Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Spiritual Belief: A World Split Apart

Powerful Essays
1651 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Spiritual Belief: A World Split Apart
Rico Spears
Ms. Lisle
9/26/12
Academic Writing and Research

Spiritual Belief
In this analysis paper I will talk about incorporating God throughout everyday life, whether it be through materialistic things or one’s own self perception of how it is to live and pattern after Godly ways . In “A World Split Apart,” Alexander Solzhenitsyn infers that there is a higher power than man; a lack of spirituality can harm ones afterlife. Through a higher power all things are possible he says, “If, as claimed by humanism, man were born only to be happy, he would not be born to die. Since his body is doomed to death, his task on earth evidently must be more spiritual: not a total engrossment in everyday life, not the search for the best ways to obtain material goods and then their carefree consumption.” Whereas in “A Voice from Russia’s Past,” by Jack Fruchtman Jr. he simply argues that Solzhenitsyn is speaking from Slavophiles point of view, which stands as a group of Russian philologists and nationalists interested in the origins of the Russian language. Fruchtman also stated that Solzhenitsyn echoed this theme at Harvard when he noted that the philosophical foundation of the West has historically rested on a “rationalistic humanism,” by which he meant “the proclaimed and enforced autonomy of man from any higher force above him. (Fruchtman 44)” My last and final source will come from “Presenting Humanism” by Jende Huang. Huang speaks from a humanist view and states that our society has been so socialized to accept the idea that believing in God is something that is "good," and even for a religious liberal, there may exist, an unconscious desire to hold onto that. The realization that you don 't need a god to live your life is a difficult one and one that cannot be easily acknowledged.

Solzhenitsyn and Huang share some of the same spiritual beliefs when referring to man. Huang states that man was created to be “God like” and to pattern ways after God. Speaking from a humanist point of view Huang says, “ideally, humanist are continually open to new ideas and new information, and refuse to be shackled by beliefs that remain outside the realm of testability,” (Huang 1-3); he proves this by stating humanism is analogous to science in the sense that both are concerned not only with the body of knowledge and the evidence that supports it, but with efficient means and methods used to gain knowledge. Is it right that man’s life and society’s activities are ruled by material expansion above all? Solzhenitsyn asks this question in reference to government. Laws are put in place to abide by but there is always a loop hole in any law system. Laws are to protect the rights of others or for humans as one body to abide by. Through all the materialistic abuse of power used by some government officials, Solzhenitsyn tends to acknowledge that even in the era that he is in, man is still the head. Life after death, as he talks about spirituality, should be better than your life on earth. Even Huang states that if you accept the bible as truth, you’re agreeing that God would spread his message to pre-agricultural nomads who couldn’t even imagine the evaluation of human society over the subsequent thousands of years. Understanding that you don’t need God to live your everyday life, Huang says, humans still do things to show representation that he is a factor in life such as: going to church and taking communion; “ Do this as often as you remember me” 1st Corinthians 11:25 (NKJ). Man is not perfect but by following the bible he can reach salvation and become cleansed through baptism and understanding that each day you can become more “God like.”
James Reston who wrote “A Russian at Harvard” states that Solzhenitsyn is right in many cases but contradicts the demeanor of his message a lot. Solzhenitsyn entitles his address “A World Split Apart” why so Reston questions the diverse message in each passage to say it sounds like a “mind split apart” (Reston pg.37). Reston says that Solzhenitsyn was right to complain about that “hastiness and superficiality are the psychic disease of the Twentieth Century” (Reston pg.38); in reference to the war period and the lack of spiritual belief. “After the suffering of decades of violence and oppression, the human soul longs for things higher, warmer and purer than those offered by today’s mass living habits, introduced by the revolting invasion of publicity, by TV stupor and by intolerable music”,(Solzhenitsyn pg.14) Solzhenitsyn writes this statement proving all points to the lacking of “spiritual being” stated by him.

Ending his speech, Solzhenitsyn speaks about a higher power. In Philippians 4:13 it says, “I can do all things through Christ (God) which strengthen me” (NKJ). Solzhenitsyn asks “Is it true that man is above everything? Is there no superior spirit above him? Is it right that man’s life and society’s activities should be ruled by material expansion above all? Is it permissible to promote such expansion to the detriment of our integral spiritual life?”(Solzhenitsyn pg.21) What is life or even afterlife? In contrast with that similar understanding Fruchtman attacks by still having Solzhenitsyn, in a Slavophile voice he states that Solzhenitsyn and the Slavophiles believe that this decline and everything accompanying it was deeply rooted in Western history, a history of man, where man has lost his spiritual tie to the infinite, the eternal, and the timeless( Fruchtman pg.45). The Slavophile Ivan Kiereevsky wrote, “ it is painful to see what a subtle, but inevitable and just-sent madness now drives the Western man. He feels his darkness and like a moth, he flies into the fire, which he takes to be the sun. He cries like a frog and barks like a dog, when he hears the word of God.”(Fruchtman pg.45) Man, in short, is no longer human, and the decline of the West is upon us. Fruchtman attests his point later on in his response when he references how Solzhenitsyn says it is a society which is doomed because of its rejection of spirituality and its concomitant worship of reason and material things.
Because the West had a tremendous fall in spirituality, Solzhenitsyn began to question, in order to get out the state that the West is in, who does man look up? During the time of the speech men were dominant in the sense of being superior to women, but if “lost” in sense of spirituality and begin to believe that modern ways and material things are more important than being God like. Is it actually true that man is everything and neither that nor anyone is superior to him? “We turned our backs upon the Spirit,” Mr. Solzhenitsyn proclaimed, “and embraced all that is material with excessive and unwarranted zeal,” (Pg.44). Fruchtman stated, for the Slavophiles, the West was decadent primarily because it had adopted the worship of rationality, matter and form. Moreover, it relied too much on legalistic systems of thought and action. This particular statement reflects Solzhenitsyn outlook on one’s self; Solzhenitsyn supports this statement when he stated that only by the voluntary nurturing in ourselves of freely accepted and serene self-restraint can mankind rise above a world stream of materialism. (pg. 20-21) Solzhenitsyn infers that no one on earth has any way left but upward climbing to the next anthropological stage (Pg.21). Anthropological is the study of humanity, social action between humans and cultural as well as religious preferences. Fruchtman goes on to say for both Mr. Solzhenitsyn and the Slavophiles, men spiritual capacities have become subverted by the overpowering influences of reason and legality. Solzhenitsyn, Fruchtman, and Huang share similar beliefs when referring to man and higher powers above man. To pattern after God means to be “God like” as Huang states while Fruchtman counters Solzhenitsyn by saying he is speaking from a Slavophiles point of view. The West, as Solzhenitsyn portrays it is one who now has a lack of spiritual belief. The West, they argued, had emphasized rationality, compulsion and above all legalistic institutions and material wellbeing. Each of these qualities was in conflict with man’s inherent, goodness and virtue, Fruchtman writes. This statement proves his thought on how Solzhenitsyn is continually speaking and analyzing from his own humanistic view. As Solzhenitsyn states, “It will demand from us a spiritual blaze” (pg.21). He infers to the west as whole and not singling any particular individual out; to act as one mind body and soul, but in government form. Laws are set in place to help us not hinder as a result he entitles this particular section “Before the Turn”. Still the question lies is there no superior spirit above man? If so how can we be more like him, how can we incorporate that higher power in our everyday life and in our law and judicial systems? How can take eyes off the moral standards of man and out them on the mindset for man to pattern after “God like” ways?

Work Cited Fruchtman, Jack, Jr. “A Voice from Russia’s Past,” . Solzhenitsyn at Harvard : The Addresses, Twelve Early Responses, and Six Later Reflections .Ed. Ronald Berman. Ethics and Public Policy Center, 1980. 43-48. PDF Huang, Jende. “Presenting Humanism.” Humanist, 69(2), 35-36.” Ehost.n.p.,2009.Web. September 2012. International Gideons The. Holy Bible. New King James Version 1st Corinthians 11:25, Philippians 4:13 Reston, James. “A Russian at Harvard,”. . Solzhenitsyn at Harvard : The Addresses, Twelve Early Responses, and Six Later Reflections .Ed. Ronald Berman. Ethics and Public Policy Center, 1980. 36-38. PDF Solzhenitsyn, Alexzander. “A World Split Apart.” Solzhenitsyn at Harvard: The Addreses, Tweleve Early Responses, and Six Later Reflections.Ed. Ronald Berman. Ethics and Public Policy Center,1980. 3-23.PDF

Cited: Fruchtman, Jack, Jr. “A Voice from Russia’s Past,” . Solzhenitsyn at Harvard : The Addresses, Twelve Early Responses, and Six Later Reflections .Ed. Ronald Berman. Ethics and Public Policy Center, 1980. 43-48. PDF Huang, Jende. “Presenting Humanism.” Humanist, 69(2), 35-36.” Ehost.n.p.,2009.Web. September 2012. International Gideons The. Holy Bible. New King James Version 1st Corinthians 11:25, Philippians 4:13 Reston, James. “A Russian at Harvard,”. . Solzhenitsyn at Harvard : The Addresses, Twelve Early Responses, and Six Later Reflections .Ed. Ronald Berman. Ethics and Public Policy Center, 1980. 36-38. PDF Solzhenitsyn, Alexzander. “A World Split Apart.” Solzhenitsyn at Harvard: The Addreses, Tweleve Early Responses, and Six Later Reflections.Ed. Ronald Berman. Ethics and Public Policy Center,1980. 3-23.PDF

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    ‘The growth of the New Age and similar movements is evidence of a spiritual revolution is society today’ to what extent do sociological views and arguments support this view?…

    • 1010 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    ‘Years of Russia, the USST and the Collapse of Soviet Communism’ David Evans, Jane Jenkins…

    • 1037 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Bibliography: 6. Montefiore, Simon. Stalin: The Court of the Red Tsar. United States: Alfred A. Knopf, 2003.…

    • 3398 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    [ 9 ]. Lynch, M., The emancipation of the Russians serfs, 1861--a charter of freedom or an act of betrayal? History Review, 2001…

    • 3297 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the introduction of Stalin’s Letters to Molotov, Lars T. Lih argues that distinguishing between Stalin’s political and personal letters help researchers understand what type of individual he was and what personality he possessed. These letters were edited to start the debate on who he was and why he went on murderous rampages. From this introduction, the reader gains information and an idea of the author who wrote these letters. These letters range from when Stalin first gained power, his concerns with his enemies, particularly Trotsky, and into the beginning stages of expansionism. Before every section, the editor Lih, provides commentary for the reader to understand the context of whom Stalin is addressing. This introduction will help…

    • 140 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Religion is a guise used by people in power to maintain the status quo and justifies how the world ‘ought to be”. The religious world is dependent on the real world and cannot be maintained without it. Religion supposed to serve as a guide to interpret behavior. However, the proletariat did not use their reasoning and let religion become the truth of their reality, the pain reliver to their inequality. No one questions their quality of life since it is not in their control, it’s in God’s hand.…

    • 1267 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Evans, David and Jenkins, Jane, (2001) Years of Russia and the USSR, 1851-1992, Hodder and Stoughton Educational.…

    • 2154 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    21. Vladistok Zubok and Constantine Pleshakov, Inside the Kremlin 's Cold War: From Stalin to Khrushchev (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1996)…

    • 4199 Words
    • 17 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    There have been many premises covering the topic of religion and spirituality assisting the understanding of the framework of the modern world. Specifically, two different hypotheses - the secularization hypothesis and the religious transformation hypothesis - aid in grasping this issue. The secularization hypothesis promotes a secular society, replacing religion with modern science and technology. On the other hand, the religious transformation hypothesis explains that religion will be constantly reshaped by modern culture. These hypotheses and their specifics give insight allowing exploration to essentially observe where religion and spirituality are headed in this contemporary world.…

    • 704 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Leon Trotsky played a very significant role in the Bolshevik success in the period 1917-1924. According to A.J Koutsoukis , 'his contributions in the years 1917 to 1924 had been second, if not equal to that of Lenin himself. Trotsky played a significant role in establishing Bolshevik control in Russia. He was also very instrumental and one of the reasons for the Red Army winning the civil war. Trotsky was regarded by his supporters as the saviour for his country for his efforts in organising the Red Army during the Civil War. According to historian E.H Carr , 'Trotsky was a great administrator, great intellectual, and a great orator...' but at times was overbearing and lead to his eventual downfall.…

    • 2333 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    [ 25 ]. Josh Brooman, Russia in War and Revolution (USA, Longman Inc. 1989) (page 31)…

    • 4689 Words
    • 19 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Ideas of globalization are so broad, so diverse and so changeable that it sometimes seems possible to pronounce virtually anything on the subject" (Scholte 427). Indeed the broad concept of globalization is hard to define. However, globalization is known as the free circulation of goods, services and concepts. As Moroccans and citizens of the “third world “globalization has a socio-economical consequence: it increases class war. Before talking about what happened to us --as Moroccans-- after globalization, let’s see how this phenomenon found its way to modern Morocco. Historically speaking, the French colonization brought and imposed the concept of “the modern country” by creating industrial cities and changing the agriculture from a small activity to a business heading toward international marketing. And so we were introduced to free market policies, export-import trade and cross-border commerce. Building the Modern Morocco required opening its gates to international companies. We presented to foreign investors mouth-watering offers with low taxes, cheap manpower and an open market on the developed west. Thus globalization entered the kingdom trough the economical gates. From the cultural point of view, Morocco has hosted several civilizations, which made it culturally rich. Its geographic position and historical background made it a well-known touristic destination. With tourist bringing their cultural identities Morocco became a place of cultural exchange, which will enhance the cross-fertilization of ideas and cultures. No one can deny that Globalization have a positive effect on the economical prosperity of developed countries, but it has more downsides than one might think of for developing and underdeveloped countries. Let’s consider the fact that globalization is a standardization process that aims unifying all cultures in one dominating culture (which is the western culture) and killing any…

    • 738 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    On December 14 2012, the United States experienced one of the worst mass shootings in history, the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting. Noah Pozner six years old, Ana Marquez-Greene six years old, Grace McDonnell seven years old, to name but a few, were the victims of Adam Lanza. The loss of basic principles in life love, patience, perseverance, compassion and forgiveness have favored the emergence of a new type of individuals, fuelled with meaningless, fearless, and immoral ideas for horrendous plans. All these basic principles, which are mainly found in spirituality were supposed to be taught by family to their members, but not anymore. Family is the first instrument of socialization for every Human being, unfortunately the lack of spirituality in family has altered the way we should behave and interact in the society. Today, Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn’s speech “The World Split Apart” Solzhenitsyn at Harvard: The Addresses,Twelve Early Responses, and Six Later Reflections. Confirmed that Human life and spirituality are tightly linked. In his speech, Solzhenitsyn presented how the lack of spirituality has negatively impacted the United States society. On the other hand Spirituality can have a good impact on mental and physical health based on the study made by Thomas Stone Carlson, Christi R. McGeorge and Amy Anderson in “The Importance of Spirituality in Couple and Family Therapy” published in Contemporary Family Therapy: An International Journal. In their study they gave a clear positive correlation between health and the practice of spirituality in family. As the basic unit of society, family is the most essential component of a country. Spirituality can have an outstanding effect in someone life, not having the chance to experience spirituality in your childhood with your family, may affect negatively your perception of life.…

    • 1918 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Levering, Ralph B. American Opinion and the Russian Alliance, 1939-1945. Chapel Hill: Univ. of North Carolina Pr., 1976.…

    • 4835 Words
    • 20 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Russian 1940's

    • 1262 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The Soviet Union in the twentieth century was a tumultuous time for Russians who wished to speak their minds and for those who wished to stretch communism to the corners of the globe. With a government consumed by annihilating its opponents and censorship, Soviet writers such as Nikolai Bukharin and Grigori Deborin were compelled to depict the glory of communism or face the harshest of consequences. In “Down With Factionalism!,” Bukharin justifies his slander of Leon Trotsky in the battle to succeed Vladimir Lenin for the leadership of Russia. In Deborin’s “The Second World War,” he explains how the Soviet Union’s allies, England and the United States, let them down and how the USSR, alone, should be credited with saving Europe from Nazi Germany. Bukharin and Deborin rationalize soviet tactics through denouncing a political opponent and condemning capitalistic allies.…

    • 1262 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays