Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Attempts to Control Population Growth Are Ineffective

Good Essays
1001 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Attempts to Control Population Growth Are Ineffective
During the Baby Boom of 1960s there was an exponentially rise in population going from 2.5 billion to 6.1 billion in just 50 years, from then on it was clear that population control would be on the forefront of government agenda’s worldwide. Population has a direct impact on the economy, providing services and the usage of scare resources. Governments therefore attempt to control population numbers. There are contrasting strategies depending on whether the country wishes to increase its population size or whether to limit it. With the two polices being pro-natalist which attitude encourages childbearing and anti-natalist which does not.
Firstly, I will discuss ineffective population policies that governments have put in place, yet have ultimately failed to control the population in its chosen direction. For instances, Singapore, between 1960s and 70s had an anti-natalist policy in place. However, as economic prospered and population growth rate fell, it adopted a pro-natalist policy the target set at increasing population by 40% in 40 years. With a replacement rate of only 1.006 in 1975 action was needed. It introduced many campaigns that aimed to promote marriage; in this case incentives such as ‘love cruises’ and cash incentives to families that have 3 or more children. In addition subsides were also put on baby caring products such as baby milk and primary schooling. Despite all this effort Singapore government found it difficult to raise the population growth. Although the number of marriages increased, the birth rate did not rise and sat at 7.72/1000. Another policy that has had limited success is that of Indian anti-natalist policy. India's population is estimated to be around one billion; India has one of the highest population growth rates in the world at 1.4%. Its main source of lowering the birth-rate was through investing in population education and family planning (increase usage of contraception). In spite of this India still have a very high growth rate and look to overtake China as the world’s most populous country by 2030, result shown that in 2001 India grew by 180 million people; more than the population of Brazil. Furthermore the policy has also caused many unwanted side effects. These two policies are therefore by some extent proving the statement is in fact true.
On the other hand, there have been some effective policies that have been very beneficial to the government’s aim of controlling their population. To illustrate this would be the world’s most serve and controversial family planning programme: China’s One Child anti-natalist Policy. Introduced in 1979 the impact was dramatic with the birth-rate falling from 33% in 1970 to 17% in 1979. The policy was that families in urban areas were by law only allowed one child; however there were some means to which this could be broken. Those who violate the policy would face fines of around $15,000 a huge sum for the average earner in China. The birth-rate as of now is 12.31/1000 with the birth-rate in 1980 21.04/1000 showing clear evidence of the drop. China is expected to reach a 0 population growth by 2050 making this policy achieve its original aims of lowering the birth-rate of china in 50 years to 10/1000. In this event this disproves the statement and shows that China was able to affect their population growth in their favour. An additional policy that was in some way effective in controlling the population of that nation would be that of Romanian’s pro-natalist policy introduced in 1966. Romania had a decreasing birth-rate at the time and a rather high child mortality of 72.20 with 60 % of pregnancies resulted in abortions or infant mortality. Romania started banning abortions, also contraception was taken off the market and only available through the black market. Those not married by the age of 25 are faced to pay 8-10% extra penalty taxes, with the legal age of marriage going down from 18 to 15. The pronatalist policy succeeded to a great extent in its first year mainly due to there being police in clinic to assure that doctors would not conduct illegal abortions the population increased from 2,73,687 to 5,27,764 in just one year. After the first year it started to fail again because the police were sent back to their normal jobs and doctors started to perform illegal abortions. With the policy falling to the back pages of the newspapers and the government’s files. Nevertheless, the huge change in population size visibly shows the success of the policy.
On the whole it is clear that not all policies are flawless and work. At the end of the day it comes down to how strict and forceful the government is going to be in its rulings, and that how much commitment it is willing to put into the case. Furthermore, something that must be noted is that not all countries have the finical access that other nations have. China had a huge budge to implement their policy while the majority of countries that face a rising population are LEDCs and hence lack the capital and this customarily leads to a failed policy. Moreover, a system that I have not noted is one of using migration to control a population size for instances USA which implements strict border regulations to control its population numbers, controlling migration would be a better solution for countries that are strongly influences by religion or one that is strongly democratic. In addition policies normally lead to many negative side effects such as gender inequality in China, and although the population size may be brought to the level in which the government wants is it right to call the population policy effective if it consequently creates so many other damaging issues. In the words of Noam Chomsky ‘You cannot control your own population by force, but it can be distracted by its consumption’.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Population Control is a thing that has been going on for ages, dating all the way back to the late 1700s in the French Indian war. Nigeria, Philippines and India are all countries that use some form of population control. However, China is the country that has garnered the most attention for their method of population control. In 1978, China’s population was 956 million people. India was the second largest country, with a population of 667 million people, a staggering near 300 million less people than China. In 1978, a woman was having about 3 children in her lifetime on average, so China decided to introduce a “one-child” policy for population control. This meant that families were only permitted to have one child per household. Ultimately,…

    • 1499 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The two policies that I have studied are the One Child Policy in China and the Population Control Program in Kerala, India. In 1978, china decided that they needed to control the population and introduced a law that only one successful pregnancy was allowed per couple and rewards were given if couples followed the rules such as pay rise, free education for child and healthcare as well whereas in Kerala, simple policies were introduced such as education of women, increasing the number of health clinics and improving availability of health clinics.…

    • 427 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In order to obtain a population that can be sustained, whether you live in an over populated area or you live in low population where no one wants to have children. There needs to be some kind of order established to control population anywhere. A country such as Italy has low birth rates; in order to bring them back up incentives need to be put in place to insure that people will want to have children. Another country with a problem with low birth rates is Germany. Us as a world need to find some kind of happy medium, where the policies are not to strict for people with lots of children and not as lenient and glorious to those who only have one.…

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As the world economy weakens, resources continue to become limited and the interdependence among countries increase, different countries have been introducing new policies which seek to control the rate at which the human population is growing. Most of these policies have been geared towards controlling the number of children a single family should have. The main aim of these policies has been to relief the environment and the resources within it some stresses of over exploitation. However while countries like China have been doing this for a long period now, many people see it as an interference with the…

    • 1094 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    China and India are the two countries that have the highest population in the world. Both countries have realised that family planning and population control had to happen around the 1950's for India and the 1970's for China. This essay will seek to compare and contrast China and India, focusing on what the major problems facing both are, why have they both had to implement policies regarding population control, and the long-term and short-term effects that these policies have on the two countries.…

    • 1532 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    This, however, proved not to be the case, as the one child policy barely affected the decline of the country’s fertility rate. “Even before its inception, the one child policy was questioned for its necessity and its enormous social costs. . .China’s one child policy may have hastened a fertility decline that was already well in progress, but it is not the main force accounting for China’s low fertility rate today. . .Most of China’s fertility decline occurred prior to the one child policy” (Document B). In this quote, authors Feng Wang and Cai Yong explain how the fertility rate had already been remarkably reduced prior to the policy being enforced. Fertility rates weren’t the only issue after the one-child policy was introduced, though. “To enforce a policy that is so extreme and unpopular for families who relied on children for labor and old age support, physical abuses and violence would be inevitable” (Document B). This excerpt relays the central message critics around the world were trying to convey when the idea of implementing a one child policy initially came up, and how they foresaw the potential consequences that would arise after the policy was put into…

    • 893 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Since the Industrial Revolution, when the standard of living increased significantly, there has been rapid population growth. Many countries, including the United States, have enough land and resources in order to comfortably support the growing population. Some countries, however, simply have more people than can be comfortably supported—like China. China’s population—a staggering 1.3 billion people—accounts for about 20% of the world’s population, housed in a relatively small space! Because of that, during the 1970’s, China implemented measures to limit their population—most famously the One-Child Policy. The One-Child policy, in simplest terms, limited each family to having only one child. However, there were many exceptions to this policy. Additionally, there were other, more sinister methods used to control the population. While China’s population control methods were effective at limiting the population, policies like the One-Child Policy caused societal issues, led to higher rates of sex-selected abortions and infanticide and violated human rights principles.…

    • 312 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    After c. 1949 when China built The People’s Republic of China, Chinese government leader Zedong Mao published a policy called “More people have more power”. Therefore, the population of China has increased fast until c. 1978. On the beginning of the year of c.1978, Chinese government finally found the serious problems from the huge population. Even though Chinese government stopped that policy, China already had 1.2 billion people. The government faced the burden of having a large population, so another policy had published which was the “One Child Policy” or “Birth Control”. (China Ends Notorious, p1-3) Just as these two names implied, “One Child Policy” or “Birth Control” order all Chinese couples to control giving birth and set the limitation…

    • 1879 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Best Essays

    In order to do so, governments introduce polices to either slow down their population growth and discourage births or encourage births in a declining populations. There are many reasons for high fertility rates which in turn leads to overpopulation; Lack of access to contraceptives, children to care for parents in old age, for agricultural purposes as in farming, having children to duplicate ideas and lifestyles, a status symbol (sign of virility), lack of education, lack of control over their own fertility and the last one, religious beliefs and traditional customs. When it comes to countries with a declining population, there are many reasons as why this happens; very poor environmental conditions, raising children in expensive countries, mainly developed countries where the standard of living is high and so the number of births are reduced, when parents lose their jobs due to economic recession there are fewer births, high status of women who like to be independent, access to family planning (contraceptives)…

    • 1604 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Best Essays

    What is striking about the global decline in fertility rates is that they are not confined to the developed world. While virtually the entire developed world has fertility rates that are at or below replacement levels, this accounts for less than 20% of the world’s population. The vast majority of countries with sub-replacement fertility rates are in low-income countries such as China. This lack of socioeconomic correlation with fertility rates makes it difficult to predict when a country will enter such a state and how long it will last. This lack of socioeconomic correlation may be due to the developed world’s intervention in low-income and third world nations, both culturally and in the subsidized distribution of birth-control, abortifacients, and abortion services. A shrinking population due to reduced fertility rates invariably means an aging population. These two factors adumbrate a host of problems. An older workforce generally means a less healthy, less educated, and less tech-savvy workforce. Additionally, a dwindling working age population will mean that inefficiencies in…

    • 2952 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    ABSTRACT According to the National Population and Family Planning Commission of China, in 2010, China 's population was more than 1.34 billion people, an increase of 5.84% in comparison with the year of 2000. However, the figure was lower than its estimation (the officials was given a number of 1.4 billion in 2010 China 's population). It could be said that China 's population growth has been slowed slightly, despite China is still the world 's populous nation for so many years. Many opinions tend to think that it is the great result of China 's one -child policy which was introduced in 1979. To find the answer, we need to know main points of the policy which will be introduced in my paper. I also present the advantages and disadvantages of the policy and that would be the most important part in my study.…

    • 2487 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    If follows that if the cost of living and the cost of having children limits family size, then government policies towards taxation and family welfare are also significant influences on how many children a couple will have. Such government policies generally include family planning programmes, financial incentives to control/increase family size, and the provision of health care facilities. Governments can adopt one of three attitudes or sets of policies with respect to their population: a pr-natal view, by which an increase in fertility is promoted, an anti-natal view, by which a decrease in fertility is promoted or a neutral view which is indifferent about population growth or decline.…

    • 426 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    When the one child policy was advanced, it had been argued that one child policy would benefit the country as well as its people (Qing, 1995). Its undeniable that the one child policy has shown its great effect on alleviating the population pressure. However, as the society develops, more and more inharmonious social problems are coming about because of the one child policy, among which the biggest problem is the unbalanced population. “By 2020, there will be about 40 million Chinese men unable to marry, because too few girls will have been born. Sociologists say that could trigger aggressive behavior among frustrated bachelors, including kidnapping and trafficking in women.” (VOA, 2006). Moreover, the one child policy is also exacerbating China's aging population problem, whose severe consequences will be further explained in the following statement.…

    • 606 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In addition, enforcing this law could prevent a country from being overpopulated because, in a way, the number of children being born in a country would be controlled by the government. This also contributes to a country’s level of development because if a country is overpopulated, the development of the country would be negatively affected.…

    • 337 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    What makes the population explosion a problem? This splurge of growth alerts politicians and economists because of the reason that human beings need resources in order to survive. Since there are limited resources, there would come a point wherein there would be no more resources to sustain life. The Philippines is one of the most densely populated countries in the world, with an estimated 99,900,177 number of inhabitants as of July 2010. The government is concerned about the huge number of inhabitants in the country, which can cause widespread food shortages, and outbreak of diseases thus suggesting the use of contraceptives for family planning. The Church says that the problem is not overpopulation but there is a problem in redistribution of wealth, the church is against the use of such things (contraceptives), and only advocates the natural way of family planning. This paper will talk about the leading causes and effects of overpopulation, and the role of the church and the government in resolving this problem.…

    • 1452 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Best Essays