A Rose for Emily vs. a Long Wintry Death Leads to a Long-Dead Friend

Only available on StudyMode
  • Download(s) : 1329
  • Published : October 11, 2012
Open Document
Text Preview
“A Rose for Emily vs. A Woman’s Wintry Death Leads to a Long-Dead Friend”
Losing a loved one is never easy to accept. It is important to be reassured by the reality that the best way to honor him or her is to retain their memory in one's heart. Miss Emily Grierson in “A Rose for Emily” and Frances Dawson Hamilton, in “A Woman’s Wintry Death Leads to a Long-Dead Friend” both handle the situation of their loved partner quite differently than one usually would. Both stories “A Rose for Emily” and “A Woman’s Wintry Death Leads to a Long-Dead Friend” lead to nearly the same resolution, but they have many differences and similarities throughout to make them unique and interesting.

The number of differences in between the two stories divides each into its unique and interesting tales. One of those differences is communication. While Emily Grierson scarcely communicates with anyone in her town, Frances Dawson Hamilton is somewhat open with others. Man-servant, who is also a combined gardener/cook, is the only one who is being seen at Grierson’s house within the past 10 or so years. Hamilton, on the other side, has a friend by the name of James Phillips. James Philips visits Hamilton, takes her shopping, and does shopping for her. Another difference between the two stories is the in climax points. Grierson is seen buying arsenic at the drugstore, which she uses to drug her partner Homer Barron. After she drugs him, Homer Barron disappears and she never mentions him. Bernard J. Kelly, Hamilton’s partner, dies from sickness. Hamilton discusses with her friend that Bernard is sick, but she states that she’s taking good care of him and he doesn’t need to see a doctor. While both women keep their partner’s dead body in the upstairs bedroom, their signs are different; this brings us to a third difference among the two stories. Grierson gives absolutely no sign that her partner’s body is on the second floor; Hamilton however, mentions to her friend that there is a man up...
tracking img