Gandhi gets so upset at South Africa's Apartheid laws over just one incident in a train. It is true that this event really happened but it is unclear why Gandhi got so angry and started his campaign in South Africa.
A weak point of the GANDHI is its inability to elaborate on major episodes. It moves across five decades of time, all fitted into three hours of film. Attenborough only shows the responders the most important things before quickly shuffling to another scene.
Throughout the whole movie, all the characters speak in English. It is true that Gandhi did speak this language when he lived in South Africa; and few of the Congressmen (particularly Jinnah) felt at home with the English language; but the Mahatma switched to talking in Hindi (the common language of Indians at the time) to identify himself with the peasants.
It seems that Mohandas Gandhi held popularity right through his whole life, but this is not true. GANDHI presents the hero of the movie as a superhuman; but not everyone in India was with him. His popularity was at an all time low, especially after he failed to convince the Round Table conference in London that Indian was ready for independence. It is likely that the march against the salt company ever happened; or if it did it was not as spectacular as shown in the film.
The two notorious fasts undertaken in the movie by Gandhi brought results immediately. Within days, Gandhi got what he asked for. Attenborough even made Gandhi look like a martyr; putting his own life in danger in an attempt to stop violence. In reality however, Gandhi went through many more fasts (notably while in prison) and probably ended them before bringing total peace to save his own life.
GANDHI does not fully outline the Gandhian theory (reaching the truth). The only Gandhian theories presented in the movie are the principles on how to overthrow the English government in India (non-violent non-cooperation).
Gandhi, in the movie, shouts out, "Oh God!" when he is shot by Godse. In reality, he shouted out "Ram," the name of an Indian God. Attenborough made Kingsley cry out "God" because he wanted Gandhi to seem open to all religions.
Excepting these few minor (if it can be called this) errors, Attenborough has made sure his film is historically accurate as well as entertaining. He spent many years just preparing to shoot the video and spent much time researching India's modern history. It is futile to even try to find major mistakes in Attenborough's masterpiece GANDHI.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
The main character eventually helps the cause or people they didn't help before and it ultimately changes their perspective and way of life; although the definition of Gandhi's quote isn't exactly made obvious in the movie. In Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade, the main character Indiana Jones has to join his dad, his boss, and his foreign friend to keep the Holy Grail safe from the Nazis who plan to use it to change the outcome of World War II. Indy and his father never got along…
- 716 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Mohandas Gandhi’s methods not only led to India’s independence from Britain but also had victories over racial discrimination in South Africa. Gandhi saw, upon his return to India from South Africa, that Britain had run India’s people into poverty and subordination. Indians were not allowed to manufacture or own their own salt. This affected the poor population most because of how often they used salt. Gandhi began by writing to the English Governor in India describing his plan to “convert the British people through nonviolence and [to] make them see the wrong they have done to India” (Document 1). He felt that the “British rule [was] a curse”. Even though Gandhi spent a total of 2.338 days in prison, he “did not feel the slightest hesitation in entering the prisoner’s box” (Doc. 7). People followed Gandhi in his protests and many followed him into jail feeling “firm in [their] resolution of passing [their] terms in jail in perfect happiness and peace” (Doc. 7). While he was in jail, Mme. Naidu, an Indian poetess, filled in his position in leading protests. She encouraged the protesters by reiterating that “[they] must not use any violence… [they would] be beaten but [they] must not resist…not even raise a hand to ward off blows” (Doc. 4). The author felt that “the western mind finds it difficult to grasp the idea of nonresistance”, but…
- 797 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
To analyze his movie, I have to watch three or four times. The film Gandhi begins at the end, on the other hand, it shows Gandhi being shot by an assassin at public events. He was killed because of the spilt of Hindu and Muslims in Pakistan and India. Making it clear that when Gandhi died it was a national tragedy. The Film goes back and shows Gandhi as a young attorney in South Africa. He was riding on a train and although he possesses a first class ticket, he is ordered to go to last class sit because of his status. He refuses to give up his first class seat and he was thrown by the conductor. After having success in South Africa, he returned to India and he was greeted as a national hero. He tries to bring the same kind of change to the people there, but the British Authority tries to stop him and his followers form creating a more equal Society. British people that are in the government were the nicest dressed and it was all format outfit, Gandhi and his people were forced by British people and they were dominated because of the way they were their clothes. Gandhi and his followers make their own cloth in a very simple ways, and burn all cloths that were made or warren by British people. These are some accomplished that he did to become a national hero of…
- 933 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Mandela campaigned for volunteers to not retaliate even when they are being attacked (document 6). He convinced people fighting back would ultimately lead to their failure. King took part in counter sit-ins where black people peacefully protested segregated lunch counters (document 1). The peace of the movement showed how extreme and hateful the majority of white people were at the time. After Gandhi was arrested, one Englishman documented Mme. Naidu leading a peaceful protest that lead to hundreds of people getting beat without flinching a muscle (document 4). The cruelty was so great that even the Englishman had to turn away from the gross and sickening…
- 606 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Gandhi was the leader of the Indian Independence movement in British ruled India. He resisted the government by using non-violent disobedience. You must keep in mind that the system that he lived in(British ruled India) was very organized and it was very hard to resist the governments laws. He used one of the most effective methods of gathering the people and controlling them to his will. For example when the people made revolts against the British government Gandhi would starve himself to get them to listen because the people really cared about him. This method can only work if the people really care about you. At 5:17 PM on 30 January 1948 Gandhi was assassinated by Nathuram Godse in the garden of the Birla house. In 1930 Mahatma Gandhi challenged the British government by ignoring the salt tax with a 400 km Salt…
- 958 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
This begins in India, 1896. India's independence has just been taken by Britain. Britain is taxing India's salt. Gandhi returns from London to help India get back their independence. Which leaves us with the question: What made Gandhi's nonviolence movement work? Gandhi's nonviolence movement was successful because he had a clear action plan, perseverance, and he protested.…
- 242 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
On January 30, 1948, Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi was assassinated by Nathuram Godse. As Godse walks up to Gandhi, he shoots him three times in the chest from three feet away (Trumball 1). As “the strongest influence for peace in India that this generation has known,” Gandhi did not deserve to be assassinated despite the beliefs of Godse (Trumball 1). Gandhi’s main goal was always to gain independence for India; to do this he undertook 17 fasts (Smith 2). The assassination of Mahatma Gandhi was unjust because he was a nonviolent world leader and he helped promote peace between different religious groups within India; however, others may believe that he was to blame for the separation of India.…
- 493 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In returning to India 20 years later, Gandhi was a hero and led peaceful strikes and movements with the help of fellow Indians. For example, after World War I he believed that Britain would grant India their freedom but as it turns out they did not. He was not satisfied at this and held peaceful protests of civil disobedience; even when the British fought with violence, Gandhi insisted the Indians stay peaceful and not resort to violence. Although some riots did out burst, he called for all the protests to end. Years later India received its…
- 776 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Discussion Guide for Gandhi Video: (Complete all 17 of these questions to answer prior to class, please.)…
- 1753 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
He had demanded the release of the British rule over India. It was because of the discrepancies between India and the British that Gandhi decided to started the "Quit India Movement." It was through this that many people stood up to stop colonialism on India. Mahatma worked hard to enhance the status of the lower class people in society. He was a leader in trying for political independence(Hartman). His first campaign was called the satyagraha campaign. This campaign was built on the foundation of non-violent protest. The goal of this movement was to end a law requiring Indians living in Transvaal to get fingerprints. Their goal was met and Gandhi continued to push other protests and organizing resistances to his cause. After all of his works done in South Africa, he took what he had learned to India. There he continued to express his feeling toward the discrimination of his people. It wasn't too soon until his fight for Indian Independence had spread and people saw him as a hero(Mohandas). As you can see Gandhi worked as a very successful political leader doing anything in his power to do what was right. Gandhi, although claiming he was only an average man, had seemed to be more than that doing things people of little faith had doubted could be done. Gandhi makes these claims in his quote saying, "I claim to be no more than an average man with less than average abilities. I…
- 1080 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
P3: Mohandas mahatma Gandhi was born on 2 October 1869. He became a leader of India's independence movement, organizing boycotts against British institutions in peaceful forms of civil disobedience. He was given the holy name Mahatmas and oversaw a diverse ashram. He was killed by a fanatic in 1948. He was against disobedience and didn’t want anybody to tell him what to do he fasted for hours until they agreed…
- 650 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Gandhi was one of the first people to use nonviolence in a major way. A book tells how Gandhi went to jail instead of others because he did not fear a jail cell and proved he was nonviolent. When Gandhi organized a march officers beat the protesters and injured them severely, but they did not raise an arm to fight back. Gandhi sent a letter to Lord Irwin saying how british rule is a curse and he will stop at nothing to free his people from british rule. Gandhi initiated the first acts of nonviolence and won freedom for the people of India.…
- 539 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
the world has ever seen. Gandhi was known for organizing boycotts against the British institutions in India. One of the most famous was the Salt march which was a protest against Britain's Salt acts. Gandhi not only had a positive impact on India, but on the world. Ghandi’s peaceful protests inspired millions around the world, including Martin Luther King Jr…
- 524 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
there thoughts. In the movie I saw how Gandhi strongly opposed the violent riot and I thought that he could have handled it in a different way. Instead on…
- 436 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
There have been many individuals throughout history that have left an indelible impact on their people and the world, but few could rival the difference that Mohandas Gandhi made. Gandhi was born on October 2, 1869 in the British Common Wealth of India. He spent his youth witnessing the injustices that the English purveyed on the Indian people; something that eventually helped him to decide to become a barrister. Shortly after passing the bar, Gandhi was offered a case in South Africa that would require him to live in that country for about 1 year and he readily accepted. Once arriving in South Africa, he almost immediately experienced the prejudice that Indians living there had been enduring. The turning point for him came when he purchased a first class train ticket but was asked to move to the 3rd class coach, simply because he was Indian. When he quietly refused, he was physically thrown from the train. It was at that point that he decided to stay in South Africa to fight discrimination and what had been planned as a 1 year stay turned into 20 years. During that time he created, taught and practiced the concept of satyagraha, a non-violent way of protesting against injustices. (Rosenberg, n.d.) Gandhi believed that freedom could not be taken but must be given willingly and that this concept helped both the oppressor and the oppressed recognize the humanity in each other. The idea of satyagraha would be used by many great civil rights leaders as a way to advance their causes. Because of this, it remains Gahndhi’s greatest contribution to political change.…
- 1163 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays