“In the end utilitarianism is simply a moral justification for individual/group selfishness”
Utilitarianism is a theory in which the quote by Jeremy Bentham applies “The greatest happiness to the greatest amount of people” which means that the best action is the one in which the most pleasure is given to the majority of people. The majority always wins rather than the minority and pleasure is the sole good whereas pain is the sole evil.
On one hand this is classed as selfless as using utilitarianism and the hedonic calculus is actually thinking of the best option for all people not just yourself or one specific person. Also, the ‘golden rule ‘is “Love your neighbour as yourself” which clearly means that you should bare everyone in mind and not be selfish and try to make everybody happy. The theory recognises intelligence and the best decision not only for immediate consequences but long consequences. It is not selfish as all people are considered in the judgement and it takes time to make a decision by using the hedonic calculus. Utilitarianism is a much less selfish act than such theories as deontology, which thinks of whether an action is right or wrong all together rather than the people involved and their feelings. Whereas utilitarianism is a teleological approach.
On the other hand, utilitarianism is selfish as although it is acting on behalf of the majority, the minority still have to put up with the decision and therefore have to deal with the consequence. Act utilitarianism is a more selfish philosophy as it is based on the pleasure of those immediately affected and not on the consequence of people in the long run. This is also a selfish theory as we are weighing out one person’s happiness being more important than another’s; for example, if two people were dying and we could only save one, one was an old man and one a new born, we would have to save the new born as they have a longer future ahead of them, but this is still selfish as the old man...
Please join StudyMode to read the full document