Preview

Alfie Kohn The Case Against Grades Summary

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
784 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Alfie Kohn The Case Against Grades Summary
In the article, The Case against Grades, Alfie Kohn talks about how the grading system is deflecting the actual purpose of why students are interested in classes. He speaks on how grades tend to diminish students and create a preference for what a student has to aim for in his or hers course. I myself have experienced this in my academic life.
A student shouldn’t be categorized and put into groups when looking at a grade.
When a student enrolls himself into a course, let’s say in high school, he or she is doing it because they’re interested in the course and the material that will be offered in it. One of the first things you’re given in classes when it’s time to do an assignment is a rubric of how different type of techniques will get you either a level 1, which is the lowest of grades(50% or D) you can get a level 2, which is a C or 60-70%. You can get a level 3 which is encouraged, that is a B or 80% and lastly a level 4 which is looked up as the
…show more content…
Graders and educators seem to emphasize assignments and grading for performance and understanding. The grading system basically labels a student’s image either being a smart/average/”dumb”. Knowing this will run very deep in how a child careers their self around school or when they have to do an assignment. The grading system makes the student more focused on what they can do to get the grade that is Above Standard than actually care about what they’re researching or learning about, this is assessing students and categorizing them basically in groups based on their knowledge and skill in the course. Teachers do try to motivate their students but it doesn’t always work and students begin to chase their grade and become disinterested in the course material. I saw a post the other day on why students cheat on exams to pass and the top reply was this “When students cheat on exams it’s because of our school system values grades more than students

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    When someone asks you why earning a higher grade in class is important to receive, your first response might be to help increase your grade point average (GPA). But why is a high GPA so coveted? Is it to get into a good post graduate school? But then why is this important? You would probably respond by saying to create more opportunities for yourself when it comes to a career to venture in. These are the questions that Steven Vogel dives into, and gets to the point that through all of these questions lead up to one underlying factor that grades are money and learning is what is paid for. He believes students will attempt to maximize…

    • 979 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are Several cringe worthy processes that we as humans, must endure throughout our lives. An example of such process is Paul Goodman`s story “A Proposal Abolish Grading “.…

    • 463 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tadarius Doricent

    • 551 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Throughout my existence on this earth, I’ve been told by personal sources that a student should reflect in his or her grades. That’s how it’s been in my household and for some odd reason I believed that. It was the way of life for me and I stood by that reason like it was my religion. That can’t be in my opinion. If a letter or a number depicts on what a good student is, isn’t the system maybe just a little broken. Throughout my school career I’ve met students who didn’t make good grades all the way through semesters. Then they ace every exam and every test in every class. This causes them to make A’s, but does that fact make them good student material? I don’t think so.…

    • 551 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Students getting graded on their standards give the students a higher opportunity to get better grades and understand the information better. Grading students on what they actually learn vs what they should learn gives the teacher a better understanding what the student is getting and what they don't understand. If students get thrown into a class they don't understand and are producing low grades they become overwhelmed and give…

    • 353 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Diagnostic essay

    • 438 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The grade scaling always competition which in return creates an environment for students to strive. WANT MORE! While in a class with someone producing better grades, and…

    • 438 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Grade Inflation

    • 1271 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Staples proposes “The evidence suggest that students and parents are demanding -and getting- what they think of as their money’s worth.” Schools are making it easier to complain about or appeal a bad grade because they treat students as a customer whose needs have to be met by the school’s product. The problem is, a school isn’t a store you can walk into and pick up a diploma of your choosing off the shelf and expect to get a shiny new job with it the next day. They are a credential that you must earn by proving yourself in your work in order to have credibility. The leniency of allowing the unjustified alterations to improve grades make grade inflation more plausible than ever…

    • 1271 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    ability to be creative and inventive. In other words, students are unimaginative. Kohn believes grading systems reduce the quality of students thinking because grades reduce a student’s interest in learning. Their lack of motivation is caused by the fact that they view any work for school as a task or chore when a grade is attached. He confirms this reason with research done in the field of motivational psychology. The research found that “the more people are rewarded for doing something, the more they tend to loose interest in whatever they had to do to get the reward.” In a student’s case, the grade, particularly a high grade, is the reward. Thus, this lack of motivation effects a student’s ability to think deeply. Moreover, grades “encourage a fact- and skill-based approach to instruction.” This approach stifles creativity as facts are simply told as truths since they are concepts already explored or events that occurred. While it is important to learn facts, it is also vital to explore for oneself and think critically about past events. To simply remember, according to Kohn, is not enough.…

    • 1345 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    References: Atkinson, J. W. (1957) Motivational Determinants of Risk Taking Behavior. Psychological Review, Vol. 64, pp 359-372. Bressette, R. “Arguments for Plus/Minus Grading: A Case Study,” Educational Research Quarterly, 25(No.3, 2002), 29-41. Brumfield, C. (2005) Current Trends in Grades and Grading Practices in Higher Education, AACRAO, Washington, DC,120 pages. Burns, J., “The Problem of Change,” Industrial Management, March, 1966, p. 1. Brown Daily Herald, Staff Editorial, “An N/C for plus/minus,” (2006, March 15). Cullen, F. T. et al. “The Effects of the Use of Grades as an Incentive,” The Journal of Education Research, 68(No. 7, 1975), 277-9. Daily Atheneaum, Staff Editorial, “Plus-Minus system has Pros/Cons,” (2006, April 10). Dixon, Chip. “Plus/minus grading: If given a choice,” College Student Journal, 38 (June 2004), 280-5. Ekstrom, R., Villegas, A.M. “College Grades: An Exploratory Study of Policies and Practices,” College Entrance Examination Board, New York. (No. 94-1, 1994), 1-39. Goltz S. and A. Hietapelto, “ Using the Operant and Strategic Contingencies Models of Power to Understand Resistance to Change,” Journal of Organizational Behavior, Vol. 22(3), 2002, pp. 3-22. Levine, A. “To Deflate Grade Inflation: Simplify System,” Chronicle of Higher Education, 40(1994, Jan. 19), B3. Malone, B., Nelson, J. S., Nelson C. V. “A Study of the Effect of the Implementation of the Plus/Minus Grading System on Graduate Student Grades,” Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Midwestern Educational Research Association (Chicago, IL, October 25-28, 2000). McClure J., Spector L. “Plus/minus grading and motivation: an empirical study of student choice and performance,” Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education, Vol.…

    • 6727 Words
    • 27 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Grading Scale

    • 1829 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Some are attacked for grading too harshly because the school needs to maintain a certain amount of passing students. The teachers are told to change and doctor the grades so that the students will pass (Mehta, 2005)! Oftentimes students will storm their instructor 's office at the end of the quarter to ask for extra credit when lost scholarships and credits loom on the horizon (Slay Jr., 2005). Not only this, but many people argue that the grading system itself is unbalanced and they have taken steps to readjust it. Many would assert that grades are necessary for students to produce their best quality work, but I would argue that grades are the cause of unhealthy habits and excessive stress in…

    • 1829 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Grade Inflation Essay

    • 1078 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Grade inflation is when instructors award higher academic grades for assignments to students who did not earn the grade they received. Grade inflation is an issue in the United States because students are graduating with grade point averages that they did not earn. While research paints a negative picture of what happens to students who fall behind in school, influencing policies and decisions that lead to grade inflation, the work force is demanding more of students coming out of school entering into professional careers. With increased pressure for student output, there remains a conflicting approach to preparing students well while maintaining a teacher's personal and professional livelihood. Evaluating how…

    • 1078 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Getting Rid of Grades

    • 1562 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Grades have been noted as what could be keeping kids from doing well in school. Many claim that grades are necessary to motivate students, but what really happens is that the students become less interested in learning and doing the work. They feel that if they are being graded on a task, it feels like more of a chore and therefore they do not want to do it. But who can really blame them? Grades only tell how well one met the criteria for an assignment. As Alfie Kohn, an author of multiple education and parenting books, wrote in his essay “From Degrading to De-Grading,” “Students are brought up in a place where grades, not intellectual exploration, count.” As a well-known critic of the education system in America, he would most likely have no problem removing grades from schools.…

    • 1562 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    An issue, stated by Saltoun Ebin, is that teachers face is keeping enrollment numbers higher. Teachers may inflate grades in order to keep students coming to their classes because some students tend to take classes they feel is an easy pass. Their enrollment numbers determine their job security which is one other reason that instructors could inflate grades.Their job security ultimately decides their money and paychecks. Schuman states that it could be, that it is not something the teacher wants to do, but something that the students push them to do because students tend to complain and bombard teachers when they receive failing grades and this causes more stress for instructors. Zuckerman and Saltoun Ebin agree that it’s also the students that lead to this because they’re spoiled and can’t take the failing grade, but would fight with a teacher and cause them more stress until they let up and pass them. Students are so used to passing that they have been taught to be spoiled when it comes to grades, so some instructors find it easier to pass students because they depend on students for their classes and their job and their…

    • 1235 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Grade Inflation Gone Wild

    • 1465 Words
    • 6 Pages

    He is also the creator of gradeinflation.com, a website which collects grade data, such as GPAs, from multiple colleges and universities and analyzes the trends. In his essay, Rojstaczer claims that this grade inflation is a problem that needs resolving in order to restore the value of an A and to allow students to get the most out of their education. The root of this problem, according to Rojstaczer, lies in the expectations of the course and its instructor. He says, “When students walk into a classroom knowing they can go through the motions and get a B+ or better, that’s what they tend to do, give minimal effort” (Rojstaczer, 75). In other words, if students do not feel much is expected of them, they will not expect much of themselves. This, in turn, leads to the student just doing what is required and, as Rojstaczer puts it, “Instead of learning, they drink” (Rojstaczer, 75). The author advocates for an active method of combatting grade inflation. To illustrate how he believes it should be done, he refers to college that has already implemented it, Princeton. Princeton, in an effort to increase the value of its A’s, created a cap for the percent of student that can receive an A per class. Other universities have followed suit and have attempted to regulate the grades which are given out. Rojstaczer concludes with a…

    • 1465 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Grades have always been disputable and have caused controversies; whether they are fair or not; whether they represent students’ knowledge or not; whether there are other alternatives that can be used instead of them. However, I believe nobody has come up with better solutions than the five letters grade system. A major issue is that has appeared in recent years related to grades is the so –called grade inflation. It means an escalating boost of grades for effort that would have received lower grades in the past. Grade inflation happens for variety of reasons, and it leads to several negative consequences. Grade inflation has negative effects on people and society because it leads to problems, such as unprepared students ending up in difficult classes, students becoming overconfident and procrastinating, and most importantly. If the majority of college graduates are straight A students, there will be no standards for industries to recruit employees.…

    • 1381 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Schools try to maintain the students that are currently enrolled in their campuses. Educators, colleges and universities completely consider that by giving students higher grades it will improve and maintain the pleasant appearance of the classes and courses. Students sometimes view themselves as consumers of education and are keen to succeed rather than to learn. The pressures that institutions provide students towards success can be very persuasive at times.…

    • 252 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays