A Whisper of Aids

Only available on StudyMode
  • Topic: AIDS, HIV, Antiretroviral drug
  • Pages : 1 (389 words )
  • Download(s) : 406
  • Published : September 23, 2012
Open Document
Text Preview
“1992 Republican National Convention Address: A Whisper of AIDS” by May Fisher (1992) at the American Rhetoric website

I read the Mary Fisher story. There are plenty of bias and fallacies examples Mary speaks of in this article. Mostly talking about how people are prejudiced and judgmental against people with the HIV virus. How people show no compassion and are so very cruel to the AIDS victims. Mary talks about how her family has shown affection to her through this difficult time but there are many other AIDS victims out there that do not have that. What they get are people being mean and treating them as outcasts. Some examples of rhetorical devices in this article could be where Mary talks about the black infant struggling with tubes in the hospital or the lonely gay man whose family has rejected him.

The speaker addresses arguments and counterarguments by talking about how AIDS is not a political creature. She talks about how fast the AIDS virus is spreading and how dangerous it is. The statement that you cry and grieve alone and do not tell anyone that someone was HIV positive and that we should be able to reach out for compassion is very true. The speaker argues that people with the AIDS virus tolerate ignorance from the people who do not have AIDS. In my opinion I would not be cruel to someone who has the AIDS virus. They are still human just as I am. I would only take precautions to ensure my own safety but would not treat them as though they are a monster.

I believe Mary’s arguments could be effective. Especially when she talks about her children and how she wants to make the world a safer place for them. She talks about how supportive her family is and that’s it perfectly fine to support someone with the AIDS virus. I believe the arguments could be effective because there are so many families out in the world who do cherish their loved ones and if they were in the same situation I believe many of them would be there for a mother or sister or...
tracking img