Top-Rated Free Essay

2007DBQ Han And Roman Attitudes Toward Technology

Good Essays
2007DBQ: Han and Roman Attitudes Toward Technology

Throughout the history Han Dynasty of China and the Roman Empire were the two enormous political unities, both developing their technology well. Han was generally positive and supportive toward the technology using though Roman thought that each job has its own social dignity, therefore leading to the inferior attribute to the craftsmen and technology involver.

Han was praiseful towards its achievements and progression of the technology, while few Roman high officials depicted that the utilizing technology is favorable. In the group of Doc#3, 4, 6, all writers hold positive opinions toward the technology in their countries and regarded the achievements were praise-worthy. Doc #3 hold a positive proposal toward Fuxi, the wise emperor because the author thought that Fuxi’s invention helped the water power to apply, and increase the water using efficiency. In Doc#4, the author claimed that the Tu Shih, the peaceful governor of the province, invented the very useful machine, water-powered blowing-engine, decreasing the labors’ efforts and benefit farmers. Through these two documents we can see that Han’s general idea toward technology is to help people as much as possible, Confucian benevolence and Han perceived technology as a gift. In Doc#6, Plutarch thought that Roman road is a pragmatic application of the technology, using a big amount of words to describe the aesthetic values of the road and the utility. The evidence glorifies the technology usage during that period.

Although Han insisted the praiseful perspective, there were still some imperfect aspects of the technology while Roman regarded the tool manufacturing is a vulgar profession of the career, both are the negative point toward the technology. In the Doc #2, Huan Guan compared the tools of previous times and those of current time, stating that the worse the tools are, the less government officials took care of the, which caused the social problem such as the price of iron was considerately high and people even couldn’t afford it. He wrote the problem relating to the tools producing, in order to reflect the problem of the society to impart the emperor that the governors did not carry on their responsibility because he thought that the duty of the government was to benefit people. Doc#5 states that the craftsmen who work with their hands are vulgar commoners and gentlemen do not work with hands. Similarly, Seneca of Doc#7 illustrate the same idea, the smart people do not work with their hands and technology is less important for him. Obviously, Doc#5 and #7 both emphasize the difference of the crafting work and mind work, stating the social dignity of the occupation that gentlemen use their minds and commoners use hands.

The high officials involve in most the documents, reflecting that whether the technology using is good or not. Doc #1, 2, 6, and 8 are all upper-class written. However, they stated in different ways. Doc #1 and 2, from Han’s officials, stated the importance of need of great technology, showing that technology is essential to the Han Empire. Doc #6 and 8 are written by Roman officials, stating that the great accomplishments -roads and aqueducts- made by the Rome, emphasizing the pragmatic and aesthetic values of the Roman technology.

Although these resources give us a generally comprehensive idea of the attitudes of the Roman and Han toward technology, an additional document from a woman is needed because all the documents are from high officials, governors or philosophers, who were all men, which made the evidence limited. We need to hear more from the other type of human beings, women, who have a comparatively low status than men, but may have a different opinion toward the technology using. Thus a document from woman will be beneficial to the thorough view.

These documents in general not only say that the differing viewpoints of the technology, but also the bias of social classification, the differing attitudes toward certain types of jobs. In Han’s society, it is not really matter whether you are a peasant but in Roman, people will have a cold eye toward you if you are a inferior artisan.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Han Dynasty

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The Han Dynasty attitude towards technology is positive and negative feelings towards society even though Rome expressed the same feelings. These 8 documents can help prove and provide evidence for my thesis. In (doc 1) and (doc 4) explain how the Han Dynasty used water for positive things. In (doc 2) and (doc 3) explain the negative perceptions, which are how tools of the first century B.C.E were good enough to use but were neutrally valued, but overtime the quality of the item decreased.…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Hans and the Romans Dbq

    • 554 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The Hans and the Romans both had very fascinating views on their technology. While The Han’s attitude toward technology was viewed as a positive contribution to their society the Romans had positive views other Romans had negative attitudes. Every document has its own opinions on the way they appreciate technology some support which is making then look good, while some think it’s for low class people and not for government. In order to fully analyze Han and Roman attitudes toward technology it would have been helpful to have an additional document of an interview with a Roman laborer because all of the other documents were from higher class Romans who did not work with tools and such technology.…

    • 554 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Han and Roman empires have their fair share of technological advancements, how each civilization reacts to them is different however. Since the beginning of time we as humans have always needed to advance but not every human being believed so. In the Han and Roman empires, as in many others, the attitudes towards these kinds of advancements were mostly positive but there were some negative outlooks.…

    • 855 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    ap world history 2007 dbq

    • 893 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Further developing technology during the First Millennium led to innovations that would establish the foundation of a basic infrastructure. In the Han, intricate waterways were created to aid the transportation of goods and basic water regulation for society. In (Doc 1), these basic structures were heavily maintained, and offices in charge of each district were recommended to maintain experienced staff with the ways of water. Technology is a constantly evolving force that would increase efficiency of products on a grand scale. In (Doc 4), the water-powered engine is described as being a great benefit to society. The water-powered engine created by Tu Shih improved the ability to create cast iron, which would be used for agriculture. Iron tools and machinery increased the benefits of…

    • 893 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In addition, we don’t have just negative results of people’s obsession with technology. There are some good effects that are important too, like to have a comfortable life, to communicate, to have a better organized life, to change life constantly, to have a better access to learning, and better production in factories. It’s good to add that it helps in having a better equipment in hospitals.…

    • 448 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    ANCIENT CHINESE INVENTIONS

    • 1610 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The Chinese invented many useful inventions such as Gunpowder, hang gliders, and the compass. Today these inventions are used daily in our everyday lives. Currently gunpowder is used in fireworks and deadly weapons such as guns. The compass is used when people are outdoors, hiking, or camping. Hang glider is used for recreation. People get on top of a high ledge and jump off to get acceleration. Now these ancient inventions are used every day and are very imporeswhrnwjfuaherfjkdsnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnejhjkhfjk jehfjksfjkehf hejkalfujkweifkjehfkewiuhfjkshfkuewhfkjshfukewhfjkshfkj hwjfksujhf whflkjsfhd wehfsjklfh weuifhjhjf hj fhfuweh fklje fhwejfke fhkjlsdhf kjef jskehfwefjh eiughkjghdkjhgjkdshgjkrehgj rjghdk gjhegkjdergergh grhjghk hjhjhjhfgtu rhjhfuduur ghj rugjfdn .hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh-…

    • 1610 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Han Dynasty Legacy

    • 672 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Today, we will be speaking about the legacy of the Qin Dynasty first. Qin Shihuangdi, the king of Qin born a peasant; proclaimed himself the first emperor and what would rule for thousands of generations. Unfortunately, the Qin had a relatively short dynastic cycle, the cycle that every dynasty goes through where it comes to power, rules and the falls apart. The Qin dynasty established a sense of centralized Imperial rule that later set the the foundation for later Emperors to Emulate. Even in that short period of time, they are going to have more of a lasting and have a profound impact on Chinese culture. Legalism, the belief that individuals are born evil, therefore the only way to get them to corporate is to have laws that are so strict…

    • 672 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    From the 2nd century BCE through the 1st century CE, both the Han and Roman empires were dealing with the advancements in technology that come from being a sedentary civilization. There were many different attitudes between the two empires, but there were also differences in opinion within the empires themselves. In the Han Empire, some believed that technology was an essential part of an empire and requires government intervention, while others thought it was simply a gift that comes from enlightened leadership. In the Roman Empire, some believed that technology was necessary, but not necessarily enlightened, while others saw it as a way to show how great their civilization really was.…

    • 1116 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Technology actually serves to harm humans rather than help them. A competition between two cities or companies usually makes lives for humans even worse. Take for example when a city builds roads to attract tourists. This creates more traffic, not less.…

    • 508 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Since their creation, humans have always had a natural inclination for invention, For instance, utilising stones, they created tools and weapons to increase their efficiency and survival chances. However, humans could have still survived without their inventions such as the wheel and the engine, albeit with a lower quality of life. In, “The Flying Machine,” by Ray Bradbury, new inventions are condemned because they could potentially be used in violence or crime. Emperor Yuan believes that if a civilization functions adequately, new inventions risk the safety of its people unnecessarily.…

    • 809 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Between 1000BCE and 600CE the technological achievements of the Han and Roman Empires greatly excelled creating an outlook of the concepts we have today. Han China as well as Rome both had great construction, where new roads were being built and advanced in the production of newly arrived iron used for tools and weaponry; however, while Han China used iron to open more land clearing the forest as well as to conquer new territories, Rome used their less impressively made iron tools and weapons to expand the empire. Also, although both empires successfully built roads, Rome’s focus leaned toward luxury while the Hans did not take their surroundings for granted therefore building what was simply needed.…

    • 391 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Han and Roman attitudes towards technology in the late BCE and early CE pointed towards two main categories, positive and negative.…

    • 533 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Hans and Romans understood the importance of technology, but unlike the Hans, the Romans viewed anyone who worked with tools or with their hands to be a person of lowly status. The Romans only showed appreciation for technologies that could hold some benefit for the upper-class. The upper-class Romans thought that craftsmen, people who made a living out of making tools, was hardly an occupation that deserved any respect. The Hans appreciated the use of tools in their labor and how it could help the people. The Hans showed a great appreciation of their technological advancements, and its effect on society.…

    • 1073 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Han and the Romans were ahead of the game when it came to technology. However, they both had very different attitudes towards the subject. The Han were determined to get ahead and they were supportive of others who made advances within the empire, whereas the Romans, although determined to get ahead, were arrogant and judgmental of each other’s work.…

    • 449 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Han Empire had a very positive outlook on the advancement of technology such as irrigation systems while the Roman Empire seemed to have a lot of opposition regarding the advancement of technology. The Roman elites viewed technology as tools for the weak. Both Empires acknowledged the change in technology in some way or another.…

    • 378 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays