Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Dworkin's Third Conception of the Law and Hart's Criticism

Good Essays
448 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Dworkin's Third Conception of the Law and Hart's Criticism
PART TWO - ESSAY

(1) Dworkin’s “third conception of the law” called Law as Integrity is based in part on the assumption that there is a single author of the law. The community personifies expressing a coherent conception of justice and fairness. According to law as integrity, propositions of law are true if they figure in or follow from the principles of justice, fairness, ad procedural due process that provide the best constructive interpretation of the community’s legal practice. Furthermore, Dworkin would approve and support the judges for creating an opinion and setting a new precedent on this case. Dworkin’s Chain Novel concept fits into this case perfectly by adding new precedent which the lawmakers of the time could not foresee. The lawmakers had not created such a provision dealing with this situation but surely did not intend to protect this defendant just because the language of the law was absent.

(2) Hart might criticize the majority opinion because he will believe that the justices have done a dishonor to the law. Regardless if the defendant attained the land through unmoral means, he did not violate any laws at that time. Social rules should not be taken into consideration with the law since there is no precedent dealing with such issue. A law is separate from morality, and does not in itself guarantee that the primary social rules of a given legal system are just or morally right (Adams 43). The majority opinion relied on judges to go beyond their jurisdiction and make moral judgments when there was no such precedent or law set on that matter. The judges, as Hart may claim, did not follow primary and secondary rules in reaching their majority opinion. Hart may support the dissent of Judge Gray by applauding Grays reasoning on the case. In particular, Hart would support Gray when Gray states, “The question we are dealing with is whether a testamentary disposition can be altered, or a will revoked, after the testators death, through an appeal to the courts, when the legislature has by its enactments prescribed exactly when and how wills may be made, altered, and revoked, and apparently, as it seems to me, when they have been fully complied with, has no left room for the exercise of an equitable jurisdiction by the courts over such matters. (Adams 152).” Hart would support this train of thought by Gray because Gray clearly makes it known to the majority that there are already laws stating how to properly handle wills, and that the courts really have no jurisdiction after a testator has deceased and the will has come into affect. Gray is only following the law and keeping morality separate.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    For instance, Dworkin looks towards John Austin's definition of a sovereign. Austin “defined a sovereign as some person or group whose commands are habitually obeyed and who is not in the habit of obeying anyone else.”, but as Dworkin added aspects of this definition have since been disregarded.20 The rule of recognition discussed by HLA Hart in Concepts of Law, argues that Austin's definition it now a two sided coin. On the one hand you have those who are in positions of power and make the law, but they are only empowered with this privelege by the sovereign will of the community at large.21 This duality ensures that judicial power is restrained because citizens would not respect the law if they believed it to be…

    • 1408 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Crime and Process Model

    • 900 Words
    • 4 Pages

    “Court reform is a topic of constant conversation in legal circles. Do a search on the topic by going to Yahoo: http://www.yahoo.com. Then, under Search, type the phrase court reform. Is court reform needed to protect the values of the crime control model or the values of the due process model?”…

    • 900 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Robbins Collections School of Law University of California at Berkley. (n.d.). The Common Law and Civil Law Traditions. Retrieved from http://www.berkley.edu…

    • 1862 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    George Davis Case

    • 643 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Although Davis argues generally that the circuit court erroneously denied his motion to correct an illegal sentence, we discern from his brief two specific arguments as to why the circuit court should have granted his motion to correct an illegal sentence. First, Davis asserts that “Count 1-Robbery with a Dangerous and Deadly weapon, Count two First Degree Assault, [and] Count 8 Use of a Handgun in the Commission of violence” should merge. Secondly, Davis contends that he was deprived of procedural due process when his motion to correct an illegal sentence was denied without a hearing, without having given Davis the opportunity to respond to the States opposition to Davis’s motion, and without the trial judge having sufficiently articulate…

    • 643 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Torture and Ethics

    • 1450 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Himma Kenneth (2009) Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Philosophy of Law Retrieved on 4-14-2013 from http://www.iep.utm.edu/law-phil/…

    • 1450 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    search and seizure

    • 1684 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Legal Information Institute, Cornell University Law School (n.d). Retrieved on January 14, 2014 from http://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/437/385…

    • 1684 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    When reviewing this case, there were several main issues that had to be considered before forming a decision. The first being if the ancient statute presented by the Plaintiff held precedent or not. In concurrence with Judge Flaherty, the statute of King Edward I does not currently hold precedent. Not only is this statute about seven hundred years old, it is also formed to serve the needs of a society that had different priorities. In the time period of King Edward I, the society had collectivist values in which an individual had a duty to…

    • 1661 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Unit 6 Assignment

    • 834 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Source: Fuller, L. (1975). The morality of law. (p. 159). New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.…

    • 834 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    My family and I established trust in this system of accountability and laws; we depended on the court’s duty to deliver justice when it was needed. This situation began when my cousin and his date were maliciously assaulted. After my cousin, Christopher, took his date, Katherine to the local theater, they both retreated to a small school playground. Soon, a large gang approached…

    • 516 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Serial Murder Case Analysis

    • 2809 Words
    • 12 Pages

    How to successfully solve serial murder cases – ideas and discussion – Crimestoppers – key facts report.…

    • 2809 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The term mechanical jurisprudence was coined by Roscoe pound in his article in 1908. It is the concept that judges apply law rigidly according to precedent and legislation without thought of consequences. In this it is argued that every eventuality that comes before the law is legislated for in advance, it is just for the judges to apply the relevant law. This concept would insinuate that every case that comes before the courts has been legislated for in advance, leaving virtually no room for judicial discretion.…

    • 1531 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Law - Riggs v. Palmer

    • 889 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The dissenting opinion argues that the court is bound by the rigid rules of law, and is not within the proper jurisdiction to modify on the basis of integrity. The dissent opinion takes a textualism approach to interpreting the case and consults the actual language of the constitution. The legislature has now imposed exclusive statutory rules for the completing of wills. These exclusive statutory rules were implemented to ensure the validity and performance of the will. The dissenting opinion finds reasoning for Palmer to receive his property, solely based on the letter of the law. Firstly, they claim that by permitting Palmer to be the respondent of the property, he was placed in a position…

    • 889 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Amid the transverse from the bounds of conventional life to constitutionality we find ourselves at a divergence of sorts. A proverbial fork in the road that only jurisprudents must navigate. On the left we have the concept of legal realism while on the right we have the more dialectic concept of legal formalism. It is in this vein of thought that I base this paper on with the added objective of juxtaposing the two concepts. After which it will become increasingly apparent that legal realism is the superior methodology. Accordingly, my aim is to demonstrate that jurisprudents owe it to themselves, institution, and the people to utilize legal realism when determining a verdict.…

    • 1318 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Television Censorship

    • 1622 Words
    • 7 Pages

    "The beginning of a new legal approach may be traced to the action of the…

    • 1622 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    This conference examines the impact of lawyers and the legal system "on government, freedom, responsibility and virtue." The conference brochure presents as a benchmark the lawyer/statesman who played such a prominent role in our country’s early years. I want to return to that ideal in addressing the particular topic that is before us in this segment of the conference — the role of the lawyer in the criminal justice system. At the risk of comparing two things that are really not comparable, I would like to compare that ideal with our current understanding of the role of the lawyer in the criminal justice system.…

    • 2465 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays

Related Topics