Preview

Alfred Lubrano How College Corrupts

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
826 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Alfred Lubrano How College Corrupts
College is the next stepping stone to better or advance ones social standing in life, whether it is moving from a blue collar lifestyle to white collar, or to continue to further their career path. However, it comes with an “unavoidable result.” Alfred Lubrano discusses this “unavoidable result” in his text “The Shock of Education: How College Corrupts.” Lubrano discusses the topic of how furthering ones education opens more possibilities but at the same time distances those held most dearly. He explains that the more knowledge gained, the bigger the gap caused between friends and family due to differences in levels of knowledge. That distance is greatly increase if one comes from a poorer region where blue collar workers are the social norm. For instance, conversations within lower class households come off more militaristic due to the fact that all opinions are “dictated by group consensus,” where what the class says is so. Juxtaposed to the middle class household where they are talked to as adults.. Lubrano does not try to dissuade one from attending college, he simply shines a light onto a hidden matter that is not discussed when continuing ones education. Lubrano hits the nail on the head about the distance gained when continuing ones education with friends and family, but does not consider the fact about that distance being magnified as a first generation American. One of Alfred Lubrano’s main points was how college distanced childhood friends as well as loved ones. He describes how he learned to “self-censor” himself and only discussed “general stuff,” because it was undiscerning to his father, a blue collar working man. Not to mention that listening to a freshman discuss the topics of race, equality, or politics, was as unsettling as “riding in a car with a new driver.” In fact, Lubrano’s professor himself told his class not to discuss what they have learned in class, Marxist theory, because it would “mess up the holiday.” Under those circumstances, one

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The author reflects on specific instances relevant to him as well as people who have shared similar experiences. He then goes on to make broader generalizations based off of the collected data. For example, in all the anecdotes, the student breaks a strong connection with either their family, peer, or loved one due to the expansion of knowledge they were exposed to. Lubrano makes the point that while college kids are off formulating their own views, their close ones are at home unable to break the mob mentality and “shared opinions” that thrives within the working class (535). Hence the change of views between family and student also thrusts the student into a state of isolation in which they become a pariah. Is this always what happens to families when a child pursues what they consider to be in their best interests? Probably not, but based on Lubrano’s use of inductive reasoning it’s likely to be the most common…

    • 577 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Marty Nemko’s article, “We Send Too Many Students to College,” he analyzes and questions whether college is truly worth the money. Marty “holds a Ph.D. specializing in the evaluation of education from the University of California, Berkeley, and subsequently taught there” (martynemko.com) as well as published five successful books. In addition to his novels, he previously was a columnist at San Francisco Chronical and The Atlantic Monthly, also a contributing editor at several other well-known companies. Nemko’s purpose is to convey the idea that, even though there may be reasons one would attend college, the complications overshadow the benefits. He adopts an impassionate tone in order to convince his adult audience to take a hard look at whether it is worthwhile for their children to attend college.…

    • 973 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although I agree with the vast majority of Frank Bruni’s claims about the benefits of the ideas of community and diversity, I believe some of his prescriptions in Demanding More From College to solve the polarizing and alienating effect of the internet on the individual in our modern society are perhaps a bit naive and misguided although for the most part a good first step. Most people agree that college is supposed to be one of the most fun times of one’s fine where one meets those who are to be one’ friends for the rest of one’ life, the Frank Bruni, author of Demanding More From College thinks “there’s another dimension to college.” In our politically bipolar landscape, Bruni suggests that college students are a crucial part of solving the problem. Bruni say that we must “confront and change political and social aspects of American life that are as troubling as the economy.” I completely agree, seeing as how…

    • 629 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The piece begins with a quote that provides insight on the importance of college. It argues that those who believe college is unimportant don’t fully realize the benefits of attending college. Contrasted with primary reasons people don’t attend college such as cost, debt and being unprepared which are introduced in a New York Times illustration called, “College is for Suckers”. Continuing on, Murray establishes credibility when he provides insight on the achievements of Freeman Hrabowski such as his presidency at the University of Maryland, being announced the chair of the President’s Advisory Commission and Educational Excellence for African Americans, and coauthor of many books. It is stated that most of quickly expanding jobs usually require a college degree. In addition, college graduates obtain the advantage over high school graduates when seeking a job, and ultimately earn more…

    • 630 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Larry Cuban, a former social studies high school teacher, superintendent, manages to compress the mantra that has been repeated for several of years with his article entitled, “Why Everyone Shouldn’t Go To College”. He accomplishes this by giving us countless of interesting facts about the reality of college and life. He argues that the annual college tuition seems to be extremely expensive, that may not worth the amount of money you’re paying.In addition, he makes note that college graduates working at manufacturing places that don’t need college diplomas, in order to complete their job. Furthermore, he makes clear that one might be a high school dropout or graduate of high school and can still be highly…

    • 117 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ellison, University of Chicago’s Dean, refused to provide trigger warnings and safe spaces in the university. In other words, students would not be warned about the discussion of sensitive topics nor would they be allowed to express their feelings to an authority in the campus. Downes disagrees with Dean Ellison’s stance and instead believes that “support systems can be a lifeline in the tumultuous environment of college, and are important precisely because they encourage a free exchange of ideas” (Downes, Paragraph 6). In other words, Downes believes that a support system is crucial in a college setting environment, where emotional topics are freely discussed in class. Furthermore, Downes ends off her piece by stating that the school’s administration cannot prevent students from supporting each other. For example, she states that “campus advocacy groups will not be deterred by a letter” (Downes, Paragraph 14) and her tone showed an approval of the students’ decision. As a result, Downes supports the idea of expanding student’s comfort levels, however she strongly agrees with the students that resources should be available to…

    • 548 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In this ever-changing society in which we live in, is centered around many norms. A norm that has taken a large leap over the years deals with college education. In Margaret A. Miller’s “The Privileges of the Parents,” she discusses the impacts that a parent’s education has on their children. She does that by referencing the difference in the economic benefit received by individuals with a variety of educational backgrounds. To support her claim, Miller centered her essay around an old folk saying, “the apple doesn’t fall far from the tree.” In which she used that saying and her knowledge to portray the concept of a student’s education being impacted either positively or negatively based on what their parents educational background it. Miller…

    • 1100 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In recent discussions of “The College Dropout Boom,” David Leonhardt made some interesting points on the works of society and it’s modern day views on education. Many of the ideas he presented were controversial to me, considering my previous perspective of social status’ having nothing to do with someone’s chances at graduating college. However, there are many ideas in which he presented that I agree with, such as the belief that obtaining a college degree doesn’t necessarily promise a well-paying job. Growing up in a household where nobody has ever earned a college degree, I can say personally that it is extremely important to have one, regardless of the immediate outcome. It’s better to be safe than sorry.…

    • 777 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    On June twelfth of 2001, Linda Lee wrote an article for the Family Circle stating a case against college. Lee attempted using pathos, ethos, and logos to persuade her readers that college is not a necessity in a child’s future. However, numerous of these appeals can easily be contradicted by somebody as simple minded as a high schooler.…

    • 652 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    College Education Flaws

    • 1299 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Delbanco argues that the purpose of college is to learn how to make decisions, challenge your views and expand your our knowledge of others to find yourself. A key claim that he points out is how American culture differentiates from this by extending their childhoods, he writes, “In America there has been an impulse to slow things down, to extend the time for second chances and defer the day when determinative choices must be made” (Delbanco 221). He supports his claim with this slippery slope of how young adults cannot make decisions due to society’s view that their childhood should be expanded. The premise is that true…

    • 1299 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    My whole life I have heard it said that going to college is a must to survive in the economy and live a successful life, but is that true? Recent events beg to differ as seen in a Newsweek article where they quoted a professor at Georgetown University’s Center on Education and the Workforce, Anthony Carnevale, saying college graduates make up almost “40 percent of the unemployed in the U.S.”. This example forms just one argument that I will use, along with the price that college demands for its services and its uselessness in fields of employment, to convince you that college isn’t all that it’s cracked up to be.…

    • 1412 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In discussion of colleges importance, one controversial issue has been on how much it really matters. On the one hand, college supporters argue that college is very important and can help one achieve a prosperous future. On the other hand, college detractors contend that college is a waste of time and not useful in the long run. My own view is that college can be useful when people use it in the right way; to gain a degree, and not just to party.…

    • 419 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Everyone in America knows that college is where you want to be. At a very young and impressionable age, the children in our schools are asked what college they want to go to. As this idea that a higher education is something they’ll inevitably have, the children go on to believe they need it to have a better life. However, is that really true? College, in particular, is a very strange and corrupt system. Many problems reside on the modern college campus, so many that we wonder if going to college was ever the better option. The truth is, it’s not. Going to college is not worth all its burdening, and often crippling, costs.…

    • 900 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Persuasive Word Choice

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In America, college is perceived as one of the most important decisions you will make in your lifetime. Since elementary school, students are taught so that they can one day attend to a good college. However, the question is: is college the best option? Many would say that it is, including authors David Leonhardt of The New York Times and Freeman Hrabowski, author of "Colleges Prepare People for Life". Even though David Leonhardt and Freeman Hrabowski both address the idea that college is worth it in the long run, Leonhardt provides a further convincing argument by revealing where exactly college fits into our constantly growing society, using persuasive word choice, and constantly incorporating facts and statistics.…

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Alfred Lubrano article, “The Shock of Education: How College Corrupts,” he forms the idea that not every working class family see the value in higher educations. He makes the argument that a person’s likeliness to have problems with their family depends on the distance between the person’s education and their parents. He gives an example of him and his family as well as a couple others from people who experienced similar situations to his. He began by explaining the different experiences he and his father had at Columbia. He talks about how during dinner he wouldn’t talk about his studies, because no one wanted to hear about him mimicking his professors’ thoughts on race and politics. He also mentions how he would study by the kitchen dishwasher…

    • 670 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays