Preview

‘What Writers Tend to Demonstrate in Texts Which Explore Relationships Between Men and Women, Is That Women Have Always Been Relatively Powerless and the Victims of Society’s Double Standards’ Compare and Contrast the

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
3734 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
‘What Writers Tend to Demonstrate in Texts Which Explore Relationships Between Men and Women, Is That Women Have Always Been Relatively Powerless and the Victims of Society’s Double Standards’ Compare and Contrast the
‘What writers tend to demonstrate in texts which explore relationships between men and women, is that women have always been relatively powerless and the victims of society’s double standards’ Compare and contrast the extent to which this interpretation applies to your chosen three texts.

Throughout Literature the role and position of women has been constantly one of debate and controversy. For centuries women have struggled to exert any power or individual identity through times of male dominance. The novel The Great Gatsby as well as the play A Streetcar Named Desire and lastly the poetry of Anne Sexton, were all written during the 20th Century in America. Throughout the 20th Century, attitudes towards women in the USA were changing, the war had given an opportunity for women to realize and prove that they could look after the household without men. This called for much debate about the rights and roles of women which carried on throughout the 20th Century and inspired many of the characters and themes within Literature. In all three texts interactions between men and women are explored and represented in different ways. Each painting pictures of women whose compliance and submissiveness have resulted in their portrayal of being male dominated victims of society’s double standards.

Central to the victimization of women in all three texts is their objectification by men. In The Great Gatsby, Tom refers to Myrtle as ‘My girl’; the possessive pronoun indicates that Tom feels an ownership over her. It is prominent that Myrtle is Tom’s mistress; therefore despite not being married to her, he feels he has the right to own her. This could be an example of Tom being ‘moralistic without being moral’ as Ronald Berman puts it, by the way that Tom feels this is a right that he has despite not being Myrtle’s husband, due to the fact that he is a man in society with more power than a women. Name calling can also be seen within A Streetcar Named Desire, when Stanley

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Tom’s physical abuse of his mistress, Myrtle, reveals his need for dominance over women. When Myrtle mentions Daisy’s name, Tom’s extreme anger causes him to break “her nose with his open hand.” (37) Tom’s need to exert physical control over Myrtle emphasizes his sexist need for control. His infuriation over her mentions of Daisy illustrate his inability to see Myrtle beyond an object for his sexual gratification. Furthermore, his immediate invalidation of his mistress’s accusations of infidelity portray his ignorance of female opinions, again exemplifying his need for dominance over the women in his life. Moreover, Tom’s disregard for Daisy and their family by having an affair further emphasizes his lack of respect for women. Additionally, Gatsby’s obsession with Daisy’s wealth displays his glorification of money and reveals his view of Daisy as a tool to break out of the confines of poverty. While describing Daisy as a “nice girl,” Gatsby focuses on her “rich house” and “rich, full life.” (149) His fixation on her material wealth reveals his identification of her as a means to achieve his desired success. This objectification of Daisy further highlights the overall dehumanization of women. Tom’s marginalization of Myrtle and Gatsby’s advantageous use of Daisy illustrate the ultimately negative and condescending attitude toward women throughout society, particularly in the wealthiest…

    • 758 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Throughout different time periods in history, perspectives change. With changing perspectives, artists and authors convey their feelings for particular social issues in varying ways through their texts. As the prescribed text, “The Great Gatsby” by F. Scott Fitzgerald and the prescribed sonnets from “Sonnets from the Portuguese” by Elizabeth Barrett Browning show, we can see the changes in perspective from the Victorian Era, compared to that of the Post-WWI period, the roaring 20’s. A comparison of these texts lets us see a change in society’s view on love, the role of women in marriage, relationships, goals and ambitions (hope) and life’s meaning (morality) and also the impact of gender differences on the perspectives conveyed.…

    • 1407 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout history, woman have played many roles in society, in the home, and in literature. They have been relied on as caretakers, home keepers, and in some eras, domestic servants. In literature, female characters are developed with similar traits attributed to the roles previously listed. I will describe the contrast in the literary version of the ideal Victorian woman and the feminist, researched modern woman…

    • 767 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    On first looking into the novel ‘The Great Gatsby’, anyone who read it shallowly enough would find it near impossible to be able to sympathise with any female character in the book. Fitzgerald’s use of Nick as a narrator could arguably be the main view of negativity upon the women, as his narration warps the reader’s perspective on the characters through his male viewpoint. Also, Fitzgerald’s presentation of women is of very little positivity in general. Fitzgerald appears to have gathered the class types of women in the 1920’s era and conjured a stereotype for each of them. Daisy Buchanan being the typically beautiful, wealthily married woman of whom has men falling at her feet, Myrtle Wilson being the working class, vulgar woman who dreams of more than what she’s worth and Jordan Baker who is portrayed as the strongest female character who works for herself independently and stands on her own feet. These are the only female characters throughout the novel that are presented in any large detail. In comparison to the male characters, these women have been written in a way almost to highlight the positivity of portrayal within the male characters in the novel.…

    • 1541 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    “I’m glad it’s a girl. And I hope she’ll be a fool – that’s the best thing a girl can be in this world, a beautiful little fool.” This is from when Daisy and Nick are having a redundant conversation. It demonstrates one of the key elements of the novel: a classic inferior role for women in the Roaring Twenties. Daisy’s quote suggests an awareness of some superb emerging obstacle, and a following impression of submission. Daisy feels individually persecuted by the world she lives in; there is damaged aspiration inside her, resulting from some type of failure. It also proposes that Daisy is very conscious of her own feminism, and the place that femininity holds in the particular historical situation. Daisy seems to have unenthusiastically allowed herself to have the lifestyle she has been given, yet there is a slight longing gleam of hope in her heart. Although she appears shallow at times, the hidden intelligence of her character should not be forgotten. In many ways, this quotation…

    • 540 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Compare how the writers present the subjugation of women in accordance to Victorian social value in the three texts.…

    • 4370 Words
    • 18 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Scott Fitzgerald’s novel was set in the 1920’s, where the role women had was moving on to make a drastic change, The Great Gatsby portrays the change in female roles through the two main female characters Daisy and Jordan. Both characters show the different characterises that many of the woman growing up in the 1920’s held, as Daisy is presented as domesticated and somewhat immobile while in contrast Jordan was shown as more independent and emancipated. Life in the 1920s was important for women, as their image was changing massively as they began to challenge society and government to be free of stereotype and gain independence and respect; however this upset the men as they felt they were losing dominance over women. Typical relationships in the 1920’s were similar to the one Daisy and Tom hold in the novel. Daisy is unhappy and immobile as she doesn’t get a voice in her relationship and is completely dependent on her husband, women were dominated and controlled and often fairly unhappy. Women were seen as objects that were to be domesticated and constantly under control of their husband; because of how poorly they were treated it was around this time that women wanted change, to make a stand to gain power over men. On August 18th 1920 the 19th Amendment gave women the right to vote, this meant women got the chance to speak out in government, following to the American nation’s first female governor, Nellie Tayloe Ross who was elected in 1922. Women getting the right to vote gave them a step to emerging from ‘out of the shadows’ of a previously male dominated society, helping them break free from the reign males had over their lives. The context behind the novel makes the women important as they are portraying the freedom and independence of American women in the 1920’s.…

    • 2610 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Gender Roles and Marriage

    • 1314 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Gender roles and marriages can play an important role in literature. It can be one of the most influential ways that gender roles are constructed. Works of literature construct images of boys and girls and men and women. These works usually depict the girls and women doing housework, playing with dolls, and cooking. The men are usually depicted as sports players and lovers, providers, and figures that are overall stronger than women. Guy de Maupassant’s, “The Necklace” and James Thurber’s, “The Secret Life of Walter Mitty” are two works of literature that focus on the themes gender roles and marriage, with some similarities, but with even more differences.…

    • 1314 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Best Essays

    Men and women are both stereotyped to behave a certain way that fits into roles that society has created for them. Men are seen as being the forefront of the family, while the women are behind the scenes and inside the household taking care of petty things. Men are always portrayed as being mentally and physically tough and mighty with the ability to forge a life outside of the household, while women are depicted as weak fragile beings that belong only in the safe interior of their household. It is thought that only a woman can be excessively emotional and tender and that qualities like such interfere with having the ability to be self reliant and powerful. Men are thought to naturally be self reliant and powerful in both a physical and mental sense. While these stereotypes might seem believable and applicable, in texts such as, The Odyssey by Homer and The Canterbury Tales by Geoffrey Chaucer, women’s role are more than meets the eye. Even though the women in the texts play the common roles of wives and mothers, there is a much deeper meaning and purpose to their function as women in the story. The women might not seem like the obvious heroes, for we have been lead to believe that a damsel in distress must always be saved by a grandiose macho man. In these texts, it is the women whom hold the power over the men even though they fall under the stereotypical labels of being a housewife and mother. Their shabby insignificant roles might seem unlikely of authority or power at first, but with analysis, it is clear that women don’t blatantly display a lust for command, yet they manage to craftily take the control away from the men.…

    • 3258 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Judith Fetterley reminds us of sexism in American fiction such as Rip Van Winkle and The Birthmark that seems to have portrayed the women characters powerless, and powerlessness was attributed to being female. We also see a struggle of power and ownership of women as a symbol of power in American Literature such as The Great Gatsby where possession of Daisy was important to both male characters. Fetterley states, “This demonstration, however, is not simply the result of a greater safety in directing anger at women than at men… It derives as well from the fact that even the poorest male gains something from a system in which all women are at some level his subjects,” suggesting that even “the most ‘powerless’ male” still has power. This perspective that American Fiction writes in, in turn, romanticizes the “tragic elements in women’s powerlessness” (xvi-xvii).…

    • 311 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    ¨ The best thing a girl can be in this world, [is] a beautiful little fool” (Fitzgerald 21), expressed by the empowering Daisy Buchanan, introduces readers to the unjust story where women are not portrayed at the same level as men. Gender inequality played a factor during the Jazz Age, where women were viewed as being incapable of having intelligence and strength. The Great Gatsby, a novel authored by F.Scott Fitzgerald takes place during the time of the Jazz Age, Fitzgerald does not fail to do an incredible job at using female authority as an important role towards the end of this thrilling story. As tragic deaths come to play and plot twists are unraveled, the source of all the drama found in this novel are the main female characters. While…

    • 162 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Feminist reproach within The Great Gatsby was playing an important role to reveal some critical problems in the society. the Feminist theory usually focuses on the women’s matters, and the serious role it plays in the society. The theory has a strong influence on the literature as well. The novelist idea was clear that the dominant man's view raises the problem of inequality although both men and women should be treated similarly and experienced equality in human rights and opportunities.…

    • 80 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout the history of our country the women have always been underestimated never being allowed to be shown their full potential. From being denied education from not being allowed to vote, women have always had more of a struggle than men. Society has progressed, women are educated, and voting if they want to. There are still problems women face on a daily basis, such as unequal pay among the issues. The plays Death of a Salesman by Arthur Miller, and Fences by August Wilson, the two playwrights investigate the role women had in 1950s America. The responsibilities these women had and their day to day lives helped shaped their families in many different ways. Miller and Wilson are highlighting that the role the women have in these plays…

    • 1089 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Like men, women have always played a specific role in society. Depending on the perspective of the viewer, one may say that the role woman have should change dramatically. In Ibsen’s play, A Doll House, legendary Greek playwright Euripides’ play, Medea and Eavan Boland’s poem “A Woman’s World,” the idea of a “woman’s place” and the appropriate conception of a “Woman’s World” is challenged. In all of these pieces of literature, women are faced with inevitable misogyny and unjustified predetermined inferences of character. Both Ibsen’s and Euripides’ pieces have these women challenging the idea of what their roles in society should be. In Medea the hatred used to strive for equality or revenge for being forced to accept the role of a woman is far more extreme than Ibsen’s Nora who takes on a more subtle approach is searching for self-worth, respect and equality. In “A Woman’s World” Boland’s message is used to show women their fault in accepting this overly domestic role in society. Bolan is trying to show woman to be more determined to find personal success, rather than simply living vicariously through the success of their husbands. In this poem the author urges women to search for equality and respect in love and society, just like the Nora and Medea in their stories.…

    • 732 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    “Mrs. Warren’s Profession”, written in 1893 by George Bernard Shaw, is a play that centers around the relationship between Mrs. Kitty Warren, a brothel owner, and her daughter, Vivie, an intelligent and hardheaded young woman. The women in this play are underpaid, undervalued, and overworked. A good comparison that explores women in the Victorian era is Wuthering Heights by Emily Bronte, written in 1846. Wuthering Heights goes in depth about the social classes that were formed back in Victorian times. During this time Women faced political and educational restrictions that triggered a fight for reform concerning their place within society. In both pieces of writing it becomes apparent that women face oppression in the public sphere and also restriction in political and educational sphere, which prohibits women from having equal opportunity and access compared to men; this further oppresses women within the male dominating society. Therefore, women become reliant on men financially. Nonetheless, in the piece written by Shaw, Vivie (Mr.s Warren’s daughter) challenges the male dominating society and pursues an education in order to successfully liberate herself from the oppressive society and Mrs. Warren actively participates in immoral activities by selling herself to the wealthy men of the town, which in turn ruins her relationship with her daughter.…

    • 1543 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays