top-rated free essay

All Men Are Created Equally, a Contradiction

By bigjewy Oct 14, 2012 677 Words
Smith 1 James Smith English 101-28 Short Answer Response #3 09/12/2012

All Men are Created Equally: A Contradiction Over the centuries america has fabricated the cultural mythology that all men are created equally. For years america has enforced that all men are created equally when in fact the statement itself is a contradiction. Years ago certain people could not vote because of slavery, race, and also gender. Also America has social classes that have always been vivid in american culture. Finally this cliche holds very little currency in this nation now. Before and during the era of the civil war, slavery was a huge issue for many reasons. One of the biggest issues was that even though they were heman and on american soil; they were not allowed to vote. At this time in history slaves were not able to vote because they were considered “Property.” “Slaves were considered property, and they were property because they were black. (“”)” How is property supposed to vote, right? Even though they were considered property, they were still human. If all men were created equally, as the constitution stated, then the slaves should of had the right to vote. Unfortunately they did not obtain this right until 94 years later. After slavery was abolished, there was still a problem. Certain people were not allowed to vote because of their race and gender. Again, all of these humans are supposed to be created equally, yet because of race and gender they are denied basic human rights. It would take another 94 years until the passage of the Voting Rights Act of 1965 for any of these people to be able to vote. So apparently all men are created equally unless they are a different gender or race. By living in america, you automatically become apart of a social class. America consists of four social classes: an upper class, working class, middle class, and finally a lower class.

Smith 2 James Smith English 101-28 Short Answer Response #3 09/12/2012

America should not even have social classes if all men are created equally. If all men are created equally, then everyone would be making the same amount of money, have the same education, and etc. This surely is not the case. “Results from these three research methods suggest that in the united states today, approximately 15 to 20 percent are in the poor, lower class; 30 to 40 percent are in the working class; 40 to 50 percent are in the middle class; and 1 to 3 percent are in the rich upper class. (“CliffsNotes”)” There is a wide variety of different people in different social classes. This fact completely contradicts that all men are created equally because clearly they are not if america divides itself into different social classes. This particular cliche holds very little currency in this nation today. It still has some value though; by this i mean anyone who is an actual citizen of the united states can vote. Other than that it holds no currency. This cliche still lingers around because it gives people a sense of satisfaction. It gives people satisfaction because they think that even though that person is richer than me, or is different from me in any way; we still have the same rights and same penalties. Therefore this phrase will stick around until people realize that it is a contradiction and cultural mythology; eventually they will become unsatisfied with it. America has fabricated that all men are created equally. As you read, you realized that the phrase itself is a cultural mythology and contradictory. There are countless other reasons why this cliche is contradictory. You now know that slavery, race, gender, and social class play a vital role in proving this.

Works Cited

Smith 3 James Smith English 101-28 Short Answer Response #3 09/12/2012

. "Conditions of Antebellum Slavery." PBS, 01 Aug 2012. Web. 12 Sep 2012. .

. "Types of Social Classes of People." CliffsNotes. CliffsNotes, n.d. Web. 12 Sep 2012. .

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • All men are NOT created equal

    ... On July 4, 1776 our founding fathers signed their names on the Declaration Of Independence envisioning a country that would guarantee freedom to all its citizens, however events in American history have not always supported these principals. In certain situations lines have been drawn between "us" and "them". Prejudice, discrimination...

    Read More
  • All Men Created Equal

    ...All Men Created Equal America has undergone incredible hardships as a nation. No issue has had more impact on the development of the American definition of freedom than the issue of slavery. Did the Constitution specify which men were created equal? Surprisingly enough the phrase "all men are created equal with certain inalienable rights" d...

    Read More
  • All Men Are Created Equal

    ...All men are created equal. That has been proven true in only fantasies with princesses and knights in shining armor. Even then, there are still discriminations visible the hero; always handsome, with blonde hair, stunning blue eyes, and being white is with out question. The world is full of stereotypes. If a person is black, he/she is in a ga...

    Read More
  • All Men Are Not Created Equal

    ...All Men are Not Created Equal Since the beginnings of our nation’s it has been implied that all people should be viewed as equals but the question is, are all people seen as equal? Our founding fathers wrote that all men were all one of the same. Everyone is familiar with Thomas Jefferson's famous quote," We hold these truths to be self-evid...

    Read More
  • All Men Are Created Equal

    ...“All Men Are Created Equal” By: Kaitlyn Manzelli The statement, “All Men Are Created Equal” is an understanding that there is no natural class of rulers among the people. Which means everyone is equal by law. The United States Declaration of Independence says, “We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equa...

    Read More
  • All Men Are Created Equal Analysis

    ...One phrase often brought up when speaking of early American history is that “all men are created equal”. It’s a key line in the Declaration of Independence, written by Thomas Jefferson in 1776, and is one that many remember today. Some would argue that this is one of the foundations of our country, and it may even be something some America...

    Read More
  • Are all men really created equal?

    ...Are all men really created equal? I have always heard the cliché in the constitution that all men are created equal but is it a valid statement? I have seen people with both physical and mental disabilities; people who view the world differently than us “normal” humans. People who have different hardships that we can never understand throug...

    Read More
  • All Men Are Created Equal - Summary

    ...that all men are created equal”. This is a precedent that was established centuries ago to tell the people of its time that there is no man lesser than another. It was set and meant to last for a very long time. Thomas Jefferson was the one who made the phrase famous, but it was his great friend Philip Mazzei who first used the saying through ...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.