top-rated free essay

Alexander Ii Summary 2

By Oceane Nov 09, 2009 540 Words
For what reasons and with what results did Alexander II try to reform Russian institutions? The ascension of Alexander II coincided with Russia’s defeat at the hands of the British and French in the Crimean War. The defeat had exposed Russia’s weakness and backwardness in comparison with more advanced nations like Britain and France. This prompted Alexander to embark on a series of reforms to “modernize” Russia. This essay will identify the causes and consequences of this period of reform. Although the peasants were grateful for their freedom, essentially they resented the terms of the Emancipation statutes and there were some serious disturbances following their implementation. Liberals were disappointed by the changes and although the government was aware of this, it declined to take the reforms further fearing “noble resentment would turn into noble antagonism”.

However, despite its flaws, it has been argued that Emancipation was a moral improvement. M.S. Andersen claims that “the grant of individual freedom and minimum of civil rights to twenty million people previously in bondage was the single greatest liberating measure in the whole history of Europe”. Alexander II has thus also been known as the “Tsar Liberator” and indeed Emancipation was an enormous step forward and opened the door to modernization.

Further administrative reform was needed as a consequence to the emancipation of serfs. The abolition of the legal and judicial control of the gentry over their serfs required a new system of local government. Rural district and provisional assemblies known as the Zemstva were established. Their functions included the administration of primary education, public health, local industry and the maintenance of infrastructure. Alexander II understood that improving the living conditions of the peasants decreased the risk of widespread unrest. However he also saw these Zemstva as props for the autocracy and they were not truly democratic. The vote weighed more heavily in favour of local landlords making it easy for the conservative nobility to dominate these assemblies. However, many resented the growing popularity and control that lawyers were gaining. Conservatives regarded justice as “something dispensed by rulers rather than something administered by society for the benefit of society”. It was evident that by introducing Judicial Reform the government had undermined its power and had “cut a great deal of ground from under its own feet”. Despite this, even revolutionaries deprecated the new system either claiming that it was a new system of exploitation for the bourgeoisie or simply opposing it on the principle that its success would make revolution less likely. Nevertheless, Judicial Reform was undeniably a great innovation and one of Alexander’s most forward thinking reforms. One of the world’s better legal systems was created and for the first time Russians had the possibility of a fair trial. However, some historians argue that although the reform process began to slow down, the main reforms had already been implemented and established and Russia was far more stable now than it had been when Alexander came to power. In fact, he was set to embark on a new set of reforms in 1881 when he was assassinated. His assassination by a group of Social Revolutionaries unfortunately led to severe oppressive measures being imposed by his successor, Alexander III.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Alexander II and Alexander III

    ...The nineteenth century was filled with a variety of tsars. There are two that deserve a great amount of focus: Alexander II and Alexander III. Alexander II hoped to change and resolve Russia and their social and economic problems. His son, Alexander III, was more conservative and wished to undo everything his father did. Alexander II ascended...

    Read More
  • Alexander Ii & Alexander Iii

    ...Alexander II & Alexander III Alexander was the eldest son of Tsar Nicholas I and was born in Moscow in 1818. Alexander became Tsar of Russia in 1855 after his father's death. At that time Russia was in the Crimean War but then in 1856 russia signed the Treaty of Paris that put an end to the war. Alexander knew that his military power wasn't s...

    Read More
  • Tsar Alexander Ii

    ...Question: “His measures of reform did not disguise his belief in the need to maintain autocratic rule.” To what extent do you agree with this point of view? Tsar Alexander II had many reforms. He was an autocratic ruler who began his reforms in Russia in 1855. Some claim that his reforms were proof of his liberal attitude and others argu...

    Read More
  • Alexander II and the Emancipation of the Serfs

    ...For what reasons, and with what effects, did the Tsar Alexander II Emancipate the Serfs? “The existing condition of owning souls cannot remain unchanged. It is better to begin to destroy serfdom from above than to wait until that time when it begins to destroy itself from below” After the defeat in the Crimean war Alexander I...

    Read More
  • Alexander Ii: Liberator or Traditionalist?

    ...Alexander II: Liberator or Traditionalist? During the Tsarist reign of Alexander II (1855 – 1881), Alexander implemented a number of reforms that were destined to change the Russian social system. These reforms were the result of Russia’s humiliating military defeat in the Crimean war, as it awakened Alexander to the need for far reaching...

    Read More
  • comparing alexander II and alexander III

    ...Compare and contrast the social and economic policies of Alexander II (1855-81) and Alexander III (1881-94) of Russia. Alexander II and Alexander III were both Tsars of Russia and they both believed in the divine will to rule the people. However Alexander II is said to be more liberal than Alexander III though they were both conservative in...

    Read More
  • The Czars of Russia: Alexander II and Alexander III

    ...Contrast the domestic policies of Alexander II, and Alexander III Tsar Alexander II and his son Alexander III were two different minded leaders who both sought for the best of Russia by changing the ancient ways of Russian beliefs and modernising them to allow Russia to become a world power once again. The father and sons ways of thinking where...

    Read More
  • Alexander II vs Alexander III

    ...Compare and contrast the domestic policies of Alexander II and Alexander III Alexander II and his successor and son, Alexander III, inherited Russia in different states and degrees of turmoil. Due to these pressures, both were required to make alterations to the systems in place, such as that of politics and economics. However the natures of...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.