Unit 3 (SCLY3) Beliefs in Society (scroll down to find SCLY4) 1. Non-religious belief systems
Ideology, science, hegemony, pluralism, patriarchy, falsification theory and paradigms 2. Defining religion and measuring religiosity
Substantive and functional definitions
Giddens' and Durkheim's definitions
Ways of measuring religiosity (attendance figures, the census)
Problems of measurement - Davie. 3. Functionalism and religion
Durkheim, Parsons, Malinowski, Bellah
Religion as a conservative force 4. Marxism and religion
Marx and Engels
Religion as a conservative force (Marx)
Religion as an initiator of change (Engels) 5. Neo-Marxism and religion
Gramsci, Maduro, Turner
Religion as an initiator of change 6. Feminism and religion
De Beauvoir, El Saadawi, Watson
Religion as a conservative force 7. Weber and religion
Historical study - Calvinism, Lutheranism
Modern view - rationalisation
Religion as a past initiator of change 8. Postmodernism and religion
Lyon, Bauman 9. Religious fundamentalism
Definitions, examples, links to secularisation 10. Religious participation
By social group (age, ethnicity, gender and social class) 11. Religious organisations
Church, cult, sect, denomination
Troeltsch, Weber, Stark & Bainbridge
Wallis - NRMs
Reasons for NRM turnover 12. Secularisation
Arguments for - Wilson, Weber, Bruce (etc)
Arguments against - Durkheim, Parsons, Armstrong
Problems of measuring secularisation - Davie
NEW: my A2 students have produced brief summaries of some of the topics above. Here are their revision notes to help other students. Marxism and religion Marxism is seen as a social conflict perspective and Marxists such as Marx and Engels believe that religion is a tool of the bourgeoisie to maintain control of the proletariat; therefore religion is considered a conservative force. Marx viewed religion as a form of false consciousness as the proletariat are unaware and therefore believe in the concept of God, so that the proletariat will accept exploitation by the bourgeoisie, an example being the caste system in Hinduism where the untouchables get constantly discriminated against for being the lowest caste, for example having to clean toilets with their bare hands. However Marx assumes that all proletariat are religious and that the bourgeoisie control religion, yet there is no proof that this is the case, an example being the people’s temple; all individuals were considered equal, therefore there wass no social divide. Neo-Marxism and religion Rather than being a conservative force, neo-Marxists argue religion is an initiator of change, an example being Catholicism which in the past changed Poland from communist to capitalist.
Gramsci stated that religion wouldn't dissapear under communism and that it can be liberating and not oppresive; moral guidelines and theoretical ideas will still be required which religion can provide.
Maduro believed religion has relative autonomy so is separate from the state; he drew this conclusion from recent disputes between the catholic church and the state in Latin America, declaring his Liberation Theology, which states members of the church should fight oppresive right-wing dictatorships.
Turner disputes the fact that the working class were controlled by religion and states they attended church due to habit or coercion; he also states that Marx's views are outdated and the use of reluigion to legitimise primogeniture is no longer relevant as other institutions are used to control the masses.
Neo-Marxists in general ignore patriarchy/ethinicity and assume that in all contries religion is seperate from the state; however evidence can be drawn from the conflict in Afganistan between government rule and the taliban to disagree. Weber and religion Weber is the founder of the social action perspectives. Weber's historical work looked at how denominations of the Protestantism aided the early development of capitalism. The denominations Calvinism and Lutheranism were the initiators of capitalism according to Weber due to the fact the people valued hard work and they didn’t spend the money so they re-invested their wages into businesses. However, this may not be the case in some countries because early capitalism existed before Calvinism and Lutheranism.
Weber's modern day view argues due to rationalisation religious beliefs have been replaced by science, this ultimately results in secularisation. Overall, religion is neither a conservative force nor an initiator of change because it has little significance in society today. In criticism, fundamentalism e.g. Islamism is growing so therefore society cannot be becoming secular.
Feminism and religion
Feminists such as El Saadawi and De Beauvoir see religion as patriarchal because they see it as a way men can oppress women, an example being women are seen as dirty for 7 days after they give birth (as stated in the bible in Christianity). They see religion as a conservative force allowing the men to keep oppressing the women for example in some rural parts of India, Hindu men still control the women in some cases because they have to jump on their husband's funeral pyre even though this is illegal. El Saadawi would say religion is used for sexual oppression and Simone De Beauvoir sees religion as a form of patriarchy, social control, and deception.
However, Badawi would say that we are past that; we are 'post patriarchal' for example Wicca is a religion that emphasises women, and also Watson says the veil is liberating not oppressing.
Postmodernism and religion
The postmodernist view on society is that we have moved on from modernity, which can mean two things: According to Bauman we can no longer believe in science and therefore we turn to religious leaders to provide us with a monopoly of truth, which leads us back to stronger religious belief. According to Lyon it's because of the fact that we have moved on from the metanarrative of science so we can now pick and mix religion and take the best bits from each. One example of this would be the Raeliens as this religion shows a combination of science and religious beliefs, therefore people have chosen the best of both worlds.
Religious fundamentalism, such as extreme Catholicism, supports Bauman's view as the Pope is the religious leader who provides a monopoly of truth, however this contradicts Lyon as the belief is in one religi
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
A religion can be seen as a unified system of beliefs and practices which are relative to sacred things and beliefs (Giddens 1972, p.224). It can shape ones thoughts and feelings and gives people a sense of hope and something to believe in. All three main sociologist writers Karl Marx, Max Weber and Emile Durkheim offer different perspectives on religion and how important it is to society. Some of the theorists chose to have a positive view whilst others argue the unimportance of religion. This essay attempts to discover which theorist has the most accurate perspective of religion in modern times. This is done by firstly explaining the basic ideas regarding to religion put forward by Marx, Weber and Durkheim. Then both Marx's and Durkheim's thought will be compared and contrasted in order to determine the differences and similarities between their ideas. Finally, it will be explained which one of the theorists views and ideas are the most relevant to contemporary times and why.…
- 1387 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
> The sociological perspective is described as seeing the general in the particular. In this essay I will attempt to apply the sociological perspective to analyze song lyrics from the first verse of the song My Block by Tupac Shakur (see appendix for lyrics). Tupac (1971-1996) is the most famous gangster rap artist of all times. He was well known for his lyrics and their ability to express the grief of the Black community. He was an advocate for Black rights and very much against the societal system and class societies. Many say he exaggerated the conditions under which the Black community and the lower class were in because he was a wealthy man rapping about suppression. To other’s he was part of the petite-bourgeoisie, but he was consistent in attempting to better the conditions under which the lower class were in.…
- 3041 Words
- 13 Pages
Powerful Essays -
2. Yes: The Bad Divorce written by Elizabeth Marquardt, Director of the Center for Marriage and Families, from First Things.…
- 540 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Communicate effectively by applying skills in reading, writing, speaking, and listening and through appropriate use of information technology. (GE Goal 1)…
- 3371 Words
- 13 Pages
Powerful Essays -
4: In his research, George Murdock determined which of the following to be a cultural universal?…
- 795 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Compare and contrast conflict theory with structural functionalism. Pay special attention to the way that each theory treats the origin of social change. When it comes to the origin of social change the conflict theory and structural functionalism differ in many ways. Structural Functionalism stresses that society as whole, including the individuals, families, educational system, politics, and the economy come together to create a functioning society. But, if any one part of these social institutions experiences dysfunction then the whole society pays a price as if it were a domino effect. For example, if families fail to discipline their children, schools, churches and the courts must take up the slack. In the end, whether it is a positive or negative change, the society as a whole must adjust in response to a transformation in a social institution. Conflict theory does not see society as a whole coming together well for one purpose. The conflict theory proposes that conflict and tension are the basic facts of life and are what make up social change and ultimately society as a whole, but it puts more emphasis on class conflict (bourgeoisie vs. proletariat). Together, both of these theories are from a macro analysis perspective.…
- 560 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Marriage in any faith is considered to be the joint union of a man and a woman. It is commitment, love and faith in themselves and their religion, which holds the marriage. Marriage in Christianity and Islam has the same goal of committing a man and a woman together however the process to that point has its own symbolistic significance within that faith. Marriage is considered to be a rite of passage in both Christianity and Islam, a rite of passage in reference to any religion is a ritual or ceremony marking an individual 's passing from one stage or state to a more advanced one, or an event in one 's life that seems to have such significance; an example is marriage.…
- 1339 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Karl Marx viewed religion as a social control used by the bourgeoisie to keep the proletariat to maintain the status quo in a given society.…
- 432 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Religion is such a complex and varied human phenomenon that some sociologists prefer to avoid definitions and think of religion in terms of an ideal type. They will say that most religions have most of the characteristics of the ideal type, but they need not have all of them. In general terms, James C. Livingston (2008) defined religion as “that system of activities and beliefs directed toward that which is perceived to be of sacred value and transforming power.” Religion is also defined as a collection of belief systems, cultural systems…
- 2589 Words
- 11 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Secularism is one of the most contested ideologies in most parts of the world. As T.N. Madan (1997) states, we may not hear of wholly secularised societies, even in the West, which is responsible for introducing the ideology to the rest of the world. In the Indian context, no other ideology may have generated more attention, debate and controversy since the country’s independence. Yet, despite the vast and varied literature and public discourse, the ideal of secularism remains elusive. Another reason for this ambivalence could be as H. Srikanth states “Like liberal Hindu gods who can take different forms and give a chance to devotees to worship in any form they like, in India the concept of secularism has acquired so many interpretations and it now means different things to different groups of people” (Srikanth (1994) cited in Roover 2002). The term has assumed a negative connotation and is deemed as insult to be called “secular” in many quarters today. Many observers argue that what we have in India is pseudo secularism. This paper will examine reasons for failure of secularism as an ideology in India.…
- 3779 Words
- 16 Pages
Best Essays -
Data about crime is collected through official statistics that are mainly based on police records where crime is reported to the police, and then the police records it and keep the records to provide measure of trends in different types of crime. Official statistics on crime are published by the Home Office. These records provide official accounts and indicate the police workload as well as being useful for an analysis of patterns of particular crimes. However, even though the police have a statutory obligation to record crime, some go unrecorded just because they have some discretion to decide how serious enough a crime is to warrant their attention. So, police crime statistics do no account for the total volume of crime living an unrecorded figure of crime. (A. Pilkington, 2005)…
- 1349 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
However, Marxists argue that religion only serves the ruling class. Marxists believe that religion justifies the bourgeoisie’s power over the proletarians by making the poor believe that it is there own fault that they are suffering and giving them false hope of a reward after death. By doing this, religion stops the working class from rebelling. Therefore, both Functionalists and Marxists believe that religion plays a major role in society, but Marxists think that there would be no need for religion if capitalism was over-come.…
- 288 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
1. One of the definitions of secularization is the transformation of a society from close identification with religious values and institutions toward nonreligious (or irreligious) values and secular institutions. The Secularization thesis states that as society progresses, particularly through modernization and rationalization, religion loses its authority in all aspects of social life and governance. Max Weber described this process as the "disenchantment of the world".…
- 1840 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Homelessness is a topic I can relate to very well, coming from a poor background and living from paycheck to paycheck has caused me to be out of residences for over ten months.It was very hard to comprehend, living under a hotel with my two daughters taught me to seek out and learn what causes homelessness.Having a background of being a nurse it was hard for me to live without a roof over my head.My oldest daughter was pregnant at the time and had no adequate health care , so it was tough for us.I am petitioning for credit from Excelsior College toward my degree in the Health Sciences department.This class will meet one of my health sciences cores.I learned a lot from being homeless.Writing is my best subject and talking with several ladies over the years who was homeless with smaller children made me learn that being homeless is a social disease and sometimes not a mental disease.Associating homelessness with mental illness does tie in for some people.…
- 482 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
It is also suggested by sociologists, like Heelas et al. in their Kendal study, that the holistic milieu and increased participation in NRMs and New-Age spirituality is evidence of a resacrilisation of society. However, critics argue that actual numbers are a small proportion of the population and that such groups still only have a marginal position in society. Bryan Wilson argues that NRMs are almost irrelevant to society, with Peter Berger describing them as ‘islands in a secular sea’. The Kendal study would seem to support this with only 2% of the population engaged in New-Age activities and only half of these individuals viewing their activities as spiritual. This supports Bruce’s view that the rise of New Age is not a threat to secularisation.…
- 952 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays