African American Reparations Negative2

Topics: African American Pages: 2 (1785 words) Published: August 12, 2015
African American Reparations Negative
We negate the resolution, Resolved: The United States Federal Government ought to pay reparations to African Americans Framework:
First, This debate revolves around the idea of race relations. At that point, the team that is best able to evaluate the root cause of racism should win the round. If we prove that reparations don’t solve for the underlying issues of racism, a negative ballot is in line. Second, the topic uses the phrase “pay reparations to African Americans”. At that point, the basis of the affirmative is to interact with the African Americans themselves. Contention 1

Subpoint A: The root cause of racism is the structures of economic inequality, which reparations can’t fix.   Nuruddin ‘1 (Yussuf, adjunct professor of African American Studies and social science at the New School University, “The Promises and Pitfalls of Reparations,” Socialism and Democracy. New York: Winter 2001. Vol. 16, Iss. 1; pg. 87, P. Proquest//DN)   Of course, human agency can only be effective at the ripe historical moment. Marcus Garvey, known for his visionary Pan Africanism rather than any materialist conception of history, once stated with Marxist clarity that "When all else fails to organize our people, conditions will." 4 The material conditions in Black America were ripe for a reparations movement. In the public discourse generated by this movement, some reactionary whites have argued that the movement by African Americans to obtain reparations for slavery would divide the American people. But the American people are already divided--by stark economic inequalities. These structural inequalities are the material conditions which have mobilized the African American populace in support of a reparations agenda. A study of households conducted in the mid-1980's showed that while income gaps between blacks and whites were closing, the median white American family owned eleven times as much wealth (real estate, investments, savings,...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Essay on African Americans
  • The Psychology in African American Essay
  • Essay on African American History
  • African American Perspective from 1959 Essay
  • Is Now the Time for Reparations for African Americans? Essay
  • Is Now the Time for Reparations for African Americans? Essay
  • Essay about African Americans in America
  • African American Literature Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free