A Case Study of the Octopus Card

Value Chain Flexibility with RFID:
A Case Study of the Octopus Card

Lam Tak Ming
The Hong Kong Polytechnic University [e-mail] Abstract: Octopus cards are an electronic payment system based on a wireless RFID technology developed in
Hong Kong. Users simply hold their contactless smartcards over an electronic reader, and the payment is deducted from the card automatically. If users link their cards to their credit card to upload money, there is no cash transaction involved. Launched in 1997, Octopus cards are the world’s most widely accepted contactless
RFID electronic payment system. The system generates value for customers, service providers, and societies.
This article makes a theoretical and applied contribution to our understanding of strategic information systems. It adopts and modifies Porter’s value chain and develops value‐chain flexibility as a theoretical framework to analyze the Octopus card system. The fast and dramatic changes in customer needs, business competition, and technological innovation are creating an urgent need for flexibility throughout the whole value chain. By looking at order fulfillment as a process, the shop outlet—either online or offline—is only part of the entire flow from customer enquiry to customer receipt. It is clear that no single idea could significantly reduce customer lead time.
Only a total effort from organizations to increase flexibility and eliminate bottlenecks can make the kind of difference needed to compete (Day, 1994; Blackburn, 1991; Yusuf, Sarhadi, & Gunasekran, 1999). Therefore, value chain flexibility must be broadly defined, and it should be applied in the service industry. In other words, organizations should be able to deal with the uncertainty along the value chain to meet customer demands. This framework analyzes how the Octopus card system

References: Blackburn,  J.  (1991).  Time‐Based  Competition.  Homewood, IL: Business One/Irwin.  Chau,  P.  K.  C.,  &  Poon,  S.  (2003).  Octopus:  An  e‐cash  Payment  System  Success  Story.  Communications  of  the ACM, 46(9).  Correa,  H. L., &  Slack, N. (1996).  Framework  to  Analyze  (1989).  Flexibility:  The Next Competitive  Battle  –  The  Manufacturing  Day,  G.  S.  (1994).  The  Capabilities  of  Market  Driven  Organiztions. Journal of Marketing, 58, 37‐52.  Doll,  W.,  &  Voderembse,  M.  A.  (1991).  The  Evolution  of  Manufacturing  Systems:  Towards  the  Post‐industrial  Enterprise. Omega, 19(5), 401‐411.  Gerwin, D. (1987). An Agenda for Research on the Flexibility  Gerwin,  D.  (1993).  Manufacturing  Flexibility:  A  Strategic  Perspective. Management Science, 39(4), 395‐410.  Gunasekaran, A. (1999). Agile Manufacturing: A Framework  for  Research  and Development. International  Journal  of  Production Economics, 62, 87‐105.  Hayes, R. H., & Wheelwright, S. C. (1979a). The Dynamic  Hayes,  R.  H.,  &  Wheelwright,  S.  C.  (1979b).  Link  Manufacturing  Process  and  Product  Life  Cycles.  Hill,  T.  (1994)  Manufacturing  Strategy:  Text  and  Cases.  Chicago, IL: Richard D. Irwin.  Huber,  G.  P.  (1984).  The  Nature  and  Design  of  Post‐ Industrial  Organizations.  Management  Science,  30(8),  928‐951.  Jordan,  W.  C.,  &  Graves,  S.  C.  (1995).  Principles  on  the  Porter, M. E. (1980). Competitive Strategy: Techniques for  Analyzing  Industries  and  Competitors.  New  York,  NY: Free Press.  Octopus Card Limited (2010).     http://www.octopuscards.com  Peppard,  J.,  &  Rylander,  A.  (2006).  From  Value  Chain  to  Olla,  P.,  &  Patel,  N.  V.  (2002).  A  Value  Chain  Model  for  Mobile  Data  Service  Providers.  Telecommunications  Policy, 26(9‐10), 5551‐5571.  Porter,  M.  E.  (1985).  Competitive  Advantage.  New  York,  NY: Free Press.  Porter,  M.  E.,  &  Millar,  V.  E.  (1985).  How  Information  Rayport,  J.,  &  Sviokla,  J.  (1995).  Exploiting  the  Virtual  Value Chain. Harvard Business Review, 73(6), 75–85.   Shapiro, C., & Varian, H. R. (1998). Information Rules: A  Strategic  Guide  to  the  Network  Economy.  Boston,  MA: Harvard Business School Press.  Skinner,  W.  (1969)  Manufacturing:  Missing  Link  in  Skinner,  W.  (1985)  The  Taming  of  Lions:  How  Manufacturing  Leadership  Evolved  1780‐1984.  In  K.  Press.   Slack, N. (1983). Flexibility as a Manufacturing Objective.  Slack,  N.  (1987).  The  Flexibility  of  Manufacturing  Systems.  International  Journal  of  Operations  and  Production Management, 7(4), 35‐45.  Stabell,  C.  B.,  Fjeldstad,  O.  D.  (1998).  Configuring  Value  Upton,  D.  M.  (1995)  Flexibility  as  Process  Mobility:  the  Management of Plant Capabilities for Quick Response  Wheelwright,  S.  C.,  &  Hayes,  R.  H.  (1985).  Competing  Through  Manufacturing.  Harvard  Business  Review,  63(1), 99‐109.  Yusuf,  Y.  Y.,  Sarhadi,  M.,  &  Gunasekaran,  A.  (1999)  Agile