Preview

Act II, Julius Caesar: Comparison of Relationship between Brutus and Portia and Caesar and Calpurnia

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2381 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Act II, Julius Caesar: Comparison of Relationship between Brutus and Portia and Caesar and Calpurnia
Act II: Development of Relationships between Husbands and Wives

Relationships between characters play a great part in Julius Caesar, the Shakespearean tragedy about the scheming of Caesar's death, which then are shown to affect all aspects of Roman life. Some relationships show the concealed discord between characters, some show the conniving spirit of those who desire power, while others show how some hearts are devoted entirely to the greater good of the republic. The dialogue between Brutus and Portia, along with that of Calphurnia and Caesar, plays a significant role in the development of the plot. Portia is a symbol of Brutus's private life, a representative of correct intuition and morality, just as Calphurnia is for Caesar, but they differ in several ways, including each wife's fears and concerns, each husband's response to the pleas of each wife, the final outcome of the exchange, and both couples' dramatic function in development of the play.

The fears and concerns of Portia and Brutus's reactions are shown once after the conspirators have left Brutus's house, where Portia becomes apprehensive to the point where she cannot hide her anxiety. Portia enters after the end of Brutus's soliloquy, approaching Brutus calmly. He, however, is a bit startled at the fact that his wife is awake at this time of night. Brutus shows his affection for Portia when he says, "Portia! What mean you? Wherefore rise you now? / It is not for your health thus to commit your weak condition to the raw cold morning"(2.1. 224-226). Telling Brutus how she senses something is bothering him, perhaps a secret he is keeping from her, and knowing that within, he is at war with himself, she explains that Brutus got out of bed for an unknown reason, and the other night had arisen during suppertime, with strange gesticulations and expressions. Reminding him, Portia says, "When I asked you what the matter was, /you stared upon me with ungentle looks. I urged you further; then you scratched

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    He goes so far as to say that “it must be by his [Caesar’s] death… he would be crowned… think him as a serpent’s egg (which, hatched, would as his kind grow mischievous) and kill him in the shell” (pages 41-42). In stark contrast to the harsh nature of planning of the murder, Brutus is portrayed as a close friend of Caesar’s, a loving husband to Portia, a wise military leader to his men, and a kind master to Lucius, his servant. However, due to his ancestor’s key role in establishing the Roman Republic and his own sense of justice, Brutus feels responsible to ensure the continued stability of the republic by any means – even if that details murdering Caesar. Antony calls Brutus’ stab the “unkindest cut of all” (page 101), showing how Caesar is betrayed by his most trusted friend. In the end, Brutus needs to weigh the republic’s existence against his friend, a man aspiring to be dictator. Choosing his city over Caesar, Brutus feels remorse for what he has done. Brutus’ guilt has so overrun him that it manifests itself into the “ghost of Caesar,” an ethereal being visible only to him, as the sole way for Brutus to acknowledge the dishonorable crime he has committed against his…

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    betrayal of Caesar, Brutus’ betrayal of his wife, Antony’s betrayal of the conspiracy, and the…

    • 873 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “The Tragedy of Julius Caesar” by Shakespeare, highlights the story of the popular figure of Rome namely Julius Caesar. It covers his return from the defeat against Pompeii till the time of his death. It also covers the fact that Caesar was betrayed and killed by his fellow comrades because he wanted all the power to himself. Of the comrades who committed the murder is his best friend, Brutus. Other comrades bought Brutus into this murder plot by sending him a letter pretending it was from the people, which the letter encouraged him to “Speak, Strike, and Redress”. However, another comrade named Marc Anthony did not buy into the plan, and the other comrades decides to kill him also. They plan to do so because they thought he stop them from…

    • 1109 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cady and Brutus

    • 525 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Brutus’s rigid idealism is both his greatest virtue and his most deadly flaw. In the world of the play, where self-serving ambition seems to dominate all other motivations, Brutus lives up to Antony’s elegiac description of him as “the noblest of Romans.” However, his commitment to principle repeatedly leads him to make mistakes that cost him much: wanting to curtail violence, he ignores Cassius’s suggestion that the conspirators kill Antony as well as Caesar. In another moment of rampant idealism, he again ignores Cassius’s advice and allows Antony to speak a funeral oration over Caesar’s body. As a result, Brutus forfeits the authority of having the last word on the murder and thus allows Antony to incite the shocked Roman crowd to riot against Brutus and the other conspirators. This is similar to when Regina George incites the entire school into chaos using the “burn book.” Brutus later endangers his good relationship with Cassius by self-righteously condemning what he sees as…

    • 525 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    12. What reasons does Portia give to insist that Brutus reveal his feelings to her?…

    • 361 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    In Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar, a play set in Ancient Rome, the characters Calphurnia and Decius are in opposition. Calphurnia hopes to prompt her husband,Caesar, to stay at home instead of going to the Senate because she fears that Caesar's life is in jeopardy. Decius, in this case Calpurnia’s adversary, wants to persuade Caesar that he should in fact go to the Senate where his doomed fate awaits him. Shakespeare uses many rhetorical devices in Calpurnia's conversation and Decius’ conversation with Caesar, each attempting to convince Caesar to take their side.…

    • 1412 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Oh, I’m in great sorrow that my wife, Portia, has committed suicide. It’s my entire fault. If I had told her what I was planning to do with Caesar there would have been a lower possibility that she would have killed herself. I showed her no trust and she had all rights to do so to herself; who would want a husband like me? A betrayer, a villain, a person who listened to a man who was only hungry for power.…

    • 702 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Portia feels as if she is Brutus’s “harlot” [prostitute] and not his wife. She believes that as a married couple they should not keep secrets from each other. “Within the bond of marriage, tell me, Brutus, Is it accepted I should know no secrets? That appertains to you? To keep with you at meals, comfort your bed, and talk to you sometimes?” (II.ii.275-276, 302-307). During the time of Julius Caesar women have an utterly different view compared to men in the society. They are just there to take care of their husbands, look after kids, clean the house, and do chores while the men are out fighting battles. Women are not taken seriously just because of their sex. Generally speaking, women are just powerless figures. Portia reasons Brutus should treat her with more respect and to treat her as a wife. Since Brutus does not tell her what is happening with his life she feels that he is solely excluding her from his life. Portia contemplates they…

    • 687 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    - The citizens have taken a day off to celebrate Caesar’s success & welcome Caesar to Rome…

    • 1820 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Brutus is an honorable man who keeps his word. At the same time, he places the good of Rome above all else. This, along with his sense of honor is what drives him to do all that he does. Out of all the conspirators who act out of selfish reasons, he is the only one who genuinely thinks that Caesar’s death is for the greater good.…

    • 532 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Marc Antony, Brutus, and Cassius are all critical characters in William Shakespeare’s famous play, The Tragedy of Julius Caesar. Due to their distinctive personalities and values, there is no trait that all of these characters share, although they do share some traits with one another. Firstly, Marc Antony and Cassius are manipulative in nature, while Brutus is not. Secondly, the root of Brutus and Cassius’ failure is their personality flaw, while Marc Antony proves strong in all the ways they prove weak. Lastly, Antony and Cassius, unlike Brutus, do not separate their private affairs from their public actions while acts only with honor and virtue and completely ignores his personal concerns.…

    • 642 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Brutus easily changes from a sympathetic protagonist to a back stabbing, narcissist. In the beginning of Julius Caesar, Brutus was loyal to both of his allies: Caesar and Cassius. However, he was always thinking about the citizens in Rome. Brutus had made a self agreement to not be on one of his friends’ side, and doing this expected that nothing intense would happen. Later, in Act II scene i, Brutus is alone in his garden and debates whether if he should help kill Caesar. He concluded with realizing he had to murder Caesar. After he made his decision, he talked to other conspirators to plan the assassination of Caesar. Brutus quickly transforms from a innocent bystander, into a blood hungry, rapacious, traitor from Cassius’ manipulation when they plan to kill Caesar however, before he was reluctant.…

    • 1016 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The realm of Caesar has come to an end and all that's left is chaos and his haunting ghost. Brutus begins to dwell on all that has happened, starting from the death of Caesar to the death of his own wife Portia. Each chaotic scene is an outcome of Brutus' decision to kill Caesar. Now that he is about to fore go his biggest challenge yet, facing Octavius and Antony. As a result, his upcoming battle has led him to see the Ghost of Caesar, which only appeared to him, to remind him of all the bad he's done. This appearance is a significant event that will foreshadow the fate of Brutus.…

    • 383 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Due to the complex nature of perspective, it is impossible to encapsulate the entire truth at once. Caesar perceives his role in public to be the “northern star” of Rome. Juxtaposed against this highhanded nature is the irony that Caesar has not fathered a child “Shake off their sterile curse,” showing a private frailty. Brutus emotively declares, “I love him well”, however his compassion is juxtaposed with the malicious metaphor “to put a sting in him” suggesting a wickedness in him. Both men however, are shown to have an overinflated sense of duty especially evidenced through the intra-conflict Brutus faces as “he is with himself at war” with the idea of murdering his long serving ally. Brutus reveals that individual’s perspectives of situations are manipulated by their own personal ideals through his justification “not that I loved Caesar less but that I loved Rome more”. Shakespeare manipulates the intrinsic virtue of duty into a vice that inspires arrogance in Caesar and malice in Brutus, clouding their judgement with personal bias.…

    • 900 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Julius Caesar is a play with many central ideas, but one in particular stands out to its readers. Shakespeare shows in Julius Caesar that following people blindly can end in conflict through the plot.…

    • 596 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays