Preview

A Critique of Lawson’s “Aid to Africa Must Be Doubled”

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1180 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
A Critique of Lawson’s “Aid to Africa Must Be Doubled”
In one of its reports, UNICEF states that more than 22,000 children die daily because of poverty and they “die quietly in some of the poorest villages on earth, far removed from the scrutiny and the conscience of the world. Being meek and weak in life makes these dying multitudes even more invisible in death.” The former heartbreaking report caused the world’s eight wealthiest countries to form a council, adequately named the group of eight, which meets annually to discuss ways to help lift incapable countries out of poverty. Despite forming the group of 8 in 1975 and meeting 30 times until the year 2005, the leaders could not come up with a solution that proved effective to release African people from their misery. That’s why in the year 2005, an association called Live 8 whose aim was to shine a light on the severity of the situation in Africa was formed, and it started pressuring the leaders of the Group of Eight to “end the scandal of stupid, immoral poverty in Africa.”
On June 21 2005, and amid all the pressure exerted on the group of eight to find a solution for Africa’s situation, Max Dawson who is a policy advisor for Oxfam (yet another association that aims to reduce poverty) decided to argue the case of doubling aid to African countries. Dawson’s web-article titled “Aid to Africa ‘must be doubled’” that was posted on the BBC news website strongly argues that emergency aid to Africa is not enough but Africa should be supplied with long-term aid in order to prosper. While Dawson’s arguments were reasonable, he committed some errors in terms of interpreting information and providing valid solutions.
In his article titled “Aid to Africa 'must be doubled”, Dawson asserts that emergency aid to Africa is not enough, but long term aid should be provided to help Africa bloom socially, economically and politically. Max Dawson states that British emergency-aid has helped remove some kids from the streets where they would have encountered infectious diseases, and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In fact, foreign aid agencies do wonderful humanitarian work to help people around the world. However, their system that they use has flaws. Too often optimists attribute failures in development and economic growth to a lack of donations. Professor and Humanitarian, Jeffrey Sachs, in his book The End of Poverty points out the apparent failure of the United States regarding the government’s goal to donate 0.5% of its GDP towards foreign aid. While his data at first appears to show the United States and other developed countries’ failure to reach 0.5% of their GDP, Sachs does not account for inflation in which the value of money changes with supply and demand over time. He also fails to refer to what currency his data uses whether the graph uses USD or the Euro, which affects the amount needed to reach 0.5% due to the difference in value of different currencies. Sachs’s deceptive statistics creates the illusion that developed countries refuse to offer enough money to make changes. The U.S. along with Germany, France, Italy, and other top donors for foreign aid actually donate more money each year despite the slow or decreasing GDP growth (see in figure 4). By using manipulative data, optimistic authors such as Sachs do not account for complex factors including inflation and immediately turn blame towards a lack of money and paint the image of crass developed…

    • 1064 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is made evident that Australia’s contribution to alleviate poverty through overseas aid is successful. The average life expectancy of individuals living in developing countries has increased by approximately twenty years in the last decade, which is substantial in contrast to the figures fifty years ago. Vanuatu has reduced the incidence of malaria by 80% with the support of Australian aid. It is a myth that foreign aid doesn’t work. 79% of Australians, according to the essential report, agree that the Government should reduce spending in foreign aid when 41% don’t know what it is. The ignorance surrounding foreign aid is what potentiates suffering of individuals living in developing…

    • 886 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Easterly explores just how helpful foreign aid actually is. He first assesses the the legend of the “poverty trap.” Through comparing growth rates between the poorest fifth of countries and the other four fifths, Easterly explains that there is no distinguishable difference in the rates. Perhaps the strong case of evidence against the poverty trap legend is that eleven out of the twenty-eight poorest countries in 1985 were not in the poorest fifth in 1950. This means that instead, countries had declined from above; while those thought to be in the poverty trap have actually emerged ahead. Thus, there cannot be such thing as a poverty trap. Easterly does take into account individual cases such as Chad and the Democratic Republic of the Congo which experienced zero and negative per capita growth rates respectively. However, those seem to be outlying cases that are present in almost any type of research. Botswana strongly supports Easterly’s argument against the poverty trap. Botswana went from being the fifth poorest country in 1950 to increasing its income thirteen times by…

    • 1551 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Esaay 3 Mary Paul

    • 701 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Africa happens to be the poorest country with the highest population growth. Since they are so poor they are in deep poverty since because they don’t have sufficient income. Although conflict and drought are certainly a problem, money is a bigger issue. There is many conflict onto in The United States should sent aid or not over to Africa to help them get out of their poverty or should they do it on their own. The United States should not send money because it is no their problem and also pouring money into a leaky bucket will not solve anything.…

    • 701 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Most westerners believe that all of africa is aid ridden and disease stricken, but they are wrong. According to Ann jones, “it;s the hard-times Africa you read about:...disaffected Western journalist whose secret woe is that the AIDS epidemic makes it too risky to to get laid.” (37) This shows that the shallow minds of western culture do not realize the major problem of the epidemic, they only realize that they can not get what they want because of it. In addition, they not realize that AIDS is in a SMALL part of africa, they, we, assume it has taken over the whole continent. Many people in the western world believe that…

    • 883 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Other authors have backed up Easterly's position; in 2006, another book written by World Bank economist Robert Calderasi entitled The Trouble with Africa concludes that international aid should be cut to Africa, saying that "Contrary to conventional recommendations, direct foreign aid to most African countries should be (cut in half), not increased" since corrupt African governments often use the money…

    • 452 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Oscar Romero

    • 901 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Aid is really effective only when it is aligned with recipients' priorities and is predictable, and donors must make sure that aid does not create unreasonable administrative demands on recipients. Low-income countries, for their part, face significant challenges when aid rises.And they have to ensure that the capacity of their public services is not overstretched. They must also make sure that aid flows do not have unintended economic effects—large aid flows can result in an appreciation of a country's currency, making exports less competitive, or causing an increase in…

    • 901 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    By attributing less agency to poor African countries than other poor countries, it ignores those communities’ political and economic success stories. When a country in the West believes they know what is best for a country outside of their own, it is not only not true usually, but it diminishes the assistance that they are trying to offer. The interference of paternalism is justified by saying that the group will be better off because of it, but as we can see from the past, it is rarely true and an idea that those in the West must work hard to re-contextualize their understanding of countries outside of the West to fit with their true…

    • 1140 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    36% of Africans live on less than a dollar a day. 20% of the population is undernourished. However, people in foreign countries can help the poorer people by donating to trustworthy charities, and giving aid to the poor Africans who need it the most. Critics of aid say that giving aid to Africans creates stereotypes and doesn’t focus on creating a good economy of government. But it is more important to keep people alive than to create a good government and economy. You need able, healthy citizens to create a good workforce for a country, which is extremely difficult in Sub-Saharan Africa without foreign aid. Aid is needed in Africa because many people would die, it helps to get better death rates and accessible healthcare, and giving aid to keep people alive is more important that improving government.…

    • 702 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Social Wicked Problem

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The report highlights how the disaster could have been prevented through early warning systems, and a quicker response time. Archie Law brings to light two major issues contributing to the famine; one being the removal of major funding in the agricultural field; governments ignoring this need for more agriculture are simply setting up for future disaster. The second major issue is the use of land; Saudi Arabians emptied their aquifers growing wheat and can longer feed themselves. They are now purchasing land in developing countries to grow their own food supply (Law, 2011). This power play of rich nations adds the issue of politics into the food system, with those with the most money always coming out on top (Maxwell, 2012). Aid is not enough to fix this issue; more must be done to help the people to help themselves (Zakaria,…

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Over the years, the United States has provided some type of foreign aid and support to those we have formed an alliance with. By providing foreign aid, countries no have some sort of peace, relief during crisis, security, and development efforts to fix damages that may occurred. Foreign aid is any food, supplies, or money given from one country to another to maintain stability in the country. In Guess how much of Uncle Sam money is going to foreign aid. Guess again, Foreign Assistance, and Foreign Aid for Development Assistance, the authors discuss what foreign aid is and what it is used for. The authors also focus on how people view foreign aid and their opinions on whether it is being used correctly or if more money needs to be put into…

    • 828 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The proliferation of crises around the world has led to a sharp increase in the scale of humanitarian aid required to meet the vital needs of the people affected by them for food, water, medical care and shelter. Humanitarian organizations can either meet those needs directly or support local services engaged in the same work. In most cases, both approaches are used. Malnutrition, illness, wounds, torture, harassment of specific groups within the population, disappearances, extra-judicial executions and the forcible displacement of people are all found in many armed conflicts. Aside from their direct effects on the individuals concerned, the consequences of these tragedies for local systems must also be considered: the destruction of crops and places of cultural importance, the breakdown of economic infrastructure and of health-care facilities such as hospitals, etc. The impact of armed conflict on people and systems vital to their survival can take different forms, as the following examples illustrate: when Rwandan refugees fled into former Zaire, the mortality rate rose sharply, to as much as 10 times what is regarded as the threshold of extreme emergency, and large scale displacement invariably causes a dramatic increase in malnutrition rates. In children under the age of five, this can reach 20% (Rwandan refugees in Zaire, 1994) or even 50% (Somalia, 1992). Aid for victims of conflict remains the primary responsibility of the warring parties. The need for outside help arises when the parties to a conflict are unable or unwilling to shoulder that responsibility. Any successful aid strategy will have different goals. For example, aid is primarily intended to prevent the disastrous consequences mentioned above by stepping in before the health of the victims of conflict deteriorates. This requires…

    • 1470 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Sub Saharan Africa Essay

    • 1085 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The hunger crisis facing Sub-Saharan Africa is among the most dire in the world. Primarily caused by poverty and a lack of food production, malnourishment is one of the most pressing issues facing Sub-Saharan governments and citizens (Smith). A wide variety of possible solutions to the problem have been suggested by those interested in Sub-Saharan Africa’s well-being. These solutions cover many sectors and industries, but most contain agricultural policy initiatives. Across Africa, agriculture employs “some 70 per cent of the work force and generates on average 30 per cent of Africa’s GDP,” and is therefore critical when considering living conditions and drivers of the economy (Ababa, 47).…

    • 1085 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    African Foreign Aid

    • 1144 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The first thought that comes to mind when thinking about Africa is often, what is going wrong there now, or it is a very dangerous place for foreigners to visit. This is a stereotype that has plagued Africa for the past hundred years and has aided to why Africa still is perceived today, especially with epidemics such as HIV/AIDs, Ebola, and refugees fleeing war torn countries. Africa is an enormous continent with over 1.26 billion people living on it spread out between 54 countries. With this in mind it is important to remember that particular crises affect only particular regions of Africa for example, northern Africa has lower HIV/AIDs rates than even the US and many other western countries, and is really a problem in southern Africa in countries…

    • 1144 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The author however did not highlight the hindrances as to why Africa is still lagging behind. For example poor leadership, civil wars, underdevelopment, poverty, overpopulation etc are some among the many problems that Africa faces. The findings from the author are presented clearly but she omitted the facts behind the whole question as to whether Africa has a say in the international system. However the results presented in the article are convincing in that there is evidence of examples of Africa’s potential in terms of resources and knowledge…

    • 839 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics