Preview

Aboriginal Voice in Canadian Political Affairs

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2478 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Aboriginal Voice in Canadian Political Affairs
In today’s modern Canadian society every group is fighting for their rights to be heard, acknowledged and more importantly respected. In Canadian history one group has had to fight harder than anyone else to receive a voice to be heard and that is the Aboriginals. The question that needs to be asked is, do they really have a voice at all? Throughout this paper I will highlight three areas of aboriginal political uprising, First the history, secondly successful initiatives for the betterment of aboriginals and finally unsuccessful actions in the political landscape.

One of the earliest instances of Canadian aboriginals having a voice in politics was seen in July 1817. Five Saulteaux and Cree chiefs signed a treaty with Lord Selkirk to provide an area for settlement purposes. This area was to include “a strip of land two miles wide on each side of the Red and Assiniboine rivers”. This would mean that the treaty would start at city of Winnipeg and extend up the Red River to the city of Grand Forks North Dakota. Plots of land also “six miles in each direction from Fort Douglas, Fort Daer, and Grand Forks were also included”. In exchange for the land, each tribe was to receive annual payments of 100 lbs of tobacco. This land treaty was the first to be signed in western Canada. This would be the stepping stone for the Canadian government to seek treaties with the aboriginal people. The aboriginal political voice was also largely seen with treaty negotiations during the European colonization of the Canadian aboriginals. A series of eleven treaties were signed from 1871 to 1921, and it is a well known sentiment among Canadians that the signing of treaties was seen as an unfair process from an aboriginal standpoint and was destined to be advantageous to the Government of Canada. The purpose of the treaties was to secure land from the Aboriginals, the land was to be used for agricultural, industrial purposes as well as settlement for Europeans and non

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Born in 1948 in Fort Rae, Northwest Territories, Georges Erasmus grew up to be a major political figure and hero of the aboriginal peoples in his career. As a political activist and member of the Assembly of First Nations Erasmus carried forth a legacy of being a “Native rights Crusader” (CBC, 2014); but what does it mean to be a native rights crusader? Georges Erasmus made a lifelong contribution to the welfare of the Aboriginal peoples of Canada. As the president of the Dene nation, Erasmus pushed for self-government of the First Nations Peoples in Canada. During this time, Georges Erasmus rose through the political structure of the Assembly of First Nations.…

    • 532 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Attawaspiskat Cree and Ojibwa are a first nations group living in parts of Canada, mainly northern Ontario. The main languages spoken by these first nation groups are Mushkegowuk Cree and Ojibway. I will compare and contrast the experience of the Attawapiskat Cree to Ojibwa in relation to the Canadian Government. This will include analyzing the treaties introduced by the government towards the Cree and the Ojibwa: in particular, treaty 9 will be discussed. In addition, to these treaties the government has divided the first nation community into two different groups: status-Indians and non-status Indians. Within these two groups further division has been accomplished by the allocation of lands know as reserves to status-Indians and independent ownership for non-status Indians. This allocation of lands in reserves for status-Indians and independent ownership for non-status Indian is based on the policies developed through dependent and independent tenure. The laws permitting only status-Indians to live in reserves have fragmented the community and changes in culture and traditions have been rapid since the arrival of the government.…

    • 1782 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dara Culhane designates the thesis in her article Their Spirits Live within Us, to how Aboriginal women are seen as invisible to the public on the Downtown Eastside of Vancouver. Culhane then continues on to establish the basis of the annual Valentine’s Day Women’s Memorial March as a way for Aboriginal women to stand up for themselves and have a chance to be noticed and heard.…

    • 925 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The report outlines the extensive issues that existed prior to the modern land claim negotiations processes, and some of the more recent efforts that the federal government has made in order to regain the trust of Aboriginal communities. This report is authorized by the Canadian government, who holds a wealth of specific details regarding land claim negotiations. In this respect, this source is about as reliable as it gets. The report fully outlines the specific and comprehensive land claim negotiations processes. This source will be instrumental to my understanding of the dialogue that occurs between the government and Aboriginal groups in land claim negotiations. As well, when working on my policy paper, I can refer to some of the legal literature referenced in this report, such as for example, The Indian Act. This can help me to obtain a firm grasp on the ways in which First Nations people have been marginalized in the past, and possible ways that the government can achieve reconciliation with…

    • 1553 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This story is important because it situates Indigenous people within the historic and contemporary nation building processes of Canada and connects their original claim to the land with the the colonial injustices of Europeans. In depicting Europeans as a settler population within Canada, Indigenous people are able to redefine their identity as intrinsically linked to their original land rights. This identification conflicts with the Eurocentric portrayal of Indigeneity, which treats Indigenous Canadians as Other. In addition, this self-segregation by Indigenous populations “…implies a high degree of solidarity among group members” (Rosenberg, 24). This is crucial in creating political unity and achieving collective political aspirations.…

    • 620 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The aboriginal population are one of the most violently oppressed groups in Canada’s History. Some say to advance as a society and reach an equal ground we have to move on looking to a bright future, but some would say to move on we need to address the issues caused by the past that still shadow aboriginal communities today. I firmly believe that to solve the problem, we must fully realise it. I am inclined to believe that this is the land God gave to Cain. “ - Jacques Cartier. This quote from famed Canadian explorer Jacques Cartier explains his thoughts on the land found by him and his crew. It started in 1534, Jacques Cartier a french explorer took one small step for man and pushed the Canadian indigenous 50 steps back. Exploring the St. Lawrence river, Cartier set base. One year later he would find what is now Montreal, welcomed with open arms by the Iroquois people who were already settled there. Cartier and his men would soon continue to search north America for gold and diamonds. Cartier set a standard for Canadian exploration and would be followed by many others. History paints Cartier as a hero, despite the accounts of murder, rape and other crimes committed by him and his crew members. Looking back to the quote, an underlying entitlement based on faith and status must be acknowledged in able to see why the problems are still…

    • 1138 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Secondly, Larissa Behrendt, is another Aboriginal activist who acknowledges that the ‘dissent’ amongst Indigenous people is largely because there is still uncertainty in the community regarding the referendum. This also makes Maddison’s assumption that the recognise campaign is a hindrance to constitutional change clear. Running the campaign before a reform to the constitution was proposed meant that Indigenous and Torres Strait Islander people could not communicate with the government properly and have no participation in debates. Similarly, the article…

    • 800 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Political Scientists, Thomas Flanagan and Roger Townshend explain the key to the big question: “Can a Native State Exist Within a Canadian State?” in the readings: “The Case for Native Sovereignty” and “Native Sovereignty: Does Anyone Really Want an Aboriginal Archipelago?”. The essay will outline and provide evidence to both sides, whether there could or could not exist a Native State in Canada. The document will argue that Natives are not organized enough to form their own government. Throughout the decades, Natives have agonized many savageries at the hands of the European settlers. The essay will take Flanagan’s side with the belief that Natives should not be sovereign, using the textbooks “Principles of Comparative Politics”, and “Contemporary Political Issues”. According to Weber’s definition of the state, the state is “a human community that successfully claims the monopoly of the legitimate use of physical force within a given territory,” (Clark, Golder, & Golder, pp. 92).…

    • 1217 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Australia’s attitude towards the rights and freedoms of Aboriginals has changed drastically from 1920 to the present. It is evident that Australia has made a greater effort throughout the years, to bridge the gap between the rights and of Aboriginals and the rest of Australia. This has been improved by the implementation of different policies such as the Protection policy, Assimilation, Integration, Self Determination and Reconciliation.…

    • 770 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Social Determinants of Health

    • 10946 Words
    • 44 Pages

    Augoustinos, M., Tuffin, K., & Rapley, M. (1999). Genocide or a failure to gel? Racism, history…

    • 10946 Words
    • 44 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Firstly, Aboriginals have not been honoured with the recognition that they rightfully deserve. For example, Aboriginals have not been treated as competent equals when negotiating land ownership treaties. In one instance “James Douglas… negotiated agreements… extinguishing Aboriginal title to the lands around Victoria, Nanaimo and Fort Rupert between 1850 and 1854… the entire Victoria area was obtained for 371 blankets” (Yellowhorn). The English took advantage of the language barrier between the two negotiating parties as well as the trust that the First Nations put into the political weight of the agreement and in doing so managed to perpetually hand Aboriginals the short end of the stick. Furthermore, First Peoples have been robbed of recognition regarding their contribution towards Canada’s history as a nation. Canada’s identity is built upon “the idea of two founding nations (English and French), and government support for (their) two (native) languages” (Yellowhorn). The failure to integrate the native languages of Aboriginals into Canadian knowledge at least at a basic level illustrates the divide of recognition in Canada. The country has neglected to acknowledge the prominent role of First Nations in their history and heritage. Therefore, Aboriginals have not been given the respect…

    • 830 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Royal Proclamation of 1763, and the Constitution Act, 1982 that reaffirmed the existing rights of Aboriginals, both establish that it is legitimate for Aboriginal self-government to be located at the national level. A nation-to-nation relationship shows the greatest respect for the sovereignty of the Aboriginal peoples and therefore have the greatest legitimacy. However, it would impossible for Aboriginal groups to make a direct transition from federal jurisdiction to full sovereignty, as they often lack the efficient capacity to self-govern, and there is no clear consensus among the rest of Canadians, about the form that self-government should take.…

    • 1638 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    During this time, the relationship of indigenous and French people was informal. There was no evidence regarding how the French were going to use the native land or the resources that they found there. In 1756 the New France and British were at war. The British won. As part of their peace treaty new France was transferred to British. They named it Quebec. When British took over they made a more formal relationship with the indigenous people with regards to the use of their land. In 1763 they signed the first treaty with the indigenous and it was known as royal proclamation of 1763. There are numerous of treaties created by the British government; however these treaties can be misinterpreted. The British and Canadian government had a misinterpretation of the treaty. The British thought that the native lands would be transferred over to them while the indigenous government did not believe in the concept of land ownership, for the treaties were an agreement to share their land to the British government. Another political impact was the 1969 white paper. The white paper is a law or act of parliament takes years to develop. Plenty of people in government must work for many years to get all their ideas together. During this time of information gathering a document of ideas emerges. The idea of white paper came from the Liberal Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau. He believes in a just society and democracy, where all of Canada’s citizens could participate equally. The aim or goal of the white paper was “to enable the aboriginal people to be free to develop Indian culture in an environment of legal, social and economic equality with other Canadians.” Although the indigenous saw this to assimilate them and that if this happens they will lose their right for the land. Harold Cardinal was a native leader that wrote the book unjust society to contradict Pierre Trudeau’s white paper. Another political impact is the Indian act. When…

    • 2296 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    A close ratiocination of the instances where there have been claims for self determination one can sufficiently claim that the right to self determination and the right of a state to its sovereignty are always at logger heads. When these two rights are pitted against each other, the quest here is for the determination of which rights supersedes the other in such scenarios. It can be referred to as a difficult balancing act. In today’s multi ethnic states there clearly have to be a balance, an acceptable equilibrium between a states sovereign power and the rights of minorities which international law has been extremely succinct about which affirms the commitment of international actors and policy makers to human dignity.…

    • 1735 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    There is an affective colonialism on aboriginal women in Canada. The histories of colonization have forced aboriginal women out of their community and family support. The violence of cultural assault or physical brutality of residential schools. It is essential to make efforts towards ending of violence against aboriginal women in Canada. The aboriginal people have grown up in poverty. Many aboriginal women run in to racism and they may shut out of labor markets. Aboriginal women turn to drug trade and sex work to survive. Aboriginal woman in vulnerable positions that over expose them to violence. The residential school experience began with aboriginal children being forcefully removed formed their homes. Often in these schools…

    • 790 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics