unenlightened, light vs. dark. It follows a prisoner and his struggle with the light vs. darkness. "The prison dwelling corresponds to the region revealed to us through a sense of sight, and the fire-light within it to the power of the Sun ." (Allegory of the Cave 731) This passage shows how he was wanting so badly to see the good, but yet the prison walls lock in the darkness that follows him. He struggles everyday with the goodness and the evil that the prison throws at him. It literally encompasses his life, this was all he thought, dreamt, and lived. In the end, he realizes that he was destined for something better than where he was at the tries to life by this hope. Both Young Goodman Brown and the Allegory of the Cave were very good stories concerning a persons everyday struggles with goodness and evil. It portrays this struggle with two very different scenarios, yet gets the message across very strong and clear. This allows the readers to interact and associate with the two stories because everyone has these issues at one time or another in their life. The stories were somewhat dark in perception, yet have a very good message and seem to truly help understand the turmoil a person goes through everyday with good and evil. These two stories portray these issues perfectly and reveal how people from every different type of situation deal with this issue on a daily basis. Young Goodman Brown and The Allegory of the Cave are two very different essays, yet they both try to capture the ever longing battle with Good and Evil.
Young Goodman Brown tries to capture the essence of Good versus Evil concerning witchcraft and different religions. Although Young Goodman Brown is primarily regarding a man 's struggle with Good versus evil, one could say it could be an inside struggle of the man 's mind; His struggle with his religion issues and what each one will do to his life for years to come. The essay focuses on Young Goodman Brown 's journey through a forest in which he runs into a ceremony/ritual going on. It focuses on the good and bad people that he encounters on the way and his struggles with reality and the figment of his imagination. The essay provides an insight on one man 's battles with good versus evil in the religion aspect of his life and how each consequence will forever change his life. The Allegory of the Cave is an essay about a man in prison and his battle with the good and evil that encompasses him while in prison. The essay tries to capture the essence of good versus evil, but in a totally different scenario. The Allegory of the Cave could be centered around a man with a mental illness and it 's about his struggle with battling his mental illness. This could be from being put in solitude or the different encounters he has at the Prison.
The Allegory of the Cave centers around a prisoner who knows that he put himself in prison by his actions, but is now realizing that not all evil has to prevail from this experience. Even though there are many things that try and keep an evil/bad presence around him. He finds good in different things he does. But he struggles with allowing the good to overtake his life through all the bad/evil.
The two essays are similar in that they both tackle the discussion of good versus evil. They both use extreme situations to give a detailed perception of this issue. Both essays are very interesting in their expressions of each scenario and the outcomes of each. These are just two very good examples of the everyday struggles with Good and Evil that people have in their lives.
Works Cited
Gwynn, R.S. and Zani, Steven J. Inside Literature- Reading, Responding, Arguing.
New York: Pearson Education, Inc., 2007.
Cited: Gwynn, R.S. and Zani, Steven J. Inside Literature- Reading, Responding, Arguing. New York: Pearson Education, Inc., 2007.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
In “Allegory of the Cave” by Plato, the nature of good is represented through the deprivation of light the prisoners of the cave experience. In this imaginary representation, the individuals are not so much prisoners of the actual cave as they are of their own ignorance. The prisoners are surrounded by darkness and faint light, depicting shadows into reality. If light is the representation of truth, then the darkness engulfing the cave represents the lies the prisoners ignorantly believe. Because the darkness is all that they have known, they…
- 851 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The Allegory of the Cave is about a group of people who have lived in a cave since their childhood. These people not only live in this cave, but they are also chained and made to face a blank wall. Even their heads are shackled such that they cannot look behind them or at the sides. On the blank wall in front of them, a fire that is behind them projects shadows of objects that are passing behind them. When one of them is released to the outside world, the people who remain in the cave do not believe the version of the story concerning the reality of the shadows they have spent the whole of their lives watching and analyzing.…
- 1275 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
Every good story has interesting main characters that the reader can follow. This includes the stories of “Young Goodman Brown” by Nathaniel Hawthorne and “The Black Cat” by Edgar Allan Poe. Both stories have their main characters change towards the end of their respective stories. In addition, both stories can be centered around the theme of losing innocence as both characters partake in actions that they thought they would never do or see. In fact, both characters are similar in the fact that they both are allured by temptation, proven as unreliable, commit unspeakable acts, and…
- 396 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The character Goodman Brown, from “Young Goodman Brown,” partakes in a journey into the forest during the late evening where he undertakes many obscure paths that transform his attitude with life completely. Goodman Brown starts off as an innocent man until he ventures deeper into the forest and meets with an elderly man that possibly represents the devil. The stranger began to corrupt Goodman Brown’s mind as they proceeded along the journey. For example, “Goodman Brown believes in the Christian nature of Goody Cloyse, the minister,…
- 665 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Plato’s work in the Allegory of the Cave emphasizes the actualization of reality and truth. Fredrick Douglass’ life, which is portrayed in Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave, is similar to Plato’s philosophical idea presented in “The Allegory of the Cave.” Plato, a Greek philosopher introduces the significant meaning of reality and truth through his philosophical text. He illustrates the difference between illusion and the real world, which represents reality. In comparison, Frederick Douglass was an African American who had limited rights since he was a slave. Douglass decided to escape the darkness and get educated to become aware of the outside world. The definition of progress in both tales, are very similar. In both stories, there are four major progressions. First, both stories begin with men who are in the stage of ignorance. Second, these men are somehow able to escape from their bondage to ignorance. Third, they are enlightened. Fourth, they go back to their fellow friends, who are still bound to ignorance, and enlighten them. “The Allegory of the Cave” and the Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass share the path to knowledge from ignorance.…
- 834 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In Descartes’ Meditations on First Philosophy, Plato’s The Allegory of the Cave, and the synopsis of The Matrix, there are many similarities as well as a few differences. One of the most notable differences that can be observed is that Meditations in First Philosophy begins and ends in the same reality, whereas The Allegory of the Cave and The Matrix begin with the deception of an alternate reality. Another difference that can be detected is the presence of forms in The Allegory of the Cave, which is Plato’s theory that there are perfect ideas or templates that exist outside of our physical world. The strongest common thread that can be traced through these three texts is the metaphysical question of what is ultimately real. Another common theme that can be observed in each of the texts is skepticism over the reliability of each of the main character’s senses and perceptions of reality.…
- 805 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
“Young Goodman Brown” by Nathanial Hawthorne, shows great examples of symbolism and allegory. Hawthorne shows how life is not easy no matter what path is chosen. The challenge the puritan society faces for their religion and how it influences them. He also reveals key components of real life and how deception can affect it.…
- 560 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
I have gone over the many similarities in both the Matrix and the Allegory of the cave such as how both protagonists have been deceived about what is real, that they cannot trust their senses, that they can accomplish great endeavors, and that it is their responsibility to tell others the…
- 585 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In the short story, “Young Goodman Brown,” Nathaniel Hawthorne uses the literary archetype of a good versus evil opposition to contribute to Goodman Brown’s fate. In the beginning of the story, Goodman Brown must choose to “put off [his] journey until sunrise, and sleep in [his] own bed” (133), or abandon his wife for the night to pursue an evil errand. Even after his wife pleads him to stay, Goodman makes the decision to leave his home to journey to an evil place. Considering how quickly Hawthorne allows Goodman to face a conflict of good versus evil in the story, readers begin assuming that Goodman’s condition will directly connect to the choices he makes in these situations. Readers find proof of this connection when Goodman…
- 400 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Young Goodman Brown: This story was confusing at first, but after the second read through I found the story of Goodman Brown to be a great revelation that people aren’t always who they seem to be. When Goodman Brown meets up with the older man, he is essentially meeting up with the devil. The devil then weaves Goodman Brown into what is described as a dream, although to me as well as Goodman Brown, it is possible that it was not a dream. In Goodman Brown’s “dream”, Goodman Brown is lead to a sort of “evil ceremony” where he discovers many surprising people attending such as the minister of the church, Deacon Gookin, and his own wife, Faith. Seeing these people who Goodman Brown thought to be pious, Goodman Brown awakens from his “dream” with a new vision of the world. After the devil’s “dream” Goodman Brown is convinced that everyone is evil and loses his trust in the people of Salem. It was when Faith, Goodman Brown’s wife, was revealed to be attending the ceremony did Goodman Brown really start to lose his trust. When Goodman Brown saw his wife, as well as the ribbons falling from her cap, Goodman Brown lost this idea of female purity. Again, at first the story of Goodman Brown was a little confusing, but the second time around the story represented the great illusion that all people are pure due to moral choice and the illusion of female purity.…
- 1223 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
The short stories "Araby" by James Joyce and "Young Goodman Brown" by Nathaniel Hawthorne are both stories about change; however both characters change in very different ways. Organized religion imposes a rebut of prescribed behavior on natural curiosity and growth and in turn causes one to seek it out on there own. In "Araby" an unnamed young boy of about twelve or thirteen depicts his personal coming of age. Due to strong religious obligations, sexuality was greatly repressed during the time of this story. "Young Goodman Brown" tells the tale of a young Puritan man drawn into a covenant with the Devil. Brown's illusions about the goodness of his society are crushed when he discovers that many of his fellow townspeople, including religious leaders and his wife, are attending a Black Mass. Allusions Goodman Brown had witnessed may have or not been real, but changed his life completely.…
- 936 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Young Goodman Brown ask a false question of faith, false in the assertion that the question can have only two answers. Faith is singularly defined as good thus all else, especially doubt, is evil. Therefore, Goodman Brown’s revelation - not all people of faith have pure faith- is profoundly troubling. In effect the rigid construct of his world is shattered. Furthermore Brown, due to his position in society, epitomizes respectability and is naturally married to Faith. His status is essentially his birthright, for his father and grandfather before him were reputable men. To an extent Brown functions as the common American man who cherishes the history of a country and family name bestowed onto him while lamenting obligation. Goodman encounters the conflict of masculinity explicitly, not only does he carry a highly regarded family name, but he also is not privy to innocence and blind faith like his wife. Faith is pink, childlike, and unknowing of darkness or doubt. Faith represents the impossibility of unadulterated belief, for it is remarkably unlikely for a mature adult to be so ignorant of life’s tribulations. However, in Young Goodman Brown unadulterated faith is presented as the only pious option even though doubt is inevitable and pervasive. Doubt and the darkness lingering in the forest have, in fact, reached nearly the whole town. There in the woods “the good shrank not from the wicked”(85). In reality, there is no clear divide between good and evil, thus there is no clear divide between faith and doubt. Such a statement, a refusal of dichotomy,…
- 405 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Have you ever watched curiosity get the best of someone, or heard the age old saying curiosity killed the cat? In the story Young Goodman Brown, Nathaniel Hawthorne illustrates this perfectly by showing just what happens when you start to question those around you. Young Goodman Brown represents an allegory by using religious imagery, character names, and struggles between good and evil. For example, the main characters’ names, Young Goodman Brown and Faith, could symbolize the innocence of youth and how temptations are always lurking. These names might foreshadow that the story is probably based on youth and faith. When the story opens, the first paragraph states, “And Faith, as the wife was aptly named, thrust her own pretty head into the…
- 810 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Young Goodman Brown is a young man who fits his name. He is innocent and believes the community is as harmless as they appear. However his innocence has blinded him to the reality of the dark world. Brown’s family, his wife, and respected members of the community such as Goody Cloyse and Deacon Gookin, have all submitted to the devil. Brown gives in by going to the ceremony, but is permanently scarred and shaken by the experience. He no longer trusts anyone in the community or fully loves his wife again. The beliefs he thought that everyone had were corrupted when he discovered their alliance with the devil. Each of these people followed one another, disregarding their personal morals. This made all the characters seem spineless and unfaithful. This shows Hawthorne’s themes of not all things are as they seem, standing firm in your beliefs, doing what you know to be right and not following the crowd just because of a popular decision.…
- 890 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The grandmother and her family encounter The Misfit and the grandmother immediately starts sweet talking him to attempt to save herself. The grandmother says “I know you’re a good man… I know you must come from nice people,” trying to manipulate him to not kill her. She stays true to her southern class and never stoops down to The Misfits level. On the other hand, Brown falls into the trap of evil. Before being summoned to the dark side, Brown was told “evil must be your only happiness. Welcome, again, my children, to the communion of your race!” Brown did not take a stand against evil, punishing himself into a lifetime of misery. Despite the grandmother’s and Brown’s similarities, one major difference is how they handle evil when it is presented to them.…
- 491 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays