Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

The Notion of Polysystem Theory in Literature

Good Essays
1255 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Notion of Polysystem Theory in Literature
I. Even-Zohar
Papers in Historical Poetics
The book consists of a set of articles in which the centre of attention is the notion of Polysystem.
The article The Function of the Literary Polysystem in the History of Literature is mostly connected with the notion of Polysystem. Language is heterogeneous, so it is labeled as a polysystem, where highly codified stratification prevails, any minor move from one stratum to another may be taken as a major offense. Polysystem is subdivided into “canonized” (usually considered “major” literature: those kinds of literary works accepted by the “literary milieu” and usually preserved by the community as part of its cultural heritage) and “non-canonized” literature (those kinds of literary works more often than not rejected by the literary milieu as lacking “aesthetic value” and relatively quickly forgotten, e.g. detective-fiction, sentimental novels, westerns, pornographic literature, etc.). Translation plays a great role in Polysystem and in the synchrony and diachrony of a certain literature. “Epigonic” literature is kind of a literature where diachronic shifts create a situation in which norms previously known as dominant become peripheral within “the new phase of literature,” but they are still in use. Canonized literature tries to create new models of reality and attempts to illuminate the information it bears, non-canonized literature has to keep within the conventionalized models which are highly automatized. In synchrony, canonized and non-canonized systems manifest two various diachronic phases, the non-canonized overlapping with a previous canonized phase. The oppositions between the various literary systems create an ideal literary and cultural balance within the literary polysystem. This is the only way for non-canonized literature to settle in literature when canonized literature succeeds in gaining ground.
The article The Relations between Primary and Secondary Systems in the Literary Polysystem distinguishres between primary and secondary systems - to what extent a certain system or type plays a major role within the literary polysystem. The Polysystem hypothesis gives us possibility to a more adequate analysis of intra- and interrelations. It is also a functional concept. It is concerned with dynamic complexes. The functions it may detect are conditioned by complex inter- and intrarelations within a hypothesized multileveled system. “Primary” type: the pre-condition for its functioning is the discontinuity of established models. Change occurs only when a primary model takes over the center of a system. Sometimes we can have the process of “secondariztion’ of the primary, what means that new elements are retranslated, into the old terms, inconsequence imposing previous functions on new carriers but not changing the functions.
The Polysystem Hypothesis Revisited. Many scholars, including Evan-Zohar considered that literature within the historical context can be conceived of as a polysystem, that is a stratified whole, where the various strata function as systems. But it became clear that no literature really overfunctions as a non-stratified whole and if the correlation between the strata within it disintegrates for some reason, a sort of stagnation takes over. The result of such process is that the system collapses. The methodological hypothesis which presumed literature to be a polysystem could now be reversed and reformulated in terms of a universal: all literary systems strive to become polysystemic.

The article Universals of Literary Contacts distinguishes source literature (SLt) and target literature (TLt) and draws the difference between two major types of literary contact: first - contacts between relatively established systems which are con-sequently relatively independent (for instance the situation of English and French languages over the past two years); and second - contacts between non-established or fluid systems which are partly or wholly dependent upon some other system(s) – these are the cases with Ukrainian and Russian, for instance. Some examples of possible universals of literary contact are provided:
- Literatures are never in non-contact, because of some social reasons. These contacts are the rule rather than the exception.
- A prestigious literature may function as a literary superstratum for a TLt.
- Literature may be selected as a SLt when it is dominant due to extra-literary conditions, for example the political domination of English and French during colonial periods.
- Contacts are also favored/non-favored by a general attitude of a potential TLt. Due to some nationalistic view, works of some writers could not be possible considered as appropriate for the national literature.
- We may observe interference when a TLt cannot resist it or has a need for it - is when a certain type evolved in a certain literature is lacking in another, for example, thrillers and detective stories undoubted-ly migrated from English literature to practically all the others.
- Items are not transplanted from a SLt to a TLt, but “needs” determine and guide the selection and the function also changes.
- A TLt tends to behave like a secondary system with respect to a SLt. This means that a TLt, under the conditions mentioned above, makes contact with a diachronic phase of a SLt which is wholly or partly outdated, and disregards a contemporary SLt phase.

Interference in Dependent Literary Polyssytems. A literature may become dependent only if it is weak. But this “weakness” means the inability of a system to function by confining itself to its home inventory only and the extreme of such a state would then denote a situation where a literature can function only because it has the opportunity of using some other literature. Russian literature was for Hebrew as a part of it on all levels, but due to the equivalency policy adopted by Bialik and his contemporaries, there was a very strong illusion of domestic “originality.” When the condition of weakness is not marked, even physical contacts and pressures may not result in interference; when it is marked, a state of dependency is very likely, especially if simultaneously accompanied by accessible contacts even in the absence of physical contact and pressures.

The next article Russian and Hebrew: The Case of a Dependent Polysystem first of all tries to show ways in which Yiddish and Hebrew developed through the centuries. The fact that many Jews lived among Slavs is of high importance because this is the reason why the language was influenced by European languages. Only in the 19th century the great development of both languages began. This period is called “The Revival Period.” The most noticeable is the influence of Russian languge. Russified items penetrated most easily into domains where the Hebrew repertoire was weakest. Hebrew separated from Yiddish only in Palestine.

The last article Israeli-Hebrew Literature: A Historical Model is about historical interrelation of Hebrew and Yiddish literature. The first period of the development can be characterized by its multiterritorial base (if the writer lives outside his country his works can be aknowledged of the country he lives in – this was common for Hebrew) , and its existence as a defective polysystem within symbiotic structures, which is the function of the first one (for instance Hebrew which influenced some other languages, mainly, where Jews lived). Due to some political reasons Israeli-Hebrew Literature didn’t have a stable centre. Only in 19th century it moved to Palestine, however a lot of publishing houses were situated in all over the world. Yiddish literature functioned for a long time as Hebrew’s non-canonized system, but after the separation the audience increased. Translations are very important in Israel Literature, because they are also a part of Israel Literature, mostly these are the translations from English, German and Russian Literatures. Despite all the pressure that Israeli underwent, the literature develops as well as researches on Translation Studies.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    This chapter provides an introduction to the book. It raises questions that will not be answered until Frye has set out a general theory of literature. These include the…

    • 3194 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Antigone - 13

    • 1735 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Bibliography: 1. Gillespie, Sheena and Fonseca, Terezinha and Sanger, Carol A.-3rd ed. (2001).Literature across cultures, Allyn & Bacon, Antigone 953-981…

    • 1735 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Kingdom of Matthias

    • 10960 Words
    • 44 Pages

    "Overview", "Setting", "Literary Qualities", "Social Sensitivity", "Topics for Discussion", "Ideas for Reports and Papers". ©…

    • 10960 Words
    • 44 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Literary Canon Definition

    • 267 Words
    • 2 Pages

    A literary canon is a classification of literature. It is compromised of literary works that share similar or related characteristics and are considered to be the most important of a specific time frame or place. The process in which a work is canonized is completely subjective. And just as the judgments and opinions of people change over time, so do literary canons. The status a work receives when it is entered into a literary canon is based on its relevance to the time period. Therefore a social change such as the feminist movement can determine what works are added and removed from a literary canon…

    • 267 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The relationship between history and literary work is often questioned. There are four main models that have been devised to explain this. The first regards a piece literary work as universal and belonging to no time period. The model states that historical context has no significance in literary texts, and that both should remain autonomous from each other. Critics are concerned with literary texts being artefacts in themselves that surpass the possibilities of a particular time, thus the idea of specific historical context is dismissed. R.S. Crane supports this view and in an essay said history is part of “the general history of culture” whereas literature should be “imaginative works considered with respect to those qualities which can truly be said to be timeless… quite apart from any knowledge of their origin or historical affiliation” (Crane, Ronald. 1967. ‘History versus Criticism in the study of literature’, in The idea of the Humanities and Other Essays Critical and Historical, Vol.2. Chicago: University of Chicago Press). In short, this model centres around the basis that a literary work should be judged on its, as Crane said, ‘timeless qualities’ for example the quality of its linguistic features and other aspects that give a work literary merits.…

    • 1207 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Context changes due to audience, writers and time; though it still has the effect of influencing perspectives and creating/ reshaping meaning. Through the context, us as readers are able to establish an understanding of the time period, the writer and the purpose of the text. Through the exploration of both contexts relationships are established to enrich and illuminate connections on the unchanging nature and universality of certain values, ideas and language forms, also highlighting through implicit or explicit means relationships, writing and societal changes. Connections are…

    • 1505 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jan R. Veenstra, in his examination of new historicism, draws upon Greenblatt and his “poetics of culture,” which determines the strong relationship between literary and historical texts and their socio-historical contexts. Greenblatt’s cultural poetics fosters the concept that texts are not merely a documentation of the social and political forces that make up history and society, but they also contribute remarkably to the social processes that refigure individual identity and the socio-political, historical situation (174). Veenstra maintains that Greenblatt’s “economic metaphor” enables texts and their symbolic significance to prevail in society insofar as the texts’ literary devices reflect the social energy circulating in other texts that speak of the same subject matter. He further elaborates that Greenblatt’s ideas on the nature of the text leads to a new method of interpretation, which foregrounds the socio-historical context that informs the text and gives it the tools by which it acquires new meanings. Accordingly, Veenstra asserts that with reference to Greenblatt, poetry and history are “forms of poesies, a creative force that pervades all domains of human activity” (176) which needs to be closely examined. Veenstra, in this regard, defines the text as “a human-made object” that “is radically informed by all the forces that condition and shape our societies and histories” (177).…

    • 603 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    What holds a lot of the determination of what stands for the written word seams lost or buried in a revisionists mind. A strong sentiment that argues that painters are masters until they have died, and that having prevailed the test have time the book must truly be great. The greatness of art seems buried in consensus, getting into this hallowed hierarchy is a lot tougher than many writers wanted to admit. Though not every writer can say that they have been given awards for a bestselling book, otherwise there would be no reason for the pronouncement of “literature”. Membership has no great benefits; the connection creates no classification or certification. So if it is easy to point to what isn’t literature, it seems difficult if not impossible to prove what is. So what is literature, and how dose certain genres shaped our society?…

    • 665 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Pardoners Tale/ Beowulf

    • 698 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The comprehension of literary history gives us insight into the past, recognition of historical events and corruption written into the works of those who were present. By including societal behaviors, political tensions, and common folklore, authors have indirectly provided the reader with a broader and deeper understanding of the literature, as well as the period in which it was written. Besides insight into society as a whole, literary history has provided future writers with models of poetic device, style and content influencing literary works in todays present. Literary history is a vehicle to understanding the past and plays a major role in its influence on literature up to and including the present day.…

    • 698 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Literature is a strong contributor to the knowledge of every country's history and is therefore the product of the historical events that have taken place. Written works take us beyond the limited experiences of our short lives and strengthen our current knowledge and understandings of historical events. Literature affects people and in return people affect literature. Events in history shape the written products of a time period, every novel, play, and poem. Each form of literature is that product. Throughout romanticism, modernism, and postmodernism, the literature was written with the hidden purpose of future readers possessing the understanding of the historical context in order to fully understand the work as a whole.…

    • 762 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sometimes, it is hard for a teenager to believe the word “modern” is not always the best, and the word “ancient” is not always unpalatable. From these encounters, my understanding of cultures, religions, and writing skills expanded. I learned the effectiveness of literary devices such as irony, allegory, onomatopoeia, and satire. The historical time frame of the writing, the cultural aspects of the writer, and historical events within the piece are important aspects in evaluating the quality of literature. If possible, reading literature in its original language helps to increase the appreciation of the quality of its excellence. Finally, reading a piece of literature more than once may enlighten a reader concerning its…

    • 1034 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Snow Crash Study Guide

    • 33018 Words
    • 133 Pages

    "Overview", "Setting", "Literary Qualities", "Social Sensitivity", "Topics for Discussion", "Ideas for Reports and Papers". ©…

    • 33018 Words
    • 133 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Prince

    • 769 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Cited: Meyer Spacks, and William G. Thalmann. The Norton Anthology Of Western Literature: The Ancient World Through The Renaissance. 8. New York: W W Norton , 2006. 1945-1961. Print.…

    • 769 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Yvonne, Fonteneau “World Literature Today” Vol. 64, No. 3, O.U. Centennial Issue (Summer, 1990), pp. 408-412, Published by: Board of Regents of the University of Oklahoma…

    • 2250 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    A Moveable Feast

    • 18515 Words
    • 75 Pages

    "Overview", "Setting", "Literary Qualities", "Social Sensitivity", "Topics for Discussion", "Ideas for Reports and Papers". ©…

    • 18515 Words
    • 75 Pages
    Powerful Essays