Preview

Essay Analysis

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
546 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Essay Analysis
Analysis of "How Boys Become Men" Jon Katz explains why men grow up to be insensitive in his essay “How Boys Become Men.” This thesis is demonstrated both with a specific set of values for boys, as well as in two personal recollections. Katz draws attention to the fact that boys are expected to learn ways to handle things alone and to hide any weaknesses, and especially tears. The main strategy used in this essay is narration. The essay tells more than one story supporting the idea that boys are taught to be tough and aren't allowed to show emotion. Illustration is also used to get the point across. Katz gives many examples of young boys following the special rules that have been set aside for them. The main point is reached using cause and effect. Little boys are taught and treated differently from little girls. Boys hear messages about being strong even before they understand what that means. This is quite possibly the main reason men are insensitive or don't quite know how to show their feelings. Jon Katz is very straight forward with his information. I do not feel as though it is an essay of opinion, but more of fact. Even if there is no research or statistic to back up the facts, Katz uses personal experience as his support. I believe that any one of us could ask ourselves, or boyfriend, or perhaps father, and we would have at least one story that also supports this idea. Have you ever had a man tell you "That hurt my feelings"? But that statement is one that women use freely. It is no secret that women and men are completely different when it comes to communicating our feelings. Katz starts his essay with a story. From the beginning he tells of experiences in his own life that support the idea that a boy's experiences while growing up prepares him for adulthood. Later he gives us the specific code of conduct for boys, which clearly is very different from the way girls are expected to behave. He ends by noting that

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    “Boys will be boys,” a commonplace phrase that constitutes a diffusion of responsibility away from the male perpetrators of aggressive attitudes and behaviors, supports a dangerous rhetoric that a young male transitioning into adulthood will perform acts of aggression, display a detached and uncaring disposition, and develop attitudes of intense homophobia and sexism as part of a biological norm of that stage of adolescence, a stage of life comprising a larger and larger part of young man’s life, ages 16-29. Kimmel challenges this rhetoric, arguing that there is an underlying culture of entitlement (as the gaining of equality by other groups such as women and minorities are perceived as a threat to privileges that the white man “deserves,” a zero-sum game of status) that is supported by a culture of silence (of refusing to bear witness to other men’s transgressions, which is perceived as support) and a culture of protection (in which communities shield “their” guys from the harsh implications and accountability) which allows these behaviors and attitudes to persist. Kimmel argues that…

    • 598 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The article written by Michael Messner explores what are some true contributing factors that prepare a young boy in male-hood leading up to masculinity. He analyzes how creating the male masculine identity for a young boy can be a result of participating in organized sports. He conducted his research starting out with interviewing 30 male athletes who mostly played baseball, basketball, football, and track. Each interviewee was retired and had at least been an athlete for 5 years.…

    • 571 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    5. Boys are held to a higher standard than women are. They are bred to become proud, authoritative figures in society while the females are nurtured into becoming submissive partners. Since boys are considered superior, it is considered a weakness when they befriend and play with girls. These beliefs will cause the boys to grow up as dominative, controlling husbands that rule over their own lives and their wives’ lives. The women will end up being common submissive partners. The future relationship is one similar to one between masters and slaves.…

    • 917 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    5. To protect our boys from this barrage Katz suggests that we have boys/men exposed to positive influences. Have men look inside for individuality and courage. One main key factor is having men express their range of emotions to express the different representations of males. Males should be encouraged to express feelings, reveal vulnerability, and most of all courage and character to admit that they need other…

    • 804 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    On Boy Trouble

    • 1001 Words
    • 3 Pages

    "On Boy Trouble"� Essay In the essay, "On Boy Trouble"� by Margaret Wente, many points were introduced to the readers. Margaret Wente lures the readers to her article by using an opening sentence such as "They are tormented by unattainable ideals,"� (pg. 427). Wente attracts the readers by exercising her writing abilities and using effective and efficient words and phrases. Also, the use of allusions are very effective. Margaret Wente's charismatic style of writing is very helpful to the readers in a way that differs from most other writers. With Wente's style of writing, the reader does not get bored or sidetracked while reading her craftsmanship. Margaret Wente opens up about her research on the male society. She proves a somewhat non-biassed point about what type of torture and anguish most adolescent males go through in order to "fit in"�. Wente expresses her points in a very effective manner by issuing facts, and examples, that seduces the reader into reading more. This is a magnificent piece of writing and is easy to read. One who is not very eager to pick up a highly intellectual piece of writing because of being in fear of becoming lost or confused while reading, should not worry about this piece. Wente does not use too many "big"� words in her essay, but does include some very effective ones. The article, "On Boy Trouble"� by Margaret Wente is a highly educational piece of writing, that tests the brain power of the reader, but does not stress it.…

    • 1001 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Kimmel writes about a society where men have to act a certain way in order to fit in with the “what it means to be man” category. He explains how men have to follow “guy codes” and those who don’t follow them accordingly are criticized and excluded not only by society but also by their fellow male friends. These men are to show no weakness, no emotion, have wealth and power, are reliable and take risks (609). These men are those who are influenced the most by society and solely base their lives off of what society will think of them. They are men who Kimmel writes about when he quotes Don as he says “any fatigue, any weakness, and sign that being hit actually hurt and he was like ‘Waah!’ Widdle Donny got a boo boo. Should we kiss it guys?”(611) This shows how men within society make fun of other men who act outside of the “guy codes.” Kimmel’s piece is specifically about “guy codes” that men have to follow in order to fit in society, but there is nothing in it about women and what kind of “girl codes” society has set for women. There are certain codes that women have to follow and some that overlap with the so-called “guy codes.” Society has so much influence in gender roles that it has led to a controversy between its members. Men who want to step away from behaving male-like and women who want to do the same…

    • 1434 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    While the education system is very important in the socialisation of males into traditional masculinities, the family is the main socialisation agent. Parents may encourage and reward behaviour that they deem appropriate and discourage that which they think is inappropriate. For example, parents may encourage their daughters to focus on their appearance and their sons to watch and support sports. Also, Oakley referred to the labels (For example, ‘princess’ and ‘pretty’ for girls; and ‘brave soldier’ and ‘strong’ for boys) as verbal appellation and says they teach the children society’s expectations. Children also imitate their parents because they are their significant…

    • 670 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Societys Mold on Men

    • 735 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Society has placed a mold on the role that men are supposed to play, what men are supposed to do, and how they are supposed to act in their culture. Throughout “Why Johnny Won’t Read”, “Mind over Muscle”, “Putting Down the Gun”, and “Boy Problems”, the authors share the different difficulties that young boys and young men face on a daily basis. Overall, the central issue affecting young boys and young men is that the education system is focused increasingly more towards the succession of women.…

    • 735 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Comparative Essay Outline Thesis Statement : In our society, you simply cannot avoid expectations. These interpretations are affected by your gender, class, and socio-economic stand. Stereotypes are present in our society. Thus we have expectations from others, besides ourselves.…

    • 458 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Raising Cain

    • 1306 Words
    • 6 Pages

    A boy longs for connection at the same time he feels the need to pull away, and this opens up an emotional divide. This struggle between his need for connection and his desire for autonomy finds different expression as a boy grows. But, regardless of their age, most boys are ill-prepared for the challenges along the road to becoming an emotionally healthy adult. Whatever role biology plays (and that role is by no means clear) in the ways boys are characteristically different from girls in their emotional expression, those differences are amplified by a culture that supports emotional development of girls and discourages it for boys. Stereotypical notions of masculine toughness deny a boy his emotional resources. We call this process, in which a boy is steered away from his inner world, the emotional miseducation of boys. It is a training away from healthful attachment and emotional understanding and expression, and it affects even the youngest boy, who learns quickly, for instance, that he must hide his feelings and silence his fears. A boy is left to manage conflict, adversity, and change in his life with a limited emotional repertoire. If your toolbox contains only a hammer, it's not a problem as long as all your equipment is running right or repairs call only for pounding. But as tasks grow more complex, the hammer's limitations become clear.…

    • 1306 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sommers

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Many parents, teachers, and gender reform have not been successful in rooting out male behavior they regard as harmful. For example, an “equity facilitator” tried to persuade a group of nine-year-old boys in a Baltimore public school to accept the idea of playing with baby dolls. According to one observer, “Their reaction was so hostile; the teacher had trouble keeping order (Sommers 366).” Sommers’ present’ research that asserts that the nature of men is a matter of biology, not conditioning, and schools should stop attempting to change natural gender roles in society.…

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    jock culture

    • 713 Words
    • 2 Pages

    He goes on to talk about that there are more than just these 2 categories of people or you can fall under both categories. Boys are taught to be tough, stoical, and aggressive, to play hurt, to hit hard,…

    • 713 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The way she describes the differences in being raised may be apparent, but let's not forget about the natural way that males and female differ. She states that beginning at a very young age, female conversations tend to be more passionate and helpful, rather than the more scattered and oblivious conversation of the males. She also carries on to explain that as they get older, it seems obvious that the males actually are listening and showing compassion, just in a different way. Females may constantly be staring into one anothers face, while males may seem like they're gazing off into space for the whole of the conversation. In actuality, it reveals that the males are indeed expressing their feelings as well, just in a macho way if I may put it. This is all too true and leads me back to my first point of natural born differences between males and females. I believe it's just in our blood to be the way we are. Disregarding the whole dominant male theory, it may just be encrypted in our blood, just the way that Windows are default on the computers you buy nowadays. Males will just always feel the need to be more macho and nonchalant than females. Not just in conversation, but in every aspect of life. Males don't want to cry, males don't want to seem like they care. Males will…

    • 924 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    She has challenged today’s expectations of what a young boy should be like, play with, and how he should behave. The question I ask myself is, has she figured out how to incorporate both “girl” and “boy” norms in order to give her son a balanced and full view on life itself, or has she taken it too far in challenging the expectations of little boys from society by over influencing?…

    • 1953 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Boys

    • 899 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In today's society men are looked at as, " the higher power " or, as " more powerful " . Naturally Boys feel the need to assert their power to others at an early age. Rick Moody's short story "Boys", shows us the relationships between brother and sister and then between the boys and their father. Boys in early ages can be very ruthless and reckless. In Rick Moody's "Boys", the power of masculinity takes over the boys lives and through tragedy the boys are able to come together and let down their guard.…

    • 899 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays