Preview

Dialect Diversity in the Classroom

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
636 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Dialect Diversity in the Classroom
English 1102-001 Phase II: Annotated Bibliography
George Reed and David Marlow USC Upstate Undergraduate Research Journal, Volume 2, Fall 2009 Talkin’ ‘Bout South Carolina: Addressing Dialect Diversity in Middle School Classroom.
In my response on the “SRTOL” Students’ Right to their Own Language, I believe that “Standard” English still has to be taught in schools. We could then bring dialects teaching in the classroom just within discussion topics. George and David are showing two main points that support my views: it wouldn’t be possible for teachers to master a variety of dialects but some dialects could be projects or topics of discussion in the classroom. This would make students have a little idea about them. The article brought to our attention that dialects are pretty hard to comprehend while you are an adult. This is supporting my view for the fact that the older people get, the harder it is for them to understand different types of dialects. When children are in their early ages, they are capable of mastering different languages and dialects because the mind is still fresh and open to receive lots of information. But as they get older and become adult, the brain starts having difficulties to incorporate more and more information. So teachers who obviously are already adults will have or actually won’t be able to answer the call for the teaching of English diversities in the classroom. However, we could have plans or projects to learn about some dialects mostly in the speech than in writing. This would build more confidence in “non-standard English speaking” students as they express themselves in class. The writers shared with us a program in which students would utilize just some dialects, study them, and better understand them. And by doing so, students would know what the suitable situations to utilize their dialects are. So overall diversity in the English language wouldn’t be possible but a study of some dominant ones could give some comfort to the



Bibliography: George Reed and David Marlow USC Upstate Undergraduate Research Journal, Volume 2, Fall 2009 Talkin’ ‘Bout South Carolina: Addressing Dialect Diversity in Middle School Classroom. In my response on the “SRTOL” Students’ Right to their Own Language, I believe that “Standard” English still has to be taught in schools. We could then bring dialects teaching in the classroom just within discussion topics. George and David are showing two main points that support my views: it wouldn’t be possible for teachers to master a variety of dialects but some dialects could be projects or topics of discussion in the classroom. This would make students have a little idea about them. The article brought to our attention that dialects are pretty hard to comprehend while you are an adult. This is supporting my view for the fact that the older people get, the harder it is for them to understand different types of dialects. When children are in their early ages, they are capable of mastering different languages and dialects because the mind is still fresh and open to receive lots of information. But as they get older and become adult, the brain starts having difficulties to incorporate more and more information. So teachers who obviously are already adults will have or actually won’t be able to answer the call for the teaching of English diversities in the classroom. However, we could have plans or projects to learn about some dialects mostly in the speech than in writing. This would build more confidence in “non-standard English speaking” students as they express themselves in class. The writers shared with us a program in which students would utilize just some dialects, study them, and better understand them. And by doing so, students would know what the suitable situations to utilize their dialects are. So overall diversity in the English language wouldn’t be possible but a study of some dominant ones could give some comfort to the way students should express themselves. Carolyn Temple Adger Issues and Implications of English Dialects for Teaching English as a Second Language, Tesol Professional paper #3 March 2003 We have here those same points I brought up in my topic; we still need to teach the “Standard” English language but can also tolerate the diversity of English dialects. The author shared with us in the article a common project that Caribbean students experiment to see the value of “Standard” English. In the “Language Awareness and Teaching Standard English” paragraph, she noticed that in some Caribbean education systems, students study historical and linguistic information to compare it with their own dialects. They use topic discussions in both dialects to analyze both languages styles. By doing that, most students see the difference, and understand better the “Standard” type of English. Also, that teaching system shows students the role of “Standard” English in their lives as it is a requirement for social consideration and in the business world. We were always told back home in Africa where I’m from, that learning the so called “Standard” English was the only way to make ourselves understandable anywhere and be part of the respectful and successful society. Understanding that fact gave us the will to learn “Standard” English because we wanted to belong to that successful society. So, first teaching students that, “Standard” English is not the requirement for passing tests but important in their daily lives, and second, showing them the differences between both “Standard” English and their own dialects result in students getting motivated to learn “Standard” English as a second language. This program, incorporated in the education system in some Caribbean countries, illustrated my point on still teaching “Standard” English but implicating some forms of dialects just to make students express themselves freely and understand those varieties and differences.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In Richard Lederer’s article “All American Dialects”, he states the ironic truth that “most of us are aware that large numbers of people in the U.S. speak very differently than we do.” (152) How is it that one language can have so many speech communities? It is because of the way our nation was developed. Our language is a mixture of culture and lifestyle that has diverted our English dialect, so that each region’s speech is unique. How I speak can define who I am, determine what I do, and locate exactly where I’m from in the U.S. This is the value of my, and my language’s speech communities.…

    • 1104 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    According to Young, we should all know and/or learn as many dialects as we are able to. He also,…

    • 335 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The setting of the ELL instructor interview was inside Mrs. Trimble’s kindergarten classroom after her class had been dismissed. This was a one-on-one interview. Mrs. Trimble was very helpful, informative, and answered questions to the best of her ability. “Narrowing the achievement gap between students who are native English speakers and those learning English as a second language is one of the biggest challenges facing U.S. educators” (Pardini, P., 2006, p. 20). In this essay the discussion will cover abilities an ELL teacher should have, the role parents and teachers have within the classroom, and changes and benefits of SIOP protocol for native ELL students.…

    • 336 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I agree with this idea because coming to a mutual agreement between the teacher and the student would help the student become confident in his or her ability to communicate with others not just with people in their community. The teacher must also understand the language of that student to help teach them proper grammar. During my sophomore year, I became more confident in my ability to write because of the understanding I had with my professor. Although, I still write in a non-standard way it is not a frequent mistake for me. I think that this would be the most effective approach to teaching a Black Student how to speak standard American English because it shows the student that his or her dialect is respected by the teacher, but it is not right if you want to succeed in mainstream…

    • 521 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When I read Delpit’s article I read some interesting stuff. Her daughter Maya transfers from Standard English to African American English when she transfers to a school where it’s majority black. For me I really don’t understand why it’s so…

    • 538 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Schools should encourage students to keep their dialects throughout the school development because it gives them a better sense of belonging and acceptance within their peers. It is crucial for students to feel accepted while learning because their skills can be the main focus in schools rather than trying to change their dialects to meet standards. As for writing, it should e rather similar because it would not be in the favor for every single teacher or professor to go out and learn as many dialects as they can, just to make a few students feel like they belong. As I have previously mentioned, the feeling like one fits in an environment can make the difference in their education and how well or not they learn. The dialects that teachers should focus on getting used to are the most common ones. These include, but not limited to Spanish, Chinese, and French. More problems have to be addressed when exposing teachers to more languages. These include the different dialect within those languages, and of course it will be too much to…

    • 1906 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    School diversity is not a surprise as presently a large number of the educational population is comprised of students from many different cultural backgrounds. According to research conducted by Education Week (2011) there was a large growth of English language learners in the United Sates over the 21st century. This rise mandated the need for public schools throughout the nation to assist English language learners with the instruction of special language.…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Some of the world’s strongest speakers came from the African-American community such as Frederick Douglass, Martin Luther King Jr., and Jessie Jackson. Although their oral tradition is “widely recognized” in educational literature, people describe African-American youth as verbally deprived or linguistically retarded. Some African-Americans do not sound the same as to Anglo-Americans when they speak. When people from different cultures come together, the cultures mix and adapt. However, when certain groups become isolated afterward, the languages will develop in a couple of ways; which would eventually create language differences. The myths about the language of African-Americans come from the linguistic inferiority principle. The principle…

    • 301 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Language in education has long been the subject of attention by educationists at all levels. Initially as concerning the 'problem' of teaching English to children for whom it is not a first language, The Swann Report 1985 pg385…

    • 3671 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Paul Laurence Dunbar

    • 1604 Words
    • 7 Pages

    basic charge of this criticism can be stated in the words of a recent critic,…

    • 1604 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this mono-linguistic culture, especially in Nebraska where it is predominantly white, many colleagues in the class have never heard of the concept of bilingualism until we viewed a documentary called Speaking in Tongues by California Visions. The film featured four students, Durrell, Kelly, Jason, and Julian from four different public schools in San Francisco area. Durell is an African-American second-grader who learns Mandarin. Kelly is a Chinese-American who learns Cantonese, the language of her parents'. Jason learns both English and Spanish in his middle school, and Julian is a Caucasian 8th grader who learns Cantonese. These four students…

    • 824 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Literacies for Learning

    • 2600 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Walsh, C. (2006). Beyond the workshop. Doing multiliteracies with adolescents. English in Australia, 41(3), 49-58…

    • 2600 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mother Tongue

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages

    As a southern girl growing up in rural Wakulla County, I have experienced prejudice based on my southern dialect and language style. Dialects and word use play a powerful role in linking specific populations together with a common bond. As powerful as this connection is to bring people together of the same group it is just as powerful to pull people apart that are not in the same group. Amy Tan writes about the power of language in “Mother Tongue”. Tan’s thesis statement - “I spend a great deal of my time thinking about the power of language the way it can evoke an emotion, a visual image, a complex idea, or a simple truth”(Tan 633) - sets the tone for the article. I am in agreement with Tan’s opinion with the power of language. Even though I’m not bilingual, I have experienced similar misconceptions because of my southern drawl and language style. Language affects the way people treat you, the opportunities that are given, and your perception of yourself.…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Moreover, dialects are also good for communication with people who come from different areas. Most people are interested in a new language. They prefer to know the different pronunciation in dialect of one word. That would be a heat topic on tables.…

    • 317 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    • Social Dialect= research has provided a great deal of information about patterns of pronounciation and grammar for different age groups.…

    • 482 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays

Related Topics