top-rated free essay

Richard Neustadt

By ysantis Nov 05, 2012 605 Words
Richard Neustadt: Presidential Power and the Modern Presidency
Writing in 1960, Richard Neustadt is an important political theorist focusing on the US Presidency. Neustadt’s work was a reaction to the “old institutionalism” represented by writers like Edwin Corwin. Neustadt takes a behaviorist approach to understanding presidential power, and argues that the real functional power of the US president arises from his “power to persuade”. Neustadt acknowledges that the formal power of the US president is spelled out in the US Constitution but he argues that these formal powers do not adequately describe the real functional power of the president. For Neustadt the key to presidential power is the president’s ability to persuade other important actors to carry out what he wants done. Neustadt views the presidency as at the apex of a pyramid of governing power that provides the president with unique leverage and vantage points to bargain with and persuade others on implementing governing policy and direction. These other actors include cabinet officers and senior government bureaucrats, the congress, military leaders, leaders of state governments, party leaders, business leaders and even foreign leaders. Neustadt does not see the US government as one of “separated power” under the Constitution. Instead he claims that the Constitution actually “created a government of separated institutions sharing powers. “ These separated institutions include the congress, federalism itself, the bill of rights and perhaps even the press as a fourth branch of government. Neustadt sees the formal powers of the president and congress as very intertwined such that neither can accomplish very much without the acquiescence of the other; and, that what one branch demands the other can resist. Neustadt notes, for example that Eisenhower claimed that the presidency was part of the legislative process, since he had the authority to veto or sign bills, etc. But Neustadt notes that when a president tries to command rather than persuade, such as when Truman nationalized the steel mills or fired MacArthur, or when Eisenhower sent the troops to Little Rock, Arkansas to enforce desegregation court orders, that there can be blowback that can neutralize presidential fiat and, ultimately, render presidential action inconclusive or effective. Neustadt sees relationships of mutual dependence between the various stakeholders and that the president depends upon the persons whom he would persuade. He notes a particular success story of persuasion when Truman worked with Republican senator Vandenberg to create the Marshall plan to rebuild Europe after WWII. That effort depended on mutual understanding, trust and a commitment to shared endeavor without which Vandenberg may have decided to wait for a Republican president to create a major new direction in US foreign policy. Neustadt sums up by arguing that for a president to have effective influence he must: (1) use the bargaining advantage that he has by virtue of his office to persuade other men that what he wants them to do is what their own responsibilities require of them (persuade them that his goals should be their own goals), 2) maintain a professional reputation in the minds of other men such that they respect his authority and ability, and (3) maintain his popular prestige such that those he bargains with believes that the public will view them favorably if they do what the president wants. In short, the president’s “power is the product of his vantage points in government, together with his reputation in the Washington community and his prestige outside.” Neustadt goes on to argue a presidents has to make proper choices and decisions, so as to preserve his reputation and prestige, or he will squander his ability to lead by losing his ability to persuade.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Richard Cory

    ..."Richard Cory" describes how one man is not as perfect as his townspeople think. The poem “Richard Cory” was written in 1897 by Edwin Arlington Robinson. It is about a gentleman by the name of Richard Cory; a man everybody admired. The townspeople look at him as if he had it all. They see his money, feel his power, know his intelligence, an...

    Read More
  • Richard Nixon

    ...Nixon: His Cover-up Who would have knew a U.S. President would have done a crime? Unless it was a good reason that is. This incident is called the Watergate scandal. At the Watergate Hotel in Washington D.C. was where this all started. This led to even more complications. In this paper I hope to prove that even though Nixon had a cover-up plan i...

    Read More
  • Richard Nixon

    ... RICHARD M. NIXON Throughout the course of history in the United States there have been controversial individuals. These people bring attention to themselves through good deeds or misdeeds. This is the case for the 37th president of the United States. His name was Richard Milhouse Nixon. His rise to power and fall from grace will f...

    Read More
  • Presidential Powers R. Neustadt

    ...Neustadt: Presidential power In Brief Key Point: "Presidential power is the power to persuade." (11) Presidents are expected to do much more than their authority allows them to do. Persuasion and bargaining are the means that presidents use to influence policy. Not only do presidents need to bargain to influence other branches of governmen...

    Read More
  • Richard Nixon Bibliography

    ...Richard M. Nixon our 37th president Born Richard Millhouse Nixon on January 9th, 1913 in Yorba Linda, California Nixon was the son of a grocer. His father owned a small lemon farm in Yorba Linda, California where he helped out as a boy. His childhood was troubled seeing that he almost died twice once by accident and the other time by pneumonia....

    Read More
  • Richard Nixon Presidency

    ...Why was Richard Nixon elected by a landslide in 1972, but forced to resign in August 1974? Richard Nixon was the 37th President of the United States and was president from 1968 to 1974. In the 1972 elections, he won the electoral vote by 96.6% due to many reasons which appealed to many parts of America. However, in 1974, he was forced to resi...

    Read More
  • Richard Cory: the Man Who Was

    ...Elliott Brown Essay #1 Cooper Richard Cory: The Man Who Was "Richard Cory" describes how one man is not as perfect as his townspeople think. They believe that he is better than everyone else. However, the man in the poem, Richard Cory, kills himself. Throughout the poem, the author, Edwin Arlington Robinson, provides insight into the chi...

    Read More
  • Richard Nixon Resignation Speach Research Paper

    ...Kels 9th Grade Honors English 11/21/13 Richard Nixon Resignation Speech Richard Nixon was the 37th president of the United States of America. On July 17, 1972, five men on the Committee to Reelect the President (CREEP) broke into the Democratic National Committee offices of the Watergate Hotel. These men were James W. Mcord, Bernard L. ...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.