12 Angry Men Critical Analysis - Differences and Similarities between the book and the movie

Topics: Difference, Not proven, Anger Pages: 3 (1036 words) Published: March 25, 2009
In Twelve Angry Men, a boy is convicted of the murder of his father and 12 jurors are chosen to decide his fate. In the beginning, all of the evidence points to him being guilty. However, after a little bit of analysis of the evidence, there is some reasonable doubt. Slowly all of the Jurors accept the boy as innocent except for one very stubborn juror: Juror 3. The differences and similarities between the stage directions and the directors shot selection in the film and in the text affect the readers interpretation of the final scene where Juror 3 says not guilty greatly.

There are many similarities between the two versions. One similarity is how the jurors reacted to Juror 3s resistance to the chance of the boy being innocent. In both the play and the film, the jurors simply stare at Juror 3 out of amazement of his ignorance to the facts. When Juror 8 asks him why he still isnt convinced, Juror 3 says that its his right. He also says that he is entitled to his opinion. This similarity helps add to the question to why Juror 3 is so bent on getting the boy convicted. Another similarity is that Juror 8 seems confident that Juror 3 will pull through his mindset of the boy being guilty. In the play, the playwright says that Juror 8 asks Juror 3 of his arguments calmly and quietly. Juror 8 does the same in the film. Juror 8s calmness and quietness seems to show that he is confident about the verdict and that he can convince Juror 3 that the boy is innocent. The final similarity being discussed will be about how Juror 3s tone of voice affected the readers inference of his character. In the play the playwrights directions for Juror 3 are mostly loudly or shouting. The same is in the movie. Juror 3 is constantly yelling and shouting, trying to make a point. From this the reader can infer that Juror 3 gets angered quickly and is stubborn at times. He also thinks his opinion is more important than the others because he only stressed his opinion and not the others. This...

Bibliography: 12 Angry Men by Reginald Rose
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • 12 Angry Men: Analysis of the Movie Essay
  • 12 Angry Men Movie Analysis Essay
  • 12 Angry Men Analysis Essay
  • 12 Angry Men Analysis Essay
  • Essay on 12 Angry Men: Analysis
  • 12 Angry Men Analysis Research Paper
  • 12 angry men movie to book analyisis. Research Paper
  • 12 Angry Men: Classic Movie Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free